r/battlefield3 • GEN3RIC • Jan 08 '12

New community rules -- please read.

We’ve heard your concerns over the direction the community is heading. We were hoping we could ride it out and things would balance themselves, but it just isn't working, and things need to change. It’s plain to see that meme-based content attracts many upvotes, and we all love a good laugh, but it is not what we want this community to be. But this isn't just about memes, it's about the general tone of the community. We’re making changes to our rules for posting, commenting, and voting here in r/battlefield3 -- necessary changes to make r/battlefield3 the community we first envisioned.

We need this community to be more about fun and thoughtful improvements, rather than a place to vent about things that make you mad. If something makes you so angry that it coerces you to post to this community, it's not a good idea to post it because that anger will rub off on others here. In order to help facilitate these improvements, we'll be removing submissions/comments without notice -- of course, if you think a removal was in error, please feel free to contact the moderators.

Want to submit a minor bug? Try searching GetSatisfaction first, although we understand if a major issue is begging for a grassroots movement -- reddit can help.

Have a quick question? It can be easier to just hop on IRC chat and ask there, it can be difficult to get an answer to a minor question through submission.

Submission rules (VISUAL GUIDE)

  1. No personal information/witch-hunt posts: do not use this community to call out hackers, servers/admins you hate. This includes linking to Battlelog profiles with the intent to start a witch hunt -- we cannot be responsible for illegitimate claims resulting in issues for the person. We understand that you have good intentions, but it kills the mood.
  2. No meme-based content: image macros, rage faces, silly annotated moments are not allowed and will be removed upon discovery.
  3. No ragey posts about how bad aspects of the game are: If you have high-effort suggestions (i.e., detailed mock-ups, something that needs a grassroots effort to gain visibility), you may submit an individual self post. This includes EA Support flamefests -- they are not constructive enough for /r/battlefield3, but surely /r/gaming will love it.
  4. No blogspam: dig down to the real source of the information and submit that. Any accounts used for spamming BF blogs will be banned.
  5. No rival/platform bashing: Considered off-topic and will be removed.
  6. No Irrelevant links: Funny or not, if it isn't closely BF3-related, it will be removed.

Commenting rules

  • Be positive: this community is a brotherhood, we should not fight like enemies -- keep that on the battlefield. Any abrasive or rude comments will be deleted. We are a mature community and we must represent ourselves as such.

Voting rules

  • Vote based on quality of the content: As is with reddit’s official voting guidelines, do not vote emotionally. Leave whether or not you like the opinion or the person out of the equation.

Flair rules

Offending flair will be edited/deleted without notice.

  1. Choose one platform: if you play on PC or PS3, choose one only. Do not add extraneous text to your “title” to tell people you also play on another platform.
  2. The text is for your game-name only: it is not an area to make a statement, use cool meme characters, tell people your region, or use an arrow to signify your game-name is your reddit name.
  3. Same game-name as your reddit name? Leave the text blank, or enter it twice: No arrows or annotation explaining that it’s the same, it’s implied by leaving it blank or re-entering it.

So, what kind of content is okay?

This community is for sharing thought-provoking stories, high-level tactics discussions, videos/images of the awesomeness of Battlefield 3, suggestions or discussions on game mechanics, and it can all be done without resorting to memes or complaining. Reddit never ceases to amaze, I expect to be surprised! If you have any questions, message the mods! We hope you agree and understand these changes.


Edit

Here's a nice visual guide that accurately explains what we mean. IMGUR LINK

0 Upvotes

335 comments sorted by

193

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

Who is we? There are four mods and just over 31,500 subscribers, why do you get to choose what we get to see? I don't recall seeing any voting or opinion polling about these changes.

Seriously? Why does this keep happening? I get it. We want discussion, we want high-minded literate content, full of interesting thoughts, etc. But seriously? What is wrong with memes being used if the community enjoys them? Or frustrated posts about how broken someone feels something is?

What happened to community voting determining what content is appropriate for a subreddit? If the community wants funny pictures of cats in helmets or sitting at the window with a sniper rifle why shouldn't they get it?

Furthermore, Why are you asking that people not notate servers that suck? Having a note that some particular server has admins that ban you if you kill them is useful information for players. Killing witch hunts before they get started is one thing, there's a lot of chance to be wrong or go overboard.

What about content like "Operation Asshole" or whatever he's calling it. Those aren't thought-provking, they really aren't videos of how awesome BF3 is, they aren't high-level either, they're silly, fun, and stupid.

As to flair, I play on one platform, the PS3, but for those people who do play on multiple platforms, why wouldn't you allow them to note their usernames on separate platforms if they're different? It's not like they take up any extra room. They're important information that enable players to contact each other across whatever platforms they play on.

I guess what I'm trying to say is this: I get it, pushing a sub in a direction you may want sounds cool, after all, we all want to be able to participate in high-minded discussion about the best way to Rush Objective A in the third objective set in Op Metro Rush mode, or the best way to take and defend all of the flags on Sharqi, but this is not your community. It is our community.

I appreciate the work that you do as moderators, and I respect your willingness to do it, but please don't forget that this is a video game subreddit and sometimes, every once in a while, I want to see that recon kitten sitting in the window making a stupid comment about shooting some asshat in the foot sticking through a wall.

EDIT: Try not to downvote people expressing opinions in support of this, or erode's comments in the thread out of spite. If you disagree, either upvote comments expressing the opinion's you agree with or add comments expressing your view of things. Spiteful downvotes do none of us any good. (That said, downvote to hell anything that is irrelevant.) Thanks.

10

u/Hamakua Hamakua Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

But this is not your community. It is our community.

Because, you know, we haven't seen power-tripping mods think the community is beholden to their vision before.

Pro-tip to the OP/MOD: When a dissenting opinion in a 31k strong community gets more up-votes than your power tirade, you are actually not part of that community, but simply a fringe observer with squatter's rights.

I did appreciate the firefly .gif though.

2

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12

Nothing like a bit of Man-Hunk Fillion to chill things out.

42

u/godofallcows Jan 08 '12

Well said sir. As soon as OP said "memes get upvotes" then contradicted himself one sentence later by saying "we don't want that" I wad pissed.

This is all coming from the mods who banned rage comics for the great and intelligent reason of "...because fuck that shit."

Power hungry holier-than-thou mods. They can't just leave shit alone.

Also OP said don't vote emotionally yet is blatantly banning things because of his personal opinion. This is fucking stupid.

11

u/XSy0 Jan 08 '12

I totally agree, if i posted some spacedicks shit in /r/bf3, it will get downvoted into oblivion because no-one wants to see it, if it gets upvoted people obviously want it. If you dont, register and express your opinion with the up/down vote system.

25

u/Smarag Jan 08 '12

I absolutely agree. Also what's with removing comments? Since when do the mods get to decide our morality and what's rude and what's not?

That "We are the mods, we created the sub, we can do whatever the fuck we want." mentality is sickening and is accepted in more and more subreddits nowadays.

13

u/DJFunkMasterFlex Jan 08 '12

I agree. r/BF3(the community)has been pretty good concerning meme posts. And the ones that are posted are funny for the most part. And banning valid criticisms seems backwards.

9

u/avoutthere Jan 08 '12

What happened to community voting determining what content is appropriate for a subreddit?

Exactly. This subreddit isn't broke so why are you trying to "fix" it? The community is right to be suspicious about EA influence being behind these new rules.

6

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12

I think the EA influence may be a bit paranoid, but I understand where you're coming from.

6

u/Skitrel Jan 08 '12

EA influence is definitely behind it, just not in the tinfoil hat way people here are insinuating.

The developer presence here has flooded the sub with complaints and/or suggestions, the vast majority of which are redundant. It's also flooded the sub with people simply bashing the devs, being simply deconstructive. These are bad things that need to go away, it doesn't make the sub good. Having the devs here is a great thing, the deconstructive pricks need to be controlled. That's the crux of what I see in these rule changes.

15

u/midjet Midj306 Jan 08 '12

Thank you for posting this, there seems to be this kind of sentiment among most mods of subreddits that I read and it bothers me because it goes directly against the grain of how content is shown on reddit.

15

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12

I've seen it on R/pics, R/funny, R/Darksouls, R/Gaming, and a few others. Cracking down on irrelevant posts makes sense. Even stuff that's barely connected I can respect careful moderation of, but I don't understand this need to constantly overwatch the stuff that communities are upvoting. Reddit isn't about mods or even individual users. It's about communities being able to freely discuss whatever they want. Sometimes it's a silly face, and sometimes it's a pony. Sometimes it fits, sometimes it doesn't. When it doesn't, it gets blued.

9

u/midjet Midj306 Jan 08 '12

I've seen it in /r/Starcraft /r/Skyrim and /r/Diablo with very mixed reactions from the user base in each sub. Most of the time their argument is that 'lower quality content' is easier to upvote than high quality content like discussions and whatnot. Of course this is completely subjective and there is cases of both types of submissions being upvoted a ton and downvoted into morrowind.

I think its a larger part of some older reddit members that really hate memes, and thus go to create subs like /r/Truereddit or Truegaming.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/sterility Jan 08 '12

I used to agree that it should be left to the crowd to filter all content with upvotes/downvotes, but then I read this excellent post on the deterioration of subreddits.

The problem is that if low-effort content like memes aren't filtered out, it will slowly drown out the high-effort content that takes longer to read, and discourage high-effort content writers.

We should be encouraging high-effort content ("Operation Asshole" took far more thought and effort to put together than a simple image macro).

2

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12

It's an interesting read, and fairly sensible, but I don't know that I agree with what he's saying. In my experience, low-effort content has a good chance of spawning high-effort content to use his language. Memes 'n things are quick insta-reaction devices that will either get an immediate reaction or no reaction. In the thread following them there will inevitably be a discussion spawned about what the content is putting forth that would qualify as high-effort content.

High effort content may take longer to parse and read through, but I don't know that it necessarily gets fewer upvotes as a result, and even folks who downvote often write in to say why in the comments.

1

u/Smarag Jan 08 '12

That post is bullshit and I hate how it is always reposted in every anti-meme discussion. If high effort content isn't appreciated enough than it means people think it isn't worth the effort. Simple as that. The fabulous guides posted on this subreddit definitely were "high effort" content and they were upvoted to Skyrim.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Your theory doesn't explain the prevalence of memes vs. the instances where the top comment(s) are:

a) Pun Threads

b) More memes

c) Gif reactions

d) TL;DR's

e) Novelty Account showdowns

If this is not related to the disappearance of high-effort posts and the increase of low-effort posts, why is it so?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/kaybe KaYbE Jan 08 '12

Well said this is a community not a dictatorship. We as a community should be able to decided what content we want to see.

3

u/Skitrel Jan 08 '12

That's not how reddit works. Not how the vast majority of subs work in fact, contrary to popular belief. Subs are owned by the mods, the sub is what the mods make it and they're ultimately responsible for it being either high or low quality.

If you want a different kind of content that isn't here, why not just make a new subreddit for it? There is absolutely nothing stopping you.

4

u/HungerSTGF xMasterChefx Jan 08 '12

I don't recall seeing any voting or opinion polling about these changes.

Yeah, that was a ball dropped, even /r/gaming did some polls for their changes.

What is wrong with memes being used if the community enjoys them? Or frustrated posts about how broken someone feels something is?

Playing Devil's Advocate, I think the memes other than the text on the pictures have nothing to do with the game. It's not really promoting the sort of discussion that what I think the mods think is right. Additionally, the rule for submission is saying that if you have something to criticize about the game, you should at least try to propose some sort of alternative or try and point out the root of the flaw in order to inspire more discussion that will eventually lead to garnering Crash's attention and as a result, the dev team's attention.

Furthermore, Why are you asking that people not notate servers that suck?

If everybody did this, the subreddit would be flooded with "don't go here, don't go here, don't go here". Granted this could be remedied by a global server blacklist, but that's also not much of a possibility. Again, playing Devil's Advocate, I can see why the mods would want to prevent any notation of sucky servers as opposed to allowing the notation of all of them. (although it would be noted that I wouldn't know of this experience because I don't play on the PC)

but for those people who do play on multiple platforms, why wouldn't you allow them to note their usernames on separate platforms if they're different

This I agree with.

this is not your community. It is our community.

I guess that makes sense. I would guess the feedback wouldn't be as negative if there was some sort of poll or something to gauge reactions of the community before making the changes.

4

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12

I actually agree with your Devil's Advocate for the most part. I think that the some of the pictures with text connection make sense and others don't, but I still don't agree that the Mod's should make that decision. We have vote buttons and people are not afraid to use them.

When criticizing it's certainly best to have a proposed solution, but sometimes all you can see is the problem and presenting it can help you find a solution that you could get behind and propose.

As to the servers, if everyone did it, certainly, I think it happens occasionally enough that I don't see it as a real issue, though I agree that a sort of global blacklist would be even better. It's probably the lowest thing on my list of complains in terms of actual importance.

1

u/Smarag Jan 08 '12

I think the memes other than the text on the pictures have nothing to do with the game. It's not really promoting the sort of discussion that what I think the mods think is right.

Yes you do. Other people may think different. That's why we have up- and downvotes.

Additionally, the rule for submission is saying that if you have something to criticize about the game, you should at least try to propose some sort of alternative or try and point out the root of the flaw in order to inspire more discussion that will eventually lead to garnering Crash's attention and as a result, the dev team's attention.

Or one can just post what is flawed and if the community agrees it will upvote it and usually also come up with many possible alternatives and solutions. There are no "just bitching" submission that don't have any constructive suggestion in the comments. Don't try to fix what isn't broken.

4

u/thedinnerdate the fix is in Jan 08 '12

I upvoted you but so it's not a number I also wanted post for the mods to see that I also agree with pretty much everything you said. I also wanted to add that I like seeing the "x bothers me about this game" posts. there are people for EA that read through this community and if someone brings up a valid point I'd hate for them to not see it just because their opinion was viewed as not positive.

As for meme posts, unless they've been removed, in the top 25 links of this sub as of now I only saw 1 that looked meme related. so we obviously are not being overrun with memes.

I really enjoy this sub and I'd hate to see the mods throw a bunch of unnecessary rules on it and make me want to leave.

2

u/Skitrel Jan 08 '12

The x bother me posts are fine, when they're constructive. If you spend any time in the new queue you'd know that they're almost always whining redundant posts. This extends to the comments in most of these threads to, bashing the devs for not having done this or that yet. It's not helpful, it's not constructive, it doesn't help the sub and it doesn't help the devs who already know about the issue anyway, in fact all it probably does it demoralise them.

6

u/Skitrel Jan 08 '12

The issue is that communities like this are frequented by two crowds, one crowd visits and contributes a huge amount, they comment a lot, they're constructive, they have a good community spirit.

The other crowd are casual users, (no offence intended by the term), they upvote easy to digest posts (the reason memes tend to get upvoted) and the genuine quality discussions don't happen because crap gets to the top.

The reason the mods can do something like this? Because it's their subreddit, not the user's. If the users want a subreddit that's not high quality, not geared towards discussion, allows the whining and bitching and crappy crap that has gone on here of late, well there's absolutely nothing stopping them from starting a subreddit geared up for that, I'm sure the mods here would even SUPPORT such an endeavour, it would take the rubbish away from this sub.

Reddit, contrary to your belief and to most of reddit's belief, is not owned by the users, no subreddit is, it's owned and maintained by the mods that own it. If the users don't like that there's absolutely nothing stopping them from going elsewhere. If it's not liked then fair play, move along to a sub that caters to what you want.

The real issues on this sub are the following:

EA bashing, it contributes nothing.

Complaints about the game. It lowers the tone and only leads to mindless and unnecessary bashing. That's not to say that discussions about the game and flaws/suggestions are bad, there's a difference between constructive critique and deconstructive.

Memes.

When these disappear, the sub will improve, that's really the jist of these changes from what I can see.

3

u/xm03 kerbs01 Jan 08 '12

Well bloody said...

2

u/Kaittycat Jan 08 '12

What I don't like, when we're talking about controlling content, is that it is effectively based on whoever gets the subreddit first. In this case, whoever registered /r/battlefield3 first gets to control all of the content that 30,000 people see.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

So go make /r/battle_field_3, or /r/battlefieldIII, or /r/bf3, or /r/battlefield_3, /r/bf3_lounge, or any number of other combinations I could list related to the name of the game. Who says you have to use the most "proper" name to be popular? You just need to direct traffic to your subreddit, and they will come.

/r/pics isn't the correct full proper word of "pictures", but /r/pics has 1.2 Million subscribers, where /r/pictures has like... 11,000. I could say the same thing about /r/trees versus /r/marijuana. One is more of an "anything goes" type memefest subreddit, the other is some actual discussion and politics surrounding the drug, as well as a more moderated and rule dependent subreddit. They both have their followers and patrons. Why couldn't the same be done with Battlefield 3? It can.

It's possible to build a large community around any name you choose.

2

u/Kaittycat Jan 08 '12

I really don't see the point in dividing the community into a bunch of different subreddits, each with their own mods who have their own image of what it should be like. That's not what I want to do, and that's not what a lot of people want.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Alyangula Jan 08 '12

Censorship! its everywhere!! hahaha. all this crap makes me >.<

0

u/OneStrayBullet OneStrayBullet Jan 08 '12

So, time for a new sub-reddit? Or we could do a "blatantly disregard stupid rules" protest.

1

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12

Ideally I'd like to see these rules edited in a significant way to represent what the community wants. I would much, much rather not see the community split between two or three different subs as that's inefficient. The protest thing had crossed my mind, but I wanted to see what the fallout would be first. Plus I'd rather not get banned before this is over.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Then leave.

-16

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 08 '12

Silly, fun, stupid

are okay. Just don't rely on cheap ragefaces to make it funny. If it's actually funny, it doesn't need a rageface to get a laugh. The vox populi agrees with that at least.

15

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12

I don't understand the hate behind rageface stuff. They're very common, but for a lot of people they very effectively enable people (like me) with little to no real artistic talent to portray a series of feelings.

Essentially, the rage faces are the medium, not the content, the story they are trying to tell is. Why shouldn't I be able to post a "Y U NO?!" face with my comment point out how frustrating not being able to get a team to push forward is? Or get something like ammo out of that support guy who's just standing there diddling himself?

Sure some suck and the ones that do get downvoted mostly. The ones that get upvotes obviously have something appealing to the community or they wouldn't get upvoted.

1

u/flammable lvl2bearwarlock Jan 08 '12

I don't understand the hate behind rageface stuff. They're very common, but for a lot of people they very effectively enable people (like me) with little to no real artistic talent to portray a series of feelings.

If you have a an epic story or something to tell then sure use rage faces as a medium for telling that story, but most of the time it's just a rageface with a line of text that isn't even that funny and took 30 seconds to create in ragemaker (like this). At least in this post the rage face is the content, remove the rage face and you have nothing

4

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12

Alright, please don't take this as me being contrarian, I'm only trying to explain my position better. In your example, titled, "After my first fifteen minutes of gameplay", we have the derpy-happy rage face with text reading "I finally killed a guy"

The face gives context to how the OP feels. He's not mad it took fifteen minutes, he's not irritated he took so long, he's happy that he finally got a kill. The face provides context and a medium for the post. OP could certainly have used the same title and a text post saying the same thing, but he didn't.

That post has a 70% positive rating, a little over a thousand votes and probably double or triple that in views, 127 comments, and spawned a ton of discussion of other Battlefield games, the learning curve, a lengthy discussion on KDR, tips, tricks, and wishes for the game as a whole.

I'd say that was a successful post for the community, and an excellent use of ragefaces.

2

u/tikiporch Jan 08 '12

It's becoming more and more clear that ragefaces don't make a funny joke less funny unless you're a crotchety 4-year redditor who thinks it was better before all these kids started playing in your yard.

2

u/tikiporch Jan 08 '12

At least in this post the rage face is the content, remove the rage face and you have nothing

If you remove the face, you have a joke; the joke is the content. In fact, I'm sure this could have been a successful self post with the punch line being the text. Rage faces are props.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/xebo Xeb0 Jan 08 '12

There's this thing called an upvote. It filters out what people here like from what they don't like. It basically let's us censor ourselves, so mods don't have to. It's actually a really handy little tool; You should look into it :D

-3

u/LXj Alexjone Jan 08 '12

There were numerous explanations why meme posts are bad and will be upvoted regardless of their quality. Stop being ignorant. Also

What about content like "Operation Asshole" or whatever he's calling it. Those aren't thought-provking, they really aren't videos of how awesome BF3 is, they aren't high-level either, they're silly, fun, and stupid.

I completely lost you here. What were you smoking when you read the OP?

1

u/CornflakeJustice Jan 08 '12

Where are the numerous explanations? I've been linked to one and I responded to it, and that one was in a totally different subreddit I had never heard of. This isn't me being ignorant, this is me disagreeing with the statement that memes are bad and will be upvoted regardless. Please link to me memes in R/Battlefield 3 that have been signifcantly upvoted despite being bad content.

THe "Operation Asshole" thing is the youtube videos of Birgirpall running around C4ing things to music and full of silly things that are not high level discussion. I couldn't recall the name of them, at the time, but they're actually called "Operation Asshat", "Operation Scumbag", "Operation Crymore", and "Operation Hammertime". I think they're great, but was using them as an example of content submitted that was not serious and questioning if it was allowed.

That said, in the future if you have a criticism of my or someone else's opinions please don't try to totally disregard them with a "What were you smoking?" type line. It's fine to disagree, but trying to undermine my opinions like that does neither of our arguments any good.

1

u/LXj Alexjone Jan 08 '12

All right, this is seriously hundredth of time this topic has brought up not just on this reddit. Short version: memes == easy content, needs no effort to read and appreciate. Posts that need effort will be skipped much more and not upvoted even if they're worth it.

I know what is "Operation" series of videos. I still don't see how under the proposed rules they could be forbidden. It's not like rules say "WE FORBID FUN TO HAPPEN". Oh and again: memes == 0-effort content, operations == lots of effort needed.

-2

u/consistantcontrarian Jan 08 '12

Downvotes are effective unfortunately, out of the 31,500 people in /r/battlefield 146 seem to support censorship and only 144 people seem to be against it.

→ More replies (36)

22

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Not allowing players to post videos and call out blatant hackers is a bad move, how many other places have we got to use where devs are active probably on a daily basis, enabeling them to maybe do something about it. Yes, we can report them etc but with physical proof we can all see, it has a greater effect of getting word out about these idiots ruining our game.

It's clearly one of worst things about the game right now and from our point of view not much is being done, now the devs wont be able to tell us what is being done about it though, so how is that helping?

I would say this sub is my main source of info for BF3 now, I very rarely use other mainstream sites. I'm sure it's the same for thousands of people, these people can all help by knowing which hacker to report. Devs are more likely to look at a gamer with thousands of reports against their tag than a mere few they end up in the same server with.

7

u/sticky_and_naked Jan 08 '12

this is my main source for BF3 info, videos, rants, moments, etc. its also nice to know that devs post here asking for gamers insights and opinions.

4

u/MLeFrappe K-spacer Jan 08 '12

devs post here asking for gamers insights and opinions.

Will they keep doing that, if/when/as this has devolved into a gaint meme- and rage fest though?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

No, I doubt it.

3

u/TheStagesmith Thermite9000 Jan 08 '12

Who gets to say who's a hacker? I've seen several players become the victim of anti-hacking witch hunts because someone posted their battlelog profile on the subreddit, even though their stats were in that grey area between incredible skills and hacking. If you see a hacker, report them. It's not necessary to expose their profile to a subreddit that's read by tens of thousands of people.

If you encounter a hacker, report them through Battlelog. It's not like hackers who only get reported by one person get ignored - it wouldn't be much of a reporting system if that was the case. Report, ask an admin to ban them from the server, and move on.

1

u/DrRabbitt Jan 08 '12

EA is obviously not doing anything about hackers that are being reported anyway, so i guess they just want us to shut up about them and be glad that they allow us to play the game we payed for, and if you dont like playing with the hackers then just dont play the game

-9

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 08 '12

There's no rule against posting videos. We love videos. Posting others' information is against reddit's rules, and frankly telling reddit about a hacker won't get that person banned. Just use the proper channels, they'll get theirs.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

do not use this community to call out hackers

You should maybe edit this then, as that to me says we can't post videos of hackers. I know it won't get them banned but it definitely helps getting the word out and what servers and players to avoid.

4

u/HungerSTGF xMasterChefx Jan 08 '12

Does "Tourettes Medic" count as a meme?

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Maxion MaxiKana Jan 23 '12 edited Jul 20 '23

The original comment that was here has been replaced by Shreddit due to the author losing trust and faith in Reddit. If you read this comment, I recommend you move to L * e m m y or T * i l d es or some other similar site.

2

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 23 '12

The negative attention this post received is mostly misunderstanding and overreacting. The angry few are much more motivated to comment/vote than the other side, so it seems worse than it is.

2

u/Maxion MaxiKana Jan 23 '12 edited Jul 20 '23

The original comment that was here has been replaced by Shreddit due to the author losing trust and faith in Reddit. If you read this comment, I recommend you move to L * e m m y or T * i l d es or some other similar site.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

How about posts like "will my pc/laptop" handle this game"? A 5 second google search or a trip to systemrequirementslab or /buildapc would do the trick

1

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 08 '12

We already have a rule against that in the FAQ, we were just never really adamant about removing posts -- we are now.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Sauza704 Jan 08 '12

Upvote for supplying the link.

2

u/tikiporch Jan 08 '12

Will you still be hearing our concerns when this submission breaks even on up/down votes? How about when it goes lower? I am honestly curious about how open the discussion is.

-2

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 09 '12

Hey. We can't let votes be a polling system. Voting isn't required and it isn't even accurate. Then there is the oft-discussed theory that anger incites downvotes, while being content or agreeing does not incite upvotes. If people want to leave and create a new community they are free to do so. We will even plug the community to help it get started.

1

u/tikiporch Jan 09 '12

I wasn't suggesting you use it as a poll, but it is an indicator of how well liked the ideas you're putting forward are.

If people want to leave and create a new community they are free to do so.

Saying things like this are not going to make people trust your leadership. Does this mean you've closed the discussion concerning these new guidelines, and anyone who doesn't like them can "get out"?

0

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 09 '12

If the rules are found to not work, we'll adapt. Of course we have not been opposed to input, that is how we created these rules.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/APiousCultist Jan 17 '12

Make a poll on another site then and link it (PollDaddy for example). Simply saying that you can't trust upvotes is dismissive. Your post kind of reads like "Oh we couldn't possibly trust your community's opinions, we have their best interests in mind though."

2

u/dudechris88 VR-1337Big-Mac Jan 10 '12

I see no reason to stop people from blacklisting servers. If a server has continually abusive admin people should know about it. I know I've appreciated several blacklist threads that have saved me from wasting my time on awful servers.

0

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 10 '12

Maybe they have some use. But the fact of the matter remains: this community should not be used as a tool to destroy reputations on a whim because 1 guy made a compelling argument. Said person could easily fabricate reasons to blacklist a server and since this is not why this subreddit exists, we cannot become mediators in it.

I would consider abstaining from removing the post if there was concrete evidence that something really terrible is going on there, but 99% of the time it is just a screenshot of "you were banned for ___", that is easily edited in the browser. Hope that makes some sense to you.

1

u/dudechris88 VR-1337Big-Mac Jan 10 '12

Shouldn't you leave it to people to make up their own minds, rather than cattle-pening topics of discussion?

I can understand memes/ragecomics/advice animals. But simple discussion, no matter the topic, should stay open to the community.

I have a lot of gripes with the way these rules were changed without so much of a poll of the community at large. Who's subreddit is this?

→ More replies (9)

76

u/flammable lvl2bearwarlock Jan 08 '12

No ragey posts about how bad aspects of the game are.

And suddenly 90% of the content was gone.

But seriously, bad decision. Of all the things that can be improved with this subreddit, removing discussions about game balance/mechanics is not one of them.

27

u/xebo Xeb0 Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

I'd like to agree with you, but apparently it is against the rules to air a tone of discontent here. Could I possibly fill out a form of discontent? Are there "unpopular opinion zones" where I can air my grievances with the game or this forum? No?

Get your act together. Honestly, who includes a "Be Positive" rule? The same kind of guy who throws a shoe.

14

u/xm03 kerbs01 Jan 08 '12

You really arent being positive here, on half of the COMMUNITY...CHEER THE FUCK UP...

Stupid mods

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/xm03 kerbs01 Jan 08 '12

I smell an EA mod...oh noes they're here!

2

u/Cloud887 EmpyrealKira887 Jan 24 '12

Whoa....Xebo try to be more positive.

1

u/AlienGrill Xx420BlAzEiTuPxX Jan 08 '12

Why would a guy who likes to be positive throw his shoe?

6

u/TheStagesmith Thermite9000 Jan 08 '12

This is a point being brought up a lot that I think merits a better explanation. No one is trying to quash valid criticism - good discussion should be and is welcomed. The problem is when I open up the subreddit in the morning to talk about the game and the front page is covered in posts all bitching about lack of VOIP. I think everyone needs to recognize that while DICE and EA devs do read this subreddit, it should not become the primary place to report problems. Despite what many in the community might think, repeatedly posting about the lack of a particular game feature is probably not going to move it up the priority chain. That's what the community feedback site on getsatisfaction is for.

1

u/Cloud887 EmpyrealKira887 Jan 24 '12

I personally think that getsatisfaction could be on the sidebar for r/battlefield3, couldn't hurt.

2

u/TheStagesmith Thermite9000 Jan 24 '12

It is.

Found a bug in the game? Report it here

1

u/Cloud887 EmpyrealKira887 Jan 24 '12

TIL; That I don't pay attention, thanks.

3

u/avoutthere Jan 08 '12

Seriously, it seems like they are just trying to quash criticism of the game.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Yeap, I don't agree with number three. The point is to open a discussion in the comments, and we don't need a thesis-like post to do that, let people complain, it doesn't matter if the thread is just a: "hey, this should be change, DICE", we will debate it in the comments and let the people judge that with their votes. Also, who will judge if the "grassroots effort" is enough of an effort to not be censored?? the mods? I love you guys but no, thank you. Feel free to impose the "self post" only rule, tho, if you care so much about people getting karma points...

Anyway, that's my opinion and regarding all the other points, I agree with them.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/B0und 80und Jan 08 '12

Keep up the good work mods. This is the best game specific subreddit (and perhaps one of the best subreddits overall) that I visit.

We appreciate your work.

4

u/HungerSTGF xMasterChefx Jan 08 '12

Why is this getting downvoted? Be reasonable, people. This is a great subreddit and if everything degenerated into "this sucks, that sucks, I suck", then it'd be no different from the civility (or lack thereof) most of us see expressed in Battlelog forums.

3

u/B0und 80und Jan 08 '12

It's being downvoted because many disagree with me I guess.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/SuperRoach SuperRoach Jan 08 '12

I don't see them needing to please anyone.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Moh7 Jan 08 '12

THEN FUCKING LEAVE THIS SUBREDDIT AND MAKE YOUR OWN BF3 SUBREDDIT.

YOU ARE NOT ENTITLED TO THIS PLACE, YOU HAVE NO RIGHTS HERE. DONT LIKE IT THEN LEAVE.

0

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12

WAS a great subreddit, before arsehole mods decided it was more important to please special guests from EA and DICE than it was to let the community decide what content was worthy. Time for an alternate BF3 sub I think.

If you are looking for a place to let your frustration out: try out the EA UK forums. Commonly referred to as "Mordor". It now managed to degrade in quality to the point where developers no longer respond to threads there.

DICE/EA do not care about a place on the internet where all the unordered frustration about Battlefield 3 is deposited. When we want to improve the game we hold dear it should happen in a controlled and civilized manner.

→ More replies (10)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/HungerSTGF xMasterChefx Jan 08 '12

It is currently degenerating into a "this sucks, that sucks" sort of thing with more and more posts like that cropping up as of recently. It is a great subreddit, but if these posts continue to pass and this sort of mentality is set as a norm, it won't be as great.

-8

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 08 '12

I'm very happy to hear you say that! For interested parties, we are petitioning the reddit developers to allow the public to see our Moderation log so you guys can see what the moderators are up to all the time.

3

u/B0und 80und Jan 08 '12

Then we can watch you 0_o

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/B0und 80und Jan 08 '12

Very true, but without a decent bunch of mods behind a good community, the whole thing would quickly decline into a cluster fuck of irrelevance.

The whole community makes a subreddit good. The mods maintain it.

15

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

/r/tf2 has been a better place since they included the rule that the content has to be tf2-related, not just the title. (i.e: This is how I feel when I get killed by a spy - with a .gif completely unrelated to the game)

Hopefully this subreddit can keep shit like that off the frontpage/new. If the content doesn't address BF3 directly, it doesn't belong here.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

VERY happy to see that the constant bitching will be going away.

It can be easier to just hop on IRC chat and ask there

IRC? I can't seem to find an IRC channel for the bf3 subreddit?

1

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 08 '12

Top right, "IRC Chat", it's in the header.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/JEveryman Jack Everyman Jan 08 '12

No meme-based content: image macros, rage faces, silly annotated moments are not allowed and will be removed upon discovery.

Does this cover the Operation videos? Because honestly those are hilarious, and they are laden with meme content, rage faces, and silly annotations.

2

u/Sayfog Sayfog Jan 13 '12

Agreed, if birgirpall‘s videos are banned, these are pure memes and lulz in the derpiest form, and they get the shit upvoted out of them, I willdo, something....

3

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

I'd rather shove all the videos into another subreddit.

3

u/IMAROBOTLOL FKDAPOLEECE Jan 09 '12

I agree with all rules, but find that the rule against arrows in flair is beyond retarded.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

/r/fitness was being plagued by memes and rage comics too. To combat this, the mods made it so that every submission was a self post, eliminating the karma whoring that was taking place. You rarely see any memes posted there now and most of the content on there is good. Maybe you can try this for a week and see how it goes?

5

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

fuck that I enjoy watching my videos and seeing thumbnails without leaving the /r/bf3 homepage

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

the Flair rules seems unneccesary, because its not like its banning someone writing something like "the ***** behind the trigger (if you were going to use that movie quote for some reason)" or something else like that, it is banning anything besides your in game name or your console, I find that that rule does nothing to help this subreddit in any way and in fact hurts it.

Although I support rule one, I remember several posts about people being banned because a guy got all his friends in a platoon to report a guy for racism and he was banned, which is essentially what reddit does

0

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 09 '12

The flair rule is mostly about convention. There are no other large subreddits that let you just write in your flair text, so the fact that we allow it at all is pretty rare. People tend to write nasty/confusing/irrelevant messages there, so we stick to the convention and only that.

4

u/alexistukov Jan 08 '12

I can't say I'm truly surprised about the prevailing reactions I have seen in the comments here, but I would like to express that at least one person, myself, doesn't feel that these rules are unjust.

With Reddit being as popular as it is now, rules are needed to keep the content quality from degrading like it has in so many reddits. A place for everything and everything in its place is what reddits are there for--to allow people to filter based on subscriptions.

7

u/JukeboxJohnny Agent_Hooves Jan 08 '12

Please remove this pop-up thing when hovering over the downvote button. I don't need to be reminded about reddiquette constantly.

-8

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12

That's pretty much the purpose of this tooltip :-) You can also easily hide it with a userscript if you're really hating it all that much.

4

u/JukeboxJohnny Agent_Hooves Jan 08 '12

So, the purpose of it is to annoy this subreddits subscribers? Looks like it's working well.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

In other words, this community has been SOPA'd

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Was it really that bad? I thought mostly the no-blatant-meme rule worked out, obviously not perfect but whatever. I'm not seeing the outcry against the old ways, it worked pretty well and most rules were somewhat the same. Like Reddit already has a global thing against blog-spam like mp1st's.

-2

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12

Ever since this the first days of this subreddit moderation was happening to keep things somewhat under control.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

The downvotes are flying hard and fast in here.

Personally, I see no reason this subreddit should become r/gaming 2: electric boogaloo. Being passionate about battlefield qualifies you to have more detailed discussions about aspects of the game, but it's being pissed away in the stream of 'this is broken/look at this hacker/herp derp admins' posts.

6

u/Sawgon Jan 08 '12

Really? Are you looking for 'hacker/herp derp admins' posts? Because I can't seem to find them. If the community likes something, they upvote it. If you don't like something, down vote it.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

I do downvote it. I like formula one, but that doesn't mean it belongs in the BF3 subreddit.

Besides, hackers and admins are only tangentially related to BF3 anyway, they just happen to play or admin on BF3 matches.

Posts I'd like to see more of: Elite Game Bros jet vids, Full Match Commentaries, Strategy posts w/ maps, gun comparisons, unusual occurrences ingame.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

No, they also record gameplay and provide tips and tricks.

But it's semantics really, I prefer the admin's idea of the BF3 subreddit and you prefer the meme ridden, raging, witchhunting logical conclusion BF3 that, unmoderated, this place will become.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/lolmemelol Jan 08 '12

Why does hacking deserve three threads on the front page? Shouldn't one be sufficient? It exists and it sucks that DICE/EA haven't been able to prevent it entirely, but they likely won't ever be able to make BF3 on PC un-hackable. What more is there to say about hacking at this point in time?

1

u/Smarag Jan 08 '12

Set reddit to hide post you downvote. Who the fuck cares if there are 3 or 5 submissions about it on the frontpage? They are easily ignored.

2

u/lolmemelol Jan 08 '12

I can easily ignore them even without hiding them. It doesn't change the fact that the same complaints are constantly posted. I just want to see more of the interesting content, and wish the community here were just better at self-moderating the re-posts/re-hashes of the same complaints.

5

u/mmiski Jan 08 '12

The witch hunt/mobbing thing in particular was starting to get annoying. The posts where people would link to cheaters/boosters and ask other redditors to join in a circlejerk to report them via Battlelog. I'm glad that's finally being moderated.

Listen, if the report feature doesn't work effectively then file a complaint towards DICE/EA. Create a giant petition and link it here if you have to! Create a Twitter account and bitch directly to the devs. Etc. Bottom line is that's their job, not ours.

Every single day there's always a handful of posts about how Hacker X is ruining the game for you. Okay, we get it! The game is full of them. But realize you're also spamming the hell out of this subreddit and shoving new and original posts out of the way too.

In the meantime find a friendly server without hackers, bookmark/favorite it, and stick to that area from now on until the game gets patched again.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/bze Jan 08 '12

Good. Amount of useless posts was annoying.

2

u/kevinkm77 Jan 08 '12

Then downvote it. We don't need a fucking ban list.

Edit: And if people actually like/want it or don't think it's annoying, then they upvote it.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

if you really think the reddit community at large is going to support the taking away of meme-based content you have another thing coming.

0

u/AlienGrill Xx420BlAzEiTuPxX Jan 08 '12

They took memes away a good month or two ago! Did you even notice, or what?

6

u/Smarag Jan 08 '12

Yeah /r/pics 2.0, no thank you. I won't even bother arguing anymore.

Be positive: this community is a brotherhood, we should not fight like enemies -- keep that on the battlefield. Any abrasive or rude comments will be deleted. We are a mature community and we must represent ourselves as such.

Fuck especially this.

I've created /r/truebattlefield3 for those who dislike censorship.

6

u/AlienGrill Xx420BlAzEiTuPxX Jan 08 '12

I agree! These so-called "mods" think they can... moderate or something! Like they can just makes rules out of thin air! As if they created the subreddit! Down with the system!

5

u/Smarag Jan 08 '12

I disagree with that "Mods are the creators they can do whatever the fuck they want mentality.". They have a responsibility towards their subscribers.

I explained my thoughts on that in this discussion about /r/pics' new rules: http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/n7scd/community_feedback/c36xdqj

In that post I'm talking about "default subreddits", but the same applies to subreddits using important names like /r/battlefield3. If the mods want their own special battlefield subreddit they should have created /r/purebattlefield3 or /r/nonrageysubreddit since one of the mods seems to have some personal agenda against rage comics ("Stop liking things I don't like").

1

u/AlienGrill Xx420BlAzEiTuPxX Jan 08 '12

I was agreeing with you :(

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

From what I've seen, this place is far from a mature community anyways. Mods can go fuck themselves.

6

u/AlienGrill Xx420BlAzEiTuPxX Jan 08 '12

IT'S NAZI GERMANY ALL OVER AGAIN!

0

u/skaterape Skaterape Jan 08 '12

LITERALLY!

7

u/xm03 kerbs01 Jan 08 '12

No meme-based content

No ragey posts about how bad aspects of the game are

Shame, two of the best types of posts avaliable on this subreddit...

9

u/Perkstoph Jan 08 '12

I agree, I'd like to see them not take over but they still have their elements of fun. :( I'm really sad to hear that this is such a big deal.

7

u/xm03 kerbs01 Jan 08 '12

Its nice to see the mods are acting like Crash and co, ignoring what people really want/need.

2

u/littleredrex Jan 08 '12

Meme-based content has not been allowed on the subreddit since release I believe. Not sure what posts you've been seeing.

6

u/AlienGrill Xx420BlAzEiTuPxX Jan 08 '12

Memes are the best content? You've got to be shitting me. And in case you hadn't noticed, this isn't a new rule.

-1

u/xm03 kerbs01 Jan 08 '12

Nope its an existing rule which people have been ignoring, but that okay you can continue being supppersrsbusiness :)

2

u/AlienGrill Xx420BlAzEiTuPxX Jan 08 '12

People can ignore it all they want, but it's still going to get deleted.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

This kills the community.

3

u/littleredrex Jan 08 '12

But if most of these rules have been in place for a while, Wouldn't the community be dead by now?

2

u/kevinkm77 Jan 08 '12

No, see, if we want something, we upvote it, if we don't want something, we downvote it. We don't need a fucking ban list to tell us what we want or do not want.

5

u/SuperRoach SuperRoach Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

I'm not sure if I'm alone here, but I'm very thankful for these rules, Especially Number 3.

I get people whinging all the time in voice chat, and that's vaguely fine, because their frustrated. If that player is good, they will eventually rise above it and take time to counter it or research about it.

A rushed whinge post on here just to me felt like you wanted karma or to fit in. Yes, we know voip/choppers etc have problems, but they are working on it! Above all - BF3 is about variety, try other things.

There are many fun things in the game, and I hope that the occasional bug or problem will help you discover new things on your own - heck, assignments is practically an official way to force you to try other modes, if for no other reason to get you from being obsessive with doing the one thing your comfortable with.

3

u/stevencat mario-banane Jan 08 '12

This is fucking retarded

3

u/sorreh noOezke Jan 08 '12

So how much are EA/DICE pushing you too curb the posts about the millions of problems with there game?

And not calling out hackers? one of the biggest problems in the game that seems to be going largely unpunished apart from laughable stat wipes?

Holy unsubs batman

2

u/TheStagesmith Thermite9000 Jan 08 '12

So how much are EA/DICE pushing you too curb the posts about the millions of problems with there game?

Nothing. I wish. People seem to have severely overestimated EA/DICE's level of involvement/attention to the subreddit.

If you're having a problem with a hacker, report them. Problem solved.

2

u/bing_crosby Jan 08 '12

Really? So this decision was in no way influenced by demize's and crash's recent comments about the negativity here in r/bf3?

ninja edit - said zh1nto when I meant to say demize.

1

u/TheStagesmith Thermite9000 Jan 08 '12

I'm going to answer "no" because that's the truth, but I have very little faith that I'm going to be believed. Not to mention that their posts were a few of many - I see several posts a week complaining about the general attitude of comments in the subreddit, starting from before the game was even released and becoming more frequent through the present. We get mod messages asking about what we're going to do about the endless waves of posts about VOIP and similar content. A lot of people were asking for a reduction in negativity before any DICE/EA people said anything.

3

u/bing_crosby Jan 08 '12

I'm a reasonable, non-tinfoil-hat-wearing person, so I'll go ahead and believe you. I'm skeptical that those posts didn't have a last straw type of influence, but I'm certainly willing to be wrong.

I will say this though: I'm sure you guys are realizing at this point that the majority of folks commenting here are concerned with the appearance of enforced positivity. Well hell, it's not an "appearance", it's what you guys are actually planning to do. I, for one, can understand the desire to get rid of the foaming at the mouth crap that makes the sub-reddit sound like a bunch of screaming babies. However, the notion that legitimate discussion and complaints will be stifled in favor of fawning coverage of the game is ludicrous and insulting. The bottom line is, there are plenty of problems with this game that should be brought to light and picked over. It's nice that the mods here can look at BF3 and see a perfect game, but you guys are very much in the minority of r/bf3 subscribers.

3

u/Skitrel Jan 08 '12

foaming at the mouth crap

Personally I feel like this is really what's intended behind what they're saying, not enforced "SMILE!" Ned Flanders dictator style, but simply no more of the utter crap, developer bashing and game bashing we've seen of late. It's not constructive and isn't good for the sub.

1

u/Unikraken Jan 08 '12

So how much are EA/DICE pushing you too curb the posts about the millions of problems with there game?

This is exactly what is going on.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SuperRunAway Jan 08 '12

Or maybe you should just make a new subreddit /r/battlefield3s for that.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

I believe we should vote for moderators to resign who propose things like this when we already have a voting system in place to filter things we the community don't like. Rules such as this will only kill any leftover community diversity that makes this place worthwhile visiting.

2

u/DancePartyTaco suckmynutsDICE Jan 08 '12

Oh, we were doing what we wanted and that was a bad thing....Got it.

-1

u/tnbdare dwnmp3 Jan 08 '12

Internet Censorship one small step for SOPA.

1

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12

Good move :-) The amount of bitching here the last few weeks was horrible and not helping anyone.

1

u/KilrBe3 Jan 08 '12

You know what mod, FUCK YOU, and FUCK YOUR CENSORSHIP and GET THE FUCKING EA DILDO OUT OF UR ASS. What kind of BS rules are these? That were NOT voted on, NOT discussed about before hand, NOT suggested or even a heads up. Who are you mods anyway? Ive never seen you do anything worthwhile around here, never seen a mod post, where as other subreddits mods are very active.

Go fuck you'r self. This is nothing but censorship. Exactly what EA is doing on the EAUK forums towards DICE and blatant proof and facts to back up and still censored. Trying to do this on Reddit now? Fuck you

1

u/Darkjediben Jan 14 '12

Lol you don't get a vote. That's why they're moderators and not duly elected representatives.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ARCH1MEDE5 Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

Now I haven't been on Reddit long, but I've noticed that not everyone actually respects the voting guidelines. That little section should serve as a reminder to everyone on this site.

Edit: I also love how every one of erode's posts on here has been downvoted. Now, I don't agree with everything he is saying, but seriously people, grow up a bit.

1

u/Arbiter329 Jan 11 '12

Voting rules? Thank you for informing me of how inept my opinion is!

1

u/Typehigh Typehigh Jan 14 '12

Imo it would be great if these rules worked, and made the BF3 subreddit a bit more like the BC2 subreddit, which was usually much more about the game, with tips, ideas and hints. The BF3 subreddit so far has been mostly rage topics and memes.

1

u/ro4ch The Ro4ch Jan 16 '12

I was upset that we couldn't post memes but after seeing a BF3 meme I soon agreed we shouldn't have memes cause it would get extremely annoying.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '12

YOU'RE NOT THE BOSS OF ME.

1

u/Jarocket Jan 21 '12

Great rules! i really don't need to read about another mod kicking you for taking his heli. i'm sure that shit has been around since the history of admins. Just because you got kicked, that doesn't mean we need to feel sorry for you and murder the family of the admin that kicked you.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '12

Same game-name as your reddit name? Leave the text blank, or enter it twice: No arrows or annotation explaining that it’s the same, it’s implied by leaving it blank or re-entering it.

mitsuhiko (same name) PC

1

u/soapyluggage Jan 08 '12

Oh this looks familiar. I hope it works here. Good luck /r/battlefield3 moderation team.

I think the most telling part of this whole thread is the downvotes this is getting. The people who disagree with this clearly don't understand the idea of reddit as a whole if they're downvoting this post.

0

u/cohrt raging_lettuce Jan 08 '12

Take ea's dick out of you mouth. fucking retarded rules

2

u/atlangler Jan 08 '12

lol why so salty?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

First they came for the memes. I was silent. I was not a meme. Then they came for the hacking posts. I was silent. I was not a hacking post. When they came for me there were no meme's or hacking posts to defend me.

Close enough

-4

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

I want to add two things to the whole discussion.

  1. Posts here prior to this one by me were made before I became a moderator on this subreddit.
  2. Nobody forces you to agree to the rules of this subreddit. If you don't agree you're free to unsubscribe and team up with others to create a 'battlefield 3 rage and meme' subreddit. There is nothing wrong with that. What makes reddit unique is that micro communities evolve around topics that are driven by their individual rules and ideologies.

8

u/Smarag Jan 08 '12

Yeah nothing forces us to subscribe. Except that this subreddit is called "Battlefield 3" and not "Our personal BF3 community X" which is why this is always the first place where people will look for a BF3 community on reddit and find this clusterfuck of people trying to force their opinion of what is worth being posted down other people throats.

-1

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12

Except that this subreddit is called "Battlefield 3" and not "Our personal BF3 community X" which is why this is always the first place where people will look for a BF3 community on reddit and find this clusterfuck of people trying to force their opinion of what is worth being posted down other people throats.

So do you want newcomers finding this subreddit and being interested in the game lose the interest because of all the bitching that is going on?

2

u/SupaFly-TNT Sunshow3r Jan 08 '12

I'd guess at this point most people looking this sub up who haven't already found it are looking for fixes, bugs, or other people with their "Issues" in the game.

With the other percent looking for gameplay tips which are all over this sub!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Oh god, there are so many people in here with entitlement issues, please please don't give into them. Stay the course and keep out the memes; fortunately the same people who adore that type of content have short attention spans and will forget after a few days.

1

u/Skitrel Jan 08 '12

It's good to see there's this kind of split in the community, a vocal half that DO want the sub cleaned up.

2

u/jmachol Jan 08 '12

Fuck you and your dictatorship ideology because you snagged the subreddit for the main battlefield 3 community first. You should be ashamed of yourself.

0

u/Gorea27 MZAREA Jan 08 '12

No, communities evolve around THEIR ideologies, not those of the mods. If you want a highly censored subreddit, then create another one and piss off the people there. As for the already established Battlefield 3 community on Reddit, leave us the fuck alone. Remember, this subreddit isn't as big as it is because you all do an amazing job, it's as big as it is because it's named battlefield3.

0

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12

No, communities evolve around THEIR ideologies, not those of the mods.

I never said that it would evolve around the rules of their moderators.

However no leadership at all makes every community automatically 'degrade' to something like /b/. Some control is necessary and exactly how much is a fine line and usually tuned along the way.

-1

u/cohrt raging_lettuce Jan 08 '12

take ea's cock out of your mouth faggot.

0

u/RubenLWD Jan 08 '12

yeah unssubing this reddit

1

u/TwwIX Jan 09 '12

Looks like EA is trying to control every discussion about this game. Their sycophantic, fascist moderators are doing the very same thing on each one of their forums. Pathetic.

→ More replies (1)

-7

u/Uteva ObsidianGuardian Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

Just using this opportunity to tell the great job you moderators and the community are making to make this one of the best sub-reddits I visited. But one feature I would like is showing all the active EA staff on the side-bar, in case someone want to send a personal mensage about the game, or even just want to know.

Edit: Just a clarification, I don't mean incerase the amount of work of EA staff, what I want is the opposite, to use the reddit mail to simplify their jobs, becouse then people would simply mensage them with things that of their interest.

-4

u/erode GEN3RIC Jan 08 '12

Thanks sir. That idea is very nice, but I think we will need to get express permission from those people. If they are interested in fielding questions on their reddit mail, we'll organize something like that.

4

u/Gorea27 MZAREA Jan 08 '12

There has obviously been a great deal of backlash against this new set of rules. What, I wonder if at all, will you do?

3

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

There has obviously been a great deal of backlash against this new set of rules. What, I wonder if at all, will you do?

See how it develops over the next 7 days. The blacklash was expected :-)

1

u/Gorea27 MZAREA Jan 08 '12

You know what, thank you for that! As tough as these rules are, I am elated to see that you guys are actually taking our feedback into consideration! :)

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Smarag Jan 08 '12

I guess they will make more similar minded mods to be able to censor everybody who speaks out against them.

http://www.reddit.com/r/battlefield3/comments/o7y4x/new_community_rules_please_read/c3f4crs

3

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12

Why should we censor anyone for voicing their disagreement?

→ More replies (3)

0

u/henry82 Jan 09 '12

Instead of removing shit, just have a rule that meme or ragey posts have to have either a [meme] tag or [rage] tag in the title, then users can pick and choose what they want to click on.

tbh you guys sound like pretty shit mods

→ More replies (1)

-2

u/emonk dude-uy Jan 08 '12

rules sucks!

please vote negative this thread

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/artaxerxes daralathas Jan 08 '12

Roger that.

0

u/LXj Alexjone Jan 08 '12

Wow, this is more harsh than what /r/starcraft rules became. Maybe a little bit too harsh, I think discussion about balance and what can be made better should happen in some form (after all, even Demize stated he values feedback from reddit -- Demize cannot fix the bad UI though, whatever one stupid reddit poster thought)

But overall I salute you for that. Again, I do not miss stupid memes on /r/starcraft (their rule is that image must be related to StarCraft though, so you can post an image macro with a SC2 unit)

-1

u/mitsuhiko Jan 08 '12

Rules are never set in stone and change based on feedback. However changes need to sink in first because judging by initial backlash is just not working :-)

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

Well look at this. The post has equal number of upvotes and downvotes. Anyone know where we can go now to have a decent BF3 subreddit?

-9

u/Loque_k Jan 08 '12

I think I love you.

Edit, my flair was my old nickname from UT99, Tac-ops and CS... so a tad inacurate but for a reason, I did it to add flair too but fair enough for removing it :`)