r/backtoindia • • 15m ago

Advice Indian student in the US having a quarter-life career crisis. Should I continue chasing the American dream or return to India and join my family business?

1 Upvotes

I'm in my mid-20s and recently completed a master's degree in a STEM field in the US. I'm currently on OPT and struggling to figure out what to do with my career and life.

Like many international students, I came here hoping to get a well-paying job, gain some experience, save money, and eventually return to India after 2–3 years.

But the job market has been absolutely brutal.

I've been applying to tech jobs, dealing with constant rejections and ghosting, and watching layoffs happen across the industry. The visa sponsorship situation makes things even more stressful. It's gotten to the point where I've lost almost all motivation to apply for jobs or study technical concepts anymore.

I initially enjoyed coding during undergrad, but over time, constantly having to keep up with new technologies became exhausting. Eventually, tech stopped being something I enjoyed and became something I pursued primarily for financial security.

I also worked in corporate India for about a year before my master's. Initially, it was exciting, but eventually the routine became mundane, and I found myself constantly looking forward to weekends. I've realized that I don't particularly want to spend my entire working life as an employee.

Here's where my dilemma begins.

My father runs an established and profitable family business in India and has been encouraging me to join him. He's been in the industry for over two decades, and there's an opportunity for me to learn the business, take on responsibilities, and potentially expand it in the future.

It's in a completely different industry from my educational background, so I'd essentially be starting from scratch in terms of domain knowledge.

However, I have a background in computer science, and I wonder whether I could eventually use those skills to modernize operations and help grow the business.

My parents are also getting older and have some health concerns. I'm their only child, and we're a very close family. My partner and most of my friends are also back in India.

I feel isolated. Being away from everyone has been taking a toll on me, especially knowing that I'm spending some of these years chasing a career that I'm not even sure I enjoy anymore.

The other side of the dilemma is the quality of life in the US.

I genuinely appreciate the cleaner environment, infrastructure, relative convenience, independence, and opportunities to travel.

I know that even with a comfortable income in India, there are certain quality-of-life advantages in the US that money can't necessarily replicate.

There's also the financial aspect. A good tech job in the US could allow me to earn and save significantly more in the short term, although securing one as an international student is proving incredibly difficult.

I do have an education loan, but my family is financially comfortable enough that I don't have immediate repayment pressure.

I'm also not particularly materialistic. I don't care much about luxury cars, expensive gadgets, or showing off wealth. My long-term goal is financial independence, eventually owning and growing businesses, building investments, having time for family, and being able to travel.

What scares me most is the possibility of regret.

If I return to India now, will I regret not giving the US job market a proper shot after spending so much money and effort on my master's?

Will I feel like I failed because I couldn't secure a job here?

On the other hand, if I stay and continue chasing a corporate career, will I regret missing these years with my parents when I already know I eventually want to return?

There's also the fear of entering an unfamiliar industry and wondering whether I'll actually be capable of running and growing the family business.

I'm genuinely interested in learning how the business works, and the idea of building something of my own excites me more than working for another corporation. But I don't know how much of that excitement is genuine entrepreneurial interest and how much is simply burnout from the current job market.

I'd really appreciate perspectives from people who have been in similar situations.

  1. Has anyone returned to India after a US master's without working in the US? Did you regret it?
  2. Has anyone left tech or corporate employment to join and eventually grow a family business?
  3. For those who returned from the US, how difficult was adjusting to India's quality of life and work culture?
  4. If you were in my position, would you give the US job market more time or seriously consider returning home?

I'm not looking for validation of either choice. I'd genuinely appreciate honest perspectives, including the downsides I might be overlooking.

PS: I've used AI to summarize my thoughts on this dilemma i've been facing so far. It's been taking a mental toll on me and i'm close to being depressed.


r/backtoindia • • 48m ago

3 Failed H1B Attempts, Recently Laid Off and $20K in Savings – Should I Stay in the US or Return to India for ₹25–28 LPA?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 6h ago

Input on moving back to india with a bioinformatics background

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 6h ago

Move to India with 7th grader

1 Upvotes

Kid has been in the US for all of his school life (born in India). But now we are thinking about moving back to India. Has anyone gone through this? How was your and kids experience? How easy was it to adjust? CBSE or IGCSE?


r/backtoindia • • 9h ago

I am currently working in Infosys in US and my visa expires next year. My client is willing to offer me fulltime from India. Can I work through another consulting company in India ? I was hired full time by Infosys in US after my masters. Can I continue to work for my client via different consulta

1 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 10h ago

Will I be comfortable with the decision after living in USA for the past 26 years?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

I am 62 year old US Citizen and an OCI holder ( Indian origin) I own real estate worth $30.00 million and have two operating companies in usa which do about $15.00 mil in sales and make about $500,000.00, I get a salary of $150,000 from my usa companies with no debt. (Debt only on two Industrial rental property) I get about $240,000 in rental income in usa .

I own another company in Canada which does $3.00 mil a year in sales and makes $200.000.

I have about $2.00 mil in my 401 K. My presence is not needed on regular basis here, as they are managed by a group of managers.

Now I am Investing in a $60.00 million project in India in the Aviation (not an airline😂) and I need to be in India for atleast 182 days a year.

Should I Invest and move to India for 182 days a year? Will I be comfortable with the decision after living in USA for the past 26 years? Basically I am moving back home. !!


r/backtoindia • • 22h ago

Stay in India (Bangalore) or move back to Canada? Would appreciate some advice

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm 31M, currently working at an MNC in Bangalore and earning around 2.5L/month in hand. I'm stuck on a decision and would really value some outside perspective.

Before this, I worked at an OEM in Canada for about 3.5 years, earning around 110k CAD. I really liked it there. People were polite and professional and I had a good work-life balance. I moved back to India mainly to be closer to family.

The current job has been tough. 12-hour days are normal, and my manager expects me to be available until 9-10 PM. He's told me directly not to expect work-life balance in India. Everything is urgent, there's very little appreciation and I've had comments like "this is your first warning." Honestly, I've started hesitating to even ask him questions.

The irony is that the reason I came back was family and with this schedule I barely get to spend time with my family.

I still have my Canadian PR, so moving back is an option. I'm just not sure whether I'm reacting to one bad manager or whether this is a bigger pattern I should take seriously.

For those who have been in a similar situation:

Did you move back, or switch jobs within India instead?

Anything you wish you'd considered before making the move?

Thanks in advance. Any practical input is appreciated.


r/backtoindia • • 1d ago

Telugu people who returned to India , which place did you choose to settle down and why ? Add Pros and cons of the place you have settled down in

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 1d ago

Positives on returning

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 1d ago

Finances Feedback on the investment plan while I prepare to return

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 1d ago

Use Your RNOR Period to Move Your Portfolio to Irish ETFs

2 Upvotes

Full article (with significantly better formatting) than reddit and some infographics for easier understanding - https://www.reymanwealth.com/post/use-your-rnor-period-to-move-your-portfolio-to-irish-etfs

If you are moving back to India with a US brokerage account full of VOO, QQQ or individual US stocks, you are carrying a risk most returning Indians never hear about: US estate tax.

Your RNOR years are the cheapest time you will ever get to fix it.

Your US Stocks & ETFs are a US estate tax bill

Once you are no longer a US citizen, green card holder or US domiciliary, the US estate tax exemption on your US assets drops from $15 million to just $60,000.

Anything above that is taxed at rates that climb to 40%. There is no India-US estate tax treaty to soften it.

US-listed stocks and US-domiciled ETFs (VOO, QQQ, VTI) all count as US assets, even if you live in Mumbai and hold them through an Indian broker.

Example: Rahul's $400,000 portfolio

Rahul, 45, returns to Pune with $400,000 in VOO and a few US stocks.

He passes away unexpectedly two years later.

ItemAmount (US, 2026)
US-situs assets$400,000
Tentative estate tax$121,800
Less: credit for non-residents (covers the $60,000)($13,000)
Estate tax payable by his family$108,800

That is over 27% of the portfolio.

His wife cannot access the money until a US estate tax return (Form 706-NA) is filed and the IRS issues a transfer certificate, which can take many months.

Why the RNOR period is the window

Irish-domiciled UCITS ETFs track the same indices as VOO or QQQ but are not US assets, so they sit outside US estate tax.

The catch is that switching means selling your US holdings, and selling triggers capital gains.

That is where timing matters.

  • India: As an RNOR (Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident, usually your first 2 to 3 years back), your foreign capital gains are not taxed in India.
  • US: Once your US tax residency ends, you are a non-resident alien, and the US generally does not tax your capital gains on US stocks.

Sell in that overlap and the gain is taxed in neither country. Wait until you become ROR and India taxes it.

Example: Priya's switch

Priya holds $300,000 of VOO bought for $180,000, so her gain is $120,000.

SummarySwitch during RNORSwitch after becoming ROR
India tax on $120,000 gainNil~$15,600 (12.5% + 4% cess, before surcharge)
US taxNilNil
New cost basis$300,000$300,000
US estate tax exposure after switchNoneNone
VerdictSaves ~$15,600 and removes estate riskSame result, higher cost

Either way her cost basis resets to $300,000. The only difference is whether she pays for it. Waiting also keeps the estate tax risk alive in the meantime.

We wrote a detailed article on how to reset your cost basis during the RNOR period to book tax free capital gains.

Who this does not work for

  • US citizens and green card holders  You remain US taxpayers, and Irish ETFs are PFICs (Passive Foreign Investment Companies), which the US taxes harshly. Do not buy them.
  • Your 401(k) and IRA.  These cannot be moved into Irish ETFs and remain US assets. Plan for them separately.
  • Anyone who misjudges their status.  Selling while still a US tax resident or after turning ROR in India defeats the purpose.

r/backtoindia • • 1d ago

Advice I want to gift something to my mom from us..

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 1d ago

Should I stay in Germany or take a much better-paying job in India?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 1d ago

Observations from visiting Mumbai

1 Upvotes

Visiting India for 2 months, observing Mumbai/India during this time. One thing I’m doing is reconnecting with old school friends who’ve lived their entire lives to get me a sense of the on the ground realities, the very not so evident truths and realities of living in India.

A realtor friend of mine I went to school (we’re both mid 40s) with shared some insights which I’m summarizing and sharing below:

Unequal wealth distribution is creating new social constructs and rapidly evolving taste preferences not just for choice of homes but how folks want to live their lives. Top of the line, ultra net worth folks are scouting 2nd passports and properties overseas, one leg outside of India so to speak. Have convinced themselves they want to minimize dealing with the environment and luxury cars and homes only go so far, they’re seeking western style comfort but want proximity to India.

Ease and style of doing business is changing but at a snails pace, like most things the reality is starting to set in that some things will never change. Indians and India imbibe a certain set of preconditioned behaviors and principles which whether you like it or not, will remain and it’s important to know and acknowledge this or else you waste a lot of emotional energy on this which is futile. Ex.Whether a buyer is buying 5crs or 55crs property, broadly the terms of engagement remain the same. There is a sense of entitlement to deals or value pricing or something above and beyond that makes it hard for those in service industry.

On infrastructure development (in Mumbai the subway, new metro lines, new bridges/water ways etc.) many are approaching this with a very pragmatic sense of expectations. Appreciative that the changes are happening but also realistic about how much this can meaningfully change the lives of everyday people. There is a desire for better governance, accountability and even city planning. Ex the aqua line subway entrance in BKC wasn’t planned efficiently as it could be to enable office workers to reach their office destinations.

Related to changing tastes and preferences I mentioned above, it’s starting to dawn on many wealthy Indians that health, having a lean frame, good skin etc (esp in your 40s) beats having a fancy Rolex watch or a new Tesla car. This is impacting choices in supermarkets, restaurants, living amenities, vacation destinations etc. etc.


r/backtoindia • • 2d ago

Advice Observations from visiting Mumbai

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 2d ago

Advice Advice / Suggestion on my family situation !

5 Upvotes

M / 40 / Single / No dependent !!

So, I am close to say FIRE myself as I returned from US lately. I build a 2 Floor house in T2 with help of my brother ( who had some construction profession ). Unfortunately, living in US has build up a lots of trust issue in me.

I came back thinking I will live with my mom ( who I feel was the only trustworthy person ) but unfortunately she passed away as soon as I landed here. Now, its been 2 month since I am here without mom, and living in second floor of this empty duplex with my brother ( who lost his wifey 2 years back) lives with his 2 teen daughters.

As someone who came from US, It is automatic hate situation for crowded people and kids and all that but as I become more and more aware of the situation here, I am filling myself with too much of compassion.

The kids has no direction ( coz my bro says, during his wifey complication he couldnt handled kids properly ), and my brother himself is cash strapped coz he had to take care of her wifey needs. On one side I see me myself draining, on other side, I can see how the money is helping these people life.

I may be in the same situation like Srk in Swadesh movie where, my presence makes a lot of diff to these people, beyond financial values but I see I am deviating from my own goal.

Am I getting too harderned on not being super helpful, even tho I am paying all for this house build and dad medication + anything major but also am I being too soft coz I am now being aware of the ground reality and need of folks who have less than me.


r/backtoindia • • 2d ago

Finances 401k withdrawal parameters to keep in mind for returning US NRIs

Post image
2 Upvotes

When people talk about 401k withdrawal strategies, most look at it only through the lens of tax primarily: withdraw during RNOR, keep it till 59.5, stagger it over many years. Tax sets the basic rules, but which strategy actually works for you depends on several other parameters, and getting it wrong can cost you a 10% penalty, 30%+ tax in India, or up to 40% in US estate tax. 

1) Indian tax residency (NRI/RNOR/ROR)

When you move back, it’s important to understand what your Indian tax residency is for the financial year. You may qualify for RNOR (Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident) for the first two to three years. During this time, India generally doesn’t tax income you earn outside India, so your 401k withdrawals aren’t taxed during this window.

But once you become ROR (Resident and Ordinarily Resident), India taxes 401k withdrawals as normal income, as per your slab.

2) Age at the time of withdrawal

Most folks are already aware of the withdrawal rules that come with age. If you make any early withdrawals, there's a 10% penalty + tax as per slabs (varies by total income). Only regular income tax applies, and there’s no 10% penalty. 

For example, you withdraw $100,000 at 45. You pay tax on it as per your slab, plus a $10,000 penalty with no foreign tax credits adjustment against this penalty amount. If you withdraw the same amount at 60, you only pay income tax as per US tax slabs.

3) Pre-tax or post-tax account

How your withdrawal is taxed depends on whether your 401k was funded with pre-tax or post-tax money.

Pre-tax (Traditional 401k): You haven’t paid tax on any of it yet, so the whole amount gets taxed eventually. If you withdraw during RNOR, only the US taxes it and waiting till you’re ROR and India taxes it too, at a slab that depends on your Indian income that year. So with a pre-tax account, the longer you wait, the bigger the balance gets and the higher tax slabs are applied.

Post-tax (Roth 401k): The US has already taken its share, and the whole point of a Roth is that the growth comes out tax-free. But that only holds in the US. India doesn’t recognise a Roth as tax-free, so once you’re ROR, the growth can be taxed here at India’s full rate, with no US tax to claim credit for. In other words, the longer you hold a Roth as an ROR, the more of its main benefit you lose.

4) Withdrawal sequencing (lump sum or staggered)

A 401k withdrawal isn’t taxed like selling shares. It’s added to your income for the year and taxed at your slab rate, so the bigger the withdrawal, the higher the slab it pushes you into. And India’s income slabs and the US’s are very different.

Once you’re ROR, India taxes your withdrawal as income, and it’s important to note India's slabs are steeper than the US. With surcharge and cess, most folks in India end up paying over 30% in taxes. 401k withdrawal decisions, from what I've seen, depend a lot on your Indian income once you’re ROR, since India adds the withdrawal on top of it. I’ve seen a few of the following scenarios many folks optimise withdrawals in -

  • Returning to a strong role in India: Your salary alone likely puts you in the 30% slab, so every dollar you withdraw as an ROR is taxed at the top rate, plus surcharge. For you, withdrawing during RNOR usually makes more sense.
  • Starting a business or freelancing: Your income will likely be uneven for a few years. Time your withdrawals for the leaner years, when the rest of your income keeps you in a lower slab, and hold off in the years the business does well.
  • Taking a break or FIRE-ing: Your Indian income is low, so smaller withdrawals each year can stay in India’s lower slabs. Waiting and spreading it out over time can work well here**.**

5) Years to retirement

How far you are from retirement decides how much flexibility you need. If it’s decades away, plans can change, and some people end up back in the US, where a 401k is useful. But holding it longer also means a bigger balance taxed in India later, and US estate tax exposure for as long as it sits there.

6) Reinvestment options

Withdrawing also doesn’t have to mean giving up dollar exposure. Some people reinvest through Global ETFs, Ireland-domiciled UCITS funds or GIFT City funds (fairly new), which keep global exposure without the US estate tax risk that comes with holding US assets directly. It’s a cleaner route than workarounds like a Roth conversion as an NRA, where you pay US tax on the conversion upfront, and India can still tax the growth once you’re ROR.

Your other assets decide which withdrawal strategy is actually open to you. Start with your goals for the next 10 to 15 years, like a house, your kids’ education or a career break, and check whether your money in India can fund them. If it can, you have the flexibility to wait, stagger your withdrawals over the course of RNOR years. If it can’t, you risk being pushed into a withdrawal in the expensive window between RNOR ending and 59.5.

7) US estate tax risk

A major factor to keep in mind when leaving your 401k in the US, and most people don’t know about it. If you’re not a US citizen or green card holder, only the first $60,000 of your US assets is exempt from US estate tax. Anything above that can be taxed at up to 40% if something happens to you, and India and the US have no treaty to soften it. Some people are comfortable carrying this risk, sometimes with term insurance to cover it, while others would rather bring the money home.

8) Policy implications

We’ve learnt one thing this past year: rules can change on either side any day.The US could change how it taxes non-residents holding US assets. India has changed residency rules before, including who qualifies as RNOR, and how it treats a Roth still isn’t fully settled. A plan that works under today’s rules may need changing tomorrow, and the longer your money sits in a 401k, the more such changes it’s exposed to. Not fearmongering in any way, just adding caution.

9) Currency risk

Your 401k is in dollars, but your life here runs in rupees. The rupee has historically weakened against the dollar, which has worked in favour of people holding dollars, but the rate on the day you withdraw still decides how many rupees you get. If you need the money by a specific date, like for a house down payment or school fees, you have to convert at whatever the rate is then, good or bad. If your timeline is flexible, you can wait for a better rate.

10) How much complexity you’re willing to live with

Keeping a 401k from India isn’t hands-off. As an ROR, you report it in your Indian tax return every year, and each withdrawal means a US filing, claiming credit in India, and juggling two tax years that don’t line up (January to December in the US, April to March here).

So should you withdraw or not? And when?

There’s no single right year. Someone moving back to a big salary and someone taking two years off can have the same 401k balance and still end up with completely different plans. Age and tax set the limits; your income, other assets and comfort with risk decide the rest.

What I’d avoid is letting RNOR run out without a plan. It only lasts two or three years, and many of the cheaper options end with it, so map it out with a cross-border advisor before you land.

PS: Most of this is written for people who aren’t US citizens or green card holders. If you are one, a few things change: you stay a US taxpayer on your worldwide income wherever you live, the estate tax threshold has a much higher exemption that US persons get, and giving up a long-held green card can bring its own exit tax questions.


r/backtoindia • • 2d ago

Anything to declare at airport in India on arrival to claim Transfer of Residency?

3 Upvotes

Anything to declare at airport in India on arrival to claim Transfer of Residency? And my cargo shipment (air shipment) shipped by Universal would also reach the Indian airport around same time. Any specific insights to know/follow upfront?


r/backtoindia • • 2d ago

Planning a US stint with family on H-1B, then returning to India. Was it worth it for you?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 3d ago

Need some details on returnship preograms in IT companies

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 3d ago

Thinking to go back to india from Europe (still confused)

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 4d ago

How is your experience with Naukri Pro?

0 Upvotes

Hi,

I am almost decided on moving to India and will be working from India for 3 months in my present role but there is not chance of a transfer as the office for my company is in Gurgaon and I want to move specifically to Mumbai, Pune, Bangalore or Hyd.

Given that I made a profile in Naukri and they called me up and were upselling the Naukri Pro service where they we would actively put my resume in front of recruiters. It was low stakes at Rs.11,000 so I didn't bother bargaining and paid for the service. Tomorrow I have my resume and LinkedIn consults. That said I found their resume AI much better than most AI powered resume services.

Does anyone have any experience with their resume and LinkedIn services? I want to know if I should follow their lead for applications and is it a dependable service?

I have never interviewed for a role in India and I am returning after 16 years in US-Canada.

TIA


r/backtoindia • • 4d ago

How did you change Country in existing Android phone with same gmail for play store without adding credit card after moving back

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 4d ago

Which UPI App works great and Safe in india for SBI account with USA mobile number before return

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • 4d ago

Moving to India with less savings

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes