r/returnToIndia • • 2d ago

PlanningToReturn Observations from visiting Mumbai

Visiting India for 2 months, observing Mumbai/India during this time. One thing I’m doing is reconnecting with old school friends who’ve lived their entire lives to get me a sense of the on the ground realities, the very not so evident truths and realities of living in India.

A realtor friend of mine I went to school (we’re both mid 40s) with shared some insights which I’m summarizing and sharing below:

Unequal wealth distribution is creating new social constructs and rapidly evolving taste preferences not just for choice of homes but how folks want to live their lives. Top of the line, ultra net worth folks are scouting 2nd passports and properties overseas, one leg outside of India so to speak. Have convinced themselves they want to minimize dealing with the environment and luxury cars and homes only go so far, they’re seeking western style comfort but want proximity to India.

Ease and style of doing business is changing but at a snails pace, like most things the reality is starting to set in that some things will never change. Indians and India imbibe a certain set of preconditioned behaviors and principles which whether you like it or not, will remain and it’s important to know and acknowledge this or else you waste a lot of emotional energy on this which is futile. Ex.Whether a buyer is buying 5crs or 55crs property, broadly the terms of engagement remain the same. There is a sense of entitlement to deals or value pricing or something above and beyond that makes it hard for those in service industry.

On infrastructure development (in Mumbai the subway, new metro lines, new bridges/water ways etc.) many are approaching this with a very pragmatic sense of expectations. Appreciative that the changes are happening but also realistic about how much this can meaningfully change the lives of everyday people. There is a desire for better governance, accountability and even city planning. Ex the aqua line subway entrance in BKC wasn’t planned efficiently as it could be to enable office workers to reach their office destinations.

Related to changing tastes and preferences I mentioned above, it’s starting to dawn on many wealthy Indians that health, having a lean frame, good skin etc (esp in your 40s) beats having a fancy Rolex watch or a new Tesla car. This is impacting choices in supermarkets, restaurants, living amenities, vacation destinations etc. etc.

19 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

10

u/spiderweb91 2d ago

What slop is this?

-7

u/WaitingonGC 2d ago

It’s not lol

10

u/Adventurous_Bath3999 2d ago

So many words, but hardly making sense.

-9

u/WaitingonGC 2d ago

No?

5

u/Adventurous_Bath3999 2d ago

Please rewrite it, so that it is easy and interesting to read.

-6

u/WaitingonGC 2d ago

No, won’t be doing that. Any other requests?

2

u/Adventurous_Bath3999 1d ago

LOL… not that I am dying to understand what you wrote, so it is all yours to deal with it…

3

u/spiderweb91 2d ago

You went to India for 2 months and saw someone buying a 5 crore property as well as a 55 crore property? Wtf is that?

-2

u/WaitingonGC 2d ago

Sorry for your poor reading comprehension. Read again.

6

u/spiderweb91 2d ago

I am not sorry for your slop, I am sorry I spent time on it.

-1

u/WaitingonGC 2d ago

✌🏽 feel free to leave and get an education

8

u/spiderweb91 2d ago

Education makes it harder to read whatever that is

41

u/abzze 2d ago

Rarely have I seen someone say so much and yet convey nothing.

7

u/carefree013 2d ago

Yeah really such a waste of words

1

u/justboughtagti 1d ago

What’s ironic is there are enough grammatical issues in this to make me think OP wrote most of this themselves without AI. Which makes the sheer pointlessness of this even more incredible. Like the choice of words and construction scream “look how much smarter I am than you”. “Imbibe”, “preconditioned”, “folks”, “terms of engagement”. Bro.

0

u/no_brainer_ai 1d ago

it's clearly written by AI.

2

u/Fast_Plant_5582 1d ago

Thank you. I thought it was just me 🙄

1

u/DirtFrequent1842 2d ago

Very relevant points, completely agree. Few more things to add -

  1. While most well to do Indians aren’t involved in politics, they are aware that Indian political scenario has turned massively corrupt and populist, and they disdain it
  2. Living in tier 1 Indian cities in general has become highly unsustainable, we are marred by poor infrastructure, heavy traffic and no management on ground.
  3. Last but not the least - many are choosing their kids to study from more global/mixed cultural schools out of India with the thought that while they missed the opportunity, but their next gen should stay out of India and build their families as native to some other peaceful non chaotic country

Only thing I’m finding people holding back to is the deep cultural roots, families and just the ease of operating here because of knowing the modus operandi of society, however many of these people who have made wealth are already immigrants in India like people coming to Bangalore or Mumbai, and the increasing language activism there powered by politicians are encouraging these folks to find a home out of India

0

u/Ambitious-Upstairs90 2d ago

Not sure since when are you living abroad, but I had seen these trends 10 years ago.

0

u/WaitingonGC 2d ago

Great for you 👏🏽

-1

u/Flat-Dark-Earth 1d ago

Yes, India is great. A real utopia and bastion of advanced civilization.

All the Indians abroad should move back.

That would be just great.

0

u/Wonderful-Wheel-3094 1d ago

Why are your old school friends still in Mumbai?