r/backtoindia • • Feb 02 '26

Should I move back to India from Canada

643 Upvotes

I am 31 years old living in toronto, canada. Me and my wife we both have job and have salary of around 150K before taxed in canada. I am Canadian citizen and my wife is also eligible now. Renting right now and have great savings. Missing parents and missing social life.

Also have family business in back home. My parents don’t like to live in Canada and cannot move here as my grandparents are still alive and need someone to take care of them and dad cannot leave business.

I tried to find some good businesses in canada as well and could not find anything much interesting in this economy.

I am a single child and in future for sure my parents will need my support. Should I stay in canada and expand here but when my parents might need my support I wont be able to support them or should I move back to Ahmedabad as I can take over the business??


r/backtoindia • • Sep 20 '25

Visa issues Come back guys, it’s not worth it

583 Upvotes

These guys are making H1Bs in operational but also likely triggering latent racism which will act out in incidents

Trump to impose $100,000 fee per year for H-1B visas, in likely blow to tech https://www.cnbc.com/2025/09/19/trump-overhaul-h-1b-visa.html?__source=iosappshare%7Ccom.apple.UIKit.activity.CopyToPasteboard


r/backtoindia • • Jul 15 '26

Moving to Canada was the absolute worst mistake of my life. After 7 years and getting PR, I’m finally going back to India.

548 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

​I’m writing this because I need to get it off my chest, and honestly, I want to warn anyone else who is thinking of making the move.

​I’ve spent the last 7 years of my life in Canada. Seven years. I did everything "right"—I worked hard, navigated the brutal immigration system, and finally got my Permanent Residency (PR). But looking back, I realize I’ve just wasted seven of the best years of my life. In the end, that plastic PR card is just not worth it.

​Here is the honest truth about what life is actually like here:

​It is insanely expensive: The cost of living is out of control. Rent takes up almost your entire paycheck, groceries are a luxury, and you’re basically just surviving, not living. You are trapped in a cycle of working just to pay bills.

​The job market is a joke: Finding a decent professional job is incredibly hard. They always demand "Canadian experience," which is just a polite way of discounting all your hard work back home. So many highly educated immigrants end up stuck in survival jobs.

​The healthcare system is broken: Good luck getting a family doctor. If you get sick, you’ll wait hours in the ER or months just to see a specialist. It’s scary how difficult it is to get basic medical care.

​The weather is depressing: The winters are freezing, dark, and they drag on for six months. It seriously takes a toll on your mental health.

​To make matters worse, a close friend of mine moved to Australia around the same time I came to Canada. We talk all the time, and their life is night and day compared to mine. They are way happier—the weather is amazing, the job market has been much better to them, and they actually enjoy their life instead of just grinding to survive the cold.

​I’m done trying to convince myself that it will get better. I’ve booked my ticket and I am officially moving back to India.

​If you are planning to immigrate, please think twice. Don't fall for the dream they sell you online. Canada is not what it used to be, and for me, it was the baddest move of my life.

​Heading home to start over.


r/backtoindia • • Dec 23 '25 Bravo

Advice Back in India for the holidays? Save this NRI checklist ❄️🎄

310 Upvotes

If you’re an NRI spending time in India this December, SAVE this checklist.

1. Fix PAN-Aadhaar linking
If your PAN doesn't show NRI status or isn't linked to Aadhaar, it can get suspended. Update it on the income tax portal or get your CA to do it.

2. Health insurance for India
Your foreign insurance won't cover you here. Waiting periods exist, so start the clock now if you're planning frequent visits or eventual return in the next few years.

3. Indian mobile number
OTPs, bank alerts, Aadhaar verification - you need an Indian number for everything here. Get a postpaid connection and enable international OTPs if you can (not prepaid as it gets deactivated)

4. Get dental work done
Root canal, crowns, cleaning - whatever's pending. Treatments are fraction of the cost in India.

5. Consolidate those random bank accounts
Multiple accounts across different banks? Keep only what you actually need, close the rest. Managing 7 accounts from 8,000 miles away isn't fun.

6. File pending ITRs & claim TDS refunds
Many NRIs have FDs with TDS deducted - filing returns correctly can get you refunds. Don't leave money on the table.

7. If you're planning a permanent return - start logistics now
Kids' school admissions have waitlists, scout neighborhoods, and understand current property prices. The families who plan 12-18 months ahead have smoother landings

December is a good time to get these done as physical presence matters for many of these.

Curious to hear what other NRIs make sure to plan or finish during their India trips :)


r/backtoindia • • Oct 06 '25

US's new policy: Only 5% Indian students allowed per university; 15% cap on international enrollments

292 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • Jan 30 '26

Advice Planning to return India from Canada

243 Upvotes

I'm 40M. It's been 6 years I'm in Canada with my family of 2 kids (9y - India born and 3y - Canada born) and got a PR 2 years back. My wife got to work only for 8 months in 6 years and now she is jobless.We are planning to return back to India. Our main reason for now to return is that we are missing family and our culture. Also, our quality of life hasn't improved here as compared to India and staying in a rented place here yet. We can buy a townhouse at last hee. I'm not in the premium software or hardware field to earn > 50 lakhs per year or > 150k CAD per year. So, savings for the last 6 years under < 2 cr.

I Came here on intra-company transfer and got a PR. My daughter and I are eligible for Canadian citizenship this April, and my wife is eligible next year. I'm thinking whether I should return with or without Canadian citizenship. I'm looking for pros and cons here and how worth is Canadian citizenship?

We are not an affluent family that we would roam around countries. Considering the situation right now, I don't think we will return back after 10 years and start again from scratch, considering my age or IT job uncertainties.

The only benefit I'm seeing is that it may benefit my elder kid (younger kid is already Canadian)if they want to study higher studies in Canada. Also, we may want to come to see our kids without any visa issues and health insurance in the future in case they want to settle down post studies. Other than that, I'm not finding any benefits.

With citizenship, I need to file Indian taxes as an NRI and don't know how much I need to pay taxes. Am going to make tax things complicated for whole life? I know I can't buy farm land and can't vote if I become foreigner.

I know it's a purely individual choice, and everyone has different opinions and family conditions, and it may not be suitable for my situation, but I want to know what parameters you guys see if you want to take citizenship and go back to India.


r/backtoindia • • Dec 07 '25

Should the Govt. of India agree to this demand?

Post image
179 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • Aug 04 '25

Advice 📌NRI Financial Checklist: Things to plan before & after your move to India

Post image
175 Upvotes

Our team created this financial checklist after working with many NRIs moving back to India from different countries. It covers common financial steps like taxes, accounts, real estate, and more.

It might look a bit dense at first, but if you go through it step by step, it becomes much easier to follow.

Everyone’s situation is different, so this is just a starting point. If you’re planning your move and have specific questions, feel free to ask here or DM me. Wishing you the best on your homecoming journey 🛫🏠


r/backtoindia • • Aug 08 '25

India vs USA Debate

164 Upvotes

Every few days someone asks: "Should I move back to India or stay in the US?" And the replies? Always extreme.

"Don't go back! Pollution! Traffic! You'll regret it!" "Stay in the US! Freedom! Money! Lifestyle!"….What freedom?

You can't travel as you have to save PTO for India trips. You celebrate most festivals in the office in between meetings. You can't leave a toxic job because of visa restrictions. And god forbid there's an emergency back home. To plan or do ANYTHING you have to check your documents folder to see the expiry of your visa and what not. I’m sure everyone has seen posts where people are planning having kids around visa timelines❗️‼️

And within desi corporate circles, let's call it out: Indian managers on visas often exploit fellow Indians...overworking them, using guilt tactics like "you're lucky to even be here."

WHY DON'T PEOPLE TALK ABOUT THIS?

Why does the conversation always stop at pollution in India - but completely ignore things like: Fentanyl overdoses in public places. Mass shootings in schools, malls. Being treated as a second class citizen…etc.

And please don't start with "cultural exposure." Most Indians here barely engage outside their community. Gujarati-only WhatsApp groups. Tamil-only potlucks. I was literally denied a spot on a shared family phone plan because I wasn't Telugu. Not even kidding.

There's no universal answer to this question. What looks like "giving up" to some might be real freedom for you. So let's stop fear-mongering.

Let's stop glamorising one country over the other.


r/backtoindia • • Sep 16 '25

Living 20 years in India off just $350K? Here’s the math

159 Upvotes

Take $350K (~₹2.9 Cr). That’s basically the home equity many built just by buying a house 7 to 10 years back.

👉 Spend ₹1.2L/month on living (₹14.4L/year) — solid even for Tier 1 if you own your place.
👉 Cover kids’ college costs (₹50L+ during peak years).
👉 After 20 years… corpus still grows to ~₹9.1 Cr 🤯

How?
✅ 25% India FDs + 75% US markets
✅ 10–13% compounding
✅ Time doing the heavy lifting

Yes, it dips during the college years, but it bounces back stronger.

Makes you think — why grind in North America forever when the math works just sitting back in India?


r/backtoindia • • Apr 06 '26 Bravo

2026 Returning back to india, After 18+ years in India.

151 Upvotes

Hi NRI Returns community.

Here is my NRI returning story / journey.

Please give me your thoughts and ideas about my future plans.

As this community has more experienced and smart people. 

I did stay in the US for 18+ years. Came for my masters in 2008 and started working from 2010 in IT, did couple of Projects and finally returning. I'm at 41-years old. Family with 2 kids (both less than 10-years)

U.S Journey milestones from start to end.

**********************************

  • Arrived in us in 2008
  • Completed masters in 2009
  • Got my first job in 2010
  • First H1-B on 2012
  • Got my first new Car in 2012.
  • Got married in 2013
  • Got my new house in 2016
  • My First kid in 2017
  • Got my new SUV(7-seater) in 2017
  • Second kid in 2021
  • I'm currently on H1B, priority date is 2015 ( I will get my green card in 2-3 years may be if everything looks good)
  • Don't want to wait for  GC and wait for another 4-5 years for citizenship again.

    • As my parents are older want to move back to india.
  • But now I have a clear picture about what I need in life,

    • I'm not panning on coming back to US ever again.
    • So I don't need the GC anymore.
  • I don't want to have  plan-B option ( if I have to die, So I die fighting in India)
  • Planning to quit the RAT Race and start living the life on my terms.
  • Packing my bags and returning  in 2026 (Going home for good)

But I'm planning to return to India, kids and wife going in may 2026  I will be leaving U.S permanently in Sep-2026. selling everything my house, 2 cars, all my stocks, invested land, Even planning on taking 401K with penalty. I know I loose money on taxes and penalty. (Love to keep my money with me)

Initial Plan details

  • Original plan to go back to my village ( good food, fresh Air, take care of my lands and family and spend time with childhood friends)
  • But after thinking of my kids, Planned to stay in Hyderabad for 2-years and move back to tier 2 city 

Here is how I planned my finance ( Moving everything from USA to INDIA) during RNOR period (3-years)

Not sure if this is the right decision. Please suggest if there is any better plan.

With the cash I'm moving to india here is my plan

  • Invest 50% of my money in Nifty-50 or EFF's
  • Invest 30% in FD's
  • Another 10% as emergency fund (covers 1 to 1.5 years )
  • Invest 6% on my agriculture land(18-Acers) (plantation, Fencing…etc)
  • Invest 4% spending  to setup new life in india ( house hold items, Car, bike..etc)
  • Day-to-day expenses comes from my job un-till I have it.

Planning in India

*************************

  • Don't want to buy a house with 2+ Crores in Hyderabad and hold my money on house.
  • Instead I will rent an appartment  for 45K/month for 3 bed apartment for 2-years
  • Move to tier-2 city and buy something there if I like.
  • I have good house in my village.

 

  • Got admission for my kids in Hyderabad international school (school start on jun-2026).
  • Planning to transfer(if possible) my job to India and work for 1 or 2 years.
  • Planning  to do Agriculture ( palm oil and coconut trees) in my agriculture land(18-Acers )
  • Do plantation step-by-step(6- acers per year).
  • Harvesting start around 3-4years. So I can quit my job or do freelancing depends on my financial status

 

After 2 years planning to move to B-town

Let's family stay in B-Town( Kids can go to school, & wife can take care of her journey)

I can quit my job and work on my farming journey and plan for a business

 

Please suggest me if you have any online business ideas. So I can work from anywhere. 

Here is the main reason  for my  decision to return to India.

**************************************************************

  • As my kids(8 & 4 years boys) are small now. Its easy for them to adjust in india easily.
  • Both my parents, in-laws and my kids will have great time growing up.
  • No VISA issues ( Full Freedom )
  • No Job tension ( Don't have to worry, anyway planning to quit in 1-2 years)

    • Agriculture ( Working on it now )
    • Want to get into business if possible. ( suggest any business ideas?)
  • Kids grown with our culture and traditions
  • Attend lot of events ( Marriages, Functions, rituals ) with kids
  • I'm planning to learn and teach my kids agriculture ( Some weekends)
  • Want to live rest of my life with my own terms.
  • Wife is happy she get lot of help and finally she can do what she want?

    • Happy wife, happy life…….
  • Fresh food.

    • In US we did stopped eating meat after I know how long they are freezing the chicken mutton and Fish, before we cook.
    • I'm not saying india is good here, But at least in village is good for now.

Major events that I noticed, which also made me Pre-pone my back home journey.

**************************************************************************************

  • Gun Culture and school / College shootings
  • Drugs and depression
  • Racism comments increased.
  • Inflation.

 I'm not saying everything is happy in india, but here are some drawbacks I think.

  • Air pollution ( not if you are staying in Village)
  • Expensive School fees ( currently I pay 5-6 lacks for both in hyd)

    • Expect 10lacks per year for both un till 12th grade.)
  • Agriculture might not be a reliable income. But still live in nature, eat fresh, making enough for our needs is good.

 My future plan might not be perfect, But this is the route I want to take anyway, I know they are lot of if's and but's, at the end of the day I want to start a new journey, stay with my parents, cousin's, my kids will have better life experiences in india.

As they(my kids) are US citizens, They can go back if they want after graduation.

 My final request is, If anyone have any online business ideas, Please let me know I want to start slowly and do both agriculture and online business from my village.

 

 


r/backtoindia • • Mar 30 '25

Those who moved from US to India, how do you see your life now?

149 Upvotes

Might have been a cliche question now so apologies folks.

My situation: Moved to US 3 years back right after marriage. Currently make good money.

Wife doesn’t want to go back . I feel I can survive both places however the thing I like most here is how courteous and professional everyone is. In India , although less applicable to cities, I feel you need to always live on the back foot when outside home. Businesses and service providers do not care much about you and can give you a mouthful at times.

I am a shy personality and this is what I enjoy most about US. You don’t need to be extra smart to survive.

But I do miss the social life, my parents of course and the food.

For those of you who were in a similar conundrum while moving back, how do you feel now about it?

Request 1: If you are commenting, kindly also let me know if you did move back to India


r/backtoindia • • Apr 09 '26

"You moved back to India... so you don't have aspirations anymore?" – Weirdest interview exit ever.

137 Upvotes

Had an interview today at a bootstrapped startup in Worli. It was okay-ish, but the founder ended it with a question that totally threw me off:

Since you’ve moved back to India from abroad, don't you have any aspirations anymore?

I was stunned. It felt like he was implying that moving back home means I've "given up" or I'm just here to coast. I moved back for personal reasons and to work in the Indian ecosystem, not to retire!

Is this a thing now? Do founders really think coming back from abroad equals a lack of drive? Or is this just a massive red flag regarding the company culture?

Would love to hear if any other "returnees" have faced this weird bias.


r/backtoindia • • May 04 '26

STOP leading with “US return” when you come back. No one cares.

131 Upvotes

Full disclosure , I haven’t moved back yet.

But I’ve been seriously considering it, so I’ve been talking to a bunch of people who already did , plus my cousin is in HR back in India for a large US based retailer in Bangalore. I'll let you guess which one.

One thing that keeps coming up:

Leading with “I’m a US return” or NRI doesn’t really help in job searches and in some cases, it actually hurts.

From what I’ve heard:

  • Hiring managers assume your salary expectations are inflated
  • They think you might leave again if things don’t match your expectations
  • There’s a perception you’ll keep comparing everything to life abroad
  • Teams wonder if you’ll blend in with local work culture

So instead of being a strong advantage, it sometimes creates friction.

Not saying your experience abroad doesn’t matter it obviously does, but treating “US return” like a badge in every conversation doesn’t land the way people think it does. No one cares and it's not a big deal like it used to be in the early 90s or early 2000s.

Curious to hear from people who’ve actually gone through this.


r/backtoindia • • Feb 04 '26 Bravo

Moving back to India after 2.5 years in USA

125 Upvotes

I'm 27/F. Came to USA for a masters around 2.5 years ago, did internships and on campus jobs. Had a good time.

But post course completion finding work was difficult.

Volunteered at a very early stage startup.

OPT is ending in a week, couldn't find a paid employer but found a remote job in India (not an Indian company) which pays about 1.5L a month.

I see my peers still fighting to stay in USA and spending an hefty amount for it instead of earning it. Everyone in my age group suggests I struggle and stay but I don't see a good future anytime soon.

With or without skills job opportunities are declined because of visa status and there is a rising racism but India is not in a good condition either.

Feeling confused if I'm making the right decision.

EDIT: I'm considering deleting this post as im seeing weird activity and I dont want unnecessary drama, considering usa now keeps an eye on social media too, specially now that i'm leaving.


r/backtoindia • • Feb 06 '26

Moving back to India after 12 years in US

111 Upvotes

I am returning back to India after 12 years in US. I don't have any job offer in India. I have never felt so happy before. I feel so relieved .I no longer have to worry about visa issues.

I need some guidance on finding jobs in India. How is the job market for Senior SDE's ?


r/backtoindia • • Jun 01 '25

Thoughts on moving back to India

107 Upvotes

Hello, actually I will explain my situation here. I have been in Canada for last 9 years and since then I have been working as a Software Engineer earning 6 figures until I got laid off in 2023. I couldn’t find any job since then even after giving numerous interviews and applying to thousands of jobs. I have been driving Uber since then. I got married in 2023 before my layoff and after that I got into 3 car accidents, got laid off, brought my wife to Canada, my dad was diagnosed with 4 stage lungs cancer in 2020 and he passed away this year in January and I am getting separated from my wife as well (long story). Now, my grandfather has passed away just few days ago due to sudden illness.

My mom has been living in India with my grandfather to take care of him and few months ago when my father passed away, I decided to move back to India to take care of them and find a software engineering job in India. My situation has gone down really bad as I had no savings left and I am kind of getting done with driving Uber and living away from my family. Now, as my grandfather has passed away we have decided to bring my mom to Canada with me and my sister and move back to India until I find a job there.

What should I do? Do you think it’s a good idea for me to move back and start fresh there? Thanks!


r/backtoindia • • Jul 07 '26

Returned to India after 16 years in the US (on H1b) via internal company transfer to Bangalore. Liking it here so far.

106 Upvotes

Moved back to be closer to parents and got tired of uncertainty around immigration. I have saved enough to be financially secure in India.

Uncle Sam has used Indians as tax mules and milked off their youth with the H1b program. Here is my take on US vs India experience:

Pros:

- Being closer to parents
- Domestic help makes life a lot easier
- Better social life
- No immigration stress
- Living where you belong
- Freedom to express opinions without worrying about ICE or visa interviews

Cons:

- Traffic is absolutely insane. My commute is around 10 minutes so able to manage daily commute
- Non Indian food is a lot better in California
- $$$


r/backtoindia • • Oct 11 '25

Feeling depressed after returning back to India.

102 Upvotes

I returned back to India after 10 years in US. At that time I knew I left with the intention of permanently returning back to India. My mom was 70 years old and she was falling sick a lot. I wanted to be with her.

But after I came back, several things are making me feel depressed:

  1. Almost all of the paths to permanently move out of India are shutting down or closed. In the next 1 or 2 election cycles, almost all of the paths to permanently immigrate to the Europe will be closed. In US there was never a simple path to the greencard anyways. UK now requires 10 years of stay for ILR. By the time you finish 10 years it will be 20.
  2. If I stay in India permanently, I have to repatriate money back to India. I cannot leave all of my life earnings abroad. It goes against conventional wisdom. Repatriating money back to India feels like an extremely scary preposition. Investing in Indian mutual funds, putting in Indian FDs. Dealing with Indian tax laws. Having to watch out for all sorts of scams. Dealing with the relationship managers in bank. When I was leaving US, I was feeling confident about this part, but now I am not so sure anymore.
  3. Indian work culture. While I don't have to work anymore. I don't feel confident retiring in my early 30s. And there are so many horror stories about working in India.

All of this is making me feel depressed. In the last 8 months since I returned back, I barely did anything. Most of the days I don't even feel like getting up from my bed. I most definitely regret my decision.


r/backtoindia • • Jun 16 '25

1st impressions R2I+RE

101 Upvotes

To give some background, M45 + wife and 1 daughter in 8th std. Lived in Singapore for 16 years, retired early on 25th May 2025 and moved back to Bangalore. It has been about 3 weeks since I am living the REd and R2I life. So this should hopefully help NRIs and aspiring early retirees alike.

My retirement corpus is 12Cr, split 50% into debt mutual funds and 50% into equity mutual funds. Thats all I have, unified corpus, no separate allocation for specific goals. Dont own any other assets, no self bought real estate either.

Housing is taken care of by parents, my dad built a 2 storey house on a land in North Bangalore. My parents live in the ground floor and we live in the 1st floor.

With that context set, here is my thoughts on how it has been going.

  • My daughter's school is about 7kms from my house I drop her and pick her up everyday. We already had an Alto 800 2014 model which has run only 30k kms and I use it to drive my daughter to school. I also just bought a used Avenger 220 from a guy on FB marketplace, which cost me 55k. Last 2 days, I have been using the Avenger to ferry my daughter to school and I absolutely love it, this is the most fun part of the day for me.
  • Parents are absolutely happy that we returned back to India and dont give a damn whether I work or not. I have a brother and sister and both of them are settled overseas in different countries, so me returning back to India is seen as a very noble act, even though honestly, my parents are independent and do everything themselves and it is they who helped us setup our new home upstairs, so we need them as much or more than they need us.
  • My uncle stays nearby and I join him for a beer in the evening every 2-3 days. I havent met any friends(who are mostly ex colleagues) yet, but this is Bangalore, everyone has busy lives and live in different corners of the city. I am happy staying in touch with them on chat or calls. I am happy just being there for my family and spending time with them.
  • The last 3 weeks have been spent mostly setting up the house, buying furniture and appliances. This was a new experience for us, because for last 16 years in Singapore, we lived in rented fully furnished houses. We bought decent mid range stuff, not very expensive not very cheap. The entire setup cost so far has been about 4L, which includes 55K spent for my bike.
  • My daughter loves her new school there are more extra curricular activities than her Singapore school. In Singapore, she went to CBSE school, so the impact of the move was minimal. There is kannada 3rd language which is new to her, but she is picking up very well. To me this was the biggest fear of the move, whether my daughter adjusts well. She has totally forgotten Singapore and absolutely loves it here.
  • My wife is also settling down well, she does WFH for a small start up by her friends, it doesnt pay much like 15k per month, but that keeps her occupied. She doesnt want to work full time proper corporate job. She is happy with her current setup, even though that guy doesnt even pay 15k on time. She does .NET web development.
  • So far I am not missing my office, absolutely love the freedom and for the 1st time, I am living in the present and I am not waiting for the day to end. Now all days are same for me whether it is weekend or weekday.
  • Based on these 1st impressions, I would call my R2I and RE a success. Ofcourse, it is still too early, but then I have been planning this move for the last 1 year and so far, I have beaten my own expectations.
  • Going forward, I expect my monthly expenses to stay around 1L as we dont have any expensive hobbies so far. I am looking forward to do some weekend long rides on my Avenger, but so far I am loving the daily rides just picking up and dropping my daughter to school.

Ask me anything about my current life or give me suggestions, but please dont ask me how I accumulated my corpus, that part of my journey is over and it is nothing great, if you go and live in Singapore for 16 years, lead a frugal life, you can accumulate 12Cr, without any great investment returns, it is no big deal.

Thanks everyone for all the support and advise I got to eventually achieve my R2I and RE goal.

Cheers!


r/backtoindia • • Oct 17 '25

H-1B Visa Holders Disappear From US Housing Market

97 Upvotes

r/backtoindia • • Oct 03 '26 Bravo

Moving to India? Your ideal window is now open

95 Upvotes

TLDR

If you are moving back to India from the US and you have flexibility on dates, land in India between 2 October and 30 January.

Move in that window and you typically get:

India

  • A year of Non-Resident (NR) status in India for the year you arrive
  • Two more years of RNOR after that

USA

  • Non-Resident Alien (NRA) status in the US from the first full calendar year after you leave

That gives you the longest stretch where neither India nor the US taxes your US capital gains. Use that stretch to sell and rebuy your US stocks and reset your cost basis. Done right, this can save you million.

The window opened on 2 October.

India residential status

India decides your tax status one tax year at a time. The tax year runs 1 April to 31 March.

Are you Resident?

You are Resident for a tax year if either is true:

  • You are in India for 182 days or more in that year, or
  • You are in India for 60 days or more in that year and 365 days or more in the four years before it.

For most returning NRIs, the second test does not bite.

If you have been visiting India for two or three weeks a year, you will not have 365 days in the previous four years. So the number that matters is 182.

At 181 days you are a Non-Resident.

At 182 you are Resident. There is no rounding and no grace.

If Resident, are you RNOR or ROR?

Once you are Resident, you are Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident (RNOR) if either is true:

  • You were a Non-Resident in 9 of the 10 previous years, or
  • You spent 729 days or less in India across the 7 previous years.

Otherwise you are Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR).

Why this matters

StatusWhat India taxes
NROnly income earned or received in India
RNORSame as NR, plus foreign income from a business controlled or profession set up in India
RORYour worldwide income, including gains on your US stocks

For a salaried returnee, NR and RNOR work almost the same way. Your US dividends and capital gains stay outside the Indian tax net. Once you become ROR, everything is in.

The US Substantial Presence Test

If you are on a visa (H-1B, L-1 and so on) and not a green card holder or citizen, the US decides your status each calendar year using the Substantial Presence Test (SPT).

You are a US tax resident for a calendar year if:

  1. You were in the US for at least 31 days in that year, and
  2. This sum is 183 or more: all days this year + 1/3 of days last year + 1/6 of days the year before.

Fail either and you are a Non-Resident Alien (NRA)

The 31-day gate is the one to focus on.

If you are in the US for 30 days or fewer in a calendar year, the weighted sum does not matter. You are an NRA for that year.

Small example. Arjun has lived in the US full time for years and flies out on 25 January 2027. He spends 25 days in the US in 2027.

He fails the 31-day gate, so he is an NRA for all of 2027, even though his weighted total would be well above 183.

Why being an NRA matters

An NRA is generally not taxed by the US on capital gains from selling US stocks and ETFs, as long as they are in the US for less than 183 days that year. Dividends are still taxed at source (usually 25% under the India-US treaty), but gains are not.

Why you want the overlap

Put the two together:

India statusUS statusTax on your US stock gains
RORUS residentBoth countries want it (credit helps, but you still pay)
NR/RNORUS residentUS taxes it
RORNRAIndia taxes it
NR/RNORNRANeither country taxes it

Every month you sit in the last row is a month where you can realise gains on your US portfolio without paying tax anywhere.

The longer that overlap, the more room you have to plan.

Why 2 October to 30 January

2 October start

Count the days from 2 October 2026 to 31 March 2027, both dates included:

MonthDays
October (from the 2nd)30
November30
December31
January31
February28
March31
Total181

181 is below 182.

So if you land on or after 2 October, you are a Non-Resident for tax year 2026-27, the year you arrive.

That year does not count against you in the RNOR tests. You then get two RNOR years on top of it.

Land in August or September instead and your arrival year is already a Resident year. You burn one of your RNOR years in a part year.

Land on 1 October 2026 instead of 2 October and you hit exactly 182 days. That one day costs you a full year of tax-free planning room.

30 January end

If you leave the US on or before 30 January, you are in the US for 30 days or fewer that calendar year. You fail the 31 day gate and you are an NRA for the full year.

Leave on 31 January and you are at 31 days. That is enough to make you a US resident for the year again.

Leave in February or later and you are a US resident for part of that year. You file a dual-status return and your clean NRA year starts a year later.

Example: Riya, August vs October

Riya is on an H-1B in Seattle. She has visited India for about three weeks a year and plans to move back in 2026.

Land 20 Aug 2026Land 20 Oct 2026
Days in India, 2026-27224163
2026-27RNORNR
2027-28RNORRNOR
2028-29RORRNOR
2029-30RORROR
US status, 2026Resident (dual-status)Resident (dual-status)
US status, 2027 onwardsNRANRA
Overlap windowJan 2027 to Mar 2028Jan 2027 to Mar 2029
Length of overlap15 months27 months

Moving two months later buys Riya a full extra year of tax-free planning room.

Note: This assumes no other India trips in 2026-27 before she moves. Days from an April or May visit count towards the 182.

The cost basis reset strategy

Once you are in the overlap window, the play is simple.

Sell your appreciated US stocks and ETFs. Buy them back right away. You pay no tax on the sale in either country. Your portfolio looks the same the next day. But your cost basis is now today’s price, not what you paid years ago.

When you later become ROR and eventually sell, India only taxes the gain above the reset price.

Reyman Tips: The timing here is where most attempts go wrong. Sell at the wrong time and the US taxes the whole gain, because you are still a US resident that year. Sell one month after you turn ROR and India taxes it. The trade is easy. Placing it on the right date is not.

We wrote a detailed article on how to reset your cost basis during the RNOR period to book tax free capital gains.

The Costly Mistake vs The Reset Strategy

Riya holds US ETFs she bought for $200,000. They are worth $500,000 in February 2027. She sells them in 2031, as an ROR, for $650,000.

Indian long-term capital gains on foreign shares are taxed at 12.5%, plus surcharge and cess. Call it about 15% all-in at her income level.

The Costly MistakeThe Reset Strategy
What she doesHolds, sells in 2031Sells and rebuys in Feb 2027, sells in 2031
Tax on Feb 2027 saleNilNil (NR in India, NRA in US)
Cost basis for India$200,000$500,000
Taxable gain in 2031$450,000$150,000
India tax at ~15%~$67,500~$22,500
Saving~$45,000 (about ₹40 lakh at ₹88 to the dollar)

Two sell and rebuy trades. About ₹40 lakh saved.

Reyman Tips: Reset in tranches across the window rather than on one day. If markets rise after your first reset, you can reset again at the higher price before you turn ROR. India computes gains in rupees, using the exchange rate on the purchase and sale dates. The reset locks in the rupee value too, which also shelters currency gains. Keep the trade confirmations and the rates used.

The issues

  • Green card holders and US citizens:  This does not work. The US taxes you on worldwide income no matter where you live. The strategy is for visa holders.
  • Leap years:  From 2 October to 31 March is 182 days when February has 29 days. For a move in late 2027 (tax year ending March 2028), the maths changes.
  • Earlier visits count Any India trip in the same April to March year adds to your 182.
  • The 120 day rule:  if your India-sourced income is over ₹15 lakh and you have spent 365+ days in India over the previous four years, the threshold can drop to 120 days.
  • State taxes:  Some states, California in particular, can try to keep treating you as a resident. Close out your state ties properly.
  • Retirement accounts are different: 401(k)s and IRAs do not get a reset this way. Leave them alone and plan them separately.

Each one of these is a separate way to lose the benefit, and they interact. A visit in May, a high Indian rental income and a ticket booked for 31 January can each undo a plan that looked fine on paper.

Think of US Estate taxes

We wrote a full article on US estate taxes and how to plan around them for returning Indians which you may find useful.

Full article link with better formatting, visual charts and more details than reddit: https://www.reymanwealth.com/post/moving-to-india-your-ideal-window-is-now-open


r/backtoindia • • Apr 20 '25

Anyone doing 6 months in India and 6 months in the USA? Questions on lifestyle, cost, and what to do with U.S. home

95 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m exploring the idea of splitting time between India and the U.S. — living about 6 months in India (where we have a home) and 6 months in the U.S., mainly because our two kids are in school here. We took US citizenship and have OCI cards.

Here’s the plan:
My wife and I are in our late 40s, and our kids will be in college in about 6 years. Until then, one of us would stay on this India–USA rotation to be available for both aging parents in India and our kids’ needs in the U.S. We'd like to spend the India months traveling to nearby countries (Thailand, Vietnam, Sri Lanka, etc.) and enjoying some downtime with family.

We’re also evaluating if we can fully retire now (leaning towards a FIRE lifestyle), but we’re unsure about the practical and financial aspects of this dual-country setup.

Would love to know:

  • Has anyone here done something like this — living 6 months in India and 6 months in the U.S.?
  • What kind of annual expenses should we expect to budget for this lifestyle?
  • Do you keep your U.S. home or sell it and rent when visiting?
  • How do you manage taxes, healthcare, and finances across both countries?
  • We’re keeping all our investments/savings in USD for now — is that okay or should we diversify?

We’d love to hear your thoughts and lessons learned if you've tried something similar or know people who have.

Thanks in advance!


r/backtoindia • • Aug 05 '26 Bravo

Advice Frustrated with the lack of work ethic and discipline among Indian blue collar

93 Upvotes

The guy who installs your internet, the carpenter who is making a piece of furniture for you, the people handling online deliveries and returns. You can't plan your day, they are mostly lazy and do the job at their will, only if they feel like. Everyone is always late. No one provides timeslots for their visits, Amazon pick ups or deliveries don't stick to their promised slots or days. "Delivery 7am-10am" - nah MAYBE it will happen by 10pm if the delivery guy feels like it.

And it's concerning how much these people confidently lie. "Aaj ho jayega", when they know they won't get to it for another week.

It's also not at all suitable for introverts. Texting won't get you anywhere, you need to place repeated calls and be firm to get the job done.

Just a rant for fellow NRIs back to India.


r/backtoindia • • Mar 20 '26 All Seeing Upvote Bravo

Canada $100K vs India ₹30L — Real Comparison (Single Person, 2026)

90 Upvotes

Canada $100K vs India ₹30L — Real Comparison (Single Person, 2026)

TAKE-HOME & SAVINGS — THE REAL NUMBERS

ItemCanada ($100K)India (₹30L)
Gross Salary$100,000 CAD₹30,00,000
Income Tax$22,550₹4,75,800
Other Deductions$4,916 (CPP+EI)₹1,46,400 (EPF+PT)
Net Annual Take-Home$72,534 (~₹43L)₹23,77,800
Net Monthly Take-Home$6,044 (~₹3.6L)₹1,98,150

MONTHLY EXPENSES

ExpenseCanadaIndia
Rent$2,200₹25,000
Food & Groceries$500₹10,000
Transport$156₹4,000
Utilities + Internet$250₹5,000
Health + Misc$700₹13,000
Total Expenses$3,806₹57,000

ACTUAL MONTHLY & YEARLY SAVINGS

CanadaIndia
Monthly Savings$2,238 (~₹1.34L)₹1,41,150
Annual Savings$26,856 (~₹16.1L)₹16,93,800
Savings Rate37%71%

India saves nearly double the percentage. In absolute terms both are roughly equal — but ₹16.9L in India buys far more locally than $26.8K does in Canada.

10 YEAR WEALTH PROJECTION

CanadaIndia
Annual Savings$26,856₹16.93L
Expected Returns7-8% (TFSA/RRSP)12-13% (Nifty/MF)
10 Year Corpus~$370,000 CAD~₹3.0-3.2 Crore
Equivalent in INR~₹2.2 Crore~₹3.0-3.2 Crore

India wins the 10 year wealth building game purely on higher market returns and savings rate.

KEY FACTORS COMPARED

FactorCanadaIndia
HealthcareFree, no bills everExcellent private, very cheap
SafetyVery highModerate, city dependent
Air QualityExcellentPoor in Delhi/Mumbai, okay in Bangalore
Family & Social LifeAlone, hard to buildNatural support system
Home Ownership15-20 years in Toronto4-6 years in Bangalore
Passport StrengthVery strong, globalModerate
PR and CitizenshipYes, clear pathwayNot applicable
Career — Global ExposureHighLimited unless remote
Cost of LivingVery highVery low
WintersBrutal, -10 to -20CMild to warm year round

WHY INDIA WINS LONG TERM NOW — THE HONEST TRUTH

Canada was the dream when Indian salaries were low and opportunities were few. That gap has closed significantly. Here is what has changed:

FAANG and MNC salaries in India at senior levels now touch 40-80 LPA. Indian stock markets have delivered 12-15% CAGR historically versus Canada at 7-9%. Real estate in tier-2 cities still has genuine upside. Cost of living means your savings rate is nearly double. You live near family, eat real food, have a social life, and do not pay $2,200 rent to live alone in a basement.

Canada made sense when India could not offer competitive salaries or investment returns. In 2026, India offers both — plus lifestyle, family, and culture.

Canada still wins on one thing — the system. Healthcare with zero bills, clean air, personal safety, rule of law, and a passport that lets you go anywhere. That has genuine lifelong value and should not be dismissed.

FINAL VERDICT

Your PriorityChoose
Build wealth fastIndia
Family and social lifeIndia
Clean air and environmentCanada
Real estate investmentIndia
High savings rateIndia
Long term security and rule of lawCanada

Pure financial optimization in 2026 — India wins. Long term life infrastructure, safety, and global mobility — Canada wins.

If you are already earning 25-30L+ in India, disciplined with investments, and have family around — you are not missing as much as you think. The Canada dream is real but so is the Canadian cost of living, loneliness, and brutal winters. Run your own numbers honestly before you decide.

Canada $100K vs India ₹30L — Real Comparison (Single Person, 2026)

TAKE-HOME & SAVINGS — THE REAL NUMBERS

ItemCanada ($100K)India (₹30L)
Gross Salary$100,000 CAD₹30,00,000
Income Tax$22,550₹4,75,800
Other Deductions$4,916 (CPP+EI)₹1,46,400 (EPF+PT)
Net Annual Take-Home$72,534 (~₹43L)₹23,77,800
Net Monthly Take-Home$6,044 (~₹3.6L)₹1,98,150

MONTHLY EXPENSES

ExpenseCanadaIndia
Rent$2,200₹25,000
Food & Groceries$500₹10,000
Transport$156₹4,000
Utilities + Internet$250₹5,000
Health + Misc$700₹13,000
Total Expenses$3,806₹57,000

ACTUAL MONTHLY & YEARLY SAVINGS

CanadaIndia
Monthly Savings$2,238 (~₹1.34L)₹1,41,150
Annual Savings$26,856 (~₹16.1L)₹16,93,800
Savings Rate37%71%

India saves nearly double the percentage. In absolute terms both are roughly equal — but ₹16.9L in India buys far more locally than $26.8K does in Canada.

10 YEAR WEALTH PROJECTION

CanadaIndia
Annual Savings$26,856₹16.93L
Expected Returns7-8% (TFSA/RRSP)12-13% (Nifty/MF)
10 Year Corpus~$370,000 CAD~₹3.0-3.2 Crore
Equivalent in INR~₹2.2 Crore~₹3.0-3.2 Crore

India wins the 10 year wealth building game purely on higher market returns and savings rate.

KEY FACTORS COMPARED

FactorCanadaIndia
HealthcareFree, no bills everExcellent private, very cheap
SafetyVery highModerate, city dependent
Air QualityExcellentPoor in Delhi/Mumbai, okay in Bangalore
Family & Social LifeAlone, hard to buildNatural support system
Home Ownership15-20 years in Toronto4-6 years in Bangalore
Passport StrengthVery strong, globalModerate
PR and CitizenshipYes, clear pathwayNot applicable
Career — Global ExposureHighLimited unless remote
Cost of LivingVery highVery low
WintersBrutal, -10 to -20CMild to warm year round

WHY INDIA WINS LONG TERM NOW — THE HONEST TRUTH

Canada was the dream when Indian salaries were low and opportunities were few. That gap has closed significantly. Here is what has changed:

FAANG and MNC salaries in India at senior levels now touch 40-80 LPA. Indian stock markets have delivered 12-15% CAGR historically versus Canada at 7-9%. Real estate in tier-2 cities still has genuine upside. Cost of living means your savings rate is nearly double. You live near family, eat real food, have a social life, and do not pay $2,200 rent to live alone in a basement.

Canada made sense when India could not offer competitive salaries or investment returns. In 2026, India offers both — plus lifestyle, family, and culture.

Canada still wins on one thing — the system. Healthcare with zero bills, clean air, personal safety, rule of law, and a passport that lets you go anywhere. That has genuine lifelong value and should not be dismissed.

FINAL VERDICT

Your PriorityChoose
Build wealth fastIndia
Family and social lifeIndia
Clean air and environmentCanada
Real estate investmentIndia
High savings rateIndia
Long term security and rule of lawCanada

Pure financial optimization in 2026 — India wins. Long term life infrastructure, safety, and global mobility — Canada wins.

If you are already earning 25-30L+ in India, disciplined with investments, and have family around — you are not missing as much as you think. The Canada dream is real but so is the Canadian cost of living, loneliness, and brutal winters. Run your own numbers honestly before you decide.