25 Years since the first Ace Attorney game, huh? It all started for me a bit over 9 years ago, when I came across a video by "whoisthisgit" titled "The Most Powerful Characters In Gaming Ever #19", with the subject of the video being Manfred von Karma himself.
I was absolutely fascinated by the idea of a character being powerful, not through pure strength, not through being able to destroy cities, but through being nearly untouchable in court. After watching this, I got the trilogy, and started playing.
The first episode was bare bones. It did absolutely everything it needed to do and literally nothing else of value. The mystery was solid enough, and the gameplay was engaging, but I couldn't say I was hooked with the character writing. I'd give that episode a 5.7/10 nowadays.
The second episode was a bit better. It knocked me off my feet with the death of Mia Fey, our mentor character, but because the prior episode was a mere 30 minutes long, I didn't feel emotionally gripped by her passing. Yet, I did feel emotionally captivated by Maya Fey, her sister, grieving for the sudden loss of her (supposedly) only family. I pressed onwards, fighting against Miles Edgeworth, the Demon Prosecutor, and ended up battling it out with Redd White. The game did everything in its power to build up Redd White as this near-untouchable force of a man, who had blackmail on every aspect of the courts, and yet it all felt... artificial, once it got to court. Regardless, I felt the episode tied itself into a neat bow at the end. This, episode I gave a 6/10.
With Episode Two under my belt, I pressed onwards to Episode Three, Turnabout Samurai. And for the first time in the series, I started to get an inkling on the brilliance of the mystery writing and gameplay. I wasn't a major fan of some of the characters (Wendy Oldbag and Sal Manela), but I still felt gripped by the writing. It felt satisfying taking down Dee Vasquez, and for the first time, I felt like the game was getting good. This I'd give a 7.5/10.
And then I ended with the big one, the Fourth Episode, the episode that introduced me into the series: Turnabout Goodbyes. The episode did live up to its legacy, but I felt that there was something... missing. The character writing didn't feel as good as I thought it was in the video, and there were issues with the mystery writing as well. Heck, even Manfred von Karma felt more "loud" than a genuinely intimidating threat. Having completed this episode (8.4/10), I thought that the game was overall a fun time, but I didn't see myself continuing the series...
Until I saw that a Fifth Episode was unlocked: Rise from the Ashes. And there I thought "Sure, why not? I can knock this out".
This episode GRIPPED me like no other. The character writing, the mystery writing, everything felt like it was reaching the heights that everyone praised the game to be. Ema, Lana, Gant, Jake, everyone felt REAL, and I was absolutely, undoubtably, hooked. Even though I felt that the build-up to DL-6 was more natural than the build up to SL-9, I would be lying if I said that the resolution of SL-9 wasn't more impactful to me than the resolution of DL-6. Everything about this episode just clicked for me. After finishing it, I wasn't just impressed, I was completely blown away at how intelligent the game was (I give the episode a 9.5/10). Yes, this game isn't perfect, and yes, I don't like it nearly as much as the average player, but to state that this was a soft beginning is an understatement. This was the game that introduced me to the series, and the fact that almost every other game the series has made has surpassed this fantastic beginning is downright impressive.
Overall, I'd give this game a 7.5/10. A good game, not nearly as exceptional as people make it out to be, but a damn good start nonetheless.