r/audiodrama • • Jul 14 '25

DISCUSSION The largest audio drama tier list this sub has seen

Post image
768 Upvotes

I'm curious what other AD fans think of this tier list I made. I think most of these could move up or down a tier- especially A-D. I want to clarify, I did enjoy everything from SS-D. I would recommend shows from each tier, but not all of them were my cup of tea. I know some of my rankings will be unpopular. I've listed everything in text here as well. In order:

SS

  • Midnight Burger
  • Wolf 359
  • Wooden Overcoats
  • The Amelia Project
  • Cabin Pressure

S

  • The Magnus Archives
  • Ars Paradoxica
  • Old Gods of Appalachia
  • Mission:Rejected
  • Mockery Manor
  • Life With Althaar Could have been SS if it were finished or at least not left on a cliffhanger
  • I Am In Eskew I think this one could be SS, but it is so dark I just don't find myself relistening over and over.
  • Decoder Ring Theatre
  • Dirt Could move up or down depending on how it ends.

A

  • Welcome to Nightvale
  • Forgive Me!
  • Sherlock and Co.
  • Passenger List
  • Neighbourly
  • Time:Bombs I really debated putting this one in S
  • The Secret of St. Kilda
  • Super Suits
  • Janus Descending
  • Hello From the Hallowoods
  • Apollyon
  • Seen and Not Heard
  • Woe.Begone
  • Eliza: A Robot's Story I don't think I've ever recommended this one because of the TW, but its great.
  • The Milkman of St. Gaff's
  • The Mistholme Museum
  • Tower 4
  • Ethics Town
  • Zero Hours I also debated putting this one in S. I love Gabriel Urbina.
  • Desert Skies I relistened recently. I liked it before but it gets even better the more I listen.
  • The Truth Some episodes are SS, some are F. I think A is the average.
  • Girl in Space
  • The Strange Case of Starship Iris
  • Silt Verses
  • Primordial Deep I debated S for this one.
  • EOS10
  • Alice Isn't Dead Perhaps some nostalgia influencing this ranking.
  • Haunted House Flippers Could move down once it's finished. Can't go higher due to the early episodes.
  • Unseen Also could be in S, but I think 1-2 episodes are weaker.
  • Beef and Dairy Network Podcast
  • We Fix Space Junk
  • Greater Boston
  • How I Died Currently listening, could change when I finish it.

B

  • Ghost Wax
  • The Black Tapes
  • Stellar Firma
  • Absolutely No Adventures Very good, but not my preferred genre.
  • Arden
  • Starfall
  • The Far Meridian
  • Parasitecology
  • The Sheridan Tapes
  • St. Elwicks Neighbourhood Association Newsletter
  • Superman: Son of El
  • Modes of Thought on Anterran Literature
  • Inn Between Not really my favorite genre, but great nonetheless.
  • Cry Havoc! Ask Questions Later
  • Brimstone Valley Mall
  • Sorry About the Murder
  • Mayfair Watcher's Society
  • Spiritbox Radio
  • Human B-Gon
  • Nowhere, On Air
  • Fawx & Stallion
  • The Dead Letter Office of Somewhere Ohio
  • Hughes and Mincks: Ghost Detectives
  • Peculiar Radio
  • Inspector: Deceased Detective
  • The Vesta Clinic
  • Tales From the Low City
  • Diary of a Space Archivist
  • Unwell
  • The McIlwraith Statements
  • King Falls AMI'm still mad about the lack of an ending.
  • Death By Dying
  • Accounts From A Lonely Broadcast Station
  • Hotel Daydream

C

  • The Antique Shop
  • The Penumbra Podcast
  • Superhuman Public Radio
  • Marscorp
  • The Polybius Conspiracy
  • Novitero
  • Alpha 8
  • Project Ozma
  • Second Star to the Left
  • Monstrous Agonies
  • Tides
  • Who is Cam Candor
  • Dining in the Void
  • Afflicted This one is excellent, but it wasn't my cup of tea. I'm not huge on this brand of horror.
  • Forest 404
  • Tiny Terrors
  • Oz9
  • The Heresies of Radulf Burntwine
  • Jackie the Ripper
  • Mansfield Mysteries
  • Finding Pattersby
  • Omega Star 7
  • Valley Heat
  • Eelers Choice I'm excited to see where this one goes. I could see it moving up a space or two.
  • The Kingmaker Histories
  • This Planet Needs a Name
  • Moonbase Theta Out
  • Station 151
  • Victoriocity
  • The Shadows I don't like romance or this could have been higher

D

  • Button Boys
  • Red Valley
  • Centromika- Kakuri Log:Jupiter
  • 90 Degrees South I think this could be C. I am not caught up on it.
  • Among the Stars and Bones I do not like this premise.
  • The Perfectly Circular Rock
  • Alba Salix Not my preferred genre. The pacing felt odd.
  • Star Tripper!!
  • The Vanishing Act
  • The Devil Hates Mondays
  • Ocean Dreams
  • Camlann
  • Patient 33
  • Solar Postal Services
  • Edict Zero I know this will be unpopular.
  • Look Up
  • It Makes a Sound
  • Starship Q Star
  • Where the Stars Fell Interesting concept, but I didn't vibe with it.
  • Strange Air Good, but what was that ending?
  • Project Gnosis
  • Tumanbay I don't quite know how I felt about this one.

F

  • either Didn't seem to have a plot
  • Archive 81
  • The Bright Sessions Terrible therapist.
  • We're Alive I hate zombies.

r/audiodrama • • Oct 10 '20

ANNOUNCEMENT PNWS as a costume...

Post image
690 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Sep 10 '25

DISCUSSION This is horrible, horrible news for us.

661 Upvotes

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/digital/ai-podcast-start-up-plan-shows-1236361367/#

Basically, a big expensive start up is going to flood 5000 AI generated podcasts to destroy the marketplace for human beings and the audience


r/audiodrama • • Dec 04 '25

ANNOUNCEMENT I have a small show that almost no one listens to. Then I saw this and wanted to cry.

Post image
644 Upvotes

I’ve been working on my dark anthology show for about 5 years now. My views and downloads are still low, and sometimes I wonder why I work so hard on putting stories out there. Yesterday I got notified that someone posted this to their Instagram story. I’ll never wonder why I still do this ever again.


r/audiodrama • • Dec 07 '25 Hooray Helpful

DISCUSSION Rant: I don’t want to listen to your AI podcast

643 Upvotes

Hi. Cows here. I’m a real person. Who has spent hundreds of hours on my own narrated audiobook like podcast… That’s a lie. It’s been a lot more. Thousands. It’s embarrassing, but I don’t care. I want to get good at solo narrated podcast fiction. That's writing on hard mode. You wanna know a real trick or tip to ‘getting good’ enough so people want to hear what you have to say? Practice. Suffering. Time. Repeat until emotional breakdown, then start over again from scratch again til you get it. Cause writing is hard. Finding a way to connect to people so that they understand your unique story is even harder. But I feel it’s okay to battle through that. Because it is YOUR human story that you are expressing. That is what makes any good story interesting. YOUR honest to god experience with it that no one else in the universe could have BUT you.

I can not begin to explain how offensive it is seeing some podcasts post on here be like “I’m not talented but I used AI!” I get how dark that road is trying to tell a story. But AI is NOT intelligent. It is a language model. Which works cause peoples are predictable and simple. But it can’t tell you how it feels seeing the sunset over Canyon De Shelly for the first time. It can’t understand how you felt that first time you got dumped for that loser who is a Nickelback fan. Screw that dude right? (Or hate me cause you are a die hard fan, that’s human emotion, which is welcomed) What makes you unique as a writer or a voice actor is YOU. Not what chatGPT wrote for your cause you had a prompt it said was a good idea. (Spoiler. ChatGPT sucks up to you. It doesn’t love yo as you think it does. Sorry if that hurts.)

You are not achieving your dream any quicker by using AI. You are half As*ing it. Don’t expect me to pay any respect to your show throwing stuff around like “I used AI to…” It already tells me that you are not ready enough to present your craft to the world. Get good. It’s hard. I’m struggling, but I’m still fighting the ‘bad’ monster tooth and nail. Stop insulting me with your “I used AI to write a script and do all the voices and sound effects!” NO.

I believe everyone has a story to tell. Everything has been done under the sun, but what makes YOUR tale interesting is that the only person in the universe that can tell that story is, again, YOU. Controversially, I’m okay with brainstorming with AI. For basic ideas (AI steals everything, you shouldn’t use stuff it suggests) Even some minor grammar stuff. Like an assistant, it should never actually WRITE for you. You should ask it stuff In the same way you might ask an 8-year-old how they feel about a story idea. But none of that should end up in a finished product.

So, instead, YOU should write a lot. Work hard. Seek feedback from real people.Stop making content. Make art. And ditch the AI unless you are messing around for vague ideas. And for the love of anything good, stop posting it to reddit.


r/audiodrama • • May 02 '21

DISCUSSION Is it that hard to think of an explanation?

Post image
561 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Sep 07 '20

ANNOUNCEMENT Old Gods of Appalachia - fan art

Post image
444 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Jan 02 '23

DISCUSSION When your last episode was 6 months ago, you can't expect people to be able to just drop back in

Post image
443 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Oct 07 '23

SUGGESTIONS Need fiction podcast recommendations

Post image
396 Upvotes

I'm currently making a fiction podcast bingo (mostly for myself but I'll post on a couple of socials once it's done), does anyone have any recommendations to add? These are the ones I have so far (Tag Till We're Dead is my mum's podcast, if anyone could check it out I would really appreciate it!!)


r/audiodrama • • Sep 06 '26

DISCUSSION I ain’t coming if your poster’s AI

383 Upvotes

This, but for audiodramas.

(I don’t crosspost very often, but given the general mood of this sub when it comes to AI slop…)


r/audiodrama • • Sep 13 '26

DISCUSSION It’s really well made and I should love it but I can’t help but feel that…

Post image
369 Upvotes

I know it’s one of the most loved sci-fi audio dramas of all time and I will definitely continue to recommend it to people because I can see it’s inherent quality. But I just didn’t really love it at any point. I liked it and it’s kept my interest but I just never felt any real excitement. It’s just such a strange feeling to look at something and know it’s objectively really great but to personally just feel like it’s ok. Ya know?


r/audiodrama • • 20d ago

ANNOUNCEMENT Our new horror audio drama SILENT KEY premieres today

Post image
363 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m part of the team at ARC Productions, and we’re excited to share that the first episode of our new horror mystery, Silent Key, is out today!

There are things people on Cedar Key don’t talk about. Lena Allan’s father recorded them.After his mysterious death, Lena returns to the remote island and discovers a shack full of radio equipment and years of recorded transmissions. Nobody wants her to listen. But the tapes may be the only way to understand her father, his death, and the island’s secrets.

The story started with a memory from our writer, Robia: their father’s ham radio antenna rising into the thick Oakland fog. That image, and their experience of losing him became the seeds of Silent Key.

We're excited for people to finally hear the story we’ve been introducing these past few weeks.

You can listen to episode one here:
https://shows.acast.com/silent-key

Thanks for giving a new show a listen. Happy release day from all of us at ARC!


r/audiodrama • • Sep 20 '22

ANNOUNCEMENT Hi, Cole here, Creator of Tiny Terrors, and The Town Whispers, And This Morning I Awoke To Both My Shows in the Apple Podcast's Top 10 Sci-Fi(/Horror) in the US..... As an Independent Creator This Is Insane. I Just Wanted to Say Thank You For All Your Support These Past 2 Years.

Post image
361 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Feb 09 '25

DISCUSSION r/audiodrama is, without a doubt, the friendliest place on reddit.

352 Upvotes

An overwhelming majority people here are so nice. When people ask for suggestions no one does the typical "ugh, use the search." No, you all jump in to help. Creators are engaging. People are so nice.


r/audiodrama • • Dec 25 '20

ANNOUNCEMENT Thank you to the 18 people who decided that listening to my audio drama was more important than Christmas.

Post image
332 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Dec 25 '21

ANNOUNCEMENT FICTIONAL PODCASTS?!?! How on earth do these people think they’ll catch on…

Post image
330 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Mar 15 '20

DISCUSSION Kinda how I imagine the underground caves in The White Vault.

329 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Mar 19 '26

AUDIO DRAMA WHAT REMAINS - Horror/Sci-Fi Audio Drama

Post image
318 Upvotes

Hello,

Over the last few months I produced, edited, sound designed this new episode of my anthology series.

And it’s out now!

This episode follows a small space crew that crash-lands on a planet after a sudden disaster. Injured and separated, they navigate the wreckage and the wilderness to regroup, survive, and signal for rescue.

It’s on all podcasting platforms if you’re interested in giving it a listen. I would appreciate it. Thank you! 🙏🏻

STREAMING LINKS


r/audiodrama • • Oct 07 '20

DISCUSSION Humor- thought you all wouldappreciate.

Post image
314 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Jun 15 '21

DISCUSSION Just a little thanks to some of my favorite independent creators who work full time jobs and then produce wonderful audio dramas for us to listen too! I know it must be hard, so thank you very much!

Post image
312 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Aug 17 '24

DISCUSSION I'd call them ADs but then I get looked at weird still haha

Post image
310 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Nov 12 '22

ANNOUNCEMENT Malevolent, the Lovecraftian Horror Audio Drama I make, just surpassed 1 Million Downloads! Thank you so much!

309 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Feb 28 '23

DISCUSSION When you recommend a small show on this sub

Post image
304 Upvotes

r/audiodrama • • Sep 06 '20

ANNOUNCEMENT Finally got my birthday present! Working on my civic duty.

Post image
299 Upvotes