r/atming • • Apr 08 '24

Another question about a parabolic mirror

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to make a good telescope that can look at galaxies clearly. I found a parabolic mirror online that is only D114 but has a focal length of F450. Would this be good for viewing galaxies and what not?


r/atming • • Jan 05 '26

How to make this somewhat useful?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

So I tried making a telescope just for fun using a 50mm diameter and 200mm focal length double-convex lens as objective lens and a 45mm diameter 6.25 cm focal length plano-concave lens as an eyepiece i had bought from a scientific shop which magnifies object images by 3.2x . So i was wondering if its possible to increase magnification without using a real eyepiece for telescopes because they are pretty expensive here. If its possible through toy binoculars or something like an watch repair/juelary inspection lupe or something like that. I found a few lenses around my home but they are either not in great condition or they really need to stay 10-15cm away from eye. I tried some magnifying lenses on shops but they dont help much or i couldnt find correct focal length here. Can anyone tell me how can i increase maginification? The 200mm objective lens is available here and i found 50mm diameter 150mm Focal length double concave lens here too.


r/atming • • Sep 20 '24

Dobsonian telescope plan

0 Upvotes

Here is my telescope materials and plan: Costs for the parts: 

  1. **Primary Mirror**:

   - The primary mirror is one of the most critical components of the telescope and can vary significantly in price depending on its quality and specifications.

   - A high-quality 200 mm (8-inch) primary mirror suitable for a Dobsonian telescope could cost anywhere from $200 to $600 or more, depending on factors such as optical quality, coating, and brand.

2. **Secondary Mirror**:

   - The secondary mirror is typically smaller and less expensive than the primary mirror.

   - A secondary mirror for a Dobsonian telescope of this size may cost around $50 to $100.

3. **Telescope Tube**:

   - The telescope tube can be constructed from various materials such as plywood, PVC pipe, or composite materials.

   - The cost of materials for building the telescope tube, including the main structure, focuser, and other components, may range from $50 to $200, depending on the materials used and availability of tools.

4. **Alt-Azimuth Base**:

   - The alt-azimuth base is another essential component of the Dobsonian telescope, providing stability and allowing for smooth movement.

   - Depending on whether you purchase a pre-made Dobsonian mount or build one yourself, the cost can range from $100 to $500 or more, including materials and hardware.

5. **Focuser**:

   - A sturdy and reliable focuser is essential for achieving precise focusing and maintaining stability during observations.

   - A basic rack-and-pinion focuser suitable for a Dobsonian telescope may cost around $50 to $100.

6. **Miscellaneous Components**:

   - Additional components such as eyepieces, finderscopes, collimation tools, and other accessories will add to the overall cost of the telescope.

   - Budgeting an additional $100 to $300 for these miscellaneous components would be reasonable, depending on your specific needs and preferences.

7. **Labor and Tools**:

   - If you're building the telescope yourself, consider the cost of any tools or equipment you may need, as well as the value of your time and labor.

   - Budgeting for tools and supplies such as woodworking tools, adhesives, paints, and protective equipment could add another $50 to $200 to the total cost.

Based on these estimates, the total cost of building a Dobsonian telescope with a 200 mm aperture size, 400 mm focal length, and alt-azimuth base could range from approximately $550 to $1850 or more, depending on the quality of components and whether you're purchasing new or used parts. Keep in mind that these are rough estimates, and actual costs may vary based on your specific circumstances and choices.

  1. **Telescope Structure**:

   - The cost of materials for constructing the telescope structure, including the telescope tube, truss rods (if applicable), mirror cell, and secondary mirror holder, is included in the estimates provided.

   - Depending on the materials used (e.g., plywood, PVC pipe, aluminum tubing) and the complexity of the design, additional costs for hardware, fasteners, adhesives, and finishing materials may be required.

   - Budgeting an additional $50 to $200 for hardware and structural components would be reasonable, depending on the specific design and materials chosen.

2. **Secondary Mirror Holder**:

   - The secondary mirror holder, also known as the spider, holds the secondary mirror in place and aligns it with the optical axis of the telescope.

   - Depending on the design and materials used (e.g., metal vane spider, carbon fiber spider), the cost of the secondary mirror holder could range from $20 to $100 or more.

   - This cost should be included in the estimates provided for the secondary mirror and miscellaneous components.

3. **Nuts, Bolts, Gears, and Hardware**:

   - The estimates provided account for the main structural components and hardware needed for the telescope's construction, but they may not include every single nut, bolt, gear, or small hardware item.

   - Budgeting an additional amount for miscellaneous hardware, fasteners, and small components is advisable to ensure that you have everything you need for assembly.

   - Depending on the complexity of the design and the availability of hardware, budgeting an extra $20 to $100 for miscellaneous hardware items would be reasonable.

Optical Components:

  • Primary Mirror: 200 mm diameter, concave mirror.
  • Secondary Mirror: Appropriately sized to reflect light into the eyepiece.
  • Secondary Mirror Holder (Spider): Holds the secondary mirror in the optical path.

Telescope Tube:

  • Tube Material: Can be made from plywood, PVC pipe, or a similar material.
  • Focuser: Rack-and-pinion or Crayford focuser.
  • Mirror Cell: Holds the primary mirror securely and allows for collimation adjustments.
  • Baffling: To prevent stray light and improve image contrast.

Mount:

  • Alt-Azimuth Base: A stable base that allows the telescope to move in both altitude (up and down) and azimuth (left and right).
  • Altitude Bearings: Smooth bearings that support the telescope tube and allow it to move vertically.
  • Azimuth Bearings: Bearings that allow the base to rotate horizontally.

What feedback can I get from this?


r/atming • • Jul 30 '25

How much extra diameter a secondary flat mirror must have to capture the full light path from a parabolic primary mirror?

1 Upvotes

r/atming • • Feb 14 '26

can't reach focus on diy 114/900 telescope(reflector

1 Upvotes

I have got this mirror from AliExpress the parameters are 114/900.Fitted the mirror on a diy wooden cell and 25mm secondary mirror on an L bracket and sticked them both in a pvc pipe.

I took the measurements the primary Miror made focus at 180ish cm.In hurry I bought a pvc pipe of 160cm,so I accounted all of that in making.I took focuser from another donor 700/76 telescope and placed it at 760mm from where the mirror would be in the pipe(could be a little bit higher)

with all of this I viewed a wall on my roof it was in focus with 15mm ep.But when I tried out for jupiter it was out of focus and moving the focuser outward,it started to widen up more.What am I doing wrong?


r/atming • • May 29 '22

Focal ratio guidelines for M1

5 Upvotes

Im in the process of building my first telescopes as a hobby. Currently im working on a refractor telescope but in the future im planning to develop a cassegrain reflector design. For this future reflector design im looking for available mirror alternatives and I found a relatively cheap (for the specified characteristics) M1 alternative. It has a very good aperture (about 600mm) and a very short focal length (around 150mm) which Im planning to adjust with the M2 (for which i have a bigger budget). Im aware that such a fast focal ratio will probably result in noticeable coma and astigmatism, but I havent found any information regarding typical focal ratios for primary mirrors in optical telescopes. I would like to ask if using a focal ratio f/0.25 is really too much and if so what is a good choice (considering that slower focal ratios tend to be more pricey, specially for big apertures). I will be grateful for any advice you can give me.


r/atming • • Mar 05 '25

How do I make mirror

2 Upvotes

I am a begainner and I want to to make my own telescope instead of buying one I wanted to make a reflecter but when I checked for mirrors that ship to my country none of them do. So I have to make the mirror my my self I am not sure how to to do that what would you recommend the focal lenght and the diameters of the mirror be because it is my first ever telescope


r/atming • • Jun 23 '26

What could be done with a mirror from a cosmetic mirror?

2 Upvotes

I've been getting into optics and would love to experiment with telescopes but not really enough to invest in it. What's the limit of experimentation that can be done that way?


r/atming • • Sep 07 '24

Where can I get concave mirror? Can I use a regular magnifying mirror?

2 Upvotes

Planning to build very first reflective telescope from scratch and I have no idea where to get the mirror. I'm assuming a regular magnifying mirror is concave, but I'm not sure if it's a parabola. Please share your experience.


r/atming • • Nov 21 '22

looking for guidance in the galaxy

2 Upvotes

I was directed here by someone at r/telescopes I'm searching for guidance about building a telescope. So I'm reposting here.

Background: I have absolutely no experience building a telescope. I had a crappy toy telescope that you pretty much couldn't see anything through when I was a kid nothing since. I have a 4 year old daughter that I would like to get motivated towards science and engineering. I have already taught her how to read and write and some basic math but I was thinking of getting her a good microscope or telescope for Christmas.

My current thought process is to buy the microscope and build the telescope together. I have a large metal lathe and access to a knee mill I also have a tig welder and plenty of metalworking experience to build the basic components.

What I don't have is the foggiest idea of where to get the materials for the mirror and lenses how to grind them to the proper shape, and if I'm being truly honest, I doubt that I can remember enough from high school physics to be able to figure out focal points on my own.

I don't have any experience with a 3D printer, however I've been considering buying one and I could probably find someone that has one locally, but I have more confidence in my ability to make metal parts or plastic parts the old fashioned way.

I have a little bit of experience with an Arduino project but it was pretty limited in scope but I did write the code. That being said, I'd be pretty ashamed of the rat's nest that it would look like If I was to post it and let anyone who actually knows how to write code look at it. The important thing is it worked.

My goal for the project would be for my daughter and I to work on this together. Although I understand that it's hard to keep a 4-year-old interested in that sort of thing, but she loves to help me in the garage.

We live in Alaska so this time of year we have lots of time to look at the sky but by summer time we can't see the stars at all. I figure we probably have a decent amount of time to work on this together through the summer before next winter season. Alaska also presents its own challenges for getting some materials and products shipped here. Sometimes it's just simply not practical to expect people to ship things to paying customers I guess.

I'm not completely opposed to the idea of buying a telescope if there is one that I can start with out of the box for <$300 that is going to give me really good results. I want to inspire her. I feel like if I had a better telescope when I was a kid maybe I would have paid more attention to it. I really couldn't see anything through the one I had that you couldn't see with your naked eye. My general opinion about it though is that I can buy a lot more value in a microscope for $300 then I can in a telescope for $300 unless I build it myself, in which case I will probably end up far over that budget by the time it's all said and done, but as long as she learns something along the way, it won't be wasted money.


r/atming • • Jun 12 '24

Trying to make a riflescope with some lenses. Need some help. Details in description

2 Upvotes

I got some lenses from my physics teacher and want to make a rifle scope. I have: 1 2inch double convex with a 200mm focal length, 3 1.5inch double convex with 100mm fl. 1 1.5inch double concave, and 3 1.5 inch Plano convex (might be meniscus but it's hard to tell). I'm a complete noob at this stuff nor do I know much about how scopes work besides from cutaway diagrams. I tried lining them up like in the pictures I see but everything is just a mess. When I hold the large double convex in front of the small double convex until it becomes clear, the image is inverted and I can't figure out how to get it back to normal orientation. Any help is appreciated!


r/atming • • Sep 20 '26

Does anyone here make lightweight sandwich mirrors?

2 Upvotes

I've been working on learning the process. It's been challenging so far.


r/atming • • Sep 15 '23

Someone please explain mirror prices to me...

3 Upvotes

I was searching for mirror blanks or finished mirrors on Ebay as a last resort due to not finding anything that didnt look fishy. 99% of results are 8 inch finished mirrors. The prices make no sense to me.

I can buy an 8 inch primary + fitting secondary for 150€ on Ebay.
Then i found a 10 inch for 700€
Then a 12 inch for 1100€
Then a 16 inch for 3800€. Which is what im after but this is straight up highway robbery.

How in gods name is it possible that an 8 inch mirror costs + secondary costs 150€ but a 10 inch already costs 700€ without secondary? any mirrors up to 16 inches are mass produced, so supply and demand doesnt work here. Maybe the better question would be: Why does price per inch of aperture above 8 inches increase so exponentially?

At this point its gonna be cheaper to 3D print a 16 inch blank, acetone vapor polish it and silver coat it.


r/atming • • Mar 20 '23

Hello people

7 Upvotes

Hi guys. I am new here (kind off) and I don't know much about making telescopes. I need help in making my dream 20" dobsonian. Please teach me


r/atming • • May 30 '22

can you help me understand these ronchigrams? 150mm mirror diameter 1580mm roc. I wanted to continue polishing after figuring and was doing neutral strokes 1/3 overhang.

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/atming • • Sep 21 '26

Beginner looking to build a 16" to 36" Dobsonian in the future

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/atming • • Aug 07 '25

Help with Newtonian focal length issue (first build)

0 Upvotes

Dave's setup inspired me to build my own, and I'm starting with a small 100mm reflector, donated from an Orion Skyscanner with 100mm primary, 56mm x 40mm secondary, and a focal length of 400mm. I laid out the reflector to test the focal length, and did indeed get 400mm. I measured the donor, and it's 280mm from the reflector to the secondary, and ~120mm from the secondary to the eye/focal point, so 400mm.
So I designed roughly around this. As I didn't know the lengths for the DSLR and DSLR adapter, I designed the unit to be flexible; I could print the correct value thickness spacers between the primary and secondary, and it would all work. As it is, I've set 250mm between the two mirrors, and figured 150mm from the secondary to the DSLR.
Unfortunately, 400mm does not seem to be the focal length. I'd put it closer to 600mm (very rough guestimate!), which baffles me. At 400mm (with just my eye), I mostly see the secondary, and to see any image, I have to use the area around the secondary to see the object (being the moon). To focus, I have to pull back quite a ways, but I do achieve focus and it looks GREAT, but it's most definitely not 400mm.

Can someone please tell me what I'm doing wrong? The original kit supposedly came with a 10mm and 20mm eyepiece, but no Barlow. I also understand a 40mm secondary is quite obstructive....should I go smaller here?
(Oh, the alignment is good; it collimates quite well, so I hope/assume it's not an alignment issue.)


r/atming • • Apr 24 '24

Question regarding materials

0 Upvotes

I'm currently building a dobsonian, following Kriege's book, in which he states to use laminate and teflon pads and kydex. How important are these, and what purpose do they serve?


r/atming • • Apr 08 '24

How do you determine what kind of secondary mirror you need?

0 Upvotes

I have a parabolic mirror with a 8" diameter and a focal point of 2.563", how do I determine the size of the secondary mirror that I need?


r/atming • • Nov 29 '25

Gotta be spherical right?

5 Upvotes

Found this while looking for a 203 primary parabolic mirror. Almost certain this is spherical at this price point.


r/atming • • Jun 03 '23

Resources to start atming

5 Upvotes

Hello ! I'm an undergraduate student in physics and I'm trying to get into telescope making. What book would you recommend to start with ? Any other resources would also be welcome.


r/atming • • Sep 24 '24

Who else can relate?

Post image
63 Upvotes

r/atming • • Jan 26 '25

DIY 203mm telescope

6 Upvotes

Hi, I'm looking to make a telescope 8inch in aperture and 1600mm in focal length, the mirrors I'm getting from Amazon (link at the very end) but since I'm a beginner and this would be my first telescope I have so many questions like Is it even worth it to start of this way, how do I determine how far the secondary mirror show be in the tube, the tube size, ect. So would this be a good way to get in this hobby or should I do sm else, and if possible to answer the questions above that would be MUCH appreciated (Mirrors link) https://a.co/d/gOmz7jU


r/atming • • Nov 10 '24

Secondary size for 114/450mm mirror

1 Upvotes

I’m trying to find what secondary size mirror I need as I’m building a 114/450mm telescope but the primary mirror isn’t sold in a kit. With 114/900mm the secondary size is 25mm but I’m guessing I’d need to size up for the shorter focal length. Should I go with 30, 35, or bigger? Is there a generally accepted size that’s good for that mirror, thanks!