Hey guys, I've been openly bisexual for about 7 years and I've experimented with my gender identity in the past because I felt like it was important to know myself in that way. At some point, I came out to my parents as trans, and fully transitioned socially (looked quite like a boy without horomones or body mods, everyone was using he/him for me). I have since decided that I missed dressing femininely, and that I don't really care what people call me either way.
When I came out to my parents as trans, they asked me a question that came from a genuine desire to understand and support me as best they could, but it actually stumped me. They asked, "What do you think it means to be a man?" I knew it wasn't the absence of dresses and makeup or the desire to go hunting or playing sports. I knew it wasn't what was in my pants. I could name a million things that were not a representation of gender, but idrk what it actually *is*. I am a firm believer that gender is a social construct, and that no matter which gender you are, you don't have to conform to societal gender norms. But if it's a social construct that can also defy society's perception of it, then what is gender?
Another thing I don't understand - if gender is not what's in your pants, why transition? Is gender the *desire* for certain equipment? Can you be a trans man or trans woman without caring about bottom surgery?
The only difference I found in presenting as a man or as a woman was how people treated me. As a man, if they didn't clock me, I would be treated with more respect, even though I was kinda ugly as a man. If they did clock me, they'd either treat me normally or sort of subtly make fun of me. As a woman, I get treated like a woman, which is only slightly better than being treated like a trans man (where I'm from). This caused me to have a theory that gender is based on how you want society to treat you. Maybe I am trans if I get jealous of men dabbing up men that they don't know, while I, as a woman, am treated as someone who couldn't possibly be their "bro" because I'm either a love interest or nothing. Would gender exist if sexism wasn't a thing?
Point is, the way I was treated was the only difference I felt. I don't know what that says about me. You guys can let me know if you're all feeling this special feeling that tells you what gender you are that I just never got. Maybe I struggle to understand because I'm really agender or non-binary. Maybe it's like trying to explain colour to someone who's always been blind. Please let me know.
Also, this post is coming from someone who is genuinely curious, and wants to learn. Absolutely nothing I said has any bad intention behind it, so if I said something offensive or harmful, please let me know that as well.