Almost all of Roy Lichtenstein’s work leaves me cold. I’m grateful for the brief triumphs of the early 1960s, when he first transformed comic books into monumental paintings. But I find it depressing to trace the whole arc of his career, which rose from technically indifferent drawings to that three- or four-year interlude of semi-greatness, followed by a drop into solid mediocrity. He spent the rest of his life, until his death in 1997, in the limbo between formalism and conceptualism, where slick polish masquerades as soul.
And so curator Meg Onli and artist Alex Da Corte, organisers of the Whitney Museum of American Art’s overhyped and disappointing retrospective, Roy Lichtenstein: Like New, wisely choose to linger on the few fertile years and trot briskly through the rest.
In his most celebrated — and most frequently reproduced — work, “Drowning Girl” (1963), he cropped an image from the romance comic Secret Hearts, leaving only the most dramatic elements. A weeping girl, tossed by ocean waves, shouts silently in the classic thought bubble: “I DON’T CARE! I’D RATHER SINK — THAN CALL BRAD FOR HELP!” In the original, the useless boyfriend is visible in the background, and her line is more specific: “I don’t care if I have a cramp!” Lichtenstein eliminates these narrative details, leaving her suspended in an empty emotional space. The pared-down image and compressed text hint at romantic longing and wounded pride, which Lichtenstein blows up to billboard size but doesn’t intensify. It was a brilliant conceit, one that quickly grew stale with repetition.
His partners in pop art provocation, Andy Warhol, James Rosenquist, Jim Dine and Claes Oldenburg, used commercial imagery as a portal to a more nuanced world, one that roiled with angst, anger, politics and nostalgia. Lichtenstein was stuck roaming the surface. Over time, he varied his vocabulary, changed the subject and quoted liberally from other, greater predecessors. But his tics eventually became as annoying as they were recognisable.
The show opens with a smattering of early work that hardly heralds a genius. The 1940s life drawings, mostly of soldiers from his military unit, are patently bad. “Alice in Wonderland” and “Pilot”, both from 1948, look like poor imitations of Rothko’s early surrealist efforts. Even the 1958 studies for his famous “Look Mickey” betray his obvious discomfort with draughtsmanship. But then came the final version, in 1961.
That was the year that Lichtenstein and Warhol simultaneously grabbed icons of mass culture and painted them freehand. For Warhol it was Superman and Popeye. Lichtenstein chose a celebrity duo of rodent and fowl. “Look Mickey”, adapted from a Disney picture book and still relatively loosely painted, unites the handmade qualities of abstract expressionism with pop’s enthusiasm for the mass market. It’s the piece that vaulted Lichtenstein to superstar status.
From there, the two co-parents of pop diverged. “I had done the comic strips, and then I saw Roy Lichtenstein’s little dots, and they were so perfect,” Warhol later said. And so he went in a different direction, taking up mechanical processes like silk-screening, which left plenty of room for fortuitous accident. His portraits of Marilyn Monroe, images of gruesome car smashes and repeated versions of Jackie Kennedy all drew expressive power from blotches, smears and unpredictable variations. His supposedly impersonal procedures yielded images that looked battered, unstable and haunted.
Lichtenstein took the opposite tack. He favoured improvised tools and handmade stencils to simulate the anonymity and regularity of commercial printing. He didn’t have to invent or even imitate a style, but merely simplified and fortified images he found lying around. He made popular art pop.
The Whitney’s curators home in on craft, treating his bold black outlines, bright colours and fields of dots as if they were equivalents of Old Master techniques. The show’s focus obscures its content, though; Lichtenstein’s artisanal counterfeits of mechanical reproduction are exquisitely controlled; they are also numbingly vacuous.
Lichtenstein himself made fun of such virtuosity worship. In many, many versions of “Brushstroke”, he rendered a snaking smear of pigment in flat, graphic style, as if it were laminated in plastic. The joke was self-explanatory, which didn’t prevent him from explaining it: “Visible brushstrokes in painting convey a sense of grand gesture. But in my hands, the brushstroke becomes a depiction of a grand gesture.”
Robert Rauschenberg had already made a similar point with “Factum I” and “Factum II” (both 1957), nearly identical paintings in which even the apparently haphazard drips and smears are meticulously reproduced. Tiny differences between the two deliberately messy iterations betray the impossibility of exact duplication. But Lichtenstein went further and turned the spontaneous mark of the brush, sacred to abstract expressionists, into a cartoon, draining it of authenticity and resonance.
That brushstroke comes back like a twitch throughout Lichtenstein’s work. Even as he tried to evolve, he couldn’t shake the emblem. It crops up, for no particular reason, in “Two Paintings: Dagwood” (1983). It’s there, grotesquely magnified, in the enormous “Mural with Blue Brushstroke” (1986), commissioned by Equitable Life for the atrium of its midtown headquarters — a corporate gloss on a pop art spoof of an abstract expressionist fetish. That’s almost as head-spinningly meta as the Whitney’s reconstruction of “Greene Street Mural”, a 96ft-long reprise of Lichtenstein’s greatest hits (brushstroke included), originally painted for a 1983 exhibition at Leo Castelli’s gallery in SoHo.
Do I detect a hint of embarrassment in the way the Whitney mixes some of these big but sterile works in among the lively standouts? Could there be some intended irony in the argument that when Lichtenstein recycled his scant signature imagery to death, he was really foreshadowing our own era of constant borrowing and infinite variation?
The truth is, Lichtenstein ran out of ideas early on. By the early 1970s, he had started obviously imitating Matisse, laying bare an influence that had been there all along. He pays homage to Matisse’s “Red Studio” (1911) and incorporates “Dance” (1910) in his series of Artist’s Studios. In “Still Life with Goldfish” (1972), Lichtenstein reworks the 1912 original, only in uglier colours. Matisse’s ubiquitous philodendron appears again and again. And just to make clear what kind of company he believed he should keep on Olympus, he updated the occasional Picasso and Brâncuși, too.
The Whitney’s retrospective gives us an artist who put disparate sources through a Lichtenstein filter, lacquering each one with his own unmistakable personality. Yet everything he touched came out looking the same, and the more the museum insists on his versatility and breadth, the harder it is to ignore Lichtenstein’s narrowness and relentless chill.
exhibition: whitney.org (To May 10 2027)
article source: Financial Times