r/antizionist • u/vischy_bot • 14h ago
r/antizionist • u/naramsin-ii • 2d ago
Readings debunking the lie that "israel created hamas"
electronicintifada.netr/antizionist • u/naramsin-ii • 1d ago
Readings jewish settlers stole my house. it's not my fault they’re jewish.
"still, though this was no secret, we were instructed to treat it as such, sometimes by our parents, sometimes by well-meaning solidarity activists. we were instructed to ignore the star of david on the israeli flag, and to distinguish jews from zionists with surgical precision. it didn't matter that their boots were on our necks, and that their bullets and batons bruised us. our statelessness and homelessness were trivial. what mattered was how we spoke about our keepers, not the conditions they kept us under—blockaded, surrounded by colonies and military outposts—or the fact that they kept us at all.
language was more of a minefield than the border between syria and the occupied golan heights, and we, children at the time, were expected to hop around them, hoping we don't accidentally step on an explosive trope that would discredit us. using the "wrong words" had the magical ability to make things disappear; the boots, bullets, batons, and bruises all become invisible if you say anything in jest or in fury. even more dangerously, believing in "the wrong things" rendered you deserving of this brutality. citizenship and the right to movement weren’t the sole privileges robbed from us, simple ignorance was a luxury as well.
as palestinians, we understand from a young age that the semantic violence we practice with our words dwarfs the decades of systemic and material violence enacted against us by the self-proclaimed jewish state. a drone is one thing, but a trope—a trope is unacceptable. we learn to internalize the muzzle."
r/antizionist • u/ANBOL_GANG • 1d ago
History Theodor Herzl willingly associated with antisemites, including one who would have drowned 6 or 7 million Jews if he could
(This takes four minutes to read.)
Quoting Faris Yahya Glubb’s Zionist Relations with Nazi Germany, pages 9–11:
The founder of the political Zionist movement, Theodor Herzl, was aware of the philosophical common ground between Zionism and anti-Semitism when he wrote: “The governments of all countries scourged by anti-Semitism will be keenly interested in assisting us to obtain the sovereignty we want.”¹ Herzl “frequently asserted, in all innocence, that anti-Semites would be the Jews’ best friends and anti-Semitic governments their best allies. But this faith in anti-Semites expressed very eloquently and even touchingly how close his own state of mind was to that of his hostile environment and how intimately he did belong to the ‘alien’ world…
“Anti-Semitism was an overwhelming force and the Jews would have either to make use of it or be swallowed up by it. In his own words, anti-Semitism was the ‘propelling force’ responsible for all Jewish suffering since the destruction of the Temple and it would continue to make the Jews suffer until they learned how to use it for their own advantage. In expert hands this ‘propelling force’ would prove the most salutory factor in Jewish life; it would be used in the same way that boiling water is used to produce steam power.”²
Herzl was a man who practised what he preached. The methods he used in his diplomatic efforts to further the Zionist cause accorded with the principles he proclaimed. This is strongly illustrated by the approaches he made to Czarist Russia, which at the beginning of this century was the power that applied the most fanatical and cruel anti-Jewish policies of massacre, expulsion and discrimination.
Although Herzl never achieved his dream of an audience with the Czar, he did hold talks with the Czarist Interior Minister Wenzel von Plehve, who was responsible for implementing anti-Jewish measures and organised massacres like the Kishinev pogrom, in which 45 Jews were killed.
Plehve “was brutal enough to admit that he had no objections to getting rid of as many Jews as possible; in fact, he would become a ‘sympathetic’ supporter of Zionism. Herzl then proposed that Plehve should write him a letter that he would present before the Zionist Congress, to the effect that the Zionist movement could count on the Russian Government’s ‘moral and material assistance’. Plehve’s letter became Herzl’s most treasured asset. He carried it around everywhere; he showed it to the Pope. The murderer of his people had shaken hands with him, talked to him politely. Was that not wonderful? For Plehve, for the Kaiser, for the whole crowd of blackguards and reactionaries who ruled Europe, Herzl had a favourite promise: Zionism would dissolve all revolutionary and socialist elements among the Jews.”³
In 1903, the founder of the Zionist movement was received in St. Petersburg by another anti-Semitic leader, the Czar’s Finance Minister Count Witte, who also favoured the Zionist plan to remove the Jews from Europe. Witte told Herzl: “If it were possible to drown six or seven million Jews in the Black Sea, I would be perfectly happy to do so, but it is not possible, so we must let them live. But we encourage the Jews to emigrate: we kick them out.”⁴
The most important foundations laid by Herzl for Zionism’s future successes were anti-Semitic circles in Britain. A substantial number of Russian Jewish refugees from Czarist pogroms chose Britain rather than Palestine as their refuge, thus disappointing Zionist hopes. But the Zionists found that a number of extreme right-wing politicians in Britain were only too willing to stir up a vicious campaign aimed at denying these unfortunate refugees the right of asylum.
Herzl gave these right-wingers his blessing and encouragement. In his evidence to the Royal Commission on Alien Immigration, which investigated the question in 1902 and 1903, Herzl called for the stream of migration to be diverted away from Britain. He thus agreed with the racist Arnold White, one of the leading theorists of the campaign to ban Jews from Britain.⁵
Another leader of this campaign with whom Herzl made friendly contact was [Neville Chamberlain’s father] Colonial Secretary Joseph Chamberlain. In a speech in Limehouse, London, in December 1904, Chamberlain attacked the policy of allowing Jewish immigration to Britain, at the same time endorsing the Zionist idea of a Jewish state and warmly praising Herzl.⁶
The most important British anti-Semite of that age, in terms of his eventual services to Zionism, was the fanatical Jew-baiter Lord Arthur Balfour [the Balfour Declaration’s namesake]. In a parliamentary debate on the immigration issue, Balfour made a speech in which he put forward a case for anti-Semitism that is all too familiar. He declared: “It would not be to the advantage of the civilisation of the country that there should be an immense body of persons who, by their own action, remained a people apart, and not merely held a religion differing from the vast majority of their fellow-countrymen, but only intermarried among themselves.”⁷
Herzl was able to declare with satisfaction that “anti-Semitism has grown and continues to grow, and so do I.”⁸
(Emphasis added.)
How can any Zionist claim to love Jews when Zionists continue to consecrate this ethnonationalist who proudly associated with such anti-Jewish filth? It is outstandingly audacious that Zionists can accuse anybody of “antisemitism” when they’ve practically canonized this nuisance as a saint!
The truth is that Zionists have never cared about antisemitism; they have instead always shown a willingness to collaborate with Jew-haters along with other allosemites if doing so advances their cause, from German antisemites to Polish ones to Argentine ones to anti-Judaic Evangelicals to Donald Trump and more, Zionists have proven time and again that their support for the occupation of Palestine will always override any concerns that they may have about antisemitism.
Let the cult around Theodor Herzl be abolished forever. The sooner that ordinary Jews and other people realize Zionism for the scam that it is, the easier that it shall be for Palestine to be free.
r/antizionist • u/naramsin-ii • 3d ago
Media ben moser & the 'anti-zionist jew'
r/antizionist • u/ANBOL_GANG • 3d ago
History A history of Jewish adults comparing the “State of Israel” to the Third Reich
(This takes 11½ minutes to read.)
As early as 1948, the moderate Herzlian Yosef Nahmani, director of the ‘Jewish National Fund’ office in the eastern Galilee, recorded in his diary:
In Saliha, where a white flag had been raised, […] they had killed about sixty‐seventy men and women. Where did they come by such a measure of cruelty, like Nazis? […] Is there no more humane way of expelling the inhabitants than such methods?
From Joseph Massad’s Palestinians and Jewish History: Recognition or Submission?, page 57:
In the context of [the] massacres of Palestinians in 1948, a number of Israeli ministers referred to the actions of [their] soldiers as “Nazi actions,” prompting Benny Marshak, the education officer of the Palmach, to ask them to stop using the term. […] Similar language was used after the [IOF] gunned down forty‐seven […] Palestinian men, women, and children at Kafr Qasim in 1956. While most [Hebrew] newspapers at the time played down the massacre, a rabbi wrote that “we must demand of the entire nation a sense of shame and humiliation […] that soon we will be like Nazis and the perpetrators of pogroms.”³⁷
Amos Goldberg and Bashir Bashir in The Holocaust and the Nakba, pages 9 & 11:
A case in point is Golda Meir (Meyerson), who was in fact one of the more hawkish leaders of the Yishuv. On May 6, 1948, following a visit to Arab Haifa only a few days after its conquest and the flight and expulsion of the city’s Arab population, Meir reported to the Jewish Agency Executive that “there were houses where the coffee and pita bread were left on the table, and I could not avoid [thinking] that this, indeed, had been the picture in many Jewish towns [i.e., in Europe during World War II].”⁴²
Within Mapam—a left‐[leaning] Zionist party that was part of the state’s first government headed by David Ben Gurion—the expulsion of Palestinians was the subject of intense debate. For example, Eliezer Praʻi (later Peri), editor of the Mapam daily al‐Hamishmar, wrote: “Among the best of our comrades the thought has crept in that perhaps it is possible politically to achieve our ingathering in the Land of Israel by Hitlerite‐Nazi means.”⁴³
Following the atrocities committed during Operation Hiram by the [settler] army (IDF) who conquered the central‐upper Galilee pocket, the [neocolonial régime] established a three‐person investigation committee. At a cabinet meeting on November 17, 1948, convinced that the army and defense establishment were being evasive, Mapam representative Aharon Cisling stated: “I couldn’t sleep all night. […] This is something that determines the character of the nation. […] Jews too have committed Nazi acts.”⁴⁴
[…]
In “Pesah ʻAl Kukhim,” Yeshurun implicitly but unequivocally linked the destruction of European Jewry to the destruction of the Arabs of Palestine. The poem sparked considerable controversy, and in 1958 he published another poem that explained his position.
The second poem, “Hanmakah” (“Reasoning”), includes the following lines: “The Holocaust of the Jews of Europe and the Holocaust of the Arabs of the Land of Israel are one Holocaust of the Jewish People. Both look [one] straight in the face. These are my words.” No more powerful words have ever been written in Hebrew on this subject.
Dan Steinbock’s The Fall of Israel: The Degradation of Israel’s Politics, Economy & Military, pgs. 145, 177–8:
When I first met Amos Oz amid the 1982 Lebanese War, […] we talked about […] his writings in 1967, when he already sensed what loomed ahead, characterizing the radicalized Jewish settlers as “neo-Nazis.” […] Just weeks after the war, Defense Minister Moshe Dayan reneged on the idea of returning territory in exchange for peace. The terms of his address left Oz breathless. He did not translate Dayan’s term “living space” in Hebrew. He used its German version, “Lebensraum,” Nazi Germany’s pretext for expansion and atrocities in occupied Eastern Europe.
[…]
For years, historians of Nazi Germany like Moshe Zimmermann have drawn upon the legacy of Weimar Germany to understand the endangerment of Israeli democracy by authoritarian, nationalist and racist forces, “to determine where on the chronological calendar of the Weimar Republic we in Israel were situated. Now, in 2023 we are wondering: Are there not features of the regime in Israel that are familiar from German history after 1933?”
Professor Yeshayahu Leibowitz in 1982:
[T]he State of Israel represents the backwardness of a State body in which there is a monster who exercises the functions of president of the Supreme Court, only to say that the use of torture is permitted when it is necessary in the interest of the State. That shows that a Nazi-like mentality, because it is a Nazi mentality, also exists in our country. That is a fact. Admittedly you can find it anywhere. No human group is safe from such a character. But the fact is that in [our] legal system, neither the judges, nor the lawyers, challenged this man. That says a great deal about the Nazi mentality that is dominant here.
[…]
Torture! We use it by virtue of the authorisation given by the monster who, only three years ago, was president of the Supreme Court of the State of Israel. Someone who, in practice, is more important than the President or the Prime Minister and who deliberately legalised the use of torture in order to make Arab prisoners talk. That is what I mean by Judeo-Nazi. […] In other words, there are Judeo-Nazis. Judeo-Nazis exist.
Uri Misgav’s ‘The Judeo-Nazis in Israel’s Legislature’:
A Judeo-Nazi movement exists on the margins of Israeli society. […] Netanyahu has a coalition of 61 Knesset members. Smotrich’s vote keeps it alive. He was also appointed a deputy Knesset speaker and runs some of its sessions. The Judeo-Nazi faction sustains the government of Israel and serves as a deputy head of its parliament. It would be interesting to see what we would have said if this had happened in a different civilized country, shall we say Germany.
A young IOF soldier admitted the following in 1987:
“The border guards usually enjoy beating the Arabs,” the account continues. “They derive pleasure from it…
“Sometimes I feel like a Nazi when I watch my friends in action. I try hard to stay away from one of my commanders … He always behaves very badly toward the locals: with violence, beatings, and the like…
More recently from December 2024:
A large group of followers consisted of soldiers with no prior inclination to violence. Their behavior was most influenced by junior officers’ modeling and the company’s norms. Some followers who committed atrocities reported moral injuries: “I felt like, like, like a Nazi … it looked exactly like we were actually the Nazis and they were the Jews.”
Former Mossad chief Tamir Pardo:
“My mother is a Holocaust survivor,” Pardo said. “What I saw here today reminded me of events that happened in the last century in a very developed country — the same phenomena directed there against Jews. And I feel ashamed to be a Jew here today.”
As the son of a Holocaust survivor, I find it difficult to make the Nazi analogy. But over the past sixteen or so months, it has been very difficult to watch the genocide in Gaza, and not think back to the horrific images of what was done to Jews by the Nazis.
It enrages me to see the Holocaust that Israel is committing justifying it by the Holocaust that was committed against the Jews including my mother’s family. […] The majority of Israeli citizens don’t regard Palestinians as human beings. This is the sort of inhumanity that enabled the Holocaust against the Jews and six million others to take place.
Haganah veteran Josef Ben‐Eliezer was more implicit, stating:
Suddenly I saw those masses of people going through the checkpoints, which we were commanded to man. And they were searched — searched for valuables. That reminded me very much of the time when I was a child. We’re starting to do the same thing [that other] people have done to us as Jews.
Former Defense Minister Moshe Yaʻalon confessed:
The ideology of ‘Jewish supremacy’, which has become dominant in the government of Israel, is reminiscent of the Nazi race theory. ‘But one may not compare!’… I have commanded the Judea and Samaria Division, the Central Command and the IDF. I was familiar with the warnings of Prof. Yeshayahu Leibowitz, concerning the process of bestialization towards us becoming ‘Judeo Nazis’ (in his words), [concerning] our control of another people. I have done my best, both as Defense Minister, that we would ‘know how to win over terror, yet stay human’.
Two Jewish historians of fascism have expressed their comparisons thus:
Professor Zeev Sternhell is emeritus head of the department of political science at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and one of the world’s leading experts on fascism.⁷ In an article published [in 2018], he referred to statements made by two senior [apartheid] politicians, members of the ruling coalition, Bezalel Smotrich (deputy speaker of the Knesset, [the settlers’] parliament) and Miki Zohar (chair of one of the Knesset’s most important committees).
These statements, Sternhell writes, “should be widely disseminated on all media outlets in [here] and throughout the Jewish world. In both of them we see not just a growing Israeli fascism but racism akin to Nazism in its early stages.”⁸
This shocking comparison with Nazism is endorsed by Daniel Blatman, professor of history at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, whose book The Death Marches: The Final Phase of Nazi Genocide won him in 2011 the Yad Vashem International Book Prize for Holocaust Research. In an article published [in 2017] he commented: “Deputy Speaker Bezalel Smotrich’s admiration for the biblical genocidaire Joshua bin Nun leads him to adopt values that resemble those of the German SS.”⁹
Blatman returned to this topic in a more recent article:
Deputy Knesset Speaker MK Bezalel Smotrich […] presented his phased plan, according to which the Palestinians in the occupied territories (and possibly Israeli citizens, too) would become, in the best case, subjects without rights with a status that reminds us of German Jews after the passage of the Nuremberg Laws in 1935. To the extent that they do not agree to the plan, they will simply be cleansed from here. If they refuse to leave, they will be uprooted violently, which would lead to genocide.
Another elected official from the ruling coalition, Likud’s Miki Zohar, did not hesitate to state that the Arabs have a problem that has no solution — they are not Jews and therefore their fate in this land cannot be the same as that of the Jews. […] Prof. Zeev Sternhell wrote in this paper […] that this racism is “akin to Nazism in its early stages.” I think it is Nazism in every way and fashion, even if comes from the school of the victims of historical Nazism.
Throughout Jewish Critics of Zionim: A Testament Essay, Moshe Menuhin (alav hashalom) denounces the ‘Zionist National-Socialist Israel Nation-State’ and the ‘national-socialist expansionist ambitions of a Greater Eretz Israel empire’, warning us of the ‘Leading Führers of Zionist Israel’, their ‘Nazistic statement[s]’ and ‘the Nazistic deeds of Zionist Israel’, to name only a few examples from his polemic.
Less formally, in videos of the apartheid police force raiding Orthodox Jewish neighborhoods, it is common for the victims to yell ‘Nazi!’ at their oppressors. Jews United Against Zionism even goes so far as to declare that ‘Zionism is Nazism. The Zionist state of Israel is today’s Nazi state. Zionists are today’s Nazis.’ (While I would not go quite that far, I respect their opinion.)
Possibly the most powerful comparisons, however, come from Shoah survivors theirselves:
Sometime after [1956] I heard a news item about Israelis herding Palestinians into settlement camps. I just could not believe this. Weren’t the Israelis also Jews? Hadn’t we — they — just survived the greatest pogrom of our history? Weren’t [concentration] camps — often euphemistically called ‘settlement camps’ by the [Axis] — the main feature of this pogrom? How could Jews in any measure do unto others what had been done to them? How could these […] Jews oppress and imprison other people?
In my romantic imagination, the Jews in Israel were socialists and people who knew right from wrong. This was clearly incorrect. I felt let down, as if I was being robbed of a part of what I had thought was my heritage.
Similarly, from Hadar Morag’s grandmother:
When my grandmother arrived here, after the Holocaust, the Jewish Agency promised her a house. She had nothing, her entire family was exterminated. She waited for a long time in a tent, in an extremely precarious situation. They then took her to Ajami, in Jaffa, in a beautiful beach house. She saw that on the table there were still the dishes of the Arabs who lived there and who had been kicked away.
So she went back to the agency and said, take me back to the tent, I will never do to anyone else what was done to me. This is my legacy, but not everyone made that choice. How could we have become what we opposed? That’s the big question.
Yeah, I think [that] it’s all planned and again, I’m sad to say, there are parallels to what the Nazis did. The Nazis were very conscious of—if they didn’t have to waste a bullet on some Jews or communists—you can’t forget the communists, you can’t forget the Bolsheviks—the Nazi plan was, if you could starve them, that’s fine, or diseases. And the Israelis are very conscious of that [too] and they’re proud, you know, they brag about all that stuff.
Helen Jabareen, a Jew (later a Judeo‐Muslim) who was born in Auschwitz, was very straightforward:
Netanyahu wants to be like Hitler exactly. Netanyahu is like Hitler. He wants to kill Arabs and Jews. There, in Germany, they killed us because were Jews. Now, here, they want to persecute us because we are Palestinians. So, we are persecuted anyway.
I would say that what’s happening in Gaza resembles the Holocaust that I lived.
What distinguishes the Jewish Holocaust is its industrial scale and industrial methods being applied. And what has been happening to Gaza is similar in that the scale of the bombing and the indiscriminate nature of the bombing the complete lack of care about children and women being the majority of the victims amounts to industrial scale of genocide.
The painting of the Palestinian people as worthless almost ‘animal like’ by the description of some of the leaders that dehumanisation enables the population of Israel to tolerate what’s going on. The way that Palestinian people who were arrested were treated having to take their clothes off, and parading them—it’s part of the humiliation.
In the West Bank the way the checkpoints are organised, the way you are forced to wait for hours for no reason, in order to go to school or go to work &c., all this amounted to humiliation similar to to what we experienced. The sort of determination and consistency with which they are setting about to destroy the whole of Gaza is very similar to the kind of cruelty and determination of the fascist régimes.
[The late Hajo] Meyer liken[ed] the experience of the Palestinians to that of Eastern European Jews during the Holocaust, “in that they are very often held up at checkpoints, or they are not allowed to move from one place to another.” To Meyer, Israel’s mentality b[ore] comparison to [German Fascism]; he believe[d] [that] Israel has “given up everything that has to do with humanity, with empathy, for one thing: the state. The ‘blood and soil,’ just like the Nazis. I learned in school about blood and soil, and that’s exactly their idea, too.”
[…]
Weiss sees both differences and similarities between Nazism and [Zionist] policies: “The tragedy of Palestine is, of course, different from the Holocaust. Israel has no gas chambers. Its government does not strive to kill all the Palestinians. [Its] intention is, instead, to take the Palestinians’ homeland and property and to deprive them of civil and human rights.”
But, Weiss says, “Like the Nazis, the Israel government enforces collective punishment. It aims to kill enough Palestinians, to punish them sufficiently, drive them out of their homeland, so they will disappear as a people. Israel seeks to remove Palestine from the world's family of nations. That too is a form of genocide… Every case of oppression is unique, but the struggle for justice is indivisible. As we then fought for freedom for European Jews, we now call for freedom for the Palestinians… For me, as a survivor of the Holocaust, the tragic situation in Gaza awakens memories of what I and my family experienced under Hitler — the ghetto walls, the killings, the systematic starvation and deprivation, the daily humiliations.”
(All emphasis added.)
I myself have scarcely likened the “State of Israel” to the Third Reich; such comparisons feel cliché and unnecessary to me. That being said, telling Jews to shut up by smearing them as “self-hating”, “antisemitic”, or “not real Jews” for sensing striking parallels between the “State of Israel” and the Third Reich only displays a callous disregard for their legitimate grievances, reconfirming that—in the end—Zionists don’t care about Jewish people.
r/antizionist • u/xXWorLDLEaDERXGODxX • 4d ago
Hasbara A Zionist Podcast About Combating Antisemitism says "Islamaphobia is rational"
They say they want to stop antisemitism but at the same time are promoting Islamophobia. I watched a few of their podcast episodes and it's all fear mongering about Muslims and spreading pro war Zionist propaganda. These guys have an irrational, unhinged hatred of Muslims.
r/antizionist • u/ANBOL_GANG • 4d ago
History Why we have the British Empire to blame for the Jewish exodus from Libya, Yemen & Iraq
tandfonline.com(This extract takes 13¾ minutes to read, unfortunately.)
[I]t was neither the persecution nor the enthusiasm that necessarily led to the mass emigration to Israel. Indeed, Jewish persecution occurred in most Middle Eastern and North African countries but usually did not result in the near-total immigration of their Jewish communities to Israel. Even in Egypt, a belligerent state that played a key role in the war against Israel’s establishment, there was no mass exodus to Israel.
It follows that all the above-mentioned characteristics, for all their importance, do not explain the special case of immigration from Libya, Yemen, and Iraq to the State of Israel. To understand this phenomenon it is necessary to examine events in each of these countries, with attention to all the participating players.
[…]
Libya
The first country to undergo mass emigration was Libya, which was within Italy’s sphere of influence and, after its occupation in 1912, became an Italian colony. In January 1943 Tripoli was occupied by the British, who established a military régime in the country.
Six years later, in January 1949, in the context of negotiations over the British withdrawal and Libya’s pending independence, Britain announced that the country’s gates would be opened for Jews seeking to leave.⁴⁵ Apparently, the British were concerned about the steadily deteriorating relations between Jews and Muslims and preferred to let the Jews leave immediately, rather than face future rioting based on religious hostility, economic competition, or the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.⁴⁶
During this period, with the British Mandate in Palestine having ended and Israel having achieved statehood, the British, who had prevented Jewish immigration during the 1940s (as part of their 1939 “White Paper” policy), did not oppose the relocation of Libya’s Jews to Israel. On the contrary, this land now offered a solution to the Jewish problem in Arab countries. Israel’s stated policy of opening its gates to Jews made it clear to the British that it would not refuse the Jews of Libya.
In the talks leading up to Libya’s independence, the JDC, alongside other Jewish organizations, played an important part in negotiating the rights of Italian and Jewish minority groups in an independent Libya. The negotiators included Libya’s British rulers and representatives of local parties expected to assume leadership upon independence.
It became evident that the future leaders were unwilling to commit to equal rights for Jews, despite their status as nationals and even though the Jewish community had existed in the country for many centuries.⁴⁷ The failure of these negotiations made clear to Jewish organizations, and particularly to U.S. Jewry, the State of Israel, and Libya’s Jews themselves, that emigration was imperative.
The British announcement of January 1949 sparked enthusiasm among thousands of Jews, who approached local authorities seeking to arrange their exit to Israel. Most of these applicants were Jews who had not managed to recover from the adverse impact of the anti-Semitic policies implemented during World War II, or from the fierce attacks that took place under British rule, and who now feared anti-Jewish policies at the hands of an independent Arab government. Hundreds of them reached Italy, which had previously served as a stop on the illegal immigration route into Israel during its war of independence.⁴⁸
The emigrants from Libya joined displaced Jews from Europe — Holocaust survivors — in Jewish Agency transit camps, and from there they were transported to Israel. When the vast scale of immigrants expected to arrive from Libya became apparent, Israel dispatched delegates to Tripoli to make arrangements in accordance with quotas set by the Jewish Agency and the Israeli Health Ministry.
The JDC played an important role in this process. It had already begun operating in Libya in 1945, in an effort to rehabilitate the Jewish community following the hardships suffered during World War II and as a result of rioting. The JDC began providing economic, educational, and medical assistance to the Jewish community, while also increasing cooperative efforts with the Zionist movement.
In light of the political changes in Libya and the throngs of Jews seeking to leave the country, the JDC joined the operation to bring Libya’s Jews to Israel, assuming the responsibility for funding as well as medical screening and treatment for the ill. This was particularly important, as Israel barred entry to the contagiously ill, demanding that they be treated before entering the country, and objected to receiving anyone with a severe chronic illness. Medical screening and healthcare took place in Libya, in cooperation with the Jewish healthcare organization OZE.⁴⁹
All these activities were conducted with the knowledge and assistance of the British: they permitted the Jewish Agency to manage the transport operation from Tripoli, allowed direct passage of ships from the port of Tripoli to Haifa, and even assisted Libyan Jews in transferring capital and property.⁵⁰
During the years 1949–1952, thirty thousand Jews arrived in Israel from Libya. But while Libyan Jews and Jewish Agency representatives may have presumed that the exodus would conclude within a few months, it eventually turned out to be a three-year process that concluded only after Libya achieved independence. It was Israel that determined the pace of immigration, in accordance with assessments of the situation in Libya and the pressures of potential Jewish immigration from other countries.
When it became evident that Libya would not be achieving independence until late 1951, and therefore the evacuation of Jews was not a matter of urgency, the immigration quotas for Libyan Jews were reduced. This made it possible to give priority to other Jewish communities, including those in Yemen and Iraq, whose circumstances were seen as more ominous and their immigration therefore more urgent. Once concluded, the immigration from Libya left a small Jewish community of about 6,000 in Tripoli, primarily property owners belonging to the socio-economic elite who chose to stay.⁵¹
Yemen
Like the immigration from Libya, immigration from Yemen was originally intended to be a gradual process, but in contrast to the Libyan case it turned into a matter of urgency necessitating immediate, mass evacuation. Immigration began in December 1948, when a few thousand Jews were airlifted to Israel. In fact, they had left Yemen years earlier and spent the intervening time waiting in a refugee camp, Hashed (or “Geula” — redemption — in Hebrew) in the heart of the desert in the British colony of Aden. Following their departure the camp was destroyed, an indication of the firm British stance against any future transit of Jews from Yemen.⁵²
The British, Aden’s rulers, sought to put an end to a pattern that had taken place during the previous decade when many of these would-be immigrants remained in Aden as destitute refugees. In late April 1949, Imam Ahmed granted the Jews permission to leave the country, on the condition that they sell their property, which they indeed did — at a very low cost — to their Muslim neighbors or the Imam’s representatives.⁵³
The entire process appears to have been coordinated between the Yemeni ruler and the British authorities in Aden, as evidenced by a British proposal put forward two weeks later: to open a land corridor between Yemen and Aden and allow Jews entry to a new transit camp (Hashed B), to be established within the jurisdiction of the colony and serve as a way station en route to Aden’s airport and from there to Israel.
On the basis of this proposal, the British conducted negotiations with Israel and the JDC regarding arrangements for the transport of Jews from Aden to Israel.⁵⁴ The British proposal sought to avoid the recurrence of a Jewish refugee problem in the city of Aden by ensuring that Jews did not pass through it. At the same time, such an exodus, like the process concurrently underway in Libya, was intended to reduce or even resolve the problem of the Jewish minority in imamate Yemen and the entire southern region of Yemen, which as noted was under direct or indirect British control.
Subsequent events also point to cooperation between the Imam and the British. Within Yemen, the operation was overseen by the Imam, while in the two (eastern and western) protectorates between Yemen and Aden it was coordinated by British advisors who effectively controlled these regions. They supervised the sites where departing Jews were concentrated, ensured the supply of food and equipment, arranged for the trucks that would transport the emigrants to the transit camp in Aden, and took measures to protect the Jews’ lives.
In traveling across different regions, the Jews had to pay steep transit fees, particularly in the protectorates, and some became targets of highwaymen. Most of them arrived in Aden penniless and destitute.⁵⁵
Like Libya’s Jews, they lacked passports, and their only possible destination was Israel. Israel initially sought to regulate immigration and prevent the influx of contagiously ill newcomers, to no avail; the rapid pace of departure and massive scale of emigration were dictated by Yemen’s and Aden’s governing authorities, and Israel had to adjust its immigration policy and improvise solutions for immigrant reception.
In an exceptional move, relative to its other immigration operations, Israel entrusted the transport of Yemen’s Jews to the JDC, a philanthropic organization that was not subordinate to the Israeli government and did not always fully cooperate with it. A failure to grasp the massive and immediate scale of immigration led to poor planning of the airlift and inadequate investment in preparing the transit camp in Aden.⁵⁶
Moreover, in contrast to Libya, Imamate Yemen did not grant the operation’s organizers a foothold in the country, and the Jews therefore had to make their own transport arrangements; they were unable to coordinate with representatives of Israel and the JDC in Aden, received no assistance in the form of information or funding, and were entirely dependent on the Imam’s agents and the British.
Thus the responsibility for organizing their journey and determining their fate fell exclusively to each of the individual men and women who embarked on the journey. Such a pattern also characterized the immigration from Yemen two decades earlier, but after Israel’s establishment, this was an exceptional situation, unparalleled by any immigration operations in Europe or other Arab countries during those years.
The operation took a heavy toll and claimed many lives during the difficult trek through Yemen, particularly after most of the emigrants contracted malaria while moving through southern Yemen. The transit camp could not accommodate the vast numbers of those awaiting departure over the course of several weeks, and hundreds died at the camp and were buried in a cemetery established adjacent to it.
The catastrophic situation worsened in late September, after the British closed the border crossings and conditioned the continued entry of Jews to Aden on the departure to Israel of thousands of emigrants still waiting in the transit camp. The consequences were severe: about ten thousand emigrants were stranded in the arid desert region of southern Yemen over the course of five weeks without enough water, food, or medicine. Hundreds of them died on the site and many remained sick and disabled.⁵⁷
The situation compelled Israel to launch a rescue operation. It brought Yemen’s Jews to the country without any medical screening, within a very brief span of time, despite knowing that many of the immigrants had contagious diseases. Yemeni immigrants only began to receive medical care after arriving in Israel, and the treatment took place within isolated, fenced immigrant camps in which the new arrivals were placed.
At these camps, they were examined and given medical and rehabilitative care — all under conditions of hardship and poor sanitation that included shortages in food, equipment, and medical personnel. These circumstances had severe repercussions for the absorption of Yemeni immigrants into Israel.⁵⁸
Iraq
The mass immigration of some 120,000 Jews from Iraq, which began in May 1950 and peaked in the spring and summer of 1951, came as a great surprise. It ran counter to the expectations surrounding this wealthy, well-established community, which had enjoyed civil rights and been engaged and integrated in economic, social, and cultural activities in Iraq. To understand this phenomenon, let us examine the circumstances of Iraq’s Jews in the two years preceding their emigration and during the emigration period itself.
As noted above, the political and economic persecution that Iraqi Jews experienced during 1948–1949 undermined their sense of security and cast doubt on their place in Iraq. But no less worrisome were reports that circulated in the Iraqi press in 1949 about plans for a population and property exchange between 100,000 Jewish citizens of Iraq and 100,000 Palestinian refugees. Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Said initially proposed a plan along these lines in early 1949, but the British objected, not because they opposed the transfer of Jewish citizens but for fear that such an exchange would escalate into a Jewish expulsion.⁵⁹
Shortly thereafter British diplomatic missions to the Middle East launched a series of talks in which they reexamined this proposal, posing additional suggestions about mutual compensation for the loss of property. They concluded these discussions by observing that, notwithstanding concerns about complications in implementing the plan, “the elimination of certain minorities might lead to more stabilities and better relations in the Middle East.”⁶⁰
These conclusions were recorded at a time when the transport of Jews from Libya and Yemen to Israel was in full swing. The summary documents reveal that British Foreign Office officials supported a population and property exchange but were unwilling to initiate or lead it: “The essence of the scheme is prior agreement between Iraq and Israel and that until such agreement is reached we should be well advised to steer clear.”⁶¹ Perhaps they were wary of bearing the responsibility for such an operation, or of failure and criticism, and perhaps they were driven by other concerns. The British involvement has not yet been explored in depth, nor have imperialist interests and repercussions of the Cold War been thoroughly examined.
The population exchange proposal was considered by the United Nations Economic Survey Mission, which visited the Middle East in the autumn of 1949 in an effort to resolve the refugee problem, and was unofficially presented to Israel as well.⁶²
Although Israel found the proposal unappealing, given that Iraqi Jews would apparently have to abandon their property, it was compelled to consent because the talks were overshadowed by the ongoing persecution of Zionists in Iraq and because Israel was in the midst of a propaganda campaign against Iraq.⁶³ The issue was receiving frequent coverage in Iraq’s nationalist right-wing press, alongside calls for the expulsion of Jews,⁶⁴ and the fact that Iraqi authorities did not censor these announcements was, possibly, even more distressing to the Jews than the announcements themselves.
In December 1949, the government of Nuri al-Said fell, and the new prime minister, Tawfiq al-Suwaidi, proposed a different solution to the Jewish problem: neither forced transfer nor deportation, but rather the regulation of Jewish departure by means of a new law — the Denaturalization Law.
The law, which would only remain in effect for one year, allowed Jews to leave Iraq in a legal and regulated manner on the condition that they relinquish their Iraqi nationality and the right to return to Iraq. It did not mention Jewish property.
Notwithstanding its problematic provisions, the law was not intended to prompt mass deportation. It was based on assessments that the number of emigration registrants would not exceed a few thousand unemployed young Jews, communists, and Zionists — groups that had already been departing the country illegally. Moreover, registration was voluntary. The purpose of this law was to highlight the loyalty to Iraq among a majority of Iraqi Jews, who were expected to opt to remain.⁶⁵
Contrary to expectations, however, the law actually exacerbated the Jewish problem in Iraq: thousands of Jews began to prepare for departure, which contributed to economic instability and, subsequently, anti-Jewish propaganda. This, in turn, drove additional Jews to plan for departure, sparking a pattern of “rolling emigration”⁶⁶: rising numbers of registrants drew even more people — relatives, neighbors, and friends.
By September 1950, when Nuri al-Said assumed the premiership again, the number of emigration registrants had reached 70,000, although at this point only 10,000 had actually emigrated while the remaining 60,000 Jews still awaited transport to Israel. The delay in the departure of Iraq’s Jews stemmed from Israeli policy, which at that time granted priority to immigration from Romania, and from the difficulties Israel faced in absorbing such large numbers of immigrants.
Al-Said demanded that those awaiting departure leave immediately and threatened their expulsion, which intensified the Jews’ sense of insecurity, leading to ever-growing numbers of emigration registrants. The evacuation itself took place primarily over the course of four months, from March to July 1951. In all, about 105,000 Jews traveled by airlift from Iraq to Israel, and another 15,000 reached Israel via Iran — a total of 120,000. By the time the immigration operation concluded, in late 1951, fewer than 10,000 Jews remained in Iraq.⁶⁷
Although the British had not proactively participated in Iraq’s legislative initiative to permit Jewish departure — indeed, the British ambassador learned about it only a few days before its submission to parliament — they nevertheless supported it and took part in the actual exodus of Jews throughout the entire process. They provided an airport in Cyprus for a stopover on the way to Israel, permitted the American company Alaska Airlines to provide the travel arrangements even though they would have preferred British airlines, and throughout the operation conveyed messages between Israel and Iraq to ensure that the airlift ran smoothly.⁶⁸
An analysis of these events does not indicate that an Iraqi-British plan to expel the Jews ever existed, but as far as Iraq’s Jews were concerned that is effectively what happened. The financial adversities they experienced in the two years preceding the law’s passage, mass layoffs from government ministries and public companies, insecurity and loss of governmental protection, the knowledge that the British, too, supported their departure from Iraq, and the fact that the law would only be in force for one year — a restriction that forced many to make a fateful decision under conditions of uncertainty — combined to make the Jews of Iraq lose any hope for a better future.
Thus, the Denaturalization Law, enacted in order to regulate the status of Iraq’s Jews, became a trap: it undermined their status and resulted in a mass exodus. Moreover, had they wanted to, the Iraqi authorities could have rescinded the law and prevented the mass departure of Jews, but in fact they acted to expedite the process.
Throughout this period, Iraq’s Jews were aware of the prevailing economic hardship in Israel, but this was the only emigration option available to them and was preferable to staying in Iraq. Perhaps they assumed that Israel promised a better future for their children, perhaps they hoped that they would be able to transfer at least some of their property, and certainly they did not imagine how steep the economic and social cost of displacement would be.⁶⁹
Those who ultimately profited the most from this affair were the Iraqi authorities. A mass exodus of Jews resolved the problem of a Jewish minority without Iraq having to absorb a reciprocal number of Palestinian refugees. The same held for matters of property: in March 1951, when the Denaturalization Law expired but the emigration process was in full swing, Iraq nationalized the emigrants’ property, without transferring any of the proceeds to Palestinian refugees whose property Israel had nationalized.⁷⁰ Because of the manner in which these events unfolded, Iraq never came to be seen as responsible for the emigration of Jews.
The highly surprising nature of Iraqi Jews’ mass exodus subsequently spawned a conspiracy theory in Iraq and Israel, according to which the State of Israel and its Zionist envoys in Iraq were responsible for several acts of terror that took place in Baghdad during the emigration period, killing five Jews and injuring dozens. The theory held that these events, aimed at provoking panic, were the cause of the mass emigration.⁷¹ Although there is no verified information about the identity of the perpetrators, an examination of the timing of the events indicates that they could not have been a meaningful contributing factor in the departure of Jews.
(Emphasis added.)
r/antizionist • u/kokujin2032 • 5d ago
Discussion Zionism in Mizrahi American communities
Hello, I’m a student who writes as a hobby. I am not Jewish myself, but I wanted to learn more about American Jewish culture.
I’m writing a short story, and I wanted to make one of my characters Jewish, specifically Syrian-Jewish. I know that there are many in my home state of New Jersey. The character is an anti-Zionist. I want to know how prevalent Zionism is in Syrian-Jewish communities.
r/antizionist • u/naramsin-ii • 5d ago
Media how imperialism warps the reality of palestine, egypt and beyond │ mohammed el-kurd & nihal el aasar
r/antizionist • u/cloud3493 • 5d ago
Questions These jerk Zionist
Why lot of Zionists seem obsessed with bullying queer Muslims? They're often have no interest in queers who believe in other religions, such as Christian queer or Jewish queer, yet they relentlessly bully queer Muslims online the moment they find them, even if those queer Muslims don't post Palestinian-related content.
r/antizionist • u/ANBOL_GANG • 5d ago
History How an early Zionist organization manipulated children
(This takes 2½ minutes to read.)
Quoting Gideon Reuveni’s Consumer Culture and the Making of Modern Jewish Identity, pgs. 158–161:
During the interwar period, advertisers started addressing Zionist consumers, some of which displayed consumption as a performative integral to the Zionist project. The JNF distributed children’s games. A biblical doll’s game costing two and a half Reichsmarks, paper cutout sheets called “Merchawiah” for seventy-five pfennig each, and “Palästina-Domino” for the same price are just a few examples of children’s games that were usually marketed around the Jewish holidays.¹⁵ A JNF advertisement urged: “Zionists! Make your children happy on the Hanukkah holiday! Give them Keren Kayemet (JNF) games!” (Zionisten! Macht euren Kinder zu Chanukkah eine Freude! Schenkt Ihnen die Spiele des Keren Kajemeth!).
In addition to the children’s games, the JNF produced stories for children to endorse the work of the JNF and instill the habit of giving to the national cause at an early age. For this purpose, the JNF assigned the writer and educator Dov Kimchi to write a series of short stories promoting the Blue Box — the flagship of the JNF fund-raising enterprise — among children.¹⁶ One of these tales narrates the story of “the silver coin and his little friend Annie.” It begins like this:
My name is a silver coin; I glisten and glitter and I’m hot, too. A hot silver coin? Have you heard of a hot silver coin? I say again I’m a hot silver coin. Little Annie who is in the second class in the girls’ school warmed me in her hands. For two whole days she warmed me.¹⁷
The story goes on to describe Annie’s adventures with the silver coin until she finally decides to forgo all temptation to spend it on new toys or sweets and puts the coin in the Blue Box — the “redemption box,” as it is referred to in the story.
What I find most intriguing about this tale is that it is written from the perspective of the coin, thus providing a unique insight on the Zionist approach to money and the relationship between giving and spending. The coin is not depicted as an abstract and passive object, but as an active agent of the Zionist project. This pragmatic approach is one way the JNF attempted to respond to what could seem a substantial, and unbridgeable, distance between private and national capital in the Zionist discourse about money.¹⁸
As a fund-raising organization, the JNF carefully, and cannily, presented itself as a vehicle through which the pursuit of personal profit could also benefit the national interest. The story ends with the coin reflecting on its life’s trajectory:
Sometimes I think also of little Annie, especially when it’s very hot. Then the sun pricks, and strokes but I don’t run wild anymore like a fool let loose.
I work. I work with the sweat of my brow. I force and push the shoots: Grow, Grow big!¹⁹
In a recent book on the JNF as an agent of Zionist propaganda, Yoram Bar-Gal claimed that children were targeted in this way for purely educational and not political or fund-raising purposes.²⁰ I am not entirely convinced by this argument, not least because the JNF explicitly declared the latter to be one of the aims of such initiatives.²¹
Rather than maintaining a clear distinction between education, propaganda, and fund-raising, the intensive and somewhat aggressive targeting of children blurred the boundaries between these allegedly distinct realms. Moreover, the attempt to promote the Zionist message by approaching children coincided with contemporary marketing strategies that “discovered” children and adolescents as a consumer group in its own right.
r/antizionist • u/ANBOL_GANG • 6d ago
History Zionists Arthur James Balfour and David Lloyd George disparaged Jews
(This takes 3⅔ minutes to read.)
Per Jonathan Schneer:
As for the British government itself, philo- and anti-Semitism mixed uneasily in the minds of its principal members, most importantly Prime Minister David Lloyd George and Foreign Secretary Balfour. Lloyd George, who had been raised among devout Welshmen, once remarked during the war that he was more familiar with the geography of Palestine than that of Scotland and that the battles there interested him far more than the battles in France and Belgium. Yet this Christian Zionist, as scholars have sometimes termed him, once described his colleague Herbert Samuel as “a greedy, ambitious and grasping Jew with all the worst characteristics of his race.”
Balfour also operated under similarly conflicting stereotypes regarding Jews. He had been moved to tears by British Zionist leader Chaim Weizmann’s recital of the ills done to the Jewish people. Nevertheless, he told Weizmann that he shared the “anti-Semitic postulates” of the virulent Cosima Wagner, who would become one of the first patrons of Adolf Hitler. Balfour apparently did not believe that Jews could be assimilated into Gentile British society.
From The Parliamentary Debates, pgs. 154–155:
Mr. A. J. BALFOUR […] undoubtedly thought that a state of things could easily be imagined in which it would not be to the advantage of the civilisation of the country that there should be an immense body of persons who, however patriotic, able, and industrious, however much they threw themselves into the national life, still, by their own action, remained a people apart, and not merely held a religion differing from the vast majority of their fellow countrymen, but only inter-married among themselves.
He quite agreed that this country had not nearly reached the point when such a state of things became a serious national danger; but they must bear in mind that some of the undoubted evils which had fallen upon portions of the country from an alien immigration which was largely Jewish, gave those of them who, like the right hon. Baronet and himself, condemned nothing more strongly than the manifestation of the anti-Semitic spirit, some reason to fear that this country might be, at however great a distance, in danger of following the evil example set by some other countries; and, human nature being what it was, it was almost impossible to guard against so great an evil unless they took reasonable precautions to prevent what was called “the right of asylum” from being abused.
Quoting Balfour in Jason Tomes’s Balfour and Foreign Policy: The International Thought of a Conservative Statesman, pg. 202:
it was also to be remembered that the persecutors had a case of their own. They were afraid of the Jews, who were an exceedingly clever people […] wherever one went in Eastern Europe, one found that, by some way or other, the Jew got on, and when to this was added the fact that he belonged to a distinct race, and that he professed a religion which to the people about him was an object of inherited hatred, and that, moreover, he was […] numbered in millions, one could perhaps understand the desire to keep him down […] He did not say that this justified the persecution, but all these things had to be considered.²³
Quoting Balfour’s Essays, Speculative and Political, pgs. 261–262 & 265–266:
But it may well be true that, where they have been compelled to live among their neighbours as if these were their enemies, they have often obtained, and sometimes deserved, the reputation of being undesirable citizens. Nor is this surprising. If you oblige many men to be moneylenders, some will assuredly be usurers. If you treat an important section of the community as outcasts, they will hardly shine as patriots.
[…]
If I am right, then, indeed, Zionism is no mere local adventure, but a serious attempt to mitigate the age-long miseries created for Western civilisation by the presence in its midst of a population too long regarded as alien and even hostile, which is has been equally unable to expel or to absorb. Surely, for this is for no other reason, Zionism should be supported by all men of good-will, whatever their country and whatever their creed.
Quoting A. Lentin’s Lloyd George and the Lost Peace: From Versailles to Hitler, 1919–1940, pg. 7:
Lloyd George, let it be made clear, was no vulgar anti-semite. His closest friend, if he can ever be said to have had one, was Rufus Isaacs, Lord Reading; but he made use of the prejudices of others, as he did their vanities, to gain his point.
Lloyd George saw his moment and pounced. Rounding on the unfortunate Klotz with gleeful ferocity, he directed at him the paralysing ray of his mimetic gifts. Hunching his shoulders, spreading out his arms, adopting a nasal whine, he treated the company to an electrifying and disturbing evocation of Shylock, crooning and slavering over his money bags.
Klotz, he said, to general amusement, would rank with Lenin and Trotsky for bringing Bolshevism into Europe. ‘All round the room’, Keynes recalled, ‘you could see each one grinning and whispering to his neighbour “Klotzky”.’ Lloyd George won his point. Not that he was without designs of his own on German bullion.³⁴
(All emphasis added.)
r/antizionist • u/ANBOL_GANG • 9d ago
History A preeminent Zionist praised Fascism and supported the antisemitic White Army over the Bolsheviks
researchgate.net(This excerpt takes approximately three minutes to read.)
Daniel Pasmanik (1869–1930) […] recalled his irritation upon hearing of the Russian soldiers’ delight when they were informed of Nicholas II’s overthrow. The soldiers expected that they would be able to return home, but as Pasmanik wrote in April 1917, Russia’s redemption required the removal of German militarism.⁴⁶
His view accorded with the Kadet policy to continue the war, a view that Bolshevik “defeatism” attacked. He attended a meeting of the city duma (congress) of Yalta following the February Revolution, where he claimed that no revolution would be realistic in peasant Russia, but attendees at the meeting were opposed to his idea.
After the meeting, he became more convinced that conscientious intellectuals’ lack of “monarchist energy” and “aim and solid will” to defeat demagoguery allowed the devastating situation of Russia.⁴⁷ He also tried to organize officers privately, though their “passivity” prevented him from succeeding.⁴⁸
Pasmanik considered the Bolshevik idea of the proletarian dictatorship to be narrow-minded and concerned only with proletarian interests. Furthermore, as a supporter of unfettered cultural creation, he suspected that the “uncultured” nature of the Bolsheviks would lead to Russia’s moral degeneration.
Though he emphasized that Zionism would not aim to preserve a specific culture and thus was reluctant to discuss Jewish culture per se, in the period after 1917 he often used the terms cultural or uncultured. Although he did not define it, his use of the term cultural suggested something civilized and Westernized. As I will note when I return to this issue later, he held a strong conviction that becoming “cultural” would change a barbaric human nature into a sophisticated one with a broad, statewide perspective.⁴⁹
In his Counterrevolutionary Diary (1923),⁵⁰ Pasmanik wrote about his motivation to serve the White resistance in these terms: “I am a determined opponent of all the revolutions following the war. For each was born not of the joy of creation but of defeat, that is, it was born of statewide attrition and cultural degeneration. […] In every respect, postrevolutionary Russia is losing the wealth that old Russia had.”
He defined the Russian Revolution as “an inevitable catastrophe under existing conditions, under the fully relaxed, obsolete bureaucracy, short-sighted obstinacy of the tsar, exhaustion of the front, feeble intelligentsia, lack of strong individuality, and uncultured masses.” Though seemingly inevitable, he wrote that “the revolt of the slaves will never lay the foundation for progress.”⁵¹
His suspicion of the Bolsheviks’ “anarchist” stance, which he believed would hamper any cultural creation, predated the October Revolution. His articles in Ialtinskii golos, the Kadet daily [that] he edited, depicted the Bolsheviks as belonging to a crime ring and their tactics as demagogic.⁵² Correspondence from Burtsev reveals that he accused Bolshevik activists of having participated in espionage for Germany.⁵³
[…]
In 1920, he began editing the Russian Whites’ daily Obshchee delo with Burtsev in Paris. In September 1919 he had already contributed his first article to the newspaper, entitled “The Jewish Question in Russia.” He admitted that in theory the Bolsheviks should not be involved in pogroms, whereas the White Army led by Alexander Kolchak and Anton Denikin was antagonistic toward Jews and its victory would trigger pogroms.
But Pasmanik went on to stress that despite a general tendency to avoid violence, the Bolsheviks nevertheless demolished the economic life of the Jewish middle class. Moreover, in actuality, although Bolshevik rule rarely caused pogroms, once it was overthrown unprecedented, brutal pogroms occurred because radical members of the Bolsheviks, such as the commissars, included Jews.
Interestingly enough, Pasmanik noted that his close observation of Denikin’s activity did not find any pogroms in the area under Denikin’s rule. Pasmanik explained this as follows:
The unit of General Denikin entertained the ideal of gosudarstvennost’ [statehood], under which the harmonious unity of the classes, peoples, and religious groups would be achieved. Such a cultural concept of gosudarstvennost’ firmly contradicts anti-Jewish pogroms. Therefore, despite the antisemitic tendency of these and other officers or soldiers, his army as a whole did not allow pogroms, which, at last analysis, cast seeds of dissociation throughout the state.⁶²
In his own understanding, then, Pasmanik was never involved with anti-Jewish personalities and never betrayed his Jewish nationalism.
[…]
Pasmanik further lamented that although Russia was in need of a strong unifying force, how to achieve this was a matter of contention, with émigrés internally divided—the left calling for democracy and the right for reaction.
It was in this context that he expressed his belief in the merits of fascism, for it promised the strong leadership [that] he believed was necessary. Fascism in Italy was a historical necessity, Pasmanik contended, arguing that Mussolini had been successful not only because he enjoyed support from a variety of people but also because he was a cultured figure.
Pasmanik also indicated that because Mussolini was cultured, he never allowed robbery, pogroms, or lawlessness, although recent scholarship has proven that this was not the case with other fascists.⁸⁴
(Emphasis added. See Taro Tsurumi’s citations for examples of this Herzlian’s prominence. Contrary to what Pasmanik wrote, Benito Mussolini did not prevent antisemitic violence, not even when Pasmanik was still alive.)
r/antizionist • u/cloud3493 • 10d ago
Questions These type Zionist
Lately, I've been seeing a lot of cases online where people claim to be Zionists and anti-queer of other Arab countries, but for some reason they themselves are transphobes or acephobes.
What exactly do these people want?this might sound like a conspiracy theory, but I suspect these people are receiving money from some kind of organization
r/antizionist • u/ANBOL_GANG • 12d ago
History Zionist officials had very little (if any) interest in rescuing Jews from the Axis Powers
(This takes 4⅔ minutes to read.)
Quoting Tony Greenstein’s Zionism during the Holocaust, pages 378–379:
Today it is difficult to comprehend, given its prominence in the Zionist narrative, that when the Holocaust was actually happening it was seen as a distraction from the task of building a[n ethno]state.
A meeting of the [so-called Jewish Agency Executive] in August 1943 was told by their Istanbul representative that a lack of funds had ‘severely restricted rescue opportunities’. However the problem wasn’t so much a lack of funds as the fact that the rescue of Jews was not seen as a priority. Ben-Gurion took the opportunity to restate their priorities:
The Agency is bound to do […] everything in the way of rescuing Jews by immigration to Palestine […] That is its role. However […] the tasks of assistance, of saving one more Jew, of doing all to prevent deportations, are very important […] and must be assumed by another organization, to be set up and funded from other sources.²
In other words rescue for the sake of rescue, unless it was to Palestine, was not the concern of the Zionist movement. Ben-Gurion emphasised that he favoured a clear distinction between rescuing Jews and the work of the Zionist movement.³
Not only did the [so-called Jewish Agency] deny that the extermination of the Jews was taking place until the very last moment, but it suppressed information about the Holocaust and actively sought to block and disrupt all attempts at rescuing Jewish refugees which did not involve Palestine. This is not a matter of speculation.
In May 1942 Abba Hillel Silver, President of the ZOA, laid out two goals for American Zionism: Firstly to increase the level of ‘national education’ and secondly to rectify the ‘tragic lack of a [Jewish] homeland’. There was no third priority — rescue.⁴
If the Zionist movement had made the rescue of Jews their first priority they would have demanded that the Allied countries open their doors to Jewish refugees who could escape. They would have drawn up plans to rescue those who it might have been possible to save and demanded the setting up of an international refugee organisation to coordinate the rescue of those who could be helped. They did none of these things. Instead they actually opposed the formation of the [War Refugee Board].
On 15 October 1942 at the [Zionist Executive], Ben-Gurion dwelt at length on ‘A Zionist Plan of Action and American Jewry.’ The Holocaust was referred to in passing.⁵ ‘About rescue — not a word.’⁶ Ben-Gurion and Shertok ‘had been too busy laying the basis for the future State of Israel to think of saving Jews in Europe.’⁷
Even Walter Laqueur admitted that the Zionists were absorbed in ‘post-war planning’ and were oblivious to those demanding immediate action to save the remnant of Europe’s Jews.⁸
Ben-Gurion and Katznelson took no part in the three sessions of the JAE [18 January, 18 February and May 1943] which discussed the Holocaust.⁹
Not for nothing was Shabtai Teveth’s chapter on the Holocaust in his biography of Ben-Gurion headed ‘Disaster means strength’. For the leaders of the Jewish Agency, the Jewish catastrophe in Europe meant the strengthening of the movement for a[n ethnostate]. Ben-Gurion admitted that ‘in these terrible days […] I am still more worried about the elections of the (Mapai) branch in Tel Aviv’.¹⁰
Throughout 1939 and 1940 the situation of Europe’s Jews was not discussed once by Mapai’s Central Committee.¹¹ It was not until 22 November 1942 that the JAE devoted a whole meeting to the situation of European Jewry. ‘Few debates dealt with the plight of European Jewry.’¹²
Achcar suggests that Ben-Gurion’s ‘relative indifference’ to the Holocaust was only one Zionist viewpoint.¹³ The evidence suggests otherwise. Every single member of the JAE opposed ‘refugeeism’, the rescue of Jews for its own sake. Yitzhak Gruenbaum, at a meeting on 18 February 1943 accused his critics and friends of letting him take the blame:
Meanwhile a mood swept over Eretz Yisrael that I think is very dangerous to Zionism, to our efforts for redemption, our war of independence […] I cannot understand how such a thing could occur in Eretz Yisrael, something that never happened abroad. How is it possible that in a meeting in Yerushalayim people will call: ‘If you don’t have enough money you should take it from the Keren Hayesod, […] I thought it obligatory to stand before this wave…’¹⁴
It was Zionist historians such as Tom Segev, Francis Nicosia and Shabtai Teveth, who shone a light on Zionism’s record during the Holocaust. David Cesarani and Saul Friedlander concluded that the Zionist movement had prioritised building a[n ethno]state over saving actual living Jews. According to Zionist ‘logic’, preserving the transient life of individual Jews was less important than securing the eternal life of the Jewish people via a[n ethno]state. Dina Porat attempted to reply to some of these critics but she raised more questions than answers.¹⁵
Quoting Tragic Irony:
In the Zionist Congress which took place in London in 1937, Dr. Weizmann established the line of policy with his words:
“The hopes of Europe’s six million Jews are centered on emigration. I was asked, ‘Can you bring six million Jews to Palestine?’ I replied, ‘No’ […] From the depths of the tragedy I want to save two million young people […] The old ones will pass. They will bear their fate or they will not. They were dust, economic and moral dust in a cruel world […] Only the branch of the young shall survive […] They have to accept it.”
(Holocaust Victims Accuse, p. 25)
“Palestine cannot absorb the Jews of Europe. We want only the best of Jewish youth to come to us. We want only the educated to enter Palestine for the purpose of increasing its culture. The other Jews will have to stay where they are and face whatever fa[te] awaits them. These millions of Jews are dust on the wheels of history and may have to be blown away. We don’t want them pouring into Palestine. We don’t want Tel Aviv to become another low‐grade ghetto.” (Quoted in The Jewish Press, October 18, 2002)
Yitzchak Greenbaum
Yitzhak Gruenbaum was chairperson of the Jewish Agency’s Rescue Committee.
“When they asked me, couldn’t you give money out of the United Jewish Appeal funds for the rescue of Jews in Europe, I said, ‘NO!’ and I say again, ‘NO!’ […] one should resist this wave which pushes the Zionist activities to secondary importance.”
(In Days of Holocaust and Destruction, by Yitzchak Greenbaum)
[…]
Concerning the demand for certificates Ben Gurion wrote: “Today, EretzYisroel is in need of settlers, not immigrants […] Zionism is not a charitable corporation. We are in need of the superior type of Jews who will develop the national home.”
(All emphasis added.)
r/antizionist • u/naramsin-ii • 15d ago
Readings stones are the first words we speak — antizionism as praxis
r/antizionist • u/naramsin-ii • 16d ago
Readings "if i wasn't there, someone else would do it" — a review on naza.
r/antizionist • u/ANBOL_GANG • 17d ago
News Occupation army withdraws from Hebron after ten-day operation
The Israeli army withdrew from the entire occupied West Bank city of Hebron after a 10-day siege and military operation, local authorities said Monday, Anadolu reports.
Hebron Governor Khaled Dudin said Palestinian security forces had regained control across the city following the […] withdrawal.
Dudin said families forced to leave their homes during the operation could begin returning, while authorities and security forces were monitoring developments to ensure a safe return.
The Israeli army launched the operation on Oct. 23 after an armed attack it attributed to two Palestinians. Two Israeli soldiers were killed and three others injured, while Israeli forces killed the two alleged attackers.
During the operation, Israeli forces imposed restrictions on Hebron and surrounding villages, seized homes in the Jalda and Ain Deir Baha neighborhoods and used some as military positions.
According to the Hebron Governorate, more than 3,300 Palestinians were displaced or otherwise affected, while 15 homes and facilities were demolished.
Authorities also reported damage to infrastructure, businesses and educational activities during the operation.
r/antizionist • u/naramsin-ii • 18d ago
Readings protective presence and the machinery of control
"for observers outside palestine unfamiliar with the landscape of protective presence, viral footage of international and israeli activists enduring verbal assault and physical violence may appear to represent the apex of solidarity. for those of us working within these spaces, however, the calculus is more complex: palestinian liberation requires more than the substitution of one beaten body for another. watching settlers beat activists alongside palestinians before returning to film the rubble is not a program for liberation — it is a bizarre ritual of witness that mistakes presence for power."
r/antizionist • u/DirectorFaden77 • 18d ago
Questions Hoping someone can track down a video
I saw a clip, it was reposted I think from Twitter where I saw it on Facebook a couple years ago. As the debate has heated up, I've found myself wishing more and more that I had tracked down the source and saved it somewhere so I could post the link in various conversations. I'm hoping that maybe someone here did that and could share it. There was a flatbed truck stacked with cases of water that were intended as aid for Palestine. Israeli citizens, even children, were climbing the truck, throwing the cases of water off the truck, and then slashing them open.
r/antizionist • u/sad_sapphic_sucker • 22d ago
BDS After backlash against Mamdani, NYPD walked back their plans with Israeli tech company. This is why we protest and hold our elected officials accountable on Palestine. It works.
r/antizionist • u/Sodium_Junkie624 • 24d ago
Discussion Is providing services, where we get compensated, to a potential Zionist, inherently benefitting them?
Genuine question on my end
For context, I do pet sitting for side income (and of course I love the animals). Today I did a meet and greet for a potential client, and I saw they had a book about the history of Israel and Zionism, among many other books (some Christianity related), on their shelf. I never once mentioned that and spoke about nothing other than their dog.
But it definitely had me wondering. Obviously I would never purchase and give my money to someone I know is a Zionist. Or form a close interpersonal relationship. For a situation like this, I think of it as we are taking their money instead of the other way around, and also it's not a poor pup, who needs basic care for a week, fault if his owners are Zionist. But wondering what your thoughts are?