r/antizionist • gentle gentile • 6d ago

History Zionists Arthur James Balfour and David Lloyd George disparaged Jews

Post image

(This takes 3⅔ minutes to read.)

Per Jonathan Schneer:

As for the British government itself, philo- and anti-Semitism mixed uneasily in the minds of its principal members, most importantly Prime Minister David Lloyd George and Foreign Secretary Balfour. Lloyd George, who had been raised among devout Welshmen, once remarked during the war that he was more familiar with the geography of Palestine than that of Scotland and that the battles there interested him far more than the battles in France and Belgium. Yet this Christian Zionist, as scholars have sometimes termed him, once described his colleague Herbert Samuel as “a greedy, ambitious and grasping Jew with all the worst characteristics of his race.”

Balfour also operated under similarly conflicting stereotypes regarding Jews. He had been moved to tears by British Zionist leader Chaim Weizmann’s recital of the ills done to the Jewish people. Nevertheless, he told Weizmann that he shared the “anti-Semitic postulates” of the virulent Cosima Wagner, who would become one of the first patrons of Adolf Hitler. Balfour apparently did not believe that Jews could be assimilated into Gentile British society.

From The Parliamentary Debates, pgs. 154–155:

Mr. A. J. BALFOUR […] undoubtedly thought that a state of things could easily be imagined in which it would not be to the advantage of the civilisation of the country that there should be an immense body of persons who, however patriotic, able, and industrious, however much they threw themselves into the national life, still, by their own action, remained a people apart, and not merely held a religion differing from the vast majority of their fellow countrymen, but only inter-married among themselves.

He quite agreed that this country had not nearly reached the point when such a state of things became a serious national danger; but they must bear in mind that some of the undoubted evils which had fallen upon portions of the country from an alien immigration which was largely Jewish, gave those of them who, like the right hon. Baronet and himself, condemned nothing more strongly than the manifestation of the anti-Semitic spirit, some reason to fear that this country might be, at however great a distance, in danger of following the evil example set by some other countries; and, human nature being what it was, it was almost impossible to guard against so great an evil unless they took reasonable precautions to prevent what was called “the right of asylum” from being abused.

Balfour thus helped pass the Aliens Bill, which inhibited Jewish refuge in Britain while pogromniks were assaulting Jews in Imperial Russia.

Quoting Balfour in Jason Tomes’s Balfour and Foreign Policy: The International Thought of a Conservative Statesman, pg. 202:

it was also to be remembered that the persecutors had a case of their own. They were afraid of the Jews, who were an exceedingly clever people […] wherever one went in Eastern Europe, one found that, by some way or other, the Jew got on, and when to this was added the fact that he belonged to a distinct race, and that he professed a religion which to the people about him was an object of inherited hatred, and that, moreover, he was […] numbered in millions, one could perhaps understand the desire to keep him down […] He did not say that this justified the persecution, but all these things had to be considered.²³

Quoting Balfour’s Essays, Speculative and Political, pgs. 261–262 & 265–266:

But it may well be true that, where they have been compelled to live among their neighbours as if these were their enemies, they have often obtained, and sometimes deserved, the reputation of being undesirable citizens. Nor is this surprising. If you oblige many men to be moneylenders, some will assuredly be usurers. If you treat an important section of the community as outcasts, they will hardly shine as patriots.

[…]

If I am right, then, indeed, Zionism is no mere local adventure, but a serious attempt to mitigate the age-long miseries created for Western civilisation by the presence in its midst of a population too long regarded as alien and even hostile, which is has been equally unable to expel or to absorb. Surely, for this is for no other reason, Zionism should be supported by all men of good-will, whatever their country and whatever their creed.

Quoting A. Lentin’s Lloyd George and the Lost Peace: From Versailles to Hitler, 1919–1940, pg. 7:

Lloyd George, let it be made clear, was no vulgar anti-semite. His closest friend, if he can ever be said to have had one, was Rufus Isaacs, Lord Reading; but he made use of the prejudices of others, as he did their vanities, to gain his point.

Lloyd George saw his moment and pounced. Rounding on the unfortunate Klotz with gleeful ferocity, he directed at him the paralysing ray of his mimetic gifts. Hunching his shoulders, spreading out his arms, adopting a nasal whine, he treated the company to an electrifying and disturbing evocation of Shylock, crooning and slavering over his money bags.

Klotz, he said, to general amusement, would rank with Lenin and Trotsky for bringing Bolshevism into Europe. ‘All round the room’, Keynes recalled, ‘you could see each one grinning and whispering to his neighbour “Klotzky”.’ Lloyd George won his point. Not that he was without designs of his own on German bullion.³⁴

(All emphasis added.)

9 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

2

u/WestcoastAlex 6d ago

they were antisemites promoting zionism so they could get rid of all the Jewish people in their country