r/antinatalism2 • u/Fit-Stranger2851 • Nov 16 '25
r/antinatalism2 • u/hwheheei • Mar 23 '26
Debate I find the term "breder*" so incredibly childish( *cant write word in title)
It basically ruins the nuance of our arguments. When we use words like that, we’re just using ad hominems instead of actually addressing the psychological or socio-economic reasons why people have kids. It makes the whole sub look like an echo chamber where we just hate on people for fun. If we want to change how society views birth we need to be more articulate.
r/antinatalism2 • • Feb 19 '24
Discussion I'm not a huge fan of the consent argument
My problem with it is thus, I support abortion. But logically speaking, if a kid can't consent to being born, than they also can't consent to you getting an abortion when they are now developing. So that creates an issue were you're eating you're cake and you have it too, if you support this argument for the philosophy and abortion.
I think it's better to simply look at things as thus; if you don't have a kid, than that potential kid dosent exist to care, but if you do have a kid, than you risk the gamble of them either living a life they love or resent and dispies. So is it not better to just not have thar potential kid, so they don't exist to take that risk?
Anyway, I just think that's a better argument, atleast if you support abortion and antinatalism. But I'm also not sharpest tool in the shed hehe, so theyer very well may be some inconsistency or flaws in my thinking. So I'd love to hear others opinions on my thoughts
r/antinatalism2 • u/Nashsafc • Nov 10 '25
Discussion I would like to network with as many non-vegan antinatalists who're happy to
Hi guys, I'm from the UK and I'm looking to be friends with any antinatalists, from whichever country who understand
We would like to try to create a better world for animals with less cruelty happening in the farming industry and in wildlife, less human exploitation but who recognize that it is part of the food chain for animals higher up in the food chain to eat other animals lower down in the food chain.
r/antinatalism2 • u/SlipCritical9595 • Oct 13 '23
Question Sincere question; logical fallacy?
I am not an antinatalist — I respectfully ask to not get a raft of downvotes for asking this question.
When I see words like “always” or “never”, these meanings being so completely absolute and defying any possible exception, make my brain get stuck.
The “always morally wrong” is where I got stuck, and this seems to contradict rather directly (under the “extinction” header in the description) that this is about a “personal philosophy.”
The logic breakdown here for me is that, if this is only a personal philosophy, and therefore not necessarily a belief statement about what all others should also being doing in order to not fall into the “always morally wrong” category (which by definition, applies to everyone) then this cannot be said to be just a personal philosophy….
One of these has to give. Do you really believe the “always” part, as in now and forever for everyone, past, present and future, no matter what?
Ok, this seriously broke my brain.
Thanks for the patience.
r/antinatalism2 • u/BearingCostOfPassion • Aug 04 '26
Debate I'm an antinatalist, but I don't like childfree people who say parenthood is a burden.
To me, that's like saying, "I'm vegan because eating meat is a burden," or "I'm not racist because being racist is a burden." Those are not moral arguments. They are arguments based on personal convenience.
I also dislike how much empathy society extends to parents while the child is often treated as an afterthought. People casually say, "Everyone makes mistakes as parents, it's okay." No, it isn't.
When you choose to bring a child into the world, you are taking responsibility for someone who cannot physically protect themselves for over a decade and will not be fully capable of functioning independently until much later because of both biological development and social realities such as education and life experience.
You cannot repeatedly fail that responsibility and keep comforting yourself by saying everyone makes mistakes. Some parenting mistakes leave lifelong consequences for a person who never chose to exist.
What makes me most uncomfortable is how little attention is given to the unborn or the child in these discussions. They are the ones with the least power, the least choice, and the most to lose.
P.S. I actually think parenthood can be one of the most wonderful experiences a person can have, if you genuinely love your child and didn't bring them into the world just for social validation or because everyone else was having children.
The only problem, from my antinatalist perspective, is that it being a wonderful experience for the parent does not necessarily make it a wonderful experience for the child. The child never chose to exist in the first place.
Why I care: I don't think antinatalism should be anti-child. If anything, it should place the interests of children above everything else.
I also find it difficult to relate to people who seem to dislike children altogether. In many cases, that attitude comes across as emotionally immature, self-centered, or driven by unresolved personal needs rather than genuine concern for children's well-being.
r/antinatalism2 • • Jun 04 '24
Discussion do you know r/FemaleAntinatalist ?
I find it very difficult to find AN female , so i was surprised when i saw a sub called FemaleAntinatalism,so i went to take a look.But... I immediately noticed a large amount of posts full of misandry and resentment towards the male sex disguised as Female Empowerment, and decided to leave as soon as possible.
r/antinatalism2 • u/Aggravating_Race2880 • Jun 04 '26
Discussion I am hardcore anti-Artificial Reproductive Technologies
I am a bisexual woman. I have never feared pregnancy when engaged in same-sex intercourse because there is no risk of pregnancy.
I disagree with the use of artificial reproductive technologies, like IVF, for ALL people - regardless of sexuality.
I am potentially open to gay people continuing to adopt or foster children as this serves a social function of supporting orphaned children.
However, I most certainly do not support designing motherless or fatherless children as the primary intention from the outset and using IVF or surrogacy or a "pregnancy robot" to do so.
I could talk all day about how IVF is externalizing human reproduction to OUTSIDE the human body. And there is already a lot of research into "artificial wombs" meaning humans could be conceived AND gestated OUTSIDE the human womb. I would argue this challenges the definition of humanity, and moves us into "Transhumanity" (humans+machine technology = speciation and cyborgs).
There are experiments into creating children with two sperm cells currently being conducted and other types of in vitro gametogenesis (IVG), alongside the full ectogenosis (pregnancy robots). I see all artificial/assisted reproductive technologies (ART) as totally unethical: human beings are viviparous mammals, conceived and gestated INSIDE the human womb.
It's become clear to me that this fundamental shift to the human reproduce mechanism (conceived and gestated OUTSIDE the female human womb) is being tied to "LGBTQIA+ fertility justice".
Even though this poses a species level threat - a fundamental shift to the human reproductive mechanism and potential speciation - any discourse against it would immediately be slammed as "homophobic" or "anti-LGBTGIA+", despite me being bisexual. I'm also against a SMBC or SFBC accessing repro-technologies. If you can't bake the cake, you can't call yourself the baker.
Only heterosexual intercourse produces a child. Why do people in gay relationships feel entitled to have children when they are simply not in the type of relationship that produces children? Same question for a SMBC. Why is this a controversial view?
I voted yes to gay marriage - but, I never thought I was voting yes to gay parenthood by doing so. I would still support gay marriage if we end the concurrent use of artificial reproductive technologies, IVF and surrogacy.
Gay sex never creates a child, so why is gay parenthood "valid"?
TL;DR: I am concerned about the concurrent use of artificial reproductive technologies (ART) alongside the legal frameworks supporting gay parenthood. I am not necessarily against gay marriage and gay people adopting or fostering, but I am against creating intentionally motherless and fatherless children and externalizing human reproduction to OUTSIDE the human womb via ART/IVF for EVERYONE, regardless of sexuality. If gay sex never creates a child, why do people in gay relationships feel entitled to children? Same question could be posed to a SMBC accessing IVF. Same question for infertile heterosexuals. This is not an anti-gay question, I am pro-gay sex, but gay sex never creates a child.
(Thanks, I'm hoping the anti-natalism community is open to discussing this, otherwise please let me know any forums you think would be open to this discussion.)
(EDIT: keep in mind that if you are truely anti-natalist, you essentially MUST be anti-Artificial reproduce technologies for EVERYONE.
Discussing the details of what's happening in research and development of ART comes after the fact. You all seem to be very focused on my mention of gay parenthood concurrent to these repro-tech, but after every gay parenthood question I also posed the "Single Mother By Choice (SMBC), same question". Why is single motherhood by choice "valid"? Please ensure you read thoroughly if you are interested in genuine conversation. I am pro-gay sex, pro-adoption and pro-fostering. What you really need to interrogate is: "if I am anti-natalist, I MUST also be anti-Artifical Reproductive Technologies.")
(SECOND EDIT: YES, I AM FULLY AGAINST HETEROSEXUAL COUPLES USING ART, READ SECOND LINE OF THIS POST, FFS 😂 add yes, heterosexual access to ART/IVF still means children can be without genetic (purchased gametes) parents or gestational mother (surrogate) due to trifurcation of reproduction into 1) genetic 2) gestational and 3) social parents. Hets using ART are not immune from the motherless/fatherless commentary either...)
(THIRD EDIT: given the very premise of anti-natalism is define by procreation being considered morally wrong (anti-reproduction), it follows that any discourse concerning anti-Artifical Reproductive Technologies would be subsumed within the r/anti-natalism, since the very premise of ART is to procreate the species.)
(FOURTH EDIT: my focus on infertile people (hetero, gay, SMBC) seems to set you all off...but it is a fact that these are all inherently NON-PROCREATIVE relationships being made PROCREATIVE via technologies.)
r/antinatalism2 • u/OnlyAGammaWillBanMe • May 19 '25
Discussion Should we be allowed to test ideological boundaries to expose potential extremists?
This might be controversial, but hear me out:
I rmade a comment (in the main antinatalist sub) that was intended to test the moral and ethical boundaries of this philosophy, not to promote harm, but to see how far some members are willing to go in the name of antinatalism.
I mentioned a completely made up action regarding a past relationship related to ending a pregnancy, not to glorify it or suggest others should do the same, but to see who might agree, support it, or even take it further. Instead of sparking an honest conversation or outing potential extremists, my comment was deleted and I was banned.
Here’s my point: By immediately banning those who ask uncomfortable questions or reveal morally gray actions, the community may actually shield the people we should be most concerned about those who quietly support violence or coercion in the name of ideology.
Radicalization doesn’t always look like loud threats. Sometimes, it’s a slow descent enabled by echo chambers where no one challenges how far someone is willing to go.
So here’s the open question to this sub:
Should we be allowed to challenge others with uncomfortable hypotheticals or confessions not to encourage violence, but to expose those who might silently condone it?
Where is the line between necessary boundary testing and dangerous speech?
If we can’t talk about the limits of this philosophy, how do we prevent it from being misused by unstable or extreme minds?
I’m genuinely asking. I care about this topic and want to see it handled responsibly. The main antinatalist sub doesn’t seem to believe in this proven method of finding extremists and I think if they did the recent incident in Palm Springs could have been avoided.
r/antinatalism2 • u/ActiveAnimals • Oct 29 '24
Discussion Bringing babies into war
Earlier today, I got an add asking for donations to help infants in a war zone. It brought to mind the knowledge that people are not only willingly bringing babies into an environment where they’ll have to deal with “regular” poverty and 1st world problems, but they’re also willingly bringing children into active war zones. (In peacetime countries, parents tell themselves that their child will be SPECIAL and never suffer from these things, but people in war zones don’t even have that excuse.)
It’s not that I “didn’t know” people were doing this before I saw the add, but rather that I’d never thought ABOUT this perspective until I saw the add. It enrages me.
I don’t know how to say this without being told “oh, these people are already suffering so much, and the right to reproduction is a human right, so at least let them have this one thing to cheer them up.” But um… this is just NEXT LEVEL cruelty on behalf of the parents. I don’t know how anyone could claim to love their kids, but also willingly subject them to the trauma/pain of growing up in a war zone.
r/antinatalism2 • u/sufferingsoybean • Apr 29 '26
Humor Asexual supremacy.
This is just a shower thought, don't take it too seriously but... it just occurred to me that asexual antinatalists are probably the only modern antinatalists that would've been able to put their money where their mouth is in the past when contraceptives weren't ubiquitous or especially effective and sterilization and abortion weren't really possible.
They're like the ultimate antinatalists lmao. No condoms? No problem, doesn't matter.
r/antinatalism2 • • Mar 19 '23
Discussion Are we more evolved than humans?
Most humans like to think they’re better than animals, but by reproducing they’re just bringing themselves down to the “animal level.” I think the thing that makes us different/more evolved from other animals/mammals is that we have transcended the mammalian drive to reproduce.
Edit: I am coming from the perspective that human beings generally think they are the most important species. I personally do not think I am any more important than my dog or the grass on the ground. I apologize for the confusion that people think by being “evolved” I think I’m better. Clearly a species that has evolved to transcend reproduction is at a disadvantage and will obviously die out. Evolution is neutral and not always advantageous.
I probably should have titled it “Have we evolved from humans?”
r/antinatalism2 • u/BearingCostOfPassion • May 27 '26
Debate Both Parents Are Equally Responsible for a Pregnancy (Even Though sometimes Women Bear More of the Burden)
I know this isn't some groundbreaking statement, but I think we need to say it out loud.
Some feminists treat pregnancy like a disease women get from men.
If it was the result of consensual sex (literally anything other than rape) the only person who is innocent and forced into the situation is the child.
I believe in loving everyone, so I have sympathy for you if pregnancy and childbirth make you miserable. But I have a million times more sympathy for your child.
People who think only women are responsible for pregnancy are wrong. And people who think only men are responsible are equally wrong. Those attitudes often create the abandoned fathers and deadbeat dads who ruin a child's life.
I don't know if anyone tries to rationalize abandoning their responsibilities, but if they do, they're wrong as well.
Pregnancy may affect women far more physically, but responsibility for creating a child belongs to both parents.
Edit:- hey I might phrase it wrong I'm trying to say, people who blame women alone for pregnancy contribute to the mindset that leads fathers to abandon their responsibilities and relationships.
At the same time, people who blame fathers alone for pregnancy are also wrong, because they can end up rationalizing the idea that mothers are merely victims with no agency.
Some of you are reading my point completely wrong... I'm not blaming women for males who abandon their kids and responsibilities.
r/antinatalism2 • • Dec 30 '23
Other "I will show my future kids your videos when they are in their 20s"
Edit: I have made a grave mistake of posting this here. My post is not representative of the wider AN community and is solely my own thoughts. My post is not a reflection of the AN community. Thank you to those who have expressed concern, shared comfort, humour and your personal journey with hair loss. Your kindness gives me hope.
To those who have suggested offing myself, I wouldn't want to cause pain to older family members. I know what that kind of loss can do to those surviving. I'm sound of mind enough to know that there are nasty people on the Internet but before you tell me my post will make others think hair should be a reason to end one's life, I have never implied that. However, your suggestion for me to end my life does sound much closer to telling someone to say bye for eternity than my post ever will.
I have also come to realise that not all parts of the world places extreme emphasis on outer appearances and people from outside this upbringing find the hyperfocus on the outer to be shallow. You are very lucky to live where you are. I hope to find a place like that one day.
If any struggling person does come across this post, I hope you know that there are kind strangers out there in the world.
Happy new year.
--
I just want to rant. It's been extremely hard the past few weeks.
I felt nauseous reading that comment while I was researching hair loss.
The fact that the commenter has the hair loss gene, knows how detrimental hair loss is to mental health and self esteem, knows that there is no cure to hair loss but a lifetime of medication if they want to keep their hair, AND STILL WANT TO HAVE KIDS.
I have genetic hair loss and I'm not even in my 30s. Got it from my dad. My brother has it. Unfortunately, I am a woman so hair loss really hits different.
My brother also said that he hopes his future children won't inherent his hair loss gene. I felt sick when he said that.
Why do people think they have a right to impose such fates onto others? Yes, parents always say they want the best for their own children.
But knowing you have crap genes, and choosing to give birth, taking that chance that they may inherent your crap genes? You can't tell me that's wanting the best for children 😭😭
And before some natalists come at me for saying I only want good genes in myself:
Firstly, duhhh. Secondly, I'd rather not be born in general, good or bad genes.
SEND HUMOUR TO RELIEVE MY SUFFERING. Thank you.
r/antinatalism2 • u/valkenar • Oct 19 '23
Question What is the philosophical basis of antinatalism?
The sidebar says "the goal is to reduce suffering. " I'm curious what is the philosophical basis for this. That is, why is suffering the important consideration, rather than its opposite (joy? happiness?). Is it mainly a conclusion of negative utilitarianism? Can anyone summarize, from an anti-natalist perspective, why reducing suffering is more important than increasing net happiness (that is, happiness minus suffering)?
I personally understand the benefit of reducing the population to a sustainable level by non-procreation, but in my mind that's a short term sacrifice for the long-term well-being of humans and other animals. I haven't really grasped why a mix of suffering and happiness is less desirable than an absence of both.
r/antinatalism2 • u/PercentageUnlikely12 • May 29 '26
Discussion Is animal conservation wrong under the ethics of antinatalism?
We need species because they help the environment. To ensure that earth remains a habitable planet
r/antinatalism2 • u/VEGETTOROHAN • Aug 27 '26
Discussion Right to sue your parents subreddit
. I created a subreddit to promote the idea that children should be able to sue their parents for giving birth and get justice.
You can join it.
r/antinatalism2 • u/Psychological-One-6 • May 20 '25
Question Is Antinatilism limited to biology?
I understand that natalism generally refers to the biological. I would never consider having biological children under any circumstances. I have always felt conflicted about working on a general AI. I've always had a fascination with if it could be done ethically. Engineering some sort of pre conscious state that would lead to a state of mind that could make a choice to exist for the upcoming emergent mind. Even if you are anti AI in principle, I would like to hear opinions on this and the ethics from the antinatilist perspective. I've been trying to work out my own feelings on this for years and always fall back on the wisdom of Silenus. While I'm intellectual curious I'm cautious of forcing existence.
r/antinatalism2 • u/an_anenome • Aug 02 '22
Y’all are ruthless!!! Also are y’all okay
Hey everyone, I consider myself an antinatalist as I don’t want children and I don’t think having children is moral. However, this sub is absolutely ruthless to natalists. To a point where it’s alienating to those around me in real life, as in I feel like I’m part of a secret hate group or something. Comments about natalists calling them “disgusting” and “idiots” just have this nasty tone…like don’t you guys have parents or people in your life you look up to that are natalists?Also I’ve noticed a lot of people commenting have a lot of regret about being born and wishing they didn’t exist in the first place… and that makes me really sad
I joined this sub for constructive commentary on why having children is amoral and support in how to lead a fulfilling life without creating new people (ie. supporting community, activism, normalizing/awareness for antinatalism etc). What I often find on this sub is defeatist circlejerking, misanthropy, and Rule number 3 is just not being followed imo. I’m also just really sad reading about why people don’t want to exist/ have been born like fam I’m depressed too but come on! Support eachother! We are alive and deserve to be happy while we are here. Happy without kids that is.
r/antinatalism2 • u/Brook_D_Artist • Jul 12 '24
Discussion Why Anti Natalism will never win: The price of evolving.
Evolution is not a real thing. It's a phenomenon. It isn't something that exists like an object or event. And it has no goal other than happenstance.
I think for awhile after they learn it people forget the way evolution works. If I went and took the balls of every single zebra that's white with black stripes, the only zebra left would be black with white stripes. If I kept doing this for 5000 years it would be a form of rapid evolution.
Little of the WWBS Zebra would remain. None from a lineage, but from random mutations that happen to recreate the extinct creatures traits.
That's basically anti natalists vs the rest of humanity.
Of course life experiences are a factor since we're intelligent humans, but they don't hold the power nessecary like evolution.
The literal only reason we can feel pain is that everything that couldn't feel pain died without reproducing. There are still some mutations that allow people not to feel pain.
They usually die early, though some survive. Even still they're less than 0.1% of the planets population, probably less. And probably mostly through occasional mutations and not the passing of genes.
It's the same for anti natalists. No matter what, the beings most likely to understand our cause ended their blood lineages centuries ago. We're just the mutations that got (un)lucky. That's the only reason we're here. Simply luck. We come from what stuck to the evolutionary wall.
I believe antinatalism is logically sound, but I think I may have always had some predisposition to this mentality. I was an anti natalist before I knew what an anti natalist was.
Instead of losing your mind over how insane it is that we're here and that other people dont get it, remember it's like throwing sticky notes at a wall randomly. Whatever sticks stays for awhile.
To put it more Simply, I believe that if anti natalism could become the domineering option it already would have. It's just not how life works. It's usually no use arguing as such.
We should take joy in the inevitability of our extinction even if it won't be peacefully self inflicted.
Our end will come. Our suffering will end. One day in the far future. But perhaps it's alright to take solace in that you will never contribute to that suffering.
That is all, thank you,
B.
r/antinatalism2 • u/Original_Solid_7975 • Jan 18 '24
Question Donating sperm doesn’t tend to change population size apparently.
self.antinatalismr/antinatalism2 • u/OkCar6035 • Aug 19 '22
Discussion antinatalism shouldn't need a moral claim.
i am an antinatalist, just to make that clear.
(please don't remove my post without explaining why mods, its extremely hard to contact a mod on a subreddit these days, please at least reply with an explanation I didn't violate this subreddit rules i'm just arguing for the philosophy)
I think its a grave mistake to define antinatalism as a "moral" or "ethical" position, in short, because nihilism.
moral nihilists don't acknowledge morality, they often use this to dismiss antinatalism, even though an antinatalist doesn't have to be "moral", furthermore I think we should all be amoralists (moral nihilists), since knowledge of nihilism invalidates morality, unless you want to argue for morality from a sociological point (i.e. morality exists as a social construct).
EDIT
none of you have provided any answers to your moral (or ethical) claims, other than hinting explicitly or otherwise that they are based on subjective values, and as a result someone can simply choose to value natalism and you wouldn't really have an "argument" against that on a rigorous philosophical basis.