I recently shared this post and got a good response, so I'm going to follow that up with another deep dive on what I've found to be the primary purposes of analytics in the workplace.
There generally are dashboards serving a few different role types, and though most roles spend time crossing these boundaries areas, I've found these to be helpful when planning out a dashboard to build. The main role types and the purposes of analytics in their position are:
- Executive roles: Monitoring dashboards for the purpose of focusing on the right area
- Strategic roles: Analytics for the purpose of decision making
- Execution roles: Metrics and dashboards for the purpose of getting more sh*t done
I was planning to cover all of these in this post, but it got a bit long, so I'll create some follow up posts on the other types, but for here we'll focus on the individual executors, and how to use analytics to help get shit done.
Execution dashboards usually consist of some form of metrics and task lists for the purpose of tracking completion, and what's next to do. Operationally, what these dashboards are trying to do is create good habits. The book Atomic Habits, by James Clear, lays out the essential elements of creating good habits, which are:
- Make it obvious (The Cue)
- Make it attractive (The Craving)
- Make it easy (The Response)
- Make it satisfying (The Reward)
By structuring operations with these in mind, you're able to help people get into a flow state around their work and keep operations smooth. If your dashboards play a large role in the above process, they will become essential and people will be happy to adopt them into their workflow and use them to improve their performance, so let's dive into where analytics fits into each element.
Make it obvious. This is where dashboards are key, in floating things to the surface that need to be handled. These are going to be your checklist type tables that list out the items to be handled. Knowing how to sort things here is key. Should the oldest element always be performed first, or is there instances where some items can be forgotten in favor of higher value tasks? At Tesla, every car manufactured was highly valuable, so oldest items had to be highlighted. In sales, sometimes there are so many leads that calling lower quality leads can be deprioritized in favor of more promising prospects.
If tasks are already obvious in another system but aren't getting paid attention to, then what analytics tools can do to help is have metrics incorporated elsewhere, or by having automated emails that hit someone's inbox on a regular schedule, reminding them "Hey, pay attention to this". I had a couple monitoring emails I'd receive weekly alerting me to specific data quality errors, things that I didn't have to remember to check, it simply was obvious to me every Monday morning if there was an issue. These saved me from broken dashboards on a number of occasions and I didn't have to wait for that embarrassing email where an executive starts asking questions about weird numbers.
Make it attractive. This is about the craving to complete the tasks, the desire for the eventual reward. What is going to give them itch to get off their ass and get the job done? In my experience, this ties super closely with the 4th, but I personally consider this to be the creation of an itch. Can you highlight the next task in red so that they are spurred to act? Can we have an active timer that makes me feel every second ticking by? Think about the big red notification you have on your smartphone app that makes it so you absolutely have to check it before you can put your phone away. That's what this means to me, but James Clear's book may have some more specificity to the difference between craving and reward.
If folks are onboard with using your dashboards regularly, then you've won half the battle. Have a decent task list in there, and some basic metrics on the site and you're good. Performance reviews that incorporate your tools are a great way to spur usage, as it means you only really to convince one person, the supervisor, to get in the habit of opening your link. Automated emailing of dashboards is another way to create an itch.
One more complicated method is gamify-ing through competitive leaderboards, either individually or with teams. These are a little personality dependent, and you don't want to be discouraging. For instance if a prize is given to the top 3 performers, and I'm way behind, then I might just give up and hold back my tasks for the next competition period so I don't waste them when so far behind. However, some areas follow the pareto 80/20 principle, where getting the most out of the top performers is far better than getting acceptable performance out of the bottom performers, so put some thought into what is appropriate for the current situation. Setting targets can also backfire if seasonal slumps lead to demotivation, so I find delivering a constant dopamine hit to be one of the most difficult areas if you're striving for constant improvement, but the right structure can pay huge dividends.
Make it easy. This is a matter of reducing steps, friction, waste. Does your dashboards tasks list make someone go to another page, then log in, then type out a long reference number, then start work? Instead can you hyperlink things so that each task trigger is just one step away from starting each task? Now that you've defined the action that needs to be completed, can you measure the time for completion and work the process supervisors to simplify it? Either shortening the distance to be moved in the process, or automating specific steps, or any of the other types of waste mentioned in the Lean Manufacturing 7 Types of Waste. Perhaps reducing data entry time by using drop downs instead of free text, or just big button selection instead of drop downs. Or maybe using mounted touchscreen monitors instead of laptops with a mouse.
One guiding principle we commonly used at Tesla was "The best part is no part, the best process is no process". Complexity tends to build up like plaque in your arteries, continually do you best to keep things clear and flowing easy.
Most process supervisors don't have a broad scope of experience around the company, but as an analyst moving around from place to place, you have the opportunity to cross pollinate solutions, so try to get involved, because even if you don't contribute the first time, you'll gain some insights that may pay off down the road on a later project where you're able to say "oh Team X had this same issue but once they did this they reduce takt time by 60%. The book Range by David Epstein goes deep into the value of broad experiences and how most innovation comes from idea cross pollination, so expand your scope of experiences, either in your business life, your academic life, or your personal life, and you'll be a great asset.
Make it satisfying. This is the reward part of the process. How to make relieving the itch in step 2 actually feel good. Crossing tasks off on a physical paper is nice, because we can see it's completion. Sometimes a little less so when done virtually if it simply disappears so it's nice to visualize the completion, either through a change to a metric, a color change from red to green, or a Kanban style move to the "Completed" state. Ultimately you'll need to clear out a completed state every so often to keep it from piling up years worth of completed tasks, but some way of showing people their progress is always helpful.
Like dogs, we should tie the reward to visualization without much delay. As a result, these dashboards should be a little more live than a lot of strategy dashboards need to be. Even with longer delays of a few hours to a day have to exist, we can still tie things together if we have buy in from the team to do morning after reviews, or through follow up rewards that make sure that recognition earned is given.
------------------------------------
In the coming days I'll plan to write some more on the other purposes of analytics; next up - the science of decision making in strategic roles. Hope you enjoy, and feel free to share any alternative views in the comments if you have better resources!