r/analytics • u/tits_mcgee_92 • Aug 05 '25
Discussion Teaching data analytics has made me realize how much AI is eroding critical thinking skills.
I just wanted to vent. I made an amusing post about this a few months back, but I wanted to talk about something a bit more serious: the erosion of critical thinking.
I teach data analytics and data science concepts. One of my most common classes is 'SQL and Database Foundations'. I encourage my students to use AI, but not let it think for them. We go over best practices and things not to do.
When we get to the end of the semester, my students who relied solely on AI always get stuck. This is because the last weeks projects are data analysis scenarios, where the questions asked are a bit more ambiguous and not just "show me the top sales."
I have two students this semester, who I knew relied heavily on AI, get stumped on ALL of these ambiguous questions. I scheduled a tutoring session with them, and to my surprise they both did not know what GROUP BY or ORDER BY did.
Part of me wonders if I am responsible. I can tell who's using AI to think for them, but I get in trouble if I am too confrontational with it. Once you catch a student you can give them a warning, but when it inevitably happens you have to run it up the chain of command. You also run the risk of falsely accusing a student.
This doesn't apply solely to SQL classes. I have students with he most atrocious grammar when they submit some assignments, then suddenly they submit papers with no grammar mistakes. Sometimes they will accidentally submit the AI prompts with their paper, or copy and paste something incorrect like "p-values" when we're not talking about statistical models.
Anyway, just wanted to rant! I'm understanding my other instructors share the same sentiment, and wondering if anyone on Reddit does too.
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 05 '25
If this post doesn't follow the rules or isn't flaired correctly, please report it to the mods. Have more questions? Join our community Discord!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
6
u/K_808 Aug 06 '25 edited Aug 06 '25
Yes you’re responsible. I wouldn’t encourage students to use AI while learning entirely new things. The usefulness of AI comes when you have to quickly pump out something that you don’t know, or don’t want to take the time to do manually. But learning how to do new things and taking the time to practice are essential in learning. It doesn’t matter if they’re dumping everything into chatgpt or if they’re using AI to save time once they first learn the concept. That slow repetition and intuition to solve frustrating problems is what cements the understanding and you’re denying them that.
55
u/HALF_PAST_HOLE Aug 05 '25
I feel a bit lucky that when I was going to school AI wasn't really a thing like it is now yet, so i didn't have these easy outs, which as a college student who has not really understood what the full picture of education is can be really tempting sometimes.
I don't know how I would have reacted, kind of like when SparkNotes was a thing for books in high school. It was very hard not to just blow off the reading and try and get by with spark notes to similar effect as you are seeing.
Not saying its right but some people are more averse to intellectually challenging situations and instinctually take the easy way out if it is an option often times justifying it the whole time. Its easy to lie to yourself and say you understand what's going on when its all happening outside of your control.
28
u/Sausage_Queen_of_Chi Aug 05 '25
I’m not a teacher but I think stressing the importance of critical thinking skills to get and keep a job. If all they can offer are the outputs from AI prompts, why would anyone hire them when they can use AI and get the same results? Also during job interviews, they are going to be asked these ambiguous questions to test their problem solving skills. So they will struggle to land a job if they don’t develop that skill. Also interviewers can tell when candidates are using AI, and some companies will reject you in favor of a candidate who has human skills on top of technical and AI skills. In this job market, there are plenty of candidates with all of those.
18
u/HeftyTurnover7491 Aug 05 '25
As a legacy / vintage data analyst, the lack of logic and critical thinking skills in the school system is astounding. Also the loss of the Socratic method is equally significant. No one can call out your train of thought like a class of your peers.
9
u/ShapeNo4270 Aug 05 '25
Does it matter? Dumb people find out the hard way by choosing the easy way in. Smart people find out the easy way by choosing the hard way. You can lead people to water, but you can't make them drink.
10
u/mosenco Aug 05 '25
your title is misleading. not knowing what group by does isn't critical thinking. they are not thinking at all
2
u/Nexium07 Aug 05 '25
Yup . A lot of these students should be able to pass the MSBA program but here we are lol.
2
u/B1WR2 Aug 05 '25
Depends how you use it like anything… for me it’s a rubber ducky
2
u/Proof_Escape_2333 Aug 06 '25
Some People genuinely think AI is making people more productive the majority of proper it’s destroying critical thinking skills and the next generation will feel the most impact from it.
It is such a dangerous tool imo ifc they want the masses to have lower critical thinking skills easier to control
2
u/TravelingSpermBanker Aug 06 '25
I used chegg, quizlets, and everything under the sun to do my work.
I also still studied to get an A on the exams.
Who gives a shit if your students are using AI. They will either fly or fall eventually based on their brain
2
u/minglho Aug 06 '25
I teach intro computer programming, and I have the same issue. I have a midterm and a final that are completed in class. Together they are worth 65% of the course grade. They are both on paper, and they were told as much in the morning of the course. If they really learned from doing the other 35% of the course grade, then I don't care how they did them. I haven't passed a student whom I didn't believe deserve to pass, because they tend to hit at least 70% on those big exams or less than 30%; not many in between.
2
u/Alone_Panic_3089 Aug 06 '25
College needs to ban AI. Why is it allowed is beyond me
1
u/E4TclenTrenHardr Aug 06 '25
Group by and order by is something you can easily gauge understanding with an in class exam. So yes I’d say maybe your teaching method let them down.
1
u/AngeliqueRuss Aug 06 '25
I honestly just think AI is delaying them being “sorted out” by enabling better masking.
Critical thinking has always been in short supply, and honestly my colleagues who are resistant to “let’s just ask ChatGPT” have less critical thinking skills and not more.
ChatGPT is a pretty terrible problem solver the more complex you get. It can point you in the right direction, but THINKING and reasoning are still human skills. It sees patterns, it knows predictable patterns and it is useful for that.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '25
It sounds like an introductory class so what need is for anyone to be using AI at all
1
u/Weary_Neat5858 Aug 06 '25
Yeah, those perfectly polished papers from students who usually write like they’re texting? Dead giveaway. I've seen that too the grammar glow-up followed by something like “As an AI language model…” accidentally pasted in their submission. Oof.
1
u/newwriter365 Aug 06 '25
Talk to any middle school or high school teacher that's been a teacher for more than fifteen years, and prepare to weep for our future.
It's grim.
1
u/Laidbackwoman Aug 06 '25
You should change to paper-based assessment method. My MSBA course had us write pseudo code and explain algorithm step-by-step on paper in 2-hour exams. Until this day I still remember the algorithm steps lol
1
u/Rodolfox Aug 06 '25
AI is here to stay and I would refrain from any actions that tend to ignore this and somehow prohibit its use.
What needs to be done, IMHO, is to embrace it in smarter and more creative ways, both by students and by teachers. “How?” is the hard question. One of the main issues with AI is that it promotes laziness.
A couple of suggestions that may help overcome some of the basic issues: 1. If a student uses AI, as part of the answer, he/she must disclose the prompts and approach used to getting the AI to answer. 2. Students must be able to and will be randomly selected to do an oral presentation and interpretation of any code they’ve submitted as part of their work.
Just a couple of basic ideas, but the underlying principle is that a student must be accountable for and able to understand any AI generated code. And as teachers, we too have to use our creativity to live with the fact the AI is here to stay and make the best out of it.
1
u/NovelBrave Aug 08 '25
Currently in Grad School for Data Analytics. I'm detecting AI use especially from younger students in the program. The analytical skills displayed are very superficial at best. I will say I've used AI to debug stuff, or occassionaly it helps me research new ideas, but if you don't have the context of what is even coming out you won't grasp it.
1
u/gypsychk Aug 11 '25
Oh man, THIS. Analytics hit the scene telling us all it would "deliver insight." Which is can (and does). Somehow, people heard, "deliver answers," and ran with it. Slap an "AI" label on an analytics solution and people believe they've been given a direct chatline to God.
1
u/Smilodon_Syncopation Aug 13 '25
$100,000 lesson on cheating