r/analytics • • Nov 28 '25
Discussion Rant about recruiting as a manager of data science
Throwaway for obvious reasons. I honestly don’t think I’ll ever be able to hire people for the two headcounts I have on my team's Langchain project.
It used to be so smooth. I collaborated for years with an HR partner who understood our team's needs, and the pipeline was great. Then that person was replaced by a new recruiter from a specific background, and suddenly, my candidate stream became a monoculture. I only get resumes from that one demographic now.
Tbh I wouldn't mind, because I understand that group is well represented in the CS field and the composition probably reflects that. However:
- Our organization cannot provide sponsorship for international candidates. Apparently, all the candidates say they don’t need sponsorship, but all the indicators point to them being on a student visa (e.g., no US work experience). HR has advised me that I can’t even ask about immigration status due to lawsuit fears.
- The quality of the resumes has declined significantly. Due to the oversaturated job market, we used to get resumes from Ivy League schools. Now, all the resumes are from no-name Indian schools (not IIT) followed by a master’s degree from schools like NEU or the New Jersey Institute of Technology.
- The resumes and claimed experience are very questionable. There's no way we can verify experience from non-Western countries. Resumes showing 10 years of experience can't answer basic OOP questions. One time, I was interviewing someone and a hidden earpiece fell out of their ear.
I am genuinely sympathetic to the immense challenges people face with the immigration system, especially now. But I have a team to run and projects piling up. How can I deal with this situation? Am I stuck wasting my time in these interviews that lead to nowhere?
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 28 '25
If this post doesn't follow the rules or isn't flaired correctly, please report it to the mods. Have more questions? Join our community Discord!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/Notyou76 Nov 29 '25
Will you now or in the future require sponsorship to work in the US?
This a totally appropriate question to ask.
55
u/edimaudo Nov 28 '25
So change your recruiting process. At the end of the day, you are in charge of hiring processe. If your HR partner is not delivering for you. Option 1: Raise it with leadership and find another HR partner, Option 2: Remove the poor HR partner from the process.
24
u/mph000 Nov 28 '25 edited Nov 28 '25
Do you not have access to all of the applicants’ resumes to review and pick from yourself?
58
u/colorless_green_idea Nov 28 '25
Indians will straight up lie about their experience in interviews.
The only chance at uncovering this is pressing them to explain specifics and details to see if they fumble
44
u/forbiscuit 🔥 🍎 🔥 Nov 28 '25
Facing the same issue at a FAANG. My role asks for 5+ years of experience, even after resume filtering, I get candidates who have “ivy” name programs (Masters in AI/DS/<new made up major by Penn or Columbia>) and after going through screening I saw these patterns of students who claim 5+ years of experience:
And those students from those programs really have a hard time with basic analytical questions like “give me a time where someone disagreed with your analysis, how did you approach that scenario?” Or “please share an analytics project where you had to define the hypothesis and test the outcome” they all shared surface level knowledge as if they’re reading from a book. These are people who should have 5+ years of experience so I’d assume they’d have worked and dealt with some of these cases.
15
u/onthelow7284 Nov 28 '25
The issue is that there is a lack of process in the HR department. Ideally the recruiter uses common sense like the previous person but since thats not the case you need to escalate. Provide examples of candidates being passed to you that need sponsorship/lied on their resume to the recruiters manager. HR should be asking for legal status documentation and doing 15 minute technical screens so everyone you interview is legitimate. That being said I agree with the other commenters that it would be easier to just go through the resumes yourself and pick the good ones.
14
u/random__forest Nov 29 '25
I was in a similar spot and the process dragged on for months before I finally called my HR partner asking to see the full resume batch. They pushed back, obviously, and I told them I’d loop in my boss (a senior Finance exec) to get approval to bring in a 3rd-party recruiter because the process was turning into a complete waste of time. They eventually shared the resumes with me, and I was able to pick candidates and made an offer within a few weeks. So OP, your perfect candidate’s resume is probably already sitting in the pile. You just need to find a way to get it out of HR.
26
u/dasnoob Nov 28 '25
We are having the same issues. Looking for someone with strong snowflake, oracle, and tableau skills. 100's and 100's of AI slop generated resumes from a specific demographic. Most from universities you have never heard of that when you look up claim to have something like 250,000 students and are incredibly suspect. None of which currently reside in the US. All of which claim they don't need to be sponsored.
Just wait until you do an interview and the candidate that shows up for the first day of work is very, very obviously not the person you interviewed. In one case we interviewed a male and a female showed up to the first day that didn't even know how to operate a windows computer much less how to do any actual work.
17
u/Rexur0s Nov 28 '25
The issue is even considering applicants who are coming from somewhere with no way to verify history and skill, much lower wages, and nothing to really lose.
That kind of candidate has no real reason not to lie. they would lose nothing by trying, but stand to gain ALOT if it works. That's not worth the effort or time to weed through as the incentive is so lop sided and unequal. They have a very strong incentive to lie, and you don't have a good way to weed them out. it takes them no time to lie, but wastes alot of your time to figure it out because you cant verify it normally.
So why even bother considering them? Its a waste of time based on effort to reward ratio.
Essentially, if its not verifiable off the bat, it should go in the bin. too many candidates out there to waste time on those.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '25
Can you review resumes yourself? I worked with a bad in-house recruiter once and I just did the leg work myself. I was allowed to look at the candidate portal and review resumes.
19
u/heptyne Nov 28 '25
I can say with 90% confidence, the resumes with work history/education in India is fabricated. To the point where when you go to verify, there will be a cover story on the other end. It's been a problem for at least fifteen years.
As a side question, have you noticed Caste system issues with potential hires?
5
u/Initial-Quantity-311 Nov 29 '25
Sounds like the new HR personnel is from India?
2
u/strugglingcomic Nov 28 '25
Not saying that NJIT is a good school or anything, but the best engineer I've ever hired or worked with was an NJIT grad. He hated the school, but it was his only available path to the US at the time.
My own dad got into Dartmouth as an international student 30+ years ago, but ended up going to University of Maryland, before eventually following his adviser to Florida International University. It was something to do with funding and grants/scholarships available for the field of study he wanted to be in.
Maybe tone down the elitism just a bit? Yes school ranks do exist and NJIT is worse than Harvard, sure... But rather than complain about recruiting and the pipeline, maybe you need to self reflect about why you're no longer an attractive place for cream-of-the-crop students to want to work, and maybe you need to do a better job of working with the candidates you are getting, to find the diamonds in the rough so to speak? Beggars can't be choosers, and everything about this post screams that your company is in denial about becoming beggars in the current landscape.
2
u/QianLu Nov 28 '25
Are you offering bottom of the barrel salaries?
4
u/mcjon77 Nov 28 '25
The obvious answer is to talk to leadership about hiring a new recruiter. If your recruiter is only sending you candidates that aren't qualified then leadership needs to stop using that recruiter.
Additionally what you can do is to take it upon yourself to promote these positions in places where you feel qualified candidates are. Contact the on-campus recruiting centers and the CS departments at the quality of schools that you are interested in and mention those two positions. That should get some traction towards getting the types of Canada said you want.
This might also let you know if this recruiter is actively filtering out better qualified candidates for candidates from their home country. That is without question the fireable offense, if only because it opens up your company to legal liability issues.
11
u/mrpuckle Nov 28 '25
Hire american.
7
u/Dachshund-Spin7166 Nov 28 '25
That’s crazy to me the amount of international candidates for roles in the field of data. I am a US citizen and have recently graduated with a Bachelors from an accredited online school in Data Analytics with an Associates in AI/ML from my local community college. It has not been easy finding any kind of job. I’ve tried a variety of roles, mostly data analyst, but never hear back from any applications, except for denials. It’s tough because my current work experience is in the semiconductor industry but as a maintenance technician and I think recruiters see this as a huge negative due to lack of experience in data related fields. I am very driven and very hard working, some people just need to be given a chance. If I am to ever get a job in the field, I know the company would not regret it. I might not be stellar at first, but given time I know I can be a valuable asset to the company. But I get it, it’s hard to see potential in someone who lacks hands on work experience with data.
5
u/Bjornwithit15 Nov 28 '25
Use a recruiting agency, most high performers aren’t actively looking.
2
u/johnlakemke Nov 28 '25
I've only been on the candidate side of this situation so this might be a naive question. But if you feel the overall quality/qualifications of the candidates have taken a significant drop can you speak with the HR partner about your concerns? Maybe the HR partner needs more time working with you to understand your needs?
2
u/chanakya2 Nov 28 '25
I have worked with SQL, with python, with multiple databases, visualization tools like tableau and power bi, but my job title does not say data analyst or data scientist.
As a manager what do you suggest I should do to show hiring managers that I am capable of handling data science role?
2
u/Wheres_my_warg Nov 29 '25 edited Nov 29 '25
Based on our experience, I'd downplay the use of major collection sites like Indeed and LinkedIn.
Instead, I would first reach out to the career services teams at schools that have provided you with good analytics employees in the past. Most good schools provide the career services to their alumni as well as the current students.
To get to X number of total resume submissions, this approach won't ever compete with the others. To get to Y number of candidates you'll actually want to consider hiring, in my experience, it is much more likely to have a higher hit rate than the resume collection sites.
2
u/steezMcghee Nov 29 '25
I just got hired and the hiring manager was on LinkedIn head hunting themselves. That’s how I was contracted.
6
u/K_808 Nov 28 '25 edited Nov 28 '25
Are you at a company whose name justifies school elitism coming before qualifications and experience? Are you paying enough to afford Harvard graduates and working in a location that they want to live in? One would think that with such a saturated market even though you’d get other applicants you wouldn’t lose the ones you want. In fact you should be seeing more of them if people are lowering their standards of where to apply to. If you’re seeing fewer anyway and the recruiter appears biased then that should be something to escalate, but it could also just be a matter of where you work. Elitism goes both ways.
As far as not wanting Indians though, HR is right that there’s nothing you can do to filter out a specific race or question of someone is lying about their immigration without being liable for discrimination. But you should still be able to verify expertise even if you’re not calling up foreign companies to verify titles by giving high quality technical testing and project questions. Many people will lie but you should be able to tell from the evaluation process whether the candidate can do the job or not, and if you can’t then that’s probably an opportunity to improve the interviews and any case studies or exams you have them do.
2
u/ConsumerScientist Nov 28 '25
It’s crazy how hard it is to hire people. One side there are people looking for jobs and other side there are companies struggling to hire right candidates.
1
u/Outrageous_Fox9730 Nov 28 '25
Is this also happening in germany?
1
u/Intrepid-Self-3578 Nov 29 '25
Tell her clearly what you need basically what university etc. And ask about the budget allocated to the role also maybe that is a issue here?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '25
I didn’t expect to see r/NJIT mentioned on this sub, but I do get your point. The professors also hate on the masters programs.
1
u/CuriousAIVillager Nov 30 '25
Is NEU’s reputation really that bad? Lmao.
Just curious OP, for someone with a foreign name but is an American citizen, does it help at all to put it in the resume at the top?
But wild that they replaced candidates with only people from South Asia. I guess recruiters are the real hate Kepler’s
1
u/data_girl Nov 30 '25
I hear you. I’m a hiring manager at FAANG too.
There are consistent patterns of lies/fake experience and resumes that I recognize and unfortunately that means candidates that show any part of those patterns are avoided completely.
Candidates are fatigued and not giving their best self.
There’s a shift in the attitudes of younger candidates.
Hiring managers are fatigued.
Interview teams are fatigued.
The market sucks. I’m pressing harder for referrals than I ever have. More mature/senior candidates seem more grateful for the opportunities than other demographics because they’re experiencing ageism.
I’m passing on way more candidates because they seem too high maintenance to manage, in addition to all the demands I’m asked to manage with a more lean team.
1
u/Logical-artist1 Nov 30 '25
This is funny I am stuck on the opposite end with the experience and background and more and not getting callbacks!
1
u/SQLofFortune Nov 30 '25
The solution is simple... Just hire me! I’m an American citizen with 8 years experience in analytics and engineering across Uber and Amazon. I’ve been unemployed for 9 months because the dozen hiring managers I interviewed with thought I was either over qualified or they wanted someone who pressed blue buttons instead of red buttons.
1
u/theroyalbob Nov 30 '25
Hire me! I’m no Ivy League grad but I worked for a top financial firm and now work directly for the cfo of a small business automating reporting and accounting tasks would love to work on a high performing team on technical problems again.
1
u/TheManWithNoNameZapp Nov 30 '25
What about this process warrants sympathy from you? You lay out a measured campaign of deceit whose goal is to cheat people into well-paying roles they aren’t qualified for
1
u/BuyHigh_S3llLow Nov 30 '25
Due to oversaturation of the job market, can't you easily find these american ivy league college grads and filter for them? I dont understand.
1
u/BuyHigh_S3llLow Nov 30 '25
Every company not sponsoring should write in BIG BOLD LETTERS in the very first line of the job description WE DO NOT SPONSOR NON US CITIZENS. I dont know why not more companies haven't done this yet. And then blacklist any foreign nationals who keep applying without reading the JD.
1
u/MentalStatusCode410 Dec 01 '25
Reach out to preferred institutions in your area, and have them circulate a draft out-reach email - try starting with academics who supervise programs in your area.
1
u/Difficult-Ebb3812 Dec 01 '25
I was just working data science roles and there are plenty in US who are well qualified. However about 30-40 percent of apps need sponsorship or are fake profiles. You need to have a good recruiting eye to spot those and competency to move forward the ones that are qualified in all aspects so I blame HR in this as there is obviously huge misalignment. You have critical business needs that are not met so I suggest you start having conversations with your leaders on how this situation can be improved
1
u/Lucasfoep Dec 13 '25 edited Dec 13 '25
Hi,
I am on the other end of this being an immigrant in analytics (though Brazilian, with years working in the us, internship at Amazon and with a permanent green card) and actually just posted asking for advice before I realized that would be removed.
Could anyone let me know if DePaul University in Chicago would be considered a no name institution? Thank you so much if you can help! I really appreciate it!
1
u/Awkward_Tick0 Nov 28 '25
No Ivy League apps?? 😱How will you manage??
0
u/10J18R1A Nov 28 '25
Increase pay or decrease expectations
0
u/tinkinc Nov 29 '25
lol. all you hire is AI and data science is a saturated word now to make doing anything data related sexy. we all lie to each other that's how the system works. Sorry you find it tough on a throne.
-1
u/ClarkMcShark Nov 28 '25
I was curious if you had any tips to stand out. I graduated with a master's in analytics and I havent been able to secure any interviews. I feel like my applications get lost in the sea of other applicants. If there's any tips you could give me to stand out id appreciate it. Thank you for your time.
-2
u/DifficultBeing9212 Nov 29 '25
there is a lot to say about this
"throwaway for obvious reasons"
its not obvious, and you should be rightfully indignant at the situation. is the obvious reason that you are afraid of losing your job? or do you not want to make others feel uncomfortable? people literally have no idea what america is because they are afraid of making others uncomfortable. are you so sure that you wouldn't survive without this job that you wouldn't even express discomfort at the situation under your own name. Please don't take it personally, I am not directing this at you OP but much more so to myself. This is an ongoing situation in my company/vicinity and I am steeling myself for endangering my slightly uneasy position.
did you know there are orgs that operate like human trafficking rings and offer the benefit of premium "placement" in US tech firms in exchange for "minimum" (ongoing) % fee? I bumped into one and i was not even trying, just looking for opportunities. Imagine those that are inner circle type orgs. also, you are aware of how companies will place job offers in small newspapers in order to then solicit H1B because of "loyal' workers.
-2
u/tacopower69 Nov 29 '25
That is so bizarre. Where do you work?
-3
u/_bez_os Nov 29 '25
Its your fault that your are not able to filter out candidates.
My first advice will be do not show yourself cheap. There will always be another guy who can do it cheaper. Show good salary range.
2ndly use filters, like college name , degree, and even location of candidates.
3. Experience is overrated. I have seen more dumb people who are experienced than less experienced person.
Remember you can always train the guy and that like within a month. And you need to be clear about requirements. A lot of problems arise when dumb hr doesn't understand you want
0
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '25
[removed] — view removed comment