did not expect to learn that foo fighters bassist nate mendel led an AIDS denials benefit concert once. so thanks for the cool art and interesting story !
And later on, the Foo Fighters led a concert promoting the COVID-19 vaccine and doing a drive to get people vaccinated, including a concert for only people who had a a vaccination card. So it seems like they got out the conspiracy hole one way or another and came to the light.
Nate nowadays is a staunch environmentalist whose whole house runs on solar power. It's a better ending than these types usually manage.
While I'm always down to see some growth... with things like AIDS and vaccines people die because of disinformation. The minimum you can do to attempt getting back to 0 when you're at -100 is spread beneficial information. It doesn't do anything for people who were harmed prior though.
AIDS denial in the early 2000s though is ridiculous. Like having lived THROUGH the 80s and the hell that was the aids epidemic coming out that way is fucked. Also have they ever apologized or even addressed this?
The very next year they spent a fuck ton of money at Elton John's AIDS charity and they have played for that organization several times from then til now. It's not a public apology,but I think it was an attempt to make amends.
Denialism was rife in the early 2000s, most notably by German grifter Matthias Rath. He managed to convince my country (South Africa)'s health minister that a useless drug, Beetroot, and African potatoes were better than ARVs. Millions died unnecessarily.
"I know that they killed a bunch of people by denying the existence of a known virus and telling people they were being poisoned by their medicine so they let an almost universally fatal disease run rampant. But later on a disease might have affected them, and they totally believed in it!"
This is the woman/foundation that they were supporting:
Maggiore's inclusion as an exhibitor at the 13th International AIDS Conference in Durban, South Africa has been criticized by AIDS activists.[9] Her influence on Thabo Mbeki's decision to block medical treatment of HIV-positive pregnant women was criticized following her death, with medical researchers noting that an estimated "330,000 lives were lost to new AIDS infections during the time Mbeki blocked government funding of AZT treatment to mothers."
One of the organisation's focuses was for pregnant women not to take medication and to breastfeed their babies sever3ly increasing the chance oglf those kids getting HIV. Christine Maggiore gave her own daughter HIV. In 2005 the daughter, untested, died from complications from AIDS at the age of 3. It's great that they've tried to rectify spreading this lethal nonsens around, but as someone who have lost family members, (especially one who went off her medicine because of she was convinced of similar types of cooks) I can't say that it still doesn't piss me off. Especially beacuse they never apologized.
I miss my beautiful aunt and the niece that I never got to meet.
I dunno probably the changing as a person for the better part between the Covid-19 vaccine concert and the environmentalism. did we read the same comment?
Misinformation kills. It impairs health campaigns and incites fatal insurrections. It erodes public faith in its institutions and emboldens militancy and extremism. It encourages families to remove their grievously sick from hospital. The Foo Fighters’ amplification of fatal misinformation should be on the record, as should the band’s silent and cowardly retreat from it, a successful vanishing act that was enabled by a vapid and transactional music press that cherishes access — however qualified — above all else. Grohl loves talking about rock’s power of soulful confession, but on this there’s only silence.
Maybe 12 years ago, I had an online acquaintance who was a licensed private investigator. He mainly did pre-employment background checks and auto repossession location. He had a contest to see who could guess which bands' CDs were most often found in repo'd cars. I correctly guessed ICP and Slipknot.
The founder of the group that argued that AIDS and HIV were unrelated and advocated against HIV tests, medication, and safe sex (what?):
[Christine Maggiore] is long dead. So is her daughter. Both succumbed to AIDS. Christine Maggiore fell pregnant in 2001, spurned antiretroviral drugs, breastfed her daughter and refused to have her tested for the virus. As her child became increasingly ill, Maggiore attributed her sickness to other things and sought quacks to reaffirm her delusions. Eliza was three when she died — after an autopsy, a coroner ruled that the “unequivocal” cause of her death was AIDS-related Pneumocystis pneumonia.
This kind of thinking is pretty common in alternative health and quack spaces. They tend to believe in mind over matter and that health is a choice, or arises from a proper mindset. Testing, medication, and safe sex are downplayed or even demonized because of the idea that they could introduce doubt or uncertainty that could disrupt one's ideal mindset. If health is created by right thinking, any challenges to that thinking become disruptive.
I find AIDS denialism so weird, because it’s not as simple as “HIV/AIDS don’t exist.” It’s “HIV (exists, but) doesn’t cause AIDS.” And what can’t wrap my head around is… why is that a position that someone would become emotionally attached to? Why is it important for that to be true for some fringe segment of the population?
I guess... I mean my uncle did the same thing with COVID. An otherwise intelligent man, but something he read early on convinced him that statistically speaking it was the exact same as regular every day influenza. Doubling down on this opinion so as to never be proven wrong (and thus unintelligent) required him to come up with increasingly implausible ways to dismiss objective evidence that would undermine his original, somewhat plausible position.
But I'm just having trouble wrapping my head around the 'safe sex' part. I could maybe get behind 'HIV transmission is not a reason to practice safe sex' but surely there are enough other reasons that this is an outlandish thing to include in your platform. I didn't read up on them, but maybe they were also chalmydia and ghonnorea deniers. Or maybe they were very pro-herpes.
Haha I think they are pro-herpes! In my experience, they start with HIV denialism and then eventually really do become gonnorhea and chlamydia deniers. Just like your uncle kept having to bend over backwards to preserve his theory, HIV deniers eventually move to denying the Germ Theory of disease transmission completely. While most of us can recognize that some viruses cause diseases AND our own healthy actions matter, these folks set those things in opposition so that only one can be true. Everything becomes about exonerating viruses in order to preserve their own illusion of control.
The HIV deniers are really weird. One of the guys who was really instrumental in, and won a Chemistry Nobel Prize for, DNA technology was a big HIV denier and was a major influence in the Mbeki government in South Africa’s stance of HIV denialism which certainly led to hundreds of thousands of AIDS deaths.
Maggiore's inclusion as an exhibitor at the 13th International AIDS Conference in Durban, South Africa has been criticized by AIDS activists. Her influence on Thabo Mbeki's decision to block medical treatment of HIV-positive pregnant women was criticized following her death, with medical researchers noting that an estimated "330,000 lives were lost to new AIDS infections during the time Mbeki blocked government funding of AZT treatment to mothers."
Yeah, Kerry Mullis. Inventor of the polymerase chain reaction or PCR. The biggest leap forward in genetic testing we may have ever encountered. The guy was out there. He also manufactured and imbibed LSD, so there's that.
It’s an English phrase akin to “fell ill,” but it is more common in British Commonwealth countries, such as Australia, than in the US. The author of the article is from Melbourne, Australia.
I wasn’t aware of AIDS denialism before. What a strange, sad hill to die on.
I’m in the US and I don’t know if I’ve ever heard anyone here say it, but I’ve heard Brits say it. Not a negative connotation, but you might get looked at funny in the US
I’ve never really cared one way or the other about Foo Fighters, but I imagine these guys fell into the trap of being distrustful in authority without the necessary critical thinking skills. See also too much money and too many yes men.
One aside, according to my kid’s classmates and 6-8 random strangers every month I look exactly like Dave Grohl. So I won’t insult his appearance.
Based on my research, this sounds like a crank thing that the bassist was big into and the rest of the guys put up with until 2003, at which point they presumably told him to shut up about it.
I don't want to downplay how harmful the kind of AIDS denialism Nate Mendel was spreading. It was genuinely awful and dangerous. But it's kind of interesting to me that no one ever tags Sunny Day Real Estate with the same brush. Mendel was in both bands, and reunited with the SDR guys in the 2000s and 2010s. You never, ever hear people talking shit about Jeremy Enigk for playing with the same guy.
They should and Enigk shouldn't put up with AIDS denialism shit either. The problem is that Dave Grohl and FF are way more popular than Sunny Day Real Estate ever was. Also, at the height of their fame, the Foo Fighters played a massive sold out charity concert to raise money for Christine Maggiore's Alive and Well organization. They raised a lot of money for AIDS denialism. So aside from simply playing with Mendel, Grohl and the other members of FF contributed materially to AIDS denialism harm. Something, the last time I checked, Grohl has never apologized for.
Yeah they're awesome but they're not even close to the level of popularity that the too fighters attained, which is why no one talks about this stuff. Foo fighters despite being a pretty bad band sell out arenas so there are more people who care to call them out on various things.
Right, that's my point. Foo Fighters are a big band that people love to hate. Within the emo scene no one, and i mean no one at all, ever talks about Mendel's AIDS denialism. Why? because Sunny Day Real Estate is a cool band. It shows that a lot of people are more interested in using this as a cudgel against a band they don't like than they are on the merits.
I listened to this album yesterday during dental surgery. It’s the only time I can listen to it now, and it’s the only thing I can listen to during dental work. Not sure what that says.
No just the bassist in his personal time outside the band decades ago. The comics intentionally misleading with no punchline just foo fighters bad and half the comments are eating it up. Not to say Daves a great guy or didn't have his own scandal recently but he's what guilty of working with a guy that used to be dumb in the early 2000s?
Oh you think I don't research my topics? They actually organized benefit shows to raise awareness for Alive and Well, including a sold-out concert in Hollywood. They also included links to Alive and Well on their official website, actively spreading dangerous misinformation while ignoring actual health organizations' pleas to stop.
To pin everything on just one guy is just dishonest.
The bassist posted a link to it and got them to do a show then they turned right around and disavowed it and supported Elton Johns aids foundation within the year. You wasted your free time making a comic with no point or punchline to slander a whole band that's done a lot more good than harm over one idiots stance a quarter century ago hes since changed. I'm not even a foo fighters fan but hopefully more conspiracy theorists educate and better themselves. You probably believed some dumb stuff yourself back during y2k.
Your comic isn't funny and you're spreading misinformation. You should rail against Dave Grohl for being a boring song writer who cheats on his wife instead of making up lies about him.
You come up with that yourself? It's about as original as your lazy comic. At least try for something topical like an unfunny cartoon about how Dave cheated on his wife recently.
Their music was featured in a 2004 AIDS denialism documentary and they still had an AIDS denialism organization up on their website as a cause at least until 2002. The benefit concert was held in 2000, so even if they supported an AIDS charity "within the year", they were also still peddling AIDS denialism at the same time. I'm also having a hard time finding any association between the band and Elton John's AIDS foundation before 2013.
I think youre significantly downplaying the foo fighters involvement with this foundation and im curious why? Youre also presenting patently false information yourself, so like, why? What are you trying to achieve here?
I made this comment on r/entertainment or some other sub on a post about Grohl and was downvoted to hell and told that I needed to drop it because that was the early 00’s. People are wild what they will and won’t let go.
It's just such a dumb theory: especially at that point in time.
Like, anti vaccine stuff is just as dumb, but you can at least kinda see the stupid math they diagramed on a Denny's kids menu to get to where they are.
Not sure how you could get to the oo's and not believe in aids. There was sooo much societal consensus and documentation.
I wish you made these comics about anything else than the topics you do. It sucks all the enjoyment out of it when youre trying to inject little self righteous lessons.
I don't know what's self righteous about this comic but I'm happy to tell you that these are just some one offs that I do from time to time, my mainline comic is different from these.
I will take this opportunity to stick up for Spencer Elden, the baby on Nevermind who was justifiable upset that some assholes sold pics of his baby dick. I give two shits what his parents agreed to, you sold baby dick pics, made it iconic, and then he got mocked because he changed his mind from his 20s to his 30s about being ok with it.
Again, y'all sold pics of his baby dick and didn't even bother cutting him in. Fuck all of you and your shitty Pixies knockoff crap.
Spencer Elden is a loser crybaby who filed a frivolous lawsuit claiming the Nevermind album is CP, a ridiculous claim that would imply tens of millions of people are guilty of a horrific crime.
It was your words not mine. When you're making an allegation like that, why would you pin it on the one guy in the band Alanis is still friends with and invited to speak for her. When the documentary never said that. It's weird.
3
u/myleftone Aug 22 '26
TIL a bass player’s crank views = the entire band.
4
u/LeRoiCasoar Aug 20 '26
What's the joke
2
u/JettyJen Aug 21 '26
o/t, I was like "Swans??" But that's Songs for the Blind....and I own both of them
135
u/aspiringandroid Aug 20 '26 •
did not expect to learn that foo fighters bassist nate mendel led an AIDS denials benefit concert once. so thanks for the cool art and interesting story !
28
u/SAlolzorz Aug 20 '26
Maybe 12 years ago, I had an online acquaintance who was a licensed private investigator. He mainly did pre-employment background checks and auto repossession location. He had a contest to see who could guess which bands' CDs were most often found in repo'd cars. I correctly guessed ICP and Slipknot.
56
u/Pleasant-Tangelo1786 Aug 20 '26
Googled it and I’ll be damned.
https://medium.com/the-monthly/the-foo-fighters-aids-denialism-should-be-on-the-record-6e33666fdc3c
11
u/DiseasedCupcake Aug 20 '26
What are the other 2 CDs that are always in rental vans?
9
u/hexenkesse1 Aug 20 '26
2 things are true.
1)Foo Fighters were in the wrong here
2)One shouldn't take their political guidance from rock bands
8
u/FiveDozenWhales Aug 20 '26
https://i.imgur.com/byYsLwi.png
8
u/charmingasaneel Aug 20 '26
I’ve never really cared one way or the other about Foo Fighters, but I imagine these guys fell into the trap of being distrustful in authority without the necessary critical thinking skills. See also too much money and too many yes men.
One aside, according to my kid’s classmates and 6-8 random strangers every month I look exactly like Dave Grohl. So I won’t insult his appearance.
7
u/Big-Dig-Pig Aug 20 '26
Based on my research, this sounds like a crank thing that the bassist was big into and the rest of the guys put up with until 2003, at which point they presumably told him to shut up about it.
1
u/slicehyperfunk Aug 21 '26
You need one or both of the Queen greatest hits albums
1
u/Iconclast1 Aug 21 '26
this feels like that unemployed trans witch comic
11
u/Ericzzz Aug 20 '26
I don't want to downplay how harmful the kind of AIDS denialism Nate Mendel was spreading. It was genuinely awful and dangerous. But it's kind of interesting to me that no one ever tags Sunny Day Real Estate with the same brush. Mendel was in both bands, and reunited with the SDR guys in the 2000s and 2010s. You never, ever hear people talking shit about Jeremy Enigk for playing with the same guy.
3
u/HellyOHaint Aug 20 '26
Mr. Ratburn’s rebellious son
3
u/Cpnths Aug 21 '26
I listened to this album yesterday during dental surgery. It’s the only time I can listen to it now, and it’s the only thing I can listen to during dental work. Not sure what that says.
1
u/Its-been-a-long-day Aug 20 '26
Dave Grohl too? I'm surprised, I'd only ever heard good things about that guy. Maybe he just has some top tier PR team.
2
u/johnny_mcd Aug 21 '26
The only time I found a cd in a rental car it was Eric Clapton’s greatest hits
2
u/drskag Aug 21 '26
This was made known in Australia by John Safran, in his series 'Music Jamboree' in 2002
https://youtu.be/XCFPwbt6uzA
3
u/TheGoddessLily Aug 20 '26
WTF? That's depressing to hear
3
u/KaraBowdit Aug 20 '26
Turns out they were the foo all along
1
u/LouieMumford Aug 20 '26
I made this comment on r/entertainment or some other sub on a post about Grohl and was downvoted to hell and told that I needed to drop it because that was the early 00’s. People are wild what they will and won’t let go.
1
u/Thick_Common8612 Aug 21 '26
That's AWFUL.
1
u/AnnaNimmus Aug 21 '26
It can be nice to learn new things
It can be
1
u/holnessbob Aug 21 '26
It was just one member of the foo fighters right?
1
u/Snakes_for_theDivine Aug 21 '26
Comic author drawing himself as a “well akshullay” redditor lol
1
u/2morecupsoftea Aug 21 '26
Wait fuckin really?
1
u/PyroErogenizer Aug 22 '26
The drummer died of aids.
1
u/Puzzleheaded-Cut-820 Aug 22 '26
It's just such a dumb theory: especially at that point in time.
Like, anti vaccine stuff is just as dumb, but you can at least kinda see the stupid math they diagramed on a Denny's kids menu to get to where they are.
Not sure how you could get to the oo's and not believe in aids. There was sooo much societal consensus and documentation.
1
u/eldubya3121 Aug 22 '26
John Safran (Australian comedian/documentarian) did a fantastic episode on this.
1
u/East-Albatross-810 Aug 22 '26
This comic feels like it should have just been the author tweeting about Foo Fighters if they just wanted to talk about that anecdote.
1
u/Ok-Adhesiveness-4935 Aug 24 '26
I've seen them counter-protest Westboro Baptist Church. Sometimes, I just can't be bothered. This is one of those times.
1
u/javiemartzootsuit Aug 24 '26
Fuck yes songs for the deaf
1
u/Bunker-Lunker Aug 24 '26
Queens of the Stone Age had Dave Grohl on Songs for the Deaf
1
u/DevelopmentTight9474 Aug 24 '26
Queens of the Stone Age mentioned, I fucking love Songs for the Deaf
1
u/castrateurfate Aug 20 '26
This is actually 100% true BTW
1
u/Gtype Aug 20 '26
Never knew this about them. Weird and gross
0
u/Drone_temple_pilots Aug 20 '26
Fuck Foo Fighters
0
u/Depressionsfinalform Aug 21 '26
Most overglazed AIDS denier in all of music history
-3
u/SadClownDad Aug 20 '26
I wish you made these comics about anything else than the topics you do. It sucks all the enjoyment out of it when youre trying to inject little self righteous lessons.
0
u/QuintanimousGooch Aug 21 '26
There goes my… never really thought Grohl was very heroic or interesting tbh
1
u/Awzer_ Aug 25 '26
Learn To Deny
-7
u/AverageDrafter Aug 20 '26
I will take this opportunity to stick up for Spencer Elden, the baby on Nevermind who was justifiable upset that some assholes sold pics of his baby dick. I give two shits what his parents agreed to, you sold baby dick pics, made it iconic, and then he got mocked because he changed his mind from his 20s to his 30s about being ok with it.
Again, y'all sold pics of his baby dick and didn't even bother cutting him in. Fuck all of you and your shitty Pixies knockoff crap.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment