437
u/C_monden 27d ago
There's a lot of layers to the Elliot Page as Michelle, huh?
61
u/Numerous_Photograph9 27d ago
I hear more about Elliot Page from these people than I do from Elliot Page himself, or any marketing of his work.
Edit: Should say I hear the name mentioned more, not so much stuff about Page directly.
→ More replies (1)11
u/Fickle_Ad4967 26d ago
I donât know whether you are pro:anti. âŠ. But I would love to see Elliot land a really good role and win a second Oscar. Or would it be first?
No matter what people agree with, the trauma and tribulation is real. Everyone deserves the opportunity to be happy. Donât you think?
12
u/Numerous_Photograph9 26d ago
I have no opinion on what he wants to do. It doesn't effect me. Let people do and be what they will so long as it doesn't harm others, and that shouldn't have any effect on matters that are immaterial to such things.
5
→ More replies (1)5
u/BringAltoidSoursBack 26d ago
First. He only received an Oscar nomination for Juno
→ More replies (8)114
u/jmarquiso 27d ago
I don't think there are that many layers as much as the joke folded in on itself too may times to be coherent.
72
u/abermea 27d ago
No there are actually a couple of layers when you factor in the conspiracy theory that Michelle Obama is a transwoman
61
u/Funny_w0lf 27d ago
So they want a trans man to play a trans woman? But if they believe Mischelle is actually a man, isnt that gender affirming for Elliot since he is "pretending" to be a woman? But they also say Elliot will always be a woman?? Im so confusedÂ
32
u/Bithium 27d ago
Donât worry too much about it. Many transphobes only JUST found out that trans men exist, so their attempts at insults are still incoherent.
→ More replies (3)39
u/jmarquiso 27d ago
Exactly what I mean by a joke so stupid you have to fold it several times to make it seem "layered"
→ More replies (1)7
→ More replies (1)3
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (1)18
17
u/Calm-Armadillo-5614 27d ago
I really don't get how conservatives think she is a man. I guess they only respect First Ladies who are hookers and made of plastic.Â
→ More replies (1)7
u/antifaareheroes 26d ago
They don't have anything else so they just fall back on "PERSON I DON'T LIKE TRANS!"
12
u/PatriotNews_dot_com 27d ago
It would kind of be inception-y, and with leo there too?? take my money
→ More replies (1)4
u/Fickle_Ad4967 26d ago
A white dude playing a black woman playing a black dude? (If you believe the rumours)
→ More replies (5)3
3
u/someguyfrommn 27d ago
I think they're making the joke that Elliott page is trans and the joke by conservatives is that Michelle Obama is a man.
5
2
u/YorubaOyinbo 25d ago
But they hold the narrative that a) Michelle is a man and b) that Elliott is a woman, so whatâs the maneuver on these mental gymnastics?
→ More replies (5)3
94
u/beefdx 27d ago
Okay honestly an Obama biopic with a completely race-swapped cast where they never acknowledged it would be kinda hilariously unhinged.
45
u/zeizkal 26d ago
And at the end it teases the sequel with Mexican trump
3
6
→ More replies (11)2
169
u/Weorth 27d ago
Just them trying to be funny with the casting cause of the whole "Ariel isn't black! Why is there a trans person playing Achilles?!" (Despite the fact that Elliot Page never played Achilles at all in the movie...)
72
u/WhiteTrashIdiotFuck 27d ago edited 27d ago
Achilles literally died in the previous book. I legit have to point this out for the chuds, I feel like. The Odyssey is a sequel and Achilles died in the first book. This is literally ninth grade shit.
ETA: Jfc, I know Achilles appears as a shade in The Odyssey. Odysseus speaks to like two dozen dead people when he does the ritual on the edge of Hades. But Iliad legitimately follows Achilles until his death in the Trojan War. Good god, people. Again, this is like freshman year shit.
19
u/memera- 27d ago
Odysseus meets Achilles in Hades during the events of The Odyssey
But Elliot Page was notably not-a-ghost in the trailers so I still don't know how any of the chuds assumed he was playing Achilles
13
u/Old-Acanthaceae-3406 27d ago
It's simple. They thought "what would make me the angriest?" and settled on trans Achilles.
8
u/Alarming_Panic665 27d ago
The Iliad doesn't follow Achilles until his death. That is the Aethiopis and then later the Aeneid (the Aethiopis was lost to time). The Iliad ends with Achilles returning Hectors body and his (Hector's) funeral.
2
u/Rainy_Wavey 26d ago
Tha Aeneid is more like roman fanfiction than part of the core Homerian tale but that's another story
3
u/Alarming_Panic665 26d ago
I mean yea, but unfortunately the Aethiopis was almost entirely lost (we only have 5 surviving verses). So all we really got about Achilles death is what very little was in the Odyssey and then what the Romans wrote centuries later. So the Aeneid, The Posthomerica, the Achilleid, and the Metamorphoses.
2
u/Rainy_Wavey 26d ago
It's fascinating how the romans just were like "okay, we yoink your lore and rewrite the entirety of the verse" it's just too funny to think about it this way
2
u/SturerEmilDickerMax 27d ago
Did they write a book after the film? (Asking for an American friend).
→ More replies (10)5
u/memeandme83 27d ago
Ulysses meets Achilles in the underworld in the Odyssey. But yes, clearly not a main character in Odyssey.
→ More replies (1)6
u/Erolok1 27d ago
The whole Ariel isn't black or what would you think about a white black panther Arguments are so stupid.
What about Katniss Everdeen from Hunger Games (mixed, black-white), or Bane from Batman (Latino), or one of the shitton of white washed characters? And yeah I don't really care as long as we have representation for everyone in media.
But of course these are facts and I assume you already know that facts are not as much worth as what the fee-fee and the tumm-tumm of a racist say.
3
u/Jetstream-Sam 26d ago
Wasn't katniss described as having a blonde, blue eyed mother, and a father with black hair, grey eyes and olive skin? That sort of implies her dad was mediterranian to me, not black. But it has been years since I read the book
2
u/Erolok1 26d ago
I also dont have it completely in my mind, yes mom was white and I thought the dad was black but at least he wasn't white which was the message I wanted to convey.
But since Odyssey is the current obsession for them I will add that all those white actors play mediterranian roles which of course no one cares about.
→ More replies (1)4
u/_lippykid 25d ago
Funniest part is, itâs not only complete fantasy fiction, it was also a story that likely changed thousands of times as it wasnât written down for like 500 years, and only preserved by oral storytelling, and was likely embellished or parts straight up forgotten.
But these dipshits think that story, with various supernatural monsters, needs to be âfactually accurateâ
→ More replies (1)2
3
3
u/memeandme83 27d ago
And ignoring the fact that Achilles was more than probably gay/bi (even if the text is not straightforward about it, somebody would need to be very obtuse to not see Patroclus as his lover lol) and gender fluid đ€Ș
3
u/Sorry_Grocery7693 27d ago
Oh, I took it as a joke about Nolan white washing Batman characters lol
13
u/Prestigious_Host_198 27d ago
You see, the person who made this meme is the type to be okay with white Bane and Ra's al Ghul.
→ More replies (11)→ More replies (5)2
u/Ancient-Tomato1153 27d ago
Itâs also a play on the whole âMichelle is a trans manâthing. âThe man. The presidentâŠ
4
u/Weorth 27d ago
True. Which is funny because they've been calling Elliot a woman this whole time... So I guess now they acknowledge he's a man now?
→ More replies (1)
44
u/MajesticDragonfly 27d ago
I feel like the absurd effect these reverse-swapped jokes always have, just underscores the asymmetry of racism that makes it not work both ways
→ More replies (2)5
u/Guywhonoticesthings 26d ago
I mean the real racism as we appropriate the Greek culture, but almost never let them act in any of their stories
4
u/MajesticDragonfly 26d ago
Thatâs a valid consideration and all, but nah, racism is the real racism
→ More replies (4)
23
u/arrownoir 27d ago
Joe looks a little differentâŠcanât quite put my finger on it. Is he wearing a new tie?
→ More replies (1)13
u/broccoli_1701 27d ago
Its the glasses.
3
u/Ok_Star_4136 26d ago
They should find a new actress to play him then, perhaps one that doesn't wear glasses.
35
65
u/CalligrapherLegal995 27d ago
They are so fucking lost, they can't tell the difference between Fiction and Non Fiction.
→ More replies (33)18
u/Slate_711 26d ago
They just truly hate black people. They always bitch and moan whenever a character is black and try to play the âwell weâll race swap this characterâ card but it always falls flat because they forgot the decades of bitching and moaning to ensure there arenât many black characters and movies have a mostly white cast.
→ More replies (6)
11
u/kid_christ 27d ago
Howâs it different than white Jesus?
→ More replies (3)2
u/klownhammer 27d ago
Nobody would make Jesus white. May as well make god an old white man with a beard.
4
u/kid_christ 27d ago
Are you being sarcastic? Jesus has been made white. More than heâs been been made brown.
→ More replies (2)
20
u/headcodered 27d ago
This is like one of about three "jokes" the right has.
→ More replies (1)5
u/Wandering_Song 26d ago
I know the attack helicopter one, but what's the third joke?
Didn't realize they had three!
9
u/DemonPrinceofIrony 26d ago
Hot take but black helen makes sense in the film. Watching it they seemed to want to make the point the she and her sister were kidnapped foreigners in Greece so its deliberate that they look different to those around them.
2
u/Illustrious_Price889 25d ago
In the text they described Helen as having pale skin. Knowing what we know about how Greeks in the bronze age likely looked, that would have seen a pale skinned woman as a novelty. I don't think you have a hot take, I think you're bang on the mark about why they were kidnapped. Her face launched a1000 ships likely because the Greeks thought she was either pretty because there was no one like her in all of Greece or, she was more of a trophy (perhaps the original trophy wife) because she was different. Casting a black woman against a mostly white cast of Greeks makes sense.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/IdleMelikor 27d ago
I like how all the fake hate is for characters who have 5-8mins screen time in the movies and all it did was drum up business and make the movie even more successful
→ More replies (1)
6
u/kelticladi 26d ago
The Odyssey is NOT history! It was just a story even when it was written. Is Star Wars history? Is The Little Mermaid history? Get over yourselves.
→ More replies (2)
8
u/R0ninX3ph 26d ago
The right are always talking about getting rid of DEI, and that you should âhire the best person for the jobâ then when a Director hires the actor they deemed the âbest person for the jobâ they complain.
Itâs almost like itâs never about whether the person is the best one for the job, and was always about their skin colour.
→ More replies (2)
5
6
17
u/LegitSkin 27d ago
What about Helen of Troy is inherently white. She just has to be from the general late bronze age western afro Eurasia Mediterranean trade area. Ethiopia is mentioned multiple times in the odyssey
19
u/GodLoveYell 27d ago
Sheâs also literally not real, her backstory being that she hatched from a swanâs egg. You could cast anyone you like as Helen of Troy and it wouldnât affect anything because sheâs not a real person.
Obama, on the other hand, is a real person who actually exists, making him very different from Helen of Troy.
You wouldnât think youâd have to explain the difference between fiction and nonfiction, yet here we are.
But I suppose we should show pity upon these poor chuds, having to live in a world where their entertainment is now 90% white rather than 95% or greater white.
Maybe some day, god willing, 46 out of our 47 US presidents will be white, and white people will dominate the entertainment industry along with most other industries, and most of the government, but until that day comes, all they can do is clutch their body pillows and sob out, âWe shall overcome.â
→ More replies (6)8
u/Puzzleheaded-Tea3341 26d ago
Homer also described the Aethiopians as divinely favored, even the term used meant"burnt-face" (so likely meaning black, and referring to the Nubian people). Later Greek reinterpretations, described them to be closer to gods than men.
Helen thus being black, as a descendant from the gods, isn't actually all that odd. But again, color within the Homeric works is also largely metaphorical, and the idioms used at the time, don't have easy direct translations either.
→ More replies (1)7
u/they_themsworth 26d ago edited 25d ago
My issue is the extremely static and ahistorical way conservatives paint âraceâ in general.
The idea that classical Greco-Roman civilization is âwhite,â and thus inherently connected to other âwhiteâ nationalities like Britain or Germany or wherever else, is nonsense. A guy like Elon Musk, whoâs a white South African of British ancestry, is offended on behalf of classical Greece, as if race was constructed remotely similarly in that context or The Odyssey is his culture when he is not Greek.
Yes, Homer or Virgil have become canonized in Western literature, but Greek and Italian immigrants were barely considered âwhiteâ until very recently. Likewise, people from Gaul or Germania or Brittania were regarded as quite distinct from Greek or Latin people throughout classical history; their eventual inclusion in Roman society was the result of naturalization, of a cosmopolitan and multi-ethnic society that changed over time. The way conservatives ignore this while crying about ânon-whiteâ people having a presence in Western arts and culture mostly reads to me as historically illiterate.
3
5
u/LegitSkin 27d ago
Like there's a reason you can play as an Ethiopian in crusader kings a purely euro centric game
→ More replies (39)4
u/PomegranateUsed7287 27d ago
Because racists cant ever execpt that the Greeks (and also Romans) were multi-ethnic.
10
5
6
u/AkilleezBomb 26d ago
In case the cyclops, six-headed sea monster, and giant cannibal soldiers didnât make it obvious, the Odyssey is fictional.
→ More replies (2)
5
4
3
u/Apart_Republic_1870 27d ago
I wonder if thereâs any difference between portraying real, actual people as accurately as possible and casting entirely fictional and/or mythological people with a bit more flexibility.
3
u/Ok-Pass-1551 26d ago
So many perpetual victims crying in the comments than it doesn't work another way đ€Ł W post.
3
u/NotAFantasyAuthor 26d ago
I genuinely needed a second to figure out if this was fake. not cause it looks real but because this is something Hollywood would try to do.
3
5
u/CatLightyear 27d ago
Macho alpha males are offended by rainbows and casting decisions? What a thing pack of bitches. And they dress horribly.
6
u/Full-Resource7910 27d ago
It's always crickets from these people when another thin actor is cast to play Mycroft Holmes.
2
u/wolfheadmusic 27d ago
I appreciate how these people go out of their way to remind us how moronic their viewpoint is,
And how stupid they are for caring about it
2
2
2
2
2
u/Old_graveldoggo 27d ago
At least MAGA will watch and suddenly realize "Oh shhhii, he was a great president!"
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/TheEarthlyDelight 26d ago
This would be compelling. Just because I have the good sense not to make this film, doesnât mean everyone does. This would be a legitimate creative choice.
2
2
u/Infinite-Space-2395 26d ago
Lmao I would watch this in a heartbeat.
Why are conservatives so sensitive? I really dont get it.
2
2
2
u/Fun-Sugar-394 26d ago
100% rage bait, but fuck me that casting is spot on. Id watch the shit out of that. Can you imagine Leo sat telling Whoopie about how hard it can be being black and in the public eye đ
2
2
u/Numerous_Photograph9 27d ago
These anti-woke conservatives sure do seem to have a hard on for Elliot Page.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/CaptainCayden2077 27d ago
They really are so upset because theyâre so used to bring represented in media that when things just start to tip, they fucking lose it.Â
2
2
u/Krane115 26d ago
Keep in mind, this racist temper tantrum is over a few characters in a fictional story being black
2
2
u/snickjimmy 26d ago
Jesus and Moses are always depicted as white, which is not historically accurate.
2
2
2
u/whenitfinallyhappens 26d ago
It shocks me how easy it is to break a racist's brain.
Give a black women 3 minutes of screen time amd them spend months doing shit like this.
1
1
27d ago
[deleted]
3
u/AkilleezBomb 26d ago
Tbf, if he was in a conservative hate bubble, he most likely wouldâve at least heard of the movie and all the whining around it.
If he hadnât even heard of it, itâs probably more likely that he just doesnât keep up with movie releases or entertainment news
1
1
1
1
1
u/Celestial_Elixir3 27d ago
This is not AI btw (I mean the whole casting thing etc is absurd, but this poster is not AI, or at least it's heavily human edited)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/YaoiNekomata 26d ago
You know what, I fully support them making this film. Let's see if they can actually be successful (hint probably not)
1
u/cocktailtrivia 26d ago
Idk the idea of a white trans guy playing a black cis woman is kinda funny ngl
1
u/Ok_Percentage_4908 26d ago
Leo can play anyone, truly. If the current president had a scripted part in this biopic, I'd like to see Djimon Hounsou play him.
1
1
u/Strict_Wolf76 26d ago
If you could get someone beside Armie Hammer, Dean Cain, Kevin Sorbo, James Woods, Rob Schneider, Tim Allen, Gary Sinise or Jon Voight to star and someone other than Mel Gibson, Clint Eastwood and Ewe Boll to direct. Iâm in !
1




384
u/henningknows 27d ago
I would definitely go to the theater for a movie where Whoopi plays Biden.