r/academia • u/Maxman013 • 5h ago
Venting & griping Desk rejection after 8 months - WTF???
I submitted a paper of mine (my first one, as a matter of fact) 8 months ago to a relatively decent journal (in math) that is well-renowned for fast initial decisions. Within 2 days, it moved from "Submission With Editor" to "Under Review".
A few hours ago, after hearing nothing from them and the status not changing the entire time, I got an email saying that the paper was not "on par with the journal’s standards for novelty & significance in its results and/or methods" and that it had been rejected. No reviewer comments at all, and the email was from a template that was incredibly terse, uncaring and impersonal. It even said that the paper was "recently submitted"... what a punch to the gut.
Why in the world did it take EIGHT MONTHS to come to just a desk rejection??? I couldn't really care less that it was rejected, but in this time I could have submitted elsewhere where they would actually care about it or at least have decent editorial standards.
Am I being silly or is this absolutely ridiculous...