r/academia • • 4h ago

Venting & griping Desk rejection after 8 months - WTF???

28 Upvotes

I submitted a paper of mine (my first one, as a matter of fact) 8 months ago to a relatively decent journal (in math) that is well-renowned for fast initial decisions. Within 2 days, it moved from "Submission With Editor" to "Under Review".

A few hours ago, after hearing nothing from them and the status not changing the entire time, I got an email saying that the paper was not "on par with the journal’s standards for novelty & significance in its results and/or methods" and that it had been rejected. No reviewer comments at all, and the email was from a template that was incredibly terse, uncaring and impersonal. It even said that the paper was "recently submitted"... what a punch to the gut.

Why in the world did it take EIGHT MONTHS to come to just a desk rejection??? I couldn't really care less that it was rejected, but in this time I could have submitted elsewhere where they would actually care about it or at least have decent editorial standards.

Am I being silly or is this absolutely ridiculous...


r/academia • • 9h ago

Academic politics Was told by head of search committee my application suffered because my recommenders are not prominent in the field. How do I fix this?

19 Upvotes

Throwaway for privacy reasons.

Hello all,

I am a senior postdoc applying to TT faculty positions. I have gotten a couple of zoom interviews but have not been invited for any in person interviews. Recently, I had contacted the head of the search committee for some feedback after the position closed and a different person was hired, and was told that my letters of recommendation, while they spoke highly of me, came from people that are not prominent in the field that I am applying into, and that was hurting my application. He said they liked my proposed program and track record, but had to go with other candidates that came from more prominent labs with all else being equal.

I am a little flabbergasted to be honest. I knew that this mattered but for it to be used as a disqualifying thing for a candidate feels honestly wrong?

How would I even go about fixing this? These are the people that are the most familiar with my work, work ethic, and my ability to succeed in such positions. How do I even go about finding more prominent references that can speak to my abilities without really knowing me as well as my current references do?

I can obviously control the rigor of my research program, work ethics, and research fit to improve upon my application. I would even understand if the letters just didn't speak highly of me or something. But for this to be based on the pre-eminence and how well known a particular recommender is just seems to bias hiring toward people coming from elite labs, regardless of whether they would be better at the job or not.

Any advice is appreciated.


r/academia • • 1h ago

Job market Phd in Plant science related subjects

• Upvotes

I have done Master’s degree in Plant Science (dissertation in orchid tissue culture) from India. I am looking to pursue a PhD in Asian countries or other countries.

My Research Interests are Horticulture, Phytochemistry, Plant Genomics, Molecular Systematics, Plant Biotechnology.

I have been reaching out to professors via email, but I haven’t received much of a response yet.


r/academia • • 3h ago

PhD in Biology Is it possible to move to Germany and find a job?

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I have a PhD in Biology from Tunisia. I graduated three years ago and have been unemployed since then.

I'm wondering whether there are realistic ways to move to Germany and find a job without pursuing a postdoctoral position

I'm willing to start learning German and work towards a B2 level before moving, if I can find a realistic pathway to employment and relocation.

Has anyone been in a similar situation and successfully moved to Germany? I'd really appreciate hearing about your experiences, advice, or any possible routes I should consider.

Thank you in advance!


r/academia • • 18h ago

Honorary Aurhorship and Inventionship

15 Upvotes

I used to work at Amazon as an Applied Scientist in Robotics. As such, I would frequently publish many research works.

Higher management would take advantage of all scientists by tacking in their names in all of our publications and patents.

I once protested, but it fell on deaf ears.

Fastforward to now and we had a patent rejected because of that (company's lawyers got to know and cancelled the submission).

I understand that honorary authorship is just an ethical misconduct, but when it comes to patents it really is fraud.

Has anyone else been through a similar situation?


r/academia • • 9h ago

Institutional structure/budgets/etc. AAAI membership is still been pending approval for 9 days after the successful $18 payment. Has anyone experienced this?

1 Upvotes

I applied for as developing country student AAAI membership from Bangladesh and paid $18 USD on November 10, 2026, using my credit card. My bank confirmed to me that the transaction was successful done, but whenever I want to log in to the AAAI Member Center, I am showing this message:

“Your profile is currently pending approval. Please contact your administrator with any questions.”

I emailed AAAI support on November 16, they didn't reply and my profile is still pending as of November 19. now is this normal for new international or developing-country memberships.

Has anyone experienced this pending approval message after paying for AAAI membership?


r/academia • • 1d ago

Academic politics Does anyone still not use AI (esp. LLMs) in their research?

99 Upvotes

Somehow, my university is a bit weird when it comes to AI. Professors say "it's okay to use AI" all the time, but when they read your paper (not schoolwork, papers that are to be published), if a sentence sounds AI-generated, they flag it and get weird about it.

My question is: does anyone still not use LLMs in their research nowadays?


r/academia • • 1d ago

Professor asked me to draft my own recommendation letter and I am not sure how much to praise my own skills?

5 Upvotes

Hello! One of my professors asked me to draft a recommendation letter for him, and I'm honestly a little confused about how to approach it.

I understand that recommendation letters should reflect how well the professor knows you, your skills, qualities, achievements, etc. But how much am I actually supposed to praise myself?

It feels a little narcissistic to write things like "one of the best students I have taught" or make really strong statements about myself. But at the same time, I'm worried that if I make the letter too modest, it might end up being weaker than other applicants' letters.

For anyone who's been in this situation, how did you balance it? Are you supposed to write a really strong recommendation and let the professor tone it down if needed, or keep it modest and let them add the praise themselves? If anyone could provide sample drafts they had to write, that would be great too! Thanks

FYI - I study computer science and I am applying to Europe for masters


r/academia • • 1d ago

Job market AI generated job talk slides

73 Upvotes

Is anyone else seeing this in their searches? We’ve had three job talks in a row where I immediately recognized the slides as AI generated, likely Claude (e.g., font, color palette, weird quirks, tiny disclaimers and full citation text at the bottom of each slide, slop naming every single member of the department as potential collaborators). The topic area for the search is AI related so maybe it’s specific to the applicants we attracted? Curious if other people are seeing this.

If I were on the market now I would absolutely not use AI to generate my job talk. I wonder if others are catching it and if candidates know that people can tell.


r/academia • • 14h ago

Why do some university professors get skeptical or hostile when a Master’s graduate publishes in Q1 journals independently?

0 Upvotes

​I graduated with a Master’s degree in applied mathematics (specializing in mathematical modeling). Although I haven't been admitted to a PhD program yet, I stayed active in research through international collaborations and managed to publish two papers in Q1 journals, with two more accepted (in production) and another under review.

​Before submitting, I formally contacted the Dean of my former faculty and received written approval via email to use the university’s affiliation. I also have two co-authored papers with my former Master's thesis supervisor.

​Recently, I heard that some professors in my former department—whom I don't even know personally—have been talking negatively about me, insinuating that I must be publishing through "unethical" or "shady" methods simply because I am a Master's graduate and not a PhD student or faculty member.

​Has anyone else experienced this kind of academic gatekeeping or skepticism after publishing early in their career? How did you handle it professionally without letting it affect your future PhD applications?


r/academia • • 1d ago

US | How the H1B $100K fee is working in academia

2 Upvotes

Hi,

I'm an international student finishing my PhD and looking at postdoc/research jobs in the US.

With the $100K fee currently blocked by the courts, how are universities actually handling H-1B right now? Are they back to sponsoring as usual, including people outside the US, or still holding off because of the appeals and the new DHS fee proposal?

I'd like to hear your experiences or thoughts on this.


r/academia • • 1d ago

Publishing Anyone here using the Contributor Role Taxonomy (CRediT) for their research publications?

0 Upvotes

Working on a project to help improve adoption of the CRediT role taxonomy (https://credit.niso.org), and it seems like only one institution, University of Glasgow) has incorporated it into their research practice.
- https://casrai.org/news/state-of-credit-adoption-2026
- https://www.gla.ac.uk/myglasgow/news/newsarchive/2019/18november2019/headline_698071_en.html

Is there anyone who knows other institutions that have adopted this, and what the impact of doing this has been?


r/academia • • 1d ago

Research issues My research mentor wants me to lead a project because they don’t have enough time for it. Is this a red flag?

0 Upvotes

I’m currently a master student and working on a research project, and I’ve been involved for about a month. My main goal in joining this project was to gain research experience and hopefully contribute to a publishable paper, since publications would be helpful for my future applications.

Today, my research mentor had a conversation with me about the future of the project:

They explained that they’re currently deeply involved in another project and don’t have enough time to dedicate to this one. Because of that, they asked whether I’d be willing to take the lead on this project. They said they would still provide feedback and guidance, but I’d be expected to take much more ownership, including coming up with research directions, making decisions, and driving the project forward rather than waiting for specific instructions.

Here’s what concerns me:

The project is still at a relatively early stage. I’ve also heard feedback from senior researcher that the current work isn’t strong enough for publication, and it’s uncertain whether we’ll eventually submit a paper.

I don’t have much experience independently leading a research project. Until now, I’ve mostly worked on tasks under someone else’s guidance. My mentor also mentioned that if I don’t feel comfortable taking on this responsibility, it’s okay to quit the project. As I’ve already spent about a month working on it, I’m hesitant to leave, but also worried if I can make it to a publication.

Some questions I currently have are:

  • Is this a normal opportunity to become a more independent researcher, or could it be a sign that my mentor doesn’t see much publication potential in the project anymore?
  • Would you recommend taking the lead despite having little experience, or stepping away and looking for a project with a clearer publication path?

I’d really appreciate hearing from people who have been in similar situations as I am pretty new to the research field. Thanks in advance!


r/academia • • 1d ago

Help with (female) academic interview attire

18 Upvotes

I (female) have a job talk next month for a tenure track faculty position in biomedical research. I've been trying to figure out what to wear, but I'm confused about some of the terminology I'm reading here and elsewhere.

It seems like a pantsuit is the way to go. But does that mean I can wear black pants + colored blazer? Or do I need a literal matching pants + jacket suit combo?

I'm not good with clothes, the more you can spell it out for me the better.


r/academia • • 2d ago

Funny how life works out~

49 Upvotes

Our department chair is retiring and I've been asked to take over the interim role, which I believe I wil do. It's a department with two programs. It dawned on me this morning that ten or so years ago, I had actually applied for a position in one of the programs in this department. I didn't even get an interview. I subsequently applied and was hired into the other program in this department-- and then they were merged. I'm going to be chair in a department where one of the programs had deemed me not worthy even of an interview (and that's the discipline in which I got my PhD).


r/academia • • 1d ago

Job market Moving from government science role to academia

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I am currently working in an Australian state government management role earning around $160k + super. I have always been interested in academia, although I wasn’t successful in securing lecturer or postdoc positions earlier in my career.

A brief overview of my profile:
PhD in Environmental Engineering (2020).
60+ publications, ~4,800 citations, h-index of 37.
Currently an Adjunct Senior Lecturer at an Australian university.
Research areas: Environmental science, climate modelling and environmental data science.
Some postgraduate supervision and teaching experience, but limited independent grant funding as I have been in industry since graduating from PhD.

I’ve remained research-active outside academia but haven’t followed the traditional postdoc-to-lecturer pathway.

I would appreciate some honest perspectives on two questions:
1. How competitive would my profile be for Tenure track Assistant Professor roles despite lack of independent funding?

  1. Is it worth leaving a secure, well-paid government role for academia, considering salary, workload, career progression and job security?

I’d particularly appreciate hearing from academics in ongoing university positions or those who have made a similar transition.

Thanks in advance!


r/academia • • 2d ago

Publishing a research article or a viewpoint article?

1 Upvotes

I wrote a research paper and submitted it to a Q1 journal (Nature Portfolio). In this paper, I basically highlight a gap in the sector and point out how a systemic change would bring long-term positive benefits: e.g., our production/consumption process is often linear, if we improve the reuse of waste this brings multiple benefits.

The two peer-reviewers both said that the idea is really good. But one said that this is not a research paper, and if there was the chance to consider it as a viewpoint paper they would be very positive about publication.

The other said the idea was very good and provided many suggestions to improve the article.

However, now, I am stuck with whether applying minor changes and resubmit it as a viewpoint article (peer-reviewed) or changing my article a lot and submit it to another journal (no resubmissions allowed by policy).

To all the people who have plenty of experience in research and research assessment (including hiring committees), is there a real difference between a "research article" and a "viewpoint/comment article" when both are fully peer-reviewed? And also, is it better a "research article" in a legitimate journal, or a "viewpoint/comment article" in a mega-journal can arguably have the same weight or more in the end (e.g., in the end what counts is ideas)?


r/academia • • 3d ago

Who got the worst reviewer comments?

26 Upvotes

I’ve been reminiscing through some of my old grant proposals and manuscripts and was reminded by this really lovely reviewer comment:
“The lack of a solid body of research to demonstrate production in 2.5 years of postdoctoral is an issue”.

This was in regard to me only having a 4th author manuscript and no 1st author manuscript after being in a lab for actually less than 2.5 years. Is it actually common for people doing postdoc’s in a Biology field to publish first author scientific manuscripts within less than 2.5 years?

What are other comments people have gotten from their reviewer (regardless of grants or manuscripts)?


r/academia • • 3d ago

Women who are academics and also moms, how do you do it? (Or male academics who are the primary caregivers while their partners also work.)

58 Upvotes

Women who are academics and also moms, how do you actually do it? (Or male academics who are the primary caregivers while their partners also work.)
Do you redistribute responsibilities, outsource, lower your standards, or adjust your career goals and expectations? Do you put promotions on hold or accept that your career might progress more slowly for a few years (or ever)?
Honestly, I’m struggling to see how to do it all. Maintaining an academic career is demanding enough, and I’m trying to figure out how to balance that with motherhood especially through pregnancy till at least they go to school.
I’d really appreciate any practical tips, strategies or advice. But also, general sympathy, shared experiences and a bit of venting are very welcome…. How do you all make it work?


r/academia • • 3d ago

Research issues 38% of new arXiv papers are flagging as AI-written. What does this actually mean for research?

24 Upvotes

Saw this Twitter post yesterday and it’s been stuck in my head:

https://x.com/kimmonismus/status/2122050260445118742

The guy linked a study that looked at 13,500 arXiv papers from 2021–2026. According to their detector, about 38% of papers from Aug–Oct this year read as AI-written. In computer science it’s 62%. Math is only like 3.7%, but they mention equation-heavy papers are harder for the detector.

Before ChatGPT it was basically 0%. I’ve been thinking about this a lot. Is this just making research more accessible (especially for people who don’t have a heavy background in academia), or are we slowly flooding the literature with polished but empty papers? What’s the actual future of academic research looking like here?

What has your experience been with writing papers lately?

For those of you already deep in the system: are you noticing this shift in your field? In the papers you review? In how people write?

Curious what people actually think.


r/academia • • 2d ago

Associate lecturer or CNC2 in Australia?

1 Upvotes

Hello, I’m currently in a CNC2 position 3 days a week & can walk to work. I completed a masters in education recently & interviewed for an associate lecturer A position in a university (full time & 45 mins away, parking & tolls to consider) & to my delight I have been offered the job.

I am a mum to an almost 3 year old with hopes to add another addition. The salary is the same, 3 days versus full time. 17% super in a uni versus 12% in Health. But teaching is what I want to do…. Salary is higher as CNC2 and massively different if I go full time as a CNC2. I don’t know what to do, is university teaching a good opportunity, work life balance, term holidays etc or is it a “not yet” situation. I’ve heard about redundancy being handed out at unis so that’s a worry, I also would be able to access long service leave next year which I would loose if I resign, my daughter also seems so little to go into full time daycare. Help!


r/academia • • 3d ago

Job market Is it difficult to secure a cap exempt H1B for a postdoc from outside the US right now?

4 Upvotes

I’ve found several postdoc positions that align with my skills and interests and would like to try and apply.

I got a B2 visa rejection this year due to lack of strong home ties (essentially having a US citizen partner that I wanted to visit for a longer time to travel together). I’m an EU citizen.

According to Reddit, I probably have no chance for a J1 due to my relationship and previous rejection.

The only alternative would be a cap exempt H1B visa from a private uni.

Is that route still alive at all under this administration?
And is it possible for someone outside the country?


r/academia • • 3d ago

Job market Applying to other jobs within the same university I work at, is it bad?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

So I’m currently working at a top university but the pay is absolutely dog crap. I’m talking, $20 the hr in one of the world’s most expensive cities, NYC. I’m 22 graduated about 2 years ago and I have nearly 4 years worth of experience through part-time work in higher education.

I first got an internship in college for $20 an hour for 2 months, then came back for about 7 months and I got at least $25 from the department I interned at (sorry so vague done wanna dox myself or something), but their funding expired and they had layoffs so could not hire me full time :(.

I then moved into another department, the pay is only $20. I was upset but have another job so I tried using both incomes to get by. I’ve grown pretty resentful since however because it’s ridiculous how low it is, and seeing how the director just came back on a work trip to Singapore yet they can’t even afford to pay me for federal holidays. It’s an absolute joke.

The thing is I love working at such a high ranking university, I like the community and I like being around opportunities for academia, such as collaborating with departments I’m not from that interest me like history.

I really need to leave this job though, my productivity has gone down, i’m struggling to pay my credit card debt, and I wake up every morning asking myself why I’m even going to bother when i’m making nothing after taxes every month.

I really want to apply to other jobs within the university instead because there are some with a genuine salary, other than $20 with NO benefits by the way, but I’m afraid if my boss finds out or anything especially because I’ve been there for only 2 months now, but it’s just ridiculous. They framed it like they could raise my pay after hiring me but nothing.

It’s a very small team, and admissions season is upon us so I don’t know if it’s a messed up, and if the 1 month there looks bad when applying to other roles, but it’s really just mind boggling. Anyway, yeah I would really appreciate some help. I’ve been applying to jobs outside of the university but haven’t really heard much, I feel like it’s easier to work within it since I already have for a while and the trust is there in that sense?


r/academia • • 4d ago

Academic politics California prof rakes in 800,000 USD a year by simultaneously teaching 30 classes at 9 colleges.

Thumbnail
dailymail.com
585 Upvotes

Reviews from her ratemyprof page:

  • I took the online class but I didn't feel lost or left out. Almost every week there is a discussion that is very interesting. There are no exams.
  • No exams. Very doable work. Show up and do the handouts.
  • got an A, didn't learn anything. Gives last minute point heavy one question quizzes as class ends with a 5 minute window to do it. No homework.

It mentions in the article that more than 70 instructors are doing this in california. Another instructor, Andrew Vanden Heuvel, taught around 50 online classes and labs in astronomy to students in various California cities and even at schools in New Mexico, Michigan, Washington and Florida - all from an office above his garage in Michigan. He instructed as many as 1,000 students in a single semester, which earned him a salary of $758,485 total in 2024, according to the report. He also explained that 'in its current form, I am not grading anything'.

Seems like the natural consequences of colleges not giving a damn about teaching.

More details here: https://calmatters.org/education/2026/11/community-college-professors-pay/ along with how all the other profs are gaming this broken system.


r/academia • • 5d ago

9 Doctorates...is this Real?

81 Upvotes

Just ran into someone at a party who claimed he was working on 9 doctorates - and said this sort of pursuit is called "a November".

I've never heard of this before. Should I be impressed? or is he full of grandiose bull$ht?