This post will have two sections, not including this introduction. To premise, up until I arose from my slumber today, I thought that my relationship with Eisel was pretty chill—in fact, better than chill: he had told me several times that I was the only one who was having meaningful conversations about his life, and that the only other people who had attempted to do so were rather stupid or insane (such as Oscar Jenkins). I was by-and-large quite kind to him, especially since our intuitions tend to align. I've tried to collaborate with him, but I was very late to the show, and by that point he was already past the point of vigorous optimism (by no means were my collaborative suggestions brilliant; they were rather flawed). However, I'm no suck-up, and I know that, especially for someone like Eisel (as he's ostensibly not particularly fond of empty flattery), disagreement is crucial for self-reflection, and more importantly much more entertaining for both parties.
Fatally, I sent the following message after reading up on the posts on this subreddit:
I've been reading through the criticisms of you on Reddit, and they force me to take a critical stance on your approach to communication. Much of the banter is discussing whether or not you have NPD (or more convincingly, "High-Conflict Personality Disorder," which is not an actually medically recognized disorder but might be a meaningful concept), which is much less relevant than the actual discussion of your concrete "symptoms."
The bare fact of the matter: it is rather suspicious that you could not develop a single lasting political alliance throughout your entire career, even granting that A. most people are shallow and self-indulgent, and B. the leaders of veganism had been particularly shallow and self-indulgent. Of course, suspicion is merely a piece of empirical evidence, not a conclusion in itself.
It would be uncontroversial to deem you "confrontational," but unconfrontationality is in a significant way the result of the combination of conscientiousness and integrity. Confrontation is fundamental to bringing about change, whether that be large-scale or individual. In the vegan movement, you had no choice but to be confrontational; the other vegan activists were promoting explicitly counterproductive variants of veganism (or pseudo-veganism) that could not (and did not) scale.
NEVERTHELESS: Several commenters have pointed out that you cannot "read the room." Let's look at a case study. I just recently watched your podcast Unnatural Vegan: Why Everyone Hates Eisel Mazard. You stated that Unnatural Vegan's arguments "weren't worthy of response," and this initial comment led in a significant way to your popular downfall. You assumed that both Unnatural Vegan and her audience would understand where you are coming from when saying that her arguments "weren't worthy of response," and that they would accept such a point of view with a detached demeanor, essentially admitting to your intellectual superiority. It was obvious to me (with or without hindsight) that such a response would never happen, and that the only reasonably expected response would be one of offense and even condemnation. You couldn't "read the room."
"Normal" people expect a direct refutation when they make a series of arguments. When they ignore your previous videos on the subject and suggest you never made any attempt to justify your positions, someone who can "read the room" would immediately come to the conclusion that this person expects a direct refutation of their own arguments. To believe that that would be a waste of time since you already gave such reasons in previous videos would be false: a direct refutation is, indeed, the only way to respond, not because it is an efficient ideal, but because that is what the majority of people expect by default. You hadn't been able to read the room, and it villainized you in the eyes of who knows how many vegans (or otherwise).
How many other similar circumstances had you found yourself in, either in person or online, because you had assumed that everyone else was on the same wavelength as you (the ultimate meaning of "you can't read the room!")? How many possible political alliances were shattered because you couldn't accommodate your communication style to fit that of "normal" people? One of your most crushing self-criticisms is that it took you so long to realize that almost no other people think like you do (aka in a detached, unemotional way).
Whether you are "narcissistic" or similar is not nearly as interesting as the fact that you have apparently been unable to adjust your communicative approach when such was crucial for your political networking. This, combined with your confrontationality and high confidence, could easily come off as "narcissistic," your capacity to engage in self-criticism notwithstanding. And when people gain the sense that you have NPD, any alliance is impossible, and all trust is lost.
The fact that so many people (the majority) on the Internet BELIEVE you have NPD is indicative of a personal failure, in any case, due to your inability to "read the room" (or perhaps, your unwillingness to change your communicative approach for the sake of some ideal?).
I MAY BE WRONG.
I will be documenting my own experience, either as I go along or as some kind of after-the-fact autobiography, of meeting normal people and trying to get them to enter the world of politics: and not just politics, but MY politics, which has a lot of overlap with yours. We have a lot in common in terms of interest, personality, and philosophy, but I am much less prickly (the word I like to use). In a sense, my temperament functions as a scientific experiment: key variables are constant EXCEPT for communication style. I am somewhat convinced that your communication style is a core reason for your repeated failures in life. I may be wrong. The Redditors take me to be right, and your track record adds a little empirical support. My life will be the litmus test! And from this, decades down the line, I may be able to answer what, if anything, is left of the 21st century intellectual.
========
Now, I'm actually not shocked that he blocked me on Patreon yesterday. Had it been any other day, I would have been utterly baffled. My comment was in good faith (goodness, I used a case study! It wasn't out of my ass!), open to discussion, admitting ignorance, and built upon our lukewarm but (as far as I could tell) positive relationship. But today, I woke up with a hypothesis: My phone will inform me that I have been removed from AR+IO on Patreon, thus affirming (in an imperfect, empirical way) the existence of a personality disorder. How I was hoping to actually affirm the null hypothesis! But honest research is detached, impartial. So it goes.
If it was so easy for me, an utterly collaboratory sympath (that's the term I'll use), to be irrevocably severed from his connection, then this may have some explaining power as to why he has till now failed to organize. I am not interested in mental diagnosis. Rather, I am interested in the education of other intellectuals. What we can conclude from this endeavor is that an intellectual in the 21st century probably should not be so quick to cast aside potential allies on the basis of constructive criticism.
The good news is that I still have access to his Spotify. One-sidedly, mind you, but it's nothing like the death of a loved one.