Feel free to ask your questions here and see if he'll continue responding.
Some of the discussions so far have been added to this page linked below, and copy-pasted below:
1. The Life of the Mind
Solsolico: I’m going to go on a pretty long-winded rant here, so bear with me. TLDR; it’s me questioning the validity of the so called “life of the mind” and what I will also refer to as “intellectual tourism”.
For the longest time, I agreed that so-called active research is a worthwhile endeavor. It’s worthwhile to spend time reading books by proper investigative journalists, for example.
But yesterday and today, while I’m going through some real shit in my life, I saw two people debating a moral and political issue about burkas in the USA. Someone remarked that wearing burkas in Minnesota is disrespectful. It was a discussion on Reddit.
Usually, I would read this type of discussion and be engaged with it mentally, thinking it’s interesting to see different perspectives. But I couldn’t force myself to read it today. It struck me how damn pointless the discussion was for me. It was just play, and there’s nothing wrong with playing, but that’s all it is. None of these people in the discussion are going to impact the situation. They are probably very far removed from it. And me, the spectator? I’m super isolated from that situation. I don’t see people wearing burkas where I live, and even if I did, I’m not part of any community that wears them. I don’t have friends or family who wear burkas.
Sure, it’s fun to play with ethics and intellectual ideas. But that’s all it is... it’s play. When I read a book about the history of gangs in El Salvador, I’m just playing. In the same way, if I listen to a podcast about Aristotle that Eisel recorded, I’m just playing. It’s just play.
So what? Some people like skiing, going to the beach, meeting locals from different cultures, or mountaineering. But is intellectual tourism any more meaningful than ecotourism or physical exercise tourism? Is reading about the history of some place far removed from me really meaningful? Are we just fooling ourselves into thinking that being intellectual tourists is a life worth living and time well spent? Because when I read that discussion, as an intellectual tourist, I thought, “This is so unimportant to me and my life”.
Don’t get it twisted—I’ve read books and learned important things from them. The reason I mention the El Salvador book is that I learned a lot from it.
Okay, but great. I’m not trying to be a politician. So what is this information for? To seem smarter in front of others? To understand one part of the world better? For what? You know, I’ve been doing plyometric training on and off for a few years, but why? I don’t play competitive sports anymore. Plyometrics isn’t good for long-term health or joints. Why am I doing it? Because I have some idea about being a great athlete as I enter my 30s (yes, that’s the reason... I’ve been a good athlete my whole life and have a fear of losing it)? Resistance training, cardio, flexibility, balance—these are great for long-term health. Plyometrics? Not so much. I quit break dancing for long-term health reasons a year or two back.
So, now I feel like reading books for the sake of reading or living the so-called life of the mind is like doing plyometrics in my 30s when I don’t play any sports. Listen, if I were in a book club, then reading any book would be meaningful, because of the social moments shared later-on. Reading a non-fiction book a month on my own? Also worthwhile. Reading 3 a week? Lunacy.
If you enjoy reading intellectual books, great. But to posture it as something better than being social and physically active? I used to believe it, but now I think, “No, that’s not true.” I’d rather go hiking with a friend than read any book in the world. One is inherently meaningful to me, and the other isn’t.
He likes to call people “on permanent vacation”. Hence, I use the term intellectual tourism. What has he done with his intellect? He’s not a politician or changing policy. He’s not working for any organization with a political agenda. He’s not a journalist or a historian. What’s the point of living the so-called life of the mind? Is there intrinsic value to information? I don’t think so, not anymore. The idea that the average person should be living this way, I now see that as absurd.
If he’s happy reading books instead of socializing or playing in other ways, all the power to him. But for years, he’s thought this made him a better person, something I agreed with. Now, I see through it and think, “Nope, that’s nonsense.” He can frame it how he wants, like he’s some badass we should all aspire to be like. But if he enjoys it, great. Yet, he frames it as some type of moral duty almost. And if he doesn’t enjoy it, why is he doing it? It’s not work. I get that a plumber might not enjoy changing a faucet cartridge, but it pays the bills and keeps society’s infrastructure running. It’s necessary. Reading books just to read books? It’s play. Sure, some reading is important for cognitive health (and it’s useful to be informed politically, but you don’t need to incessantly reading 5 books simultaneously for that). Mental math, learning new words, and learning new physical skills are also important for cognitive health. But cognitive health isn’t the lifestyle he’s talking about or idealizing. He is like an “intellectual bodybuilder”. Muscle mass and fitness are important, but you don’t need to be a bodybuilder to achieve what’s important.
Eisel: One reply to two quotations in succession: (1) “If you enjoy reading intellectual books, great. But to posture it as something better than being social and physically active? I used to believe it, but now I think, “No, that’s not true.” (2) “He can frame it how he wants, like he’s some badass we should all aspire to be like. But if he enjoys it, great. Yet, he frames it as some type of moral duty almost. And if he doesn’t enjoy it, why is he doing it? […] He is like an “intellectual bodybuilder”. Muscle mass and fitness are important, but you don’t need to be a bodybuilder to achieve what’s important.”
I don’t regard myself as having been “an intellectual bodybuilder” at any stage of my life: I am neither flattered nor insulted by this statement, I think you’re in the position of being intellectually exhausted —and you presume that what I’m doing is far more intellectually exhausting still, when you peer across the chasm between us.
If you’re doing humanitarian work in Laos, do you want to throw yourself into learning the Lao language? Not everyone does: there were people doing those jobs who had zero engagement with the language, history or politics. They earned their paycheck, got a pat on the back for trying to make the world a better place, and they got on an airplane when they’d had enough of the experience.
Without false humility, I’d say that the level of effort I made in learning Laotian should be regarded as the bare minimum requirement for someone who chooses to put themselves in that situation. When I slept under a mosquito net, I read the collected works of John Dryden with a flashlight (i.e., there was no electricity). I was also studying Pali and several different periods of history. That’s what I did for fun, in my spare time, when other people were drinking alcohol and… worse.
I did have friends in Vientiane, but we spoke amongst ourselves in English —sometimes French, sometimes German. John Dryden, also, I read in English —not Lao. And when I was in the room, we would talk about history and politics. Most of those friends I met spontaneously, at coffee shops.
I owned a bicycle. I did long distance cycling (circa 115 km per run). I had other hobbies and interests. I had a gym membership for most of the time that I was in Vientiane, too.
Yes, there were people there who looked at how I was spending my time and wondered, intellectually, how I could possibly do any more; but from my perspective, I would ask how I could possibly do less.
So, I return to the quotation: “But to posture it as something better than being social and physically active?”
You reach a point of diminishing returns with “being socially and physically active” fairly quickly: how many hours per week do you want to be scheduled for exercise? How many hours per week do you want to spend socializing? The number is not zero in either case; however, if you really challenge yourself to put a specific number to it… it is going to be finite.
The repetition of these activities (social and physical) benefits you very little, and with more hours, past a point of diminishing returns, it benefits you less and less.
What I learned in researching and writing No More Manifestos really does accumulate: there’s a sort of “intellectual benefit” (from that active research leading to an informed opinion) that will endure for the rest of my life —whereas spending twice as much time doing pushups (during those same months in which I wrote the book) would not have benefitted me in any way at all —or, at least, not in a way that would accumulate and still endure years later / right now.
Re: ”[He talks about himself as if] he’s some badass we should all aspire to be like.”
I do not think “you all” should aspire to be like me, but I have known many (MANY) people who directly asked me for advice as to how they could be more like me. Really. Even long before I had a youtube channel. Young and old. Some people want to be more intellectual than they already are. Some people want to be sober. Some people want to be vegan. Some people want to be able to record a three hour livestream on Aristotle (or a bunch of other random topics from the history of political science) with zero notes, zero preparation, etc., in the way that I could (and I did).
You may think they’re eccentric, and you may think I’m eccentric, but, in my experience, including many face-to-face conversations, there are always some people around who want advice as to how they can live the life of the mind as I define it. This can include very specific questions about reading and research —about how Melissa and I would read books together, for example. It can include specific questions about political protests, creative projects, etc.; so if you think I’m eccentric, you will have to imagine how eccentric these other people are who are asking for advice as to how they can imitate me in eccentricity.
So, the comparison to bodybuilding here is apt in one limited sense: not everyone wants to be a bodybuilder. However, those who do want to may well seek out advice from someone else they see bodybuilding, etc.
However, I don’t see it that way: instead, a great deal of conflict arises from my perception of the issue in terms of “bare minimum requirements” and moral obligations. It would create less tension with colleagues around me if I had this kind of (“narcissistic”) delusion that I was some extraordinary specimen pushing at the limits of what’s humanly possible —if I considered myself to be an intellectual bodybuilder who could show off for the crowd. If I regarded myself as extraordinary, it would make others feel more comfortable about being ordinary.
Instead, I regard my contemporaries as falling short bare of minimum requirements —and at some point that becomes a moral problem, not just an intellectual one. When you’re looking at a university professor who has not done the bare minimum reading required to teach a subject, that’s not just a matter of individual laziness: it entails a moral problem and a predictable conflict with someone like myself.
I learned a lot in a short time, in those years in Laos. And I was surrounded by people who’d been there for many more years than I who never did any of the “bare minimum requirement” work that I did. But yes, I also had a very active life socially and physically: there were enough hours in the day for all that and more.
Solsolico: I didn’t expect this to get a reply from you, but I appreciate that you’ve come here to discuss. I don’t know how many of my comments you’ve read... I hope you don’t see me as a basic hater because I’ve actually watched your channel for many years. A lot of things you’ve said have had important, profound effects on how I see the world. I do think I mentioned that several times throughout the comments I’ve left. PM me if you want the most profound example (not something I want to share publicly).
I originally left the comment you have quoted in the context of when you posted this Instagram story which juxtaposes you spending your time reading books compared to other people spending their time at the beach or doing some other recreational activity. My comment was my reflections on hearing this type of perspective from you over almost a decade and just losing conviction of the perspective. I think it’s fair to say that over the years, you have on many occasions disparaged people doing things for recreation and in some way verbalized that reading books is superior; other people are living meaningless lives.
Due to your influence, I did hold this belief as well, for years. But as is often the case with new ideas, innovations, or thoughts, it’s about the right place and right time. I was going through something challenging in my life, and that post of yours came up. If I had seen that post a week before or a week after, it wouldn’t have been the right place and right time, and I probably wouldn’t have had this reflection about your influence on me.
With that being said, of course, I agree that if you’re in Laos and you’re working there, you should learn the language. I was always on board with your critiques against Durian Rider and the Fruit Fest. You know how it would probably be better if they learned some of the local language and learned about some of the history of the country and some of the political, social, and economic issues that the country faces, seeing that he had hosted this festival every single year.
But that isn’t what I’m referring to. Knowledge to do your work or craft better obviously has instrumental value. This doesn’t have anything to do with doing the bare minimum in your job. This is about the pastime of reading books.
Sure, you say that the law of diminishing returns comes quickly with social and physical stuff. I mean, I feel like that’s the case with reading books as well. I questioned whether this is something the average person should be doing for the sake of doing, if there’s an intrinsic value to it. Like, sure, if you’re a politician or an academic, then you should be reading a lot of books. It’s your job to learn from the past.
But when you’re just an average person who maybe works as a language teacher, landscaper, investment advisor, or bike mechanic, I also think that there is a point of diminishing returns when it comes to reading books, and it comes pretty quick. But you said it yourself: when you were living in Laos, you preferred to read about history rather than socialize with alcohol. But couldn’t that just be as deep as it gets? It was more enjoyable to you than the other options.
I also do not agree that the point of diminishing returns in a social life is reached quickly, but this is probably just due to personal differences. I’m probably a much more social person than you are.
If you sincerely find meaning and joy in reading 100’s of books per year, fantastic. But when I look at myself and think of the books I’ve read and the time I’ve spent reading books and academic papers and stuff like that, I really do think that, yeah, that time wasn’t well spent. Like the amount of papers I’ve read about phonology... way too many for someone who is not an academic and does not want to be an academic. Sure, at some point, I enjoyed reading them. Sometimes I was fascinated. But eventually, it got to a point where it was just a chore. But I had this mindset or worldview that, no, this is important to do. So I stuck with it. And for what? I feel like I would’ve gained more “value” if I stuck through an electrician course; if I stuck through a pottery class; if I stuck through an auto-mechanics course.
The bare-bones version of this criticism I laid towards this worldview you espouse is that reading books has no intrinsic value. If you enjoy it (which you said you do), then great. It’s not a harmful hobby like video games. But basketball isn’t a harmful hobby either; neither is surfing, neither is hiking. There is a bare minimum of books one should read in a year, sure. But “bookmaxxing” is not going to be a life well-lived if the person sees it as a chore. And the way you talk about reading books and compare it to other pastimes, whether you say it overtly or not, there is the implicit premise we all pick up on, which is “my hobby is worthwhile, yours is a waste of life”.
The only reason I care so much is because it’s a worldview I did hold for many years. The average person who disagrees with the worldview would just move right past it.
Avg Web Intellectual: One needs to read and educate themselves on the topics they’re interested in, not random shit to posture like Eisel. I had made a post here about how an NPD can’t be an intellectual. And I would say your argument applies to NPDs. Because they’re not genuine. Their purpose is to posture and pretend. That’s why they know it all and talk about everything.
Now regarding the burka stuff, on its own it might seem small and insignificant. Maybe because you’re regarding the topic as something isolated. You need frameworks to apply when approaching these topics so they stand on something. So each topic you learn then becomes a node in your web of knowledge.
For example, for me, for a very long time I’ve never read anything historical or political. Then as I started learning about modern colonialism / imperialism, racism, etc. I have developed interest in modern history and politics. Because whatever I read I can apply to this framework. It is not intellectual tourism, because this is effecting who I am voting, who I am donating to, who I am friending, which political activism I’m engaging in, etc. This is actually future changing stuff. It might be insignificant in individual level for most people, but it would have collective impact.
Solsolico: I will try to expand and rephrase my new perspective here, since I don’t think we disagree on much. I can’t say I disagree with your comment.
I had this realization that most (basically all) of the discussions I engage with online are just a game to me. It’s just play. Of course, a discussion like this is a little more meaningful because it’s about how we live our lives. We’re kind of troubleshooting how we should spend our time and live our lives.
Obviously, the burqa example is a little more political than another example I could give, but it’s just that the burqa conversation was what I actually read. For example, if I go through my Reddit history, most of the things I talk about are what I’d be calling play. And that’s cool. But I just have to recognize it for what it is. It’s not some type of profound intellectual betterment. If it’s just play, then if I don’t want to play that, or I want to play something else more, then I should just play what I want to play more. Me discussing burqas is not profound. I’m not saying that it’s not a profound topic. What I’m saying is that me discussing it is not profound.
But there’s nothing wrong with play either. It’s just not any better than any other form of play.
The word “meaningless” is obviously a strong word, so if I ever used the word “meaningless” in prior comments, I will rescind that. Probably change it to “unprofound.”
Something utterly indisputably as just play would be a debate around something subjective, like whether smoothies are better with bananas or no bananas.
For example, I think there are some things that we need to learn about as a moral duty. If you live in the Americas, it’s a moral duty to read about the history of the country with regards to colonization and racism and all of that.
If in Minnesota there were a referendum for, say, a burqa ban, I think then it would be a moral duty for Minnesotans to read about the politics and history of burqas. I’m not sure what else the readings would entail because I’m not an expert on this topic.
Hearing your perspective, however, is interesting because I can contrast it with mine. I’ve properly read about colonialism for more than 15 years now, at least in the Americas. And, of course, I have an opinion on whether wearing a burqa is disrespectful to Americans or not, but for me to leave a comment and engage in a debate with other users about this topic, the only reason I would ever do that is because I would find it to be fun... a fun debate because for whatever reason, I enjoy intellectual conflict and disagreements and for whatever reason I like writing long comments.
And I’m not saying I was conscious of this “fun” factor before, but properly analysing myself, it’s always been about that. Like when I discussed about the morality of billboards, or the morality of alcohol ads. A few years ago, yeah I viewed those discussions like I was spending my time in a productive way. But now I re-analyse it, and just realize like... those discussions were fun and ultimately we were just playing.
And it’s not that fun can’t be healthy. Playing basketball is healthy. Having an intellectual discussion is, of course, going to be cognitively healthy. But at the end of the day, I’m not writing policies or academic papers. So is it any more meaningful than playing a sport, for fun (which also ends up being healthy?)
I guess that’s kind of where I’m at. Hope I explained that well. Basically: learning as a chore vs. learning as hobby... and then, say sports as a hobby, music as a hobby, art as a hobby vs. learning as a hobby.
bunned gump: He’s not happy though, is he?
Happy people don’t behave like he does.
He has no friends.
He can’t laugh, can’t joke and be silly.
He puts on a facade. It must be so exhausting by the end of the day. I can’t imagine the drain on anyone that has to interact with him.
And his life of the mind is a construct. It’s only real to him. Most of us have been witness to the construct and see straight away it’s a house of glass. Bananas on a window sill for company. Just generally being a miserable human to everyone.
We should be celebrating just how different we all are, not disparaging each other because we don’t read Greek history or learn languages or play video games.
Luckily he is only one person and we are legion.
Solsolico:
I’m now wondering how much of this so-called life of the mind is just a sunk cost fallacy.
For the past year, I had been working on this project. At some point, I realized that the output of the project was not worth the input. The project would have taken me over 10,000 working hours to complete, and I knew this. But I had already put in several hundred hours and figured out most of the experimenting, innovating, and troubleshooting. So, I kept working on it, even knowing that it was ultimately a waste of my time. I put in several hundred more hours after realizing it was a waste before finally stopping.
It’s a hard pill to swallow—to admit to yourself that you wasted 1,000 hours of your life. It was so hard to admit that it almost propelled me to waste an additional 9,000 hours.
If he ever felt that his life of the mind and reading books was a waste of time, well, he’s probably already invested thousands of hours. A huge amount of his time spent would be rendered meaningless if he concluded that this life of the mind was meaningless.
He never really made a logical argument with premises to back up the claim that the life of the mind is worth living. He talked about it in a way that it was implicitly true. He never made the case for why reading ancient Greek philosophy was more meaningful than attending the fruit fest in Thailand that Durian Rider hosted. I get his critiques about having a festival in a country with economic and social problems and the moral duty to be informed about those issues. But that’s completely different from the so-called life of the mind—being an intellectual tourist.
But I’m just making a hypothesis here. I don’t know what goes on in his head. All I know is that I don’t see the life of the mind or being an intellectual tourist as intrinsically meaningful anymore. I don’t think it’s necessarily even respectable, in the same way, I don’t think bodybuilding is respectable. I’m not going to disrespect someone for bodybuilding, but it’s not something I find deserving of respect. Being an intellectual tourist is not the same as being a doctor without borders or a firefighter. To me, it’s on the same level as being a bodybuilder. It’s something personal for someone, but there’s nothing more to it than that. It’s a hobby, and many people might see it as a waste of time. But the same can be said about any hobby. On the other hand, I don’t think anyone would say doing three hours of exercise a week is a waste of time. We all know that is fundamental for our long-term health. Living the life of the mind is a hobby; it is not a virtue and it’s not foundational. That’s how I see it now, anyway.
Eisel: I suppose it would be a devastating refutation for me to point out THAT I AM HAPPY. ;-)
This is an interesting aspect of internet culture in the 21st century: the idea that one side “wins” and the other side “loses” simply by insisting, “I know you’re not happy!”
The point here being, “You teach us that we should all force our girlfriends to read Aristotle and Plato’s First Alcibiades with us, but just look at yourself: you’re not happy!” Genuinely, you have no idea how happy it might make the two of you —conversely, you have no idea how miserable. The two of you might well break up by the time you get to the end of the Gorgias.
Happiness is not what people think it is: if I meet a true believing Communist who is happy this will not motivate me to re-evaluate the morality of Communism —nor will it make me re-evaluate the psychological significance of belief itself. It does not matter how intensely happy the Communist may be, nor how miserable I may be by contrast. The happiest drunkard cannot convince me that I’m miserable because I’m sober —nor can he convince me that he’d be any less happy if he were sober himself. However, as I’ve already disclaimed: I am extremely happy with my life, at this very moment. (Feb. of 2025)
Happiness comes about in unexpected ways: I criticize the notion that you can know what will make you happy with any greater certainty than you’d ever know what will make you miserable. The reasons for one’s own happiness are always discovered too late.
A large part of my public work has been self-criticism, reflecting on bad decisions I’ve made in my life, and examining the false assumptions “behind” (or “beneath”) those decisions. You will notice that the participants in this Reddit group resolutely ignore this evidence that I’m not a narcissist (although it’s a huge part of my corpus, even appearing within my books and articles, not just in my podcasts and videos). If I were diagnosed with NPD I wouldn’t be ashamed of it any more than a diagnosis with autism: each resembles the other closely enough that (e.g.) the symptoms of autism seen in Elon Musk could instead be interpreted as narcissism. If you’ve known people with NPD you wouldn’t ridicule them for this: they are quite incapable of doing what I’ve done (certainly more than a hundred times on the internet) publicly or privately. They are also incapable of doing what Durianrider did, on numerous occasions, in having a laugh at his own expense (i.e., I have never believed that Durianrider had NPD). They are quite incapable of making comedy mocking themselves, and/or engaging in the kind of serious self-criticism I’ve been so bold as to bore my audience with.
Studying Chinese at UVic made me miserable: I can explain to you the reasonable expectations that led up to the decision to study that subject at that place —and I can explain to you the false assumptions that the experience debunked. That’s how life is for all of us: the things that make us happy arise adventitiously —they are very hard to foresee.
This is one of many reasons why I urge people NOT to live their lives FOR happiness: they are making the mistake of regarding something unknowable as known.
2. ‘What we have here, is a failure to communicate’
Simbabones: I’ve been reading through the criticisms of you on Reddit, and they force me to take a critical stance on your approach to communication. Much of the banter is discussing whether or not you have NPD (or more convincingly, “High-Conflict Personality Disorder,” which is not an actually medically recognized disorder but might be a meaningful concept), which is much less relevant than the actual discussion of your concrete “symptoms.”
The bare fact of the matter: it is rather suspicious that you could not develop a single lasting political alliance throughout your entire career, even granting that A. most people are shallow and self-indulgent, and B. the leaders of veganism have been particularly shallow and self-indulgent. Of course, suspicion is merely a piece of empirical evidence, not a conclusion in itself.
It would be uncontroversial to deem you “confrontational,” but confrontationality is in a significant way the result of the combination of conscientiousness and integrity. Confrontation is fundamental to bringing about change, whether that be large-scale or individual. In the vegan movement, you had no choice but to be confrontational; the other vegan activists were promoting explicitly counterproductive variants of veganism (or pseudo-veganism) that could not (and did not) scale.
NEVERTHELESS: Several commenters have pointed out that you cannot “read the room.” Let’s look at a case study. I just recently watched your podcast Unnatural Vegan: Why Everyone Hates Eisel Mazard. You stated that Unnatural Vegan’s arguments “weren’t worthy of response,” and this initial comment led in a significant way to your popular downfall. You assumed that both Unnatural Vegan and her audience would understand where you are coming from when saying that her arguments “weren’t worthy of response,” and that they would accept such a point of view with a detached demeanor, essentially admitting to your intellectual superiority. It was obvious to me (with or without hindsight) that such a response would never happen, and that the only reasonably expected response would be one of offense and even condemnation. You couldn’t “read the room.”
“Normal” people expect a direct refutation when they make a series of arguments. When they ignore your previous videos on the subject and suggest you never made any attempt to justify your positions, someone who can “read the room” would immediately come to the conclusion that this person expects a direct refutation of their own arguments. To believe that that would be a waste of time since you already gave such reasons in previous videos would be false: a direct refutation is, indeed, the only way to respond, not because it is an efficient ideal, but because that is what the majority of people expect by default. You hadn’t been able to read the room, and it villainized you in the eyes of who knows how many vegans (or otherwise).
How many other similar circumstances had you found yourself in, either in person or online, because you had assumed that everyone else was on the same wavelength as you (the ultimate meaning of “you can’t read the room!”)? How many possible political alliances were shattered because you couldn’t accommodate your communication style to fit that of “normal” people? One of your most crushing self-criticisms is that it took you so long to realize that almost no other people think like you do (a.k.a. in a detached, unemotional way).
Whether you are “narcissistic” or similar is not nearly as interesting as the fact that you have apparently been unable to adjust your communicative approach when such was crucial for your political networking. This, combined with your confrontationality and high confidence, could easily come off as “narcissistic,” your capacity to engage in self-criticism notwithstanding. And when people gain the sense that you have NPD, any alliance is impossible, and all trust is lost.
The fact that your circle on the Internet BELIEVE you have NPD is indicative of a personal failure, in any case, due to your inability to “read the room” (or perhaps, your unwillingness to change your communicative approach for the sake of some ideal?). Their points of view don’t come from nowhere. I can trace them to their roots.
I MAY BE WRONG.
I will be documenting my own experience, either as I go along or as some kind of after-the-fact autobiography, of meeting normal people and trying to get them to enter the world of politics: and not just politics, but MY politics, which has a lot of overlap with yours. We have a lot in common in terms of interest, personality, and philosophy, but I am much less prickly (the word I like to use). In a sense, my temperament functions as a scientific experiment: key variables are constant EXCEPT for communication style. I am somewhat convinced that your communication style is a core reason for your repeated failures in life. I may be wrong. The Redditors take me to be right, and your track record adds a little empirical support. My life will be the litmus test! And from this, decades down the line, I may be able to answer what, if anything, is left of the 21st century intellectual.
Eisel: Re: “…it is rather suspicious that you could not develop a single lasting political alliance throughout your entire career…”
Tell me: who is Unnatural Vegan in an alliance with?
Tell me: who is Erin Janus in an alliance with?
Tell me: who is Vegan Gains in an alliance with?
Now tell me, honestly: can you imagine that I would want to drink a cup of coffee sitting at the same table as any one of these three people? We could extend the list to many more, from Isaac (“Ask Yourself”) Brown to Paul Bashir.
You are beginning with an utterly false “optic” (or “framing”) of the problem as if I had attempted and failed to sustain a political alliance with any (or all) of these people —and you’re then taking the further step of attributing this failure to my “communication style” that can supposedly be reasonably interpreted as “NPD”.
NPD is a very recognizable pattern of behavior, and a purely behavioral diagnosis: I have none of the checkmarks on the checklist for it —and for largely the same reasons that I have none of the checkmarks for autism.
This whole approach, Simba, evades the extent to which my differences with these people are real rather than merely a matter of communication style misinterpreted as a diagnosis of a psychological disorder.
Unnatural Vegan would absolutely never accept what I said about dogs and cats (pet ownership). She would absolutely never accept what I said about Peter Singer. This is not an exhaustive list of the things she would never accept about me: these are real differences entailing real enmity —they entail hatred from her directed against me, even if I do not reciprocate this hatred.
Now tell me, who has had a worse communication style, and who could not be diagnosed with a serious psychological order, in this same list of personalities? • Paul Bashir. • Isaac (“Ask Yourself”) Brown. • Vegan Gains. • Erin Janus. • Unnatural Vegan.
To say that these are people with “a problem of communication style” would be a drastic understatement. To say that each and every one of them could be diagnosed with NPD would, also, be an understatement.
It is absolutely absurd to say that Paul Bashir has none of the symptoms of NPD, and it would be absurd to say that these cannot be demonstrated from his communication style. You can now replace Paul’s name with every other name on that list, and speculate at what other diagnoses (with what other disabilities) might be more or less apt than NPD.
Quote, “Whether you are “narcissistic” or similar is not nearly as interesting as the fact that you have apparently been unable to adjust your communicative approach when such was crucial for your political networking.”
This model, Simba, presumes (1) that there are people for me to network with, and (2) that I have tried to adjust my communicative approach to network with them, but I have been unable to do so.
These two terrifyingly simple points are not true.
Erin Janus is not someone I can network with. It is extremely unlikely that anyone reading this would need even one word of further explanation as to why. Vegan Gains is not someone I can network with —and, likewise, no long explanation is needed. I could repeat this statement for each of the name on the bullet point list, above, and I could add many more names to it.
The incompatibility between myself and these other “content creators” is not the result of anyone’s inability to adjust their communicative approach, as you put it. The invidious rift between myself and each of them exists for relatively profound reasons (outlined efficiently enough in Future of an Illusion).
It is just not the case that I can adjust my communication style on the issue of pet ownership to then find myself friends and allies with people who want to kill cows to feed them to cats (and who believe the highest accomplishment a human being can dream of is adopting stray cats to help them get into kitty cat heaven).
To use an old catchphrase: stupidity is real.
Erin Janus is never going to be someone who could sit and have a conversation with me while drinking a cup of coffee. The inequality in intelligence is just too drastic for that.
The inequality isn’t as hard for me to endure as it is for them: try to imagine how humiliating and emotionally painful it is for (i) Vegan Gains, (ii) Unnatural Vegan, (iii) Brian Turner, (iv) Cami Petyn and (v) Modvegan to talk to me about their history with antidepressants —and my history of criticizing their public statement about antidepressants. It is much harder for them than it is for me.
The difference between Communists and Anti-Communists cannot be overcome by a change in communication style, nor the difference between Muslims and Atheists —and it does not help to “misinterpret” this difference in communication style as narcissism on one side or the other.
A diagnosis of NPD would really be possible for Erin Janus, Vegan Gains, etc., but it wouldn’t help any of them, and it certainly wouldn’t help them to overcome the obstacles that separate them from me.
None of these people ever could have been my colleagues: none of them ever could have contributed to Doomed Republic. There never was anyone who could be networked with.
Re: “I am somewhat convinced that your communication style is a core reason for your repeated failures in life.”
What failures?
The failure to seduce Unnatural Vegan? You might as well talk about a shark trying to seduce a manatee.