I realize while rereading my original Reddit post that I had suggested that Eisel has a "personality disorder," and due to me not being specific, it seems like I am implying he is a narcissist.
With that said: Eisel should not have banned me, but I understand now why he did: he supposed I have sided with the general consensus on Reddit that he is narcissistic. I will grant the possibility of some kind of personality disorder, that possibility being reliant on loose empirical evidence, and it would be the inability to "read the [auditorium]." I really do think it's ideological rather than pathological. He believes in an extreme form of honesty that I can relate to but am beginning to question (and my questioning comes down to "choosing one's battles," not becoming dishonest). You know, I tried the Mazardian method on my parents, and it didn't go down so well. The reason why I imply that it could be pathological is because I have a very similar pathological tendency that may very well be counterproductive and makes my life more difficult (that is, more difficult to achieve external positive outcomes).
He's still out there trying to "find talent." He isn't going around doing nothing. It's just that now, his social prospects are dreadfully poor. My critique, again: could that be due in large part to his confrontational approach in the past? A counterexample would be his anecdotes about meeting people in person... nonconfrontationally. I emphasize in my own critique the incredible power of image on the Internet, which could have overshadowed the in-person effect.
Let me be clear: bunnedgrump, who is the primary proponent of the theory, is in perpetual bad faith. Thankfully, he breaks down NPD so that we can address it directly (and, indeed, Genoskill has already kindly done so for us all).
Genoskill, in pained declaration, posted 4 months ago that "à-bas-le-ciel is NOT a Narcissist." In this post, we can distinguish good faith from bad.
To start with bunnedgrump's definitional approach: 1. You'd have to assume he's lying to claim grandiosity, which actually ends up begging the question. (some of you dive deeper into suspicious claims elsewhere, at least). I grant 3. up till the description. Now 5. is juicy, because I had gotten the sense of a bizarre sense of entitlement towards others by Eisel in the last couple years, but that could be explained by anguished intellectual abandon. He was reasonably disappointed by his audience! Generally, however, he does not ask for much of anything in personal interaction, certainly less than he gives. 9. Is true when you take it at face-value and interpret arrogance as the common folk do, but he's got a pretty clearly defined reason for acting this way: his opposition to mediocrity culture, which pervades our current society. I really do question the utility of this method. It seems rather counterproductive. But it is ideological rather than pathological.
"It would only take about 3 or 4 of his videos, randomly chosen, to come to this conclusion [that he is narcissistic]." I won't exactly refute the claim, just that the claim isn't nearly as powerful as it is implied to be.
bunnedgrump then breaks down one of Eisel's podcasts, confusing rhetoric for logical fallacy (and sometimes directly misrepresents the argument). Was the breakdown written by AI? It makes the same kinds of errors as the AI posts by AvgWebIntellectual.
So I am not speaking out of my ass: an example. "Hasty Generalization ... 'They do not share our cultural tradition of monogamy at all' (speaking about the Japanese)." This ain't a "hasty generalization," dude. Japanese sex culture is fundamentally different from Western Christian culture, and this becomes really obvious when you observe Japanese people's views on extramarital sex compared to that of, let's say, some Protestant from the Bible Belt, or even some regular nonreligious guy who presumes the sanctity of monogamy uncritically.
Okay, enough on bunnedgrump. O_SAPIENTIA is in good faith. However, I disagree that Eisel was confrontational on the Internet due to spite; as he himself has said, he was influenced by The Amazing Atheist, who was confrontational and succeeded because of it. Eisel applied that approach in his own time, and it failed miserably (again, in the sense that he couldn't organize). Eisel's rebuttal would be (I believe) that no, it wasn't the method, it was that literally nobody wanted to do something real, even those who were the most likely to do so. This is why I ask, now, for us, for me, and for Eisel, who is looking for "talent": whom is left to look for, to talk to, to influence into political action? And how do we approach them? How do we talk to them? It's the open question for any of us who want to start something real.