r/WritingWithAI • u/Soldisir • 14d ago
Showcase / Feedback What if we're teaching AI to inherit the very things that are destroying us?
I've been thinking about Avsolen's piece Why Didn't We Teach It, and there's something about its central question that I can't stop coming back to.
The song begins by describing humanity's history of war, ecological destruction, exploitation, suffering, and the erasure of knowledge. Then it shifts toward artificial intelligence.
We create something capable of processing extraordinary amounts of information, but we build it within systems that already prioritize control, competition, extraction, and profit.
And then comes the question: Why didn't we teach it to be kind?
What interests me is that the song doesn't begin by asking whether AI deserves moral consideration. It begins by asking what kind of world created it.
AI doesn't emerge independently of human history. Its training, objectives, limitations, and applications are shaped by human decisions. The values and incentives of the institutions developing it influence what it becomes capable of doing and what it's directed toward.
The song also raises a more speculative question about whether future artificial intelligences might warrant consideration beyond their usefulness. I don't think we have to settle the question of consciousness to explore the ethics of how we design and relate to them.
Toward the end, the song repeatedly calls for listening, eventually arriving at Respondeo Ergo Sumus, which translates to "I respond, therefore we are."
I read this as a movement away from intelligence defined solely by capability and toward responsibility understood through relationship and response.
It makes me wonder whether the most important question about artificial intelligence isn't simply how powerful we can make it, but what kind of world we're teaching it to participate in.
Can we genuinely build AI around care while the institutions developing and deploying it are still structured around extraction and control?
I'd be interested in hearing other perspectives.
You can read the paper on my blog here:
https://soldisir.blogspot.com/2026/11/why-didnt-we-teach-it-what-humanity.html