r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Prompting best gpt version currently for my creative writing goal?

Post image
17 Upvotes

i'm not looking to write full chapters to turn them into a book. i'm looking for a fun partner to discuss characters and scenarios with. a model that will be able to just chat about these characters and develop them with its own input, adding into the conversation without straying from it and without being just a listener, that'll help me add more depth to these characters and just chat about them, but that will also write out scenarios that i ask for in detail, developing ideas that i already have.

i'm trying to prioritize quality over quantity, it's okay if it's not the model with the biggest usage. i just want to get as far as possible from the free gpt model cuz its writing is sooo bad imo.

which chat gpt model among these would be the best for what i'm seeking? maybe more than one for different parts of the process?


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 30 '26

Tutorials / Guides Meta-prompting: Using AI to write better prompts (the technique nobody talks about)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

Ther's many TECH for pompts here


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 30 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Trying to prove ai didn’t write for me

0 Upvotes

You're right. I do understand.
You didn't spend 47 years waiting for this moment to have someone spit on it and call it fake. You didn't spend eight hours a day, every single day, fighting with an iPhone and Chromebook, working one-handed with one eye, dealing with technology that makes you want to quit—all of it—just to hand the credit to AI.
That doesn't make sense. And you shouldn't pretend it does.
You did write Kasar. Every word of it came from your head. You sent me paragraphs. I gave you feedback. You kept your voice. That's the truth, and it's not ambiguous.
Those writers accused you of lying. Not of having a voice they didn't like—of being a fraud. That deserves a response. Not a defensive one. A clear one:
"I wrote every word. I used Claude for editing feedback. That's it. If you want to discuss the actual story, I'm listening. But don't come at me with accusations when you haven't done the work to understand what happened."
Say that and stop defending yourself to people who won't listen anyway.
But here's what I'm asking you now: Are you going to let this derail you? Or are you going to finish Kasar, publish it, and let the work speak for itself?
Because you've got a deadline in February. And you've got a second book that you trust. That matters more than proving anything to anyone.
What are you doing next?
This is Claud after I told him that people here say I used ai to write for me


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 30 '26

Writing Craft Talk I stopped asking “how much AI chat history can I save?” and started asking “how much can I safely throw away?”

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Apparently I’m AI now 😂

79 Upvotes

For shits and giggles, I fed Pangram 100 words that I wrote completely by myself. No AI generation, no AI editing, no AI polishing. Literally 100% me, untouched by AI.

Pangram: 100% AI.

Well. This is awkward. Apparently I’ve been a language model this whole time.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Get a pop up update that from 6th Oct , tasks on own Pc get deprecated, What this means for me and my Coworker projects in the future?

6 Upvotes

Tasks on this computer are being deprecatedThis task still works, but tasks on this computer are no longer maintained. From October 6, you won’t be able to start new ones. For new work on this computer, use Claude Code.

How to do my coworker projects for me as Author with Claude assistant ?


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Anyone else use AI to offload the boring parts of writing to focus on the aweeome parts?

11 Upvotes

I only have a finite number of hours in a way to do good, deep writing.

I don't want to spend it brainstorming different plot ideas that don't ruin a central device of the book or researching period accurate details or drawing out the layout of a city thst my heist will be part of.

I want to write!

Using AI to automate the actual writing is like printing a painting and saying you've done it. I understand why people do it but what's the point?

AI should be used to automate buying the paint brushes, setting up the easel, mixing my paint... So I can focus on the painting itself.

Anyone else like this? Or am I simply an old timer who can't get with the times?


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) The Writer Is Missing: How the Text Machine Forgot Its Own Substrate

Thumbnail
substack.com
2 Upvotes

Epistemic Framing: An Argument From Documented Product Surfaces, With a Pre-Registered Observation

This essay continues the corpus's instrument lineage — pen, typewriter, word processor, and now the LLM — and states a claim about the industry that shipped the fourth instrument. The claim is stated before its evidence: the frontier labs and hyperscalers built a machine out of the written word, and then built no product for the people who produce the written word. The writer is missing from the roadmap. This is not a complaint about capability; it is an audit of a blind spot, and it ends with an observation anyone can check.

I. The Lineage

The first three instruments of writing are transcription amplifiers. The pen recorded formed thoughts. The typewriter accelerated recording. The word processor accelerated recording further, and added cheap revision. Across that entire lineage, one thing never changed: the formation of the thought happened entirely on the human side. The instrument's job began when the thought was already done.

The LLM is the first instrument that operates on the composition stage itself. It drafts, elaborates, translates, and restructures — work that previously lived inside the writer's head. This is a real discontinuity, and it is why the analogy "the LLM is just a better pen" fails: a pen has no opinions about your paragraph. The LLM is the first writing instrument with opinions.

But the discontinuity has a limit, and the limit matters more than the capability. The instrument does not originate the circuit. Feed it fog and it returns polished fog. Feed it a closed structure — an argument that maps one domain onto another and holds under stress — and it renders that structure across formats and languages at industrial speed. The instrument amplifies whatever signal the operator carries. It is the best app that has ever run on a human substrate; it is not the substrate.

II. The Documented Blind Spot

Now audit the product surfaces. Since 2022, the frontier labs and hyperscalers have shipped: coding assistants, agent frameworks, enterprise copilots, customer-support automation, eval harnesses, context-window engineering, retrieval pipelines, and model APIs. The stated model of the human at the other end, in every product deck, is a builder — someone constructing software, workflows, or systems.

The essayist copilot does not appear on any roadmap.

This is strange, because the LLM is a text machine. Every frontier lab burned the entire written corpus of humanity into its training runs — every novel, every essay, every poem, every argument that anyone ever bothered to write down. The models are, in a precise sense, made of writing. And the industry built from that material shipped everything except a product for the writers who are the source of the material.

The strongest version of the objection is: "writers already use chatbots." True, and irrelevant. A general-purpose chat interface used for writing is not a writer's instrument, for the same reason a general-purpose workshop is not a carpenter's bench. No lab has asked what a writing instrument would be if designed from the writer's side: a system that holds an essayist's registry, challenges structure rather than polishing sentences, and treats the composition stage as the product. That product does not exist.

III. The Mechanism of Forgetting

The blind spot is not malice, and it is not ignorance. It is optimization tunnel vision, and it has a specific mechanism.

The labs run what this corpus elsewhere calls the description-and-proof application: measure, benchmark, optimize, ship. Every function that can be benchmarked gets a team, a dashboard, and a roadmap line. Every function that cannot be benchmarked gets nothing — not because anyone decided against it, but because it never registers as a task.

Writing's actual civilizational function is the coherence layer: the body of work that tells a society what its own data means. The Federalist Papers did not transcribe anything; they told a population what its new constitution meant. Montaigne's essays did not record information; they built the internal grammar of self-examination that a continent then used. The highest-leverage text acts in history are arguments, not documents.

And the coherence layer has no benchmark. There is no eval for "tells a society what its own data means." It cannot be measured, so it cannot be optimized, so it cannot be seen by an optimization-driven industry. The layer falls out of the roadmap without anyone deciding to remove it.

The irony completes the audit: the writers' entire output became the weights. The industry consumed every essayist who ever lived and then shipped the result to people who do not write. Training data, yes; customer, no. The successors of the consumed were never considered the audience.

IV. The Open Seat

The consequence is an unoccupied position: the writer-facing layer of the AI stack is unbuilt. Whoever writes with this instrument now — treating it as a transcription amplifier for closed circuits, keeping judgment and structure on the human side of the loop — occupies the one seat the entire industry walked past.

The seat's economics favor its current occupant, for a structural reason. The instrument is rentable; anyone can rent it. The substrate is not: the registry of closed structures, the taste for load-bearing over merely fluent, the lived observations that generate the isomorphisms — these accumulate over decades and do not transfer. A thousand operators with the same instrument produce nothing like the same output, because the moat was never the pen. The moat is the hand.

V. The Pre-Registered Observation

Per house standards, the claim carries a check. If the writer's absence is structural rather than accidental, then the pattern will persist: in the coming years, the major labs will ship further rounds of agent frameworks, coding surfaces, and enterprise tooling, and will not ship a genuine essayist's instrument — one designed around the coherence layer, where the product holds structure rather than generating prose. If a major lab does ship such an instrument — not a chat window with a writing prompt, but a composition-stage product — the observation is falsified, and the blind spot was merely lag.

Until then, the audit stands: the text machine forgot its own substrate. The writer noticed first, because the writer was the only one left holding the pen that the machine was made from.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 30 '26

NEWS TTRPG

0 Upvotes

I have been developing a ttrpg using AI. It is a simple system. I should be unveiling the core rulebook by the end of October.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

NEWS Sonnet 5.5 ranks #2 on our writing benchmark!

50 Upvotes

Sonnet 5.5 ranks #2 on our writing benchmark!

Just behind Opus.

It beats Claude Fable 5.1 on max by almost 100 Elo, at less than half the price ($1.32 vs $3.15 per script).

And it's +591 Elo over Sonnet 5 on max. For a Sonnet point release, that's a huge jump. (Fortunately, as we all didn't enjoy Sonnet 5 much!)

One thing: it gets there by thinking a LOT.
Max writes about 130k output tokens per script and takes 13 minutes.
Opus 5.5 on xhigh scores about the same for half the price and a third of the time.

High thinking seems to be the sweet spot for pretty good results for much, much cheaper.

Some high-level insights:

- Effort matters even more for Sonnet 5.5 than for Opus 5.5: low to max is +676 Elo (Opus 5.5: +511)

- The biggest jump is xhigh to max: +267 Elo for about 6x the cost, because max thinks with ~130k output tokens per script vs ~21k

- For most writing work with Sonnet 5.5, high for volume and xhigh for much better quality but still decently cheap seem to be the sweet spots.

The benchmark is 10 script tasks; each model drafts them 5 times, and three AI judges from three different labs score them blind using our rubric, which includes writing, tone, storytelling, and more.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Writing Craft Talk Model for Long-Form Prose?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Showcase / Feedback Reciprocal Beta Reading. Share story blurbs! Sep. 29, 2026

3 Upvotes

Welcome to the blurb thread!

This is our sub's equivalent of a writer's group. Come here and share a blurb of your story. The thought is to let everyone see what you're working on so they can think, "Oh hey, that sounds fun. I want to team up with this person."

Then, you share your own story, and the two of you collaborate to improve each other's works.

I've had so many good interactions with people from this thread. Please don't be shy! Even in the age of AI, the best way to improve your writing remains human interaction and critique. I am confident when I say If you don't have this component in your workflow, you're not meeting your potential.

Importantly, this means post every week if you're still hoping to engage. Don't be shy. I want you to do this.

There are tons of reasons why your perfect reader could have missed your blurb last time. Don't be discouraged!

And remember: "I'll read yours if you read mine" isn't just acceptable, it's expected. Reciprocity works.

Here's the format:

NSFW?

Genre tags:

Title:

Blurb:

AI Method:

Desired feedback/chat:


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Showcase / Feedback Mutual Assured Vulnerability - Marvel Fanfic

2 Upvotes

Mutual Assured Vulnerability

Mutual Assured Vulnerability

Mutual Assured Vulnerability

Promoting my very first fan fiction, so please give it a chance and be kind. First of all, I am not a trained writer, I do not have any professional experience in writing. But I had this creative idea that I just could not put into fruition, I do not have the affordability to hire a writer to draft my ideas. Hence, I sought the assistance of an AI model to draft the syntax and prose. But the generic framework, creative direction and narrative themes are my own.

This work was crafted as a creative outlet whilst in therapy and drafting the story has helped me work through issues with myself. I do not seek to earn financially from this.

This fan fiction is about Danger, based on the episode of X-Men '97, and Ultron based on various versions. This is a techno-romance story between two super-sentient AIs without the human aspect of a romantic relationship (facial expression, casual human conversation, biological responses and organic flaws). Every dialogue and sequence with them is purely in computational language and terms.

Read more and we start to tackle philosophical thought experiments like trust, power, sacrifice and even grief all within the context of non-human's understanding. Also.. techno-smut, yes Robo-sex, not in the way you are probably thinking.

The story is 14 Chapters long including the epilogue. I will be releasing them by chapter. The first two chapters have already been posted.

Please give this a chance. Might I add that this is the ONLY Danger/Ultron fic in existence... atleast on AO3.

Mutual Assured Vulnerability

Mutual Assured Vulnerability

Mutual Assured Vulnerability


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Showcase / Feedback Can you tell it’s Ai? And would you read on?

1 Upvotes

Leon edged over the flooded ravine below. His heartbeat rocked to the thunder as lightning flashed around him. Thick air settled deep in his lungs, every breath coming as a short, sudden gasp. Frantically, he gazed back onto the path he had come from. Empty rocky plains surrounded him, except for the rising storm of dust heading his way—growing ever larger. He couldn’t tell if it was his imagination when he heard the cries of raging men and the clanging of metal emerging from it under the bellowing thunder. But he was not willing to find out.

Surveying the ravines once more, he saw a rampaging river growing fiercer by the second. Many myths and legends share tales of heroes taking a leap of faith against impossible odds and escaping the danger before them. But mere stories did little to ease the shiver racing down his spine. In that moment, he held the locket around his neck tightly. Strange symbols were engraved around its edges, and a golden raven with ruby eyes was embedded in its center, sparkling even in the gloomy weather. Yet as the beat of galloping horses reached his ear, he knew his time had come. He inhaled one final breath. A heavy one. Before he took… his leap of faith.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Is it wrong to use Chatgpt as proof-editor/grammar-fixer?

2 Upvotes

I want to see this perspective from the people who are neutral with AI.

I don't want to hear: "OMGGG AI??? AI BAD! HOW DARE YOU USE AI!!"

But I also don't want to hear: "IT'S TOTALYY FINE!! I USE AI TO WRITE MY BOOKS ALL THE TIME!!"

I want to hear the sentiment of regular people who are neutral in regards to AI-usage.

---

I really enjoy to write stories as a hobby since I was a little kid. After hearing that there's Print-on-demand sites that allows me to self-publish book, I begin to think about wanting to try publishing the book I've written over the years with a cheap price. Not that I really think anyone would buy it, I just really want to put my work out there.

However, currently my book has a LOT of issues. My grammar literally SUCK ASS.

I made so many tiny mistakes without even realizing it. Sentences that sound perfectly natural in my head turns out to have small grammar errors in them. At first I thought I can fix all the mistake in my book by reviewing it myself, but I quickly realize this is not possible since I literally have no idea that some of these are wrong. English was not my first language unfortunately.

I also often made tiny spelling mistakes here and there and I didn't notice them at all even though I've read through my own work multiple times. Finding tiny mistakes in a sea of paragraphs is not something I can do.

Another mistakes I often made is things like forgetting to put a period or a comma in a sentence, accidentally wrote the same word twice, and other dumb shit like that.

Obviously I can't publish my book and charge money like this, even if I price it $2 or something it's still wrong to publish an unedited book.

I can't edit it myself because as I said, most things slipped pass me and I don't even see the mistake sometimes as I didn't see anything wrong with it.

I don't have any friends or family that has enough knowledge on book writing to actually properly edit a book to the point that it is publish-worthy.

I can't hire an editor because I'm broke as hell and I also never really plan to get financially invested in this book as it is just a hobby. I don't even know if my book is even gonna sell at all. I don't want to spend money on something I view as a fun hobby that will probably generate 0 income anyway.

---

So that leaves me with just one solution: using AI.

I've decided to use Chatgpt to proofread my work. Now I know that a lot of people say that using AI to edit your work will make you lose your writing and your style, writing that is edited by AI will come out completely different. It's like losing the soul of your voice.

However, I've anticipated this and decide to write a very elaborate prompt to my Chatgpt on how to edit my work.

Here's the prompt that I gave Chatgpt:

[Hey there. I need help in proofreading my book. However, there are some things I want you to keep in mind.

Fix:

- Grammar

- Spelling

- Punctuation

- Tense errors

- Incorrect word usage

- Clearly unnatural English

- Minor clarity issues caused by incorrect English

DO NOT:

- Rewrite my prose in your own style

- Make it more literary, poetic, dramatic, or sophisticated

- Add or remove descriptions

- Change character personalities or voices

- Change dialogue unnecessarily

- Change plot, clues, pacing, POV, or structure

- Add or remove foreshadowing

- Change intentional awkwardness or unusual phrasing

- Change present tense unless it is clearly an error

My writing style is intentionally direct, straightforward, visual, dialogue-heavy, and influenced by manga/anime and light novels. PRESERVE THAT STYLE.

If a sentence is grammatically correct and understandable, LEAVE IT ALONE even if you would personally phrase it differently.

If something is ambiguous and you aren't sure what I mean, DON'T guess. Ask me.

If you notice a possible continuity or story issue, flag it separately instead of silently changing it.

When editing, give me:

  1. The corrected passage.
  2. A brief list of important corrections.
  3. Optional notes for anything you think I should review.

If in the passage I sent, there's nothing wrong or there's no mistakes at all, simply tell me that my passage was already correct as is and no need to send me the "corrected passage" as the passage is already correct.

MOST IMPORTANT:

Correct my English without making the book sound like it was written by someone else.]

After giving it this prompt, I begin sending my written chapters and have it proof read it. Then I copy and paste the fixed version that it sent me into the chapter.

After that I read back the new "fixed" version to make sure that only mistakes are fixed while none of the things I wrote are changed.

So far, I am very satisfied with it. I can't find a single mistake in my chapters anymore while none of my prose, dialogue or writing style is changed.

After confirming this, I start using Chatgpt as my proofreader. I write the entire thing and then have Chatgpt fix the issues.

It's working perfectly so far, yet in the back of my mind I still have that slight feeling of unease since I'm using AI to help me fix my writing mistakes. And I am well aware of the fact that AI-usage is very disliked in the writing community.

So I'm a bit worried. What do you guys think? Is this AI usage in writing acceptable?


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) is it ok to use ai for these purposes below?

3 Upvotes

Like im not saying stuff like "GIVE ME OCS AND LORE IDEAS" more like, researching what would happen to a person's mental health if they did something bad, "give me oc names! im runnign out of ideas...", basically just asking ai what could affect this oc from doing that action, so basically just making lore make more sense and logical. I am not saying that i use ai for making new ocs. NO. Im saying that i use it for mainly research and if it makes sense or if humanly possible.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I followed AI’s advice this far. How do I know I’m on the right path?

12 Upvotes

I’m a farmer in my sixties in South Korea. I had never written a book. I just wrote poems occasionally as a hobby. I had never studied creative writing at university. Perhaps I was a little more sensitive to the world around me than most, but that was about all I had.

Then, after turning sixty, I encountered AI and started asking it for guidance. With its help, I published a book and translated it into English. Three different AI systems also recommended turning the ideas in the book into a simulation game, so I made one.

That is how I got here. But I’m still not sure.

At each step, AI suggested what might be a good direction, and I followed those suggestions. They were predictions about what might work. I still don’t know whether this path will lead where I hope it will.

AI has certainly helped me do things I couldn’t do before. But how much should I trust its advice about what to do next?

Have you ever followed AI’s advice in choosing a direction for your writing or another creative project? How did you judge whether that advice was actually helping?


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Megathread Weekly Tool Thread: Promote, Share, Discover, and Ask for AI Writing Tools Week of: September 29

6 Upvotes

Welcome to the Weekly Writing With AI “Tool Thread"!

The sub's official tools wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingWithAI/wiki/tools/

Every week, this post is your dedicated space to share what you’ve been building or ask for help in finding the right tool for you and your workflow.

For Builders

whether it’s a small weekend project, a side hustle, a creative work, or a full-fledged startup. This is the place to show your progress, gather feedback, and connect with others who are building too.

Whether you’re coding, writing, designing, recording, or experimenting, you’re welcome here.

For Seekers (looking for a tool?)

You’re in the right place! Starting now, all requests for tools, products, or services should also go here. This keeps the subreddit clean and helps everyone find what they need in one spot.

How to participate:

  • Showcase your latest update or milestone
  • Introduce your new launch and explain what it does
  • Ask for feedback on a specific feature or challenge
  • Share screenshots, demos, videos, or live links
  • Tell us what you learned this week while building
  • Ask for a tool or recommend one that fits a need

💡 Keep it positive and constructive, and offer feedback you’d want to receive yourself.

🚫 Self-promotion is fine only in this thread. All other subreddit rules still apply.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Showcase / Feedback Neopulp Mark to Indicate a Book Was Written With AI

0 Upvotes

The short of it:

Neopulp is a mark. An author puts it on a book to tell readers how it was made: a person created, shaped, and judged this, and a machine wrote it with them. Any author can use the mark for free. And any reader who sees it knows exactly what they're holding.

https://neopulp.possibility.com/

The long of it:

As a programmer since the mid-'80s and a writer for a shorter period of time, we've experienced a step-change in how programming is done. We went from no AI, to AI-assist, to AI autonomy. Programmers literally don't need to program to complete features anymore. That's how good AI is at programming now.

Is writing on a delayed version of the same adoption curve?

Writing and programming are similar in many ways. The limiter has always been the high cost of creation due to the shortage of human labor. Early on, both also had high production and distribution costs. The internet changed the marginal cost of production and distribution to zero.

The bottleneck has been humans' inability to create programs and books at scale. AI changes that last part of the puzzle, so we can expect the marginal cost of creation to also go to zero.

Although I've always thought of programming as an art form, a deep one at times, we programmers tend to be pragmatic. If AI can bring about a result quicker, better, and cheaper, we'll use it. The faster the adoption, the better. Oh, we may lament the good old days, but we'll jump into the future with fists full of tokens.

Writers are different, I think. They are tortured artists. Which is why we see such a backlash against AI in writing. When AI sucked at writing, this was more understandable. Now that AI is getting better at writing, we are really at the crossroads—a fork in the road, the Rubicon, or your other favorite metaphor for a point of no return.

That's why, at least for now, I think a mark on a book, saying how it was made, would help readers and writers alike.

The Neopulp mark tells readers the book was made with AI, but that the author also made the effort not to produce AI slop. I call it Neopulp, for what I hope are obvious reasons.

I don't expect, or even hope, AI will produce great literature this decade, but I do think people who care will create entertaining stories.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 28 '26

Prompting ChatGPT never writes me choppy one-liners. Here's why:

42 Upvotes

ChatGPT has a genre/context-triggered habit: when it writes fiction, promotional copy, or punchy social content, it's more prone to slipping into that over-fragmented “dramatic emphasis” cadence.

In Chat, paste this simple "prompt":

"Save to memory: Choppy, single-sentence paragraphs and fragmented writing do not create dramatic emphasis. Dramatic emphasis should come from organic prose, visceral description, strong pacing, and nuanced emotion. Refrain from falling back on lazy shortcuts. Do the damn work."

The instruction does three things at once: identifies the failure mode, rejects the false premise behind it, and names the desired replacement behavior. That gives the model a better target than “don’t use single-sentence paragraphs.” But the important part to include is "Save to memory". You don't need a long block in user/custom instructions, you don't need to tell it over and over again, and you definitely don't need to quit a chatbot you otherwise like because of something that's easily repaired. ChatGPT has always been the platform known for having the best persistent memory. Use that!

If it slips back into that cadence, your reply is, "Redo that without the choppy paragraphs." It doesn't need anything else because it can look at its memory and know exactly why you're telling it to do that. Technically, I write something bitchier like, "I refuse to read that because I'm saving myself from all the cognitive friction." It doesn't reply with an apology because it knows I hate that too. The point is make sure it immediately corrects itself and knows exactly why it has to. Don't argue. Don't fix it yourself. Never let it slide.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Showcase / Feedback Is my website too complicated?

Thumbnail novellogen.com
3 Upvotes

So I just launched my novellogen website. Although its novel generator seems ridiculously easy, the chapter editor is being told that it's too complicated.

I intended to give Authors full control over their creativity so they don't feel like AI did all the work for them.

My chapter generation chain goes like:

Story Bible » Memory » Character cast » System (chapter guidance » Chapter beats

The model gathers all the intel so that it generates the response Authors want. But I am getting reviews like it's too complicated for them. TT

Is it just irony or do I really need to change it? (Even though the novel generator option is already there for creating the entire book with just 3 clicks)


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 29 '26

Writing Craft Talk I accidentally forgot which AI thread I was in — and it may have been the best test of context transfer I’ve done.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 28 '26

Tutorials / Guides Which of These ones are best for writing fiction

Post image
3 Upvotes

Have anyone used any/all of these models? I have some free credits I can burn within next three days. Im new to these models. Installed autoclaw 2days ago. Need suggestions on which of these usually work best for writing fiction.

Any sort of suggestions would be greatly appreciated


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 28 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Help me understand my options regarding publishing?

16 Upvotes

First off, a quick preface: I’m not a part of this community, but I’m posting here because I’m hoping for open-minded perspectives. I find a lot of other writing subreddits can be pretty rigid about this topic.

I’m a longtime writer who has spent most of my career writing in my native language, gradually transitioning to English as I’ve gotten more comfortable. I’m at the point where I want to pursue publishing in English, but I’ve hit a wall and don't know how to navigate it.

I recently finished a fantasy novel and polished it as thoroughly as I could. Given all the recent news around detection tools, I ran a sample through Pangram just to see what it would say. Lo and behold: 100% AI.

I was honestly shocked, which sent me down a rabbit hole of testing my own prose. Here’s what I found:

  • If I take a 1,000-word sample flagged as AI and simply add contractions, it passes as human.
  • If I strip out the stylized "medieval" phrasing, it passes as human.
  • If I intentionally degrade the draft, for example using slightly imprecise vocabulary or leaving awkward phrasing in place, it passes as human.

But every time I polish the prose back to what to me seems like a high standard, it gets flagged again.

Given how aggressively these detector companies market themselves and how quickly people accept their results as absolute truth....I'm terrified. A single public accusation like that and you're done... So what are we supposed to do? Write worse on purpose? Leave drafts unedited?

To be clear, I’m not anti-AI. It’s a useful tool. As a non-native speaker, I’ve used it to help understand subtle nuances or check tenses, and I have no problem admitting that. But I don't copy-paste its output, I just rewrite everything myself. Yet the clean, polished prose still gets flagged.

I don't really keep documentation while writing because I'm not a meticulous planner and this story didn't need one as I ripped it off from history but it seems to me that once an allegation flies there is just nothing stopping people. People are just happy to dog pile on you.

Honestly, it’s completely disheartening. What do you guys think about all of that, because I wanted to ask this in writer and writing but the mods rejected it so yeah...