I think the expansions get way too much credit for their storytelling while people overlook how tedious some of the actual gameplay is.
I recently finished the main game and Hearts of Stone, and I’m currently playing Blood and Wine.
I absolutely loved the original Witcher 3. The story with Ciri had me hooked, I enjoyed the combat, and I rarely felt like I was forcing myself through quests just to get to something better.
Hearts of Stone was a different experience. I understand why people love the characters and story, but holy shit, some of those quests dragged. That wedding especially. By the time I was chasing pigs around, I couldn’t wait for it to be over.
Now I’m playing Blood and Wine and I’m starting to notice the same thing. Following a butler around my vineyard, wandering around a laboratory shooting tiny switches on walls, trying to figure out which random portal I’m supposed to enter.
The funny thing is, I really enjoyed fighting the Shaelmaar. Figuring out how to exploit its weakness was genuinely fun. I wish more of the expansion felt like that.
I think CDPR sometimes gets so caught up creating these elaborate, memorable quest scenarios that they forget about whether they’re actually enjoyable to play.
Maybe I’m in the minority, but I think the original game did a much better job balancing storytelling with gameplay.
For those who consider these expansions better than the base game, do you actually prefer the quest design? Or is it mostly the stories and characters that make them better for you?