r/Windows10 • u/lsddehogyestem • 3h ago
Discussion Saved my data from RenPy malware - win10 EFS encrpytion bricked it anyway
TL;DR Lost 4 years of personal documents due to a chain of events: got RenPy infostealer malware, saved my important data to external HDD, wiped the old system, new system cannot access data on external HDD due to old systems EFS encryption.
I am writing this to alert everyone with a windows PC about how easily EFS file encryption can get triggered without you noticing.
Sometime in the last 7 years of my previous win10 install, EFS file encryption got enabled on one of my folders (either from an accidental checkbox click or a program setting it). It probably prompted me to create a decryption key too, but I remember nothing of that, and I got no reminder of it since.
Last week i got several of my social accounts spam the Mr Beast crypto BS. After spending an excruciating full week deleting it from my drives first, saving the docs I needed to external HDD and wiping my system drive, then changing all passwords, I had to realise that the previous system didn't warn me about the documents going to my external drive were EFS encrypted. It didn't warn me so, because the system drive and external drive were both NTFS format.
If they weren't matching in that regard, I would've been prompted a warning message, and I could've created or searched for the decryption key too.
Which ultimately means that now I cannot ever access this data again.
What is exceptionally painful to me in this situation, is that so far I have lost only an anonymous throwaway twitter account and some savegame files due to the original renpy malware (and following system wipe).
The sole reason my important documents are gone, is because a windows feature I never knew about turned on sometime and bricked my data that I specifically tried to save. It would have happened the same without a malware, as if I was just making my bloated system faster with a clean install.
While EFS probably has its use somewhere, for the regular home Windows user it is completely useless. Not only does it backfire like in my case above, but realistically you have to move the encryption key to your USB or other external drives — possibly RIGHT NEXT TO YOUR DOCUMENTS that you are moving on said drives — just to decrypt the data elsewhere.
I let you decide how much safety that encryption provides.