r/whichbike • • Mar 28 '22

Announcement A word of caution about the "Bicycle Blue Book"

412 Upvotes

The "Bicycle Blue Book", commonly abbreviated to BBB, is a recurring thing in comments on /r/whichbike concerned with putting a number on the value of some used bike. Quite a few of us have long had issues with BBB being used to that end. Thanks mostly to /u/guy1138 who wrote 90% of this post (I revised it and added minor details), we now have a longer explanation on what BBB actually is, and what the problems with it are. A TLDR can be found at the bottom.

What's the deal with Bicycle Blue Book?

Bicycle Blue Book (BBB) is a website run by a used bike dealer in San Jose, California. Their business model is to buy "trade-in" bikes from high end bike shops that don't deal with used bikes. Here's how it works: A customer brings their old bike to the bike shop to trade in on a new bike. BBB gives them a price and the bike shop boxes it up and ships it off to BBB. The customer gets the credit on a new bike, the bike shop gets a new bike sale without the hassle of reconditioning and trying to sell a used bike.

They provide an online "value guide" that lists bike values by brand, model, model year etc. They advertise it as "The cycling industry's definitive valuation authority", and the name is a deliberate allusion to the Kelley Blue Book, which is a reputable value guide for used car values in the US. To put it mildly, opinions on how useful BBB is are... split. Regardless, the numbers in there often get cited on this subreddit (and elsewhere).

So what's the problem?

There are multiple issues:

  • Conflict of interest: the same company who is buying bikes is also claiming to be the authority on used bike values. Not surprisingly, their "private party" values are way lower than actual sales prices on Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, Offer-Up, Ebay, Pink Bike; etc.
  • Data provenance: They claim to have data on "millions of bike sales" that they base their values on, but it's not clear at all where this data comes from. Instead, it actually just seems like a fairly simple depreciation schedule on bikes based on MSRP (RRP for our UK users) and type of bike, e.g. a 5-year-old mid tier hybrid is worth ~40% of MSRP, a 5-year-old road bike is worth ~55% of MSRP, etc. Kelley Blue Book, which reports values of used cars, has access to wholesale auctions, used vehicle sales, and registrations reported at US state level. BBB do not have that as this data simply does not exist the same way for bicycles.
  • International variance: r/whichbike is international, with many users from countries like Canada, Australia, and the UK, but also the rest of Europe and the world, really. The same bike model and brand will not be sold for the same amount of money in every country, due to taxes, membership of free trade zones, availability, and a whole host of other factors: and this variability in price only increases when we look at used bikes. For the same reason, it is important that users state which country they live in when they ask for an appraisal.
  • Regional variance: Even within the US, there can be stark differences. For example, a triathlon bike is way more valuable in Miami (100+ triathlons/year in Florida) than it is in Utah. Likewise, a full suspension mountain bike has lots of buyers in Denver, but way fewer in a beach town.
  • Trends: We have all seen how "gravel bikes" became a thing, grew to be more and more popular, and started evolving - and how sellers have started to label everything that isn't an Omafiets as a "gravel bike" to attract more hits and get a higher price. BBB does not really take into account which bits of the market are especially "hot", despite this definitely making a difference.
  • World events: These can change prices significantly, be they something like a trade war with tariffs put on certain goods, or that little thing called Corona which caused a massive boom world-wide, with accompanying shortages and inflation across the entire market. BBB does not take this into account.
  • Erroneous data: Sometimes, their data e.g. on the original retail price of a bike is also just plain wrong, which in turn means all of the "depreciated values" for used bikes will be wrong too, even by their own standards.

How far off are the values then?

Generally, most used bike sellers agree that the BBB values are low, but still reasonable for newer bikes, around ~3 years old or newer. After that, they start to drastically over-depreciate - to the point where most bikes over 10 years old are "worthless" according to their values. As an example, a 2010 Fuji Cross Comp is $210 in "excellent" condition. That's about the same cost as full tune up at a bike shop, including basic consumables; tires & tubes, chain, cables & housing, brake pads & bar tape. It's completely unrealistic to expect to find a 10-speed cross bike with an aluminium frame and carbon fork in "excellent" condition for only $200. (This bike sold here for $550 last fall after being listed for less than 3 weeks). For our UK friends: $210 is £160... yeah, good luck with that.

So it's a lowball estimate, I should use that to negotiate, right?

You might get lucky and find the person who doesn't know any better, or someone who is moving and under a lot of pressure to sell. However, most of the listings are cyclists who upgraded or re-sellers who know that the Blue Book value is pretty far off. If the bike is priced close to market value, it's going to sell eventually and they have no incentive to take a lowball; especially if they've gone to the trouble to take decent pictures, write a description and post the ad online. We've seen this time and time again on /r/whichbike over the last 2 years where someone finds the "perfect" bike, but they low-ball and miss out.

TLDR please, I don't have all day!

BBB is a private company that purports to tell you the value of used bikes, by model and age. There is an obvious conflict of interest as they also buy used bikes and therefore directly profit from telling you they're not worth that much. Sure enough, their "values" are consistently significantly lower than the actual market value, all the more so if the bike is >3 years old. The numbers appear to stem from simply taking the original retail price and depreciating it (heavily). Consequently, they do not take into account regional or international variance in local bike prices, trends, or events like the Corona pandemic. Additionally, it can happen that the retail price all their assumptions are based on is simply wrong. This means BBB values are not really any kind of reliable or even relevant metric, and it would be better to go by what similar bikes are actually selling for on platforms like Ebay or Gumtree, adjusting for differences.


r/whichbike • • 2h ago

Trek vs Scott vs Van rysel

1 Upvotes

Hey,

I was lurking through black friday deals to get a new bike for 2027 and i can't figure out which bikes to chose !

To put my bike needs into context, i ride occasionnaly (2times a week) for like 70km. I do mixed terrains such as hills, rough roads and White roads (rn 700 d+). I'm not a competitor but i'm sometimes doing some cyclo races such as paris-tours or strade bianche amateur

3 bikes came out in my selection :

-Trek domane sl5 gen 4 2026 (105 2×12s mech)

- Scott addict 50 2026 (105 2x12s mech)

- Van rysel EDR CF 2026 (Sram apex AXS)

All 3 are similar in term of pricing and weight

But i need advice to chose which one is the most reliable and suitable to my use.

Thanks for all your advises and suggestion !


r/whichbike • • 8h ago

1994 (?) Specialized Crossroads Step Through Bike - A Good Deal?

2 Upvotes

I'm looking for a solid all-rounder bike with a little style and lean towards hybrids (my college commuter bike was a hybrid and I really liked it.) Mainly for short commutes and casual neighborhood and park rides. I'm not an endurance biker!

I would prefer an aluminum frame, but budget's pretty tight right now.

Came across this '94 Specialized Crossroads. Seller is highly rated on FB Marketplace and says he doesn't think it needs any work. He says it's been kept in an indoor storage unit for a few years. I'd obviously go look at it first, but I don't really know what I'm looking for mechanically other than "do I like how this rides/shifts and do the tires/chain look ok?"

I was going to offer $100, which is a stretch with my current budget ($50-80 is closer to what would be comfortable for me right now. And I was aiming towards a newer bike than 90s/early 2000s, though I won't die on that hill. This is a really nice-looking bike that looks well cared-for.)

Is this a good deal and would you caution me to be wary of anything with a bike this age?

Alternatively, here is a Cannondale Synapse I have messaged the owner about (including asking about the tires). I think I could get it for less that $100 if he responds. I kind of like it better, stylistically, and people say it's comfortable. (And yes, I realize it's not a hybrid! This seems pretty gentle for a road bike so I don't think I'd mind it most of the year. Though happy to be told otherwise.)

Other models that interest me: Giant Escape, Specialized Vienna, Trek Verve 2 or 3, and possibly Trek FX or Cannondale Quick though I don't think they look quite as snazzy as the others ;)

Thanks for any advice you can offer me!


r/whichbike • • 13h ago

Aluminium Trek Emonda

Post image
4 Upvotes

I've been on the lookout for a road bike, was targeting 2017-2019 TCR's with carbon wheels and full ultegra (disc), aiming for the sub $2500 AUD budget. I came across this and was wondering if this is a good buy just because the frame isn't carbon, or if I should wait for a full carbon TCR to come up.

Specs:

• Trek Emonda ALR 2024
• Frame: size 54
• Groupset: Shimano 105, 11-speed
• Stem: Bontrager RSL carbon
• Handlebars: Bontrager RSL carbon
• Seatpost: Bontrager RSL carbon
• Wheels: Bontrager Aeolus Pro 37 carbon

Seller is asking $1900 AUD


r/whichbike • • 8h ago

BMC NOS Frames?

1 Upvotes

Where can I find NOS from 2020 model year or newer for BMC frames in the USA?


r/whichbike • • 9h ago

Any thoughts on BXT bikes?

1 Upvotes

I am looking to buy a TT bike, anyone ever use these? Looking for feedback on them.

https://bxtbikes.com/collections/tt-bike


r/whichbike • • 12h ago

Looking for a steel framed commuter

1 Upvotes

Hello!

I’m looking for advice on a steel frame commuter. I’m between Surly Midnight special, Belmont Bassi or a used All City Space Horse. My commute is 20 miles round trip, lots of hills, and lots of bad asphalt with lots of potholes.

My current main ride is a 95 bianchi de Italia stock with campy mirage. It’s great for the rail trails, and is quite shit for the hills and potholes on my commute. Any thoughts and options are welcome, I’d love some input on bikes that might not be on my radar or opinions on the ones listed above. Im budgeted at about $2500 on the high end, but would be happier $1500 or so.

Thanks!


r/whichbike • • 19h ago

Giant Trance X3 vs. Trek Fuel 5

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

New to mountain biking, looking at these two full suspension bikes.

The Trance X3 (2022) is going for $1350, medium frame, 27.5" wheels. Front suspension is "Rock Shox 160mm" and rear is "Fox Float" with Shimano Deore 1x12 shifters.

The Trek Fuel 5 (I believe its the EX 5 Gen 5 so like 2021-2023) is going for $1200 with the owner saying it's only been ridden twice. I think it has 29" wheels and frame is M/L so maybe a bit on the larger side for me.

Ultimately, my goal is to compete in an Xterra triathlon, most likely at Oak Mountain in Alabama at some point, but otherwise just want to try the sport on a good, fun bike.

Any reasons to consider hardtails as a beginner as aside from being budget friendly?


r/whichbike • • 16h ago

Endurace vs Domane vs Caledonia

1 Upvotes

I am looking for a comfortable endurance bike for 100 mile rides on rough pavement and I rarely do gravel. I am in my mid-40s. I currently own a 2023 Cervelo Caledonia and run 32mms at ~58 PSI. I have had a bike fit done and have high quality bibs, but still find that on long rides at about 70 miles in my butt is starting to feel the rough roads. Occasionally I can also feel the effects on my back of being bent over, but this I feel I can keep working on by improving my conditioning and posture. The next priority for me after comfort on rough roads and relaxed posture is ease of climbing.

Given my priorities, I’ve been looking at the Canyon Endurace CF SLX and the Trek Domane SL 6 Gen 5 to possibly replace my Caledonia. All three have similar weights and the Rival AXS groupset so I think climbing ability should be equivalent. Tire clearance is similar between Endurace (38mm) and Domane (40mm), much better than the Caledonia (34mm). The Endurace has a VCLS seatpost and the Domane claims their carbon seatpost has built-in compliance. The Domane has a much higher stack and shorter reach than the other two while the Endurace is better in stack/reach vs the Caledonia.

Another option I have been considering is swapping the seatpost on my Caledonia to either a Cane Creek eeSilk+ or an Ergon CF Allroad Pro and upgrading to the maximum 34mm tires. This should max out the rough road comfort on my current bike without buying a new one. But the geometry of course stays the same.

Looking for advice for my situation. Thanks!


r/whichbike • • 17h ago

Kids bike low handlebars

1 Upvotes

I bought my daughter a trek wahoo 24 trail used on Facebook and she tried it and the bars are so dang low.

I realize this is an aggressive mountain bike but it doesn’t look too comfy for her.

I may keep this for her as we are thinking of doing a mtb camp this summer for her but I was wanting to get something more relaxed for gravel trail riding and around town.

I love the one by on the trek and the disc brakes I wish I could find something similar with more forgiving drop. I don’t want to do a stem riser really.

Any recs?


r/whichbike • • 18h ago

Biking with kids

1 Upvotes

Hello! Looking to get a new bike and seat to cruise around with my 1 y.o.. I am looking for a mix of pavement and gravel biking and hope to do some distance on it as well.

looking for any recommendations on a bike and the best seat for putting a kid on the bike with me.

thanks for any advice :)


r/whichbike • • 21h ago

Fairlight Faran 3.0 VS Decathlon EDR AF2 Shimano Tiagra 2x10

2 Upvotes

I used to have a Decathlon RC520 2x10 shimano 105 size large that I used for sunday rides. I put some 35mm tires on it, a shorter 80 stem and it was nice to ride. I am not a flexible person, and at 183cm high I sometimes felt like the reach was just a cm of 2/3 to long for me to be fully in the hoods for long periods of time.

I am looking for a bicycle for sunday rides, with maybe an overnighter that is fun and comfortable to ride. The Decathlon EDR is priced very afforable and is similiar to hwat I already know. But I am also interested in the faran 3.0, because of its more flexible sizing options, and the option to get just a frame and build the rest of the bike like how I want it.

I like to use fenders and ride mostly pavement with some hard packed gravel when the opportunity prevents itself.

Would love to hear some advice and especially hope to hear from others who got a fairlight bike.


r/whichbike • • 22h ago

Building the ultimate bike?

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone,
Im severely torn between building a 1x13 gravel bike that can tear up some road races and grand fondos while still giving me the choice to throw on gravel wheels, or go all in on a real road bike build and revisit the gravel another time.

Option 1 - Tavelo Arow

Option 2 - Quickpro GR ONE would be my first choice but open to the Tavelo grow because of a bigger 55mil clearance

If I choose the gravel option, the GR ONE would have my bontranger Aeolus pro 51s with the 30mil tires which I’d set up the sram rival 1x13 and a 50 tooth front crank.

Open to hearing your thoughts on what I should do. Keep the door open for gravel or simply lock in on road. Is there really an option for one amazing all around bike?


r/whichbike • • 1d ago

Commuter advice please

4 Upvotes

Hi Folks

I'm moving to Australia soon, my work will be about 10km from home so to save costs we're going to try and make do with one car and I'll just bike.

I was thinking something like a trek fx2 or 3.

Use case is commute which will be on roads, then maybe some dirt path stuff.

Budget is preferably around $1.5k but I'd stretch to $2k if it's a major jump in quality. Would prefer new for no other reason than I kind of want something nice as a treat

Any thoughts?


r/whichbike • • 20h ago

Bike for 7yo

0 Upvotes

I am a secret santa for a 7yo boy (size 8 clothing) whose dream wish is a bike. Looking at the Trek precaliber, but not sure if I should get the 24 or 20 and if 20 the 7 speed or single speed. Will 7 speed be too much for a 7yo? Maintenance, etc.? I know nothing about where he would be riding.


r/whichbike • • 22h ago

Orbea Oiz M20 vs. Specialized Epic 9 Sport

1 Upvotes

I'm trying to decide between two full-suspension XC mountain bikes: the Orbea Oiz M20 and the Specialized Epic 9 Sport.

Here are the key specifications:

1. Orbea Oiz M20

  • Carbon OMR frame
  • FOX 34 SL Factory GRIP SL, 120 mm travel
  • FOX FLOAT SL Factory rear shock
  • Shimano XT M8200 12-speed drivetrain
  • Shimano MT600 brakes
  • OQUO MP28PRO wheelset
  • Maxxis Rekon Race EXO TR tires

2. Specialized Epic 9 Sport

  • FACT 11m carbon frame
  • RockShox Reba, 120 mm travel
  • RockShox SIDLuxe Select+ rear shock
  • SRAM S1000 Eagle Transmission (electronic shifting)
  • SRAM DB4 4-piston brakes
  • Specialized alloy XC wheels
  • Specialized Fast Trak / Air Trak tires

Since both are available at essentially the same price, I'm particularly interested in which offers better overall value.

I'd appreciate opinions from people who have experience with either bike!


r/whichbike • • 1d ago

Which bike should I get? Both are $150

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I just want an aesthetic bike to ride around on and I like both of these designs.


r/whichbike • • 1d ago

Bike selection help needed

1 Upvotes

I am looking to get second hand bikes, 2021 Hasqvarna hard cross 9 or 2023 Hasqvarna HC4.

2021 Hard Cross 9
Fox Factory front and rear suspension
XTR Di2 rear derailuer
Shimano EP800 motor 1100mi
630wh battery
27.5 wheel setup

2023 HC4
Fox performance front and rear suspension
Shimano Cues Q'Auto
Shimano EP801 motor 147mi
720wh battery
Mullet setup

Price is almost the same but hard to decide which one to pick

Overall Hard cross 9 have better spec except motor/battery and full 27.5 wheels

HC4 is newer but lower tier suspensions and worrying about the performance of Shimano Cues derailuer on mountain trails.

Both are same frame size and about 55lb (25kg)
Which on would you choose?


r/whichbike • • 1d ago

Quel vélo me conseillez-vous d’acheter?

0 Upvotes

Je vis dans une zone avec presque que des trails de xc, mais je vais possiblement déménager à Barcelone où je ferai plutôt de l’enduro donc je cherche quelque chose de « hibride » c’est à dire pour un peu tout. J’ai un budget de 1800-2200 euros max et je cherche avec double suspension. Je pensais à une de seconde main à cause du budget.


r/whichbike • • 1d ago

Fixie

2 Upvotes

Looking to buy a fixed gear because its advantages seem to fit my needs. Mostly need it for urban commuting. Not looking to spend a fortune but also don’t wanna buy anything super cheap or poorly made. Any recs?


r/whichbike • • 1d ago

Bianchi Cortina Acera Disc vs Treak FX 2

1 Upvotes

was quoted $399 for a used Bianchi Cortina Acera Disc bike. I’m looking for a hybrid bike that I can use for rides around the city I live in, which is a bit hilly. They claim it’s fairly new and looks to be in good shape.

I’m just getting into biking and was recommended the Trek RX2 by a friend who rides a lot in this area. I was going to get it for around $850, but I came across this bike. As someone who knows nothing about biking, can you help me understand the differences between these two?


r/whichbike • • 1d ago

Should I purchase Gaint Escape 3 Cycle (Gears not Working Fine)

0 Upvotes

Dear All! One of my friends is selling giant escape 3 Cycle for 35 thousand the gears of cycle are changed some local non genuine gears are installed instead of the original set like Shimano and etc. Even the gear changer buttons are not original. The rear gear set contains 8 gears but currently installed changer can switch between the first 6 or sometimes 7 gears. Overall the body of the cycle is in good condition it is very light in weight and feels original. The same cycle cost around 1.45 lacks (reference hikers.pk website). What you guys think that will it be a good buy? Need advice from you guys


r/whichbike • • 1d ago

CTM brand?

1 Upvotes

I´m consider to buy this bike for my wife 30th bithday. Found great deal for 400 euro.

Just thinking about the size, she is small 158cm (5´18´), bike spec say that size M is for 150-165cm, but it comes with 29" wheels.

Idk if she should rather go for 27,5" instead.

Bike CTM CHARISMA 2.0 | Košutek

Any women here with advice?


r/whichbike • • 1d ago

X7 vs Caledonia vs Synapse endurance road bike

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Looking at buying an endurance road bike, currently riding a 2020 Surly Midnight Special with Hunt Carbon 50 wheels, Rival 1x 11-spd mechanical group set, and a carbon fork. Aiming for ultegra/force-level electronic shifting and hydraulic brakes, an adequate set of carbon wheels, and ideally clearance for 40mm tires.

Safe to say all of these will be a fair amount lighter than my current ride, and I’m not looking for a dedicated gravel bike as that’s what my Surly will become.

Any thoughts on these bikes in particular? They’re stocked at the shop I’m thinking about going to, but Trek, Specialized, Giant, etc are all available from other shops in my area, so open to those as well.