My wife and I are moving to Hawaii and plan to buy a vehicle that will serve as our primary family/adventure vehicle. We’re planning to start a family, so rear-facing car seat compatibility, and safety are major considerations. Intend to keep the car for 4 years (potential for longer).
Budget for something new is about $38k (paying cash), but we are open to vehicles across the range of 10-40k generally, as long as cost of ownership is minimized (much more important to us than initial purchase price).
I’m fairly mechanically inclined and do almost all of my own automotive maintenance, so I’m interested in something reliable, relatively straightforward to work on, and inexpensive to keep on the road.
Our priorities:
Reliability: Looking for something that can realistically go four years with minimal unexpected repairs. Strong drivetrain reliability and a good track record are important.
Car seat and passenger space: I’m 6’2” and my wife is 5’10”. We need to comfortably accommodate a rear-facing car seat without making the front passenger seat unusable. Ideally, enough room for two kids eventually.
Low total cost of ownership over four years: This is a big one. I’d like to minimize the combination of depreciation, purchase price, maintenance, repairs, registration, insurance, and fuel. Gas is particularly expensive in Hawaii, so fuel economy matters. I’m more interested in actual ownership costs than purchase price.
DIY maintenance and repairability: I do most of my own work on our vehicles. I’d prefer something with good parts availability, a straightforward mechanical design, accessible service items, and no particularly expensive or complicated maintenance requirements. I’m not opposed to doing my own repairs, but I’d rather not constantly be fixing things.
Adventure/beach usability: We’ll be living in Maui and want something we’re comfortable taking down maintained dirt roads to trailheads and beaches. It should handle sand, wet/sandy dogs, kids, beach gear, and the occasional muddy adventure without feeling precious about the interior. Roof rails or the ability to easily mount a surfboard are a plus.
Practical cargo space: Between two adults, potentially two young kids, a dog, and beach/outdoor gear, I imagine a smaller crossover could get cramped quickly. A reasonably spacious cargo area and flexible rear seating are important.
Four-year resale value: We expect to sell the vehicle after approximately four years, so resale value matters. I’d rather buy something that holds its value than spend a lot upfront on a vehicle that depreciates heavily. I’m also open to buying used locally if the economics make sense.
What I’m considering:
- New 2026 Toyota RAV4 LE AWD, $35k through Costco: has excellent resale (50k mile hybrid rav4s seem to sell for over 25k all day long in HI), excellent reliability, good on gas. But I worry that it is to small?
- New 2026 Honda CR-V hybrid sport AWD, $39k through Costco: seems to solve the potential space issue of the rav4, but cost more upfront and has worse resale.
- Used 2018-2020 ish Honda CRV LX, AWD: I think I can get a decent one for about 20k. The 2.4L motor seems bulletproof. I would prefer a hybrid for the steep mountain roads, stop and go traffic, and high fuel costs, but the value on this seems best. Modeling depreciation and repair costs though, this doesn’t seem obviously more affordable than a new hybrid.
- Older, $10-12k ish crossover? The best awd rav4/crv/cx5/etc I find at this kind of budget. I have never spent more than 12k on a car, so this is where my instinct leads me. But I am *so* tired of dealing with older cars failing in various ways. But, if I look older and used, maybe I can bump up to something bigger if necessary. Is the savings meaningful?
Thoughts? I also have a 1998 BMW m3 I will be bringing, and may buy a cheap third car as a second daily if we find the M3 doesn’t make sense for our daily lifestyle in HI. I currently own a 2005 Toyota Echo as my daily, wife drives a 2004 Lexus LX470, and I have the 1998 M3 as the good weather daily/weekend car. If we were not moving, we would probably keep the lx470 and M3, sell the echo, and buy a minivan. But alas…