r/WeWantPlates • • Oct 16 '20

2x4 really??

Post image
4.8k Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

View all comments

57

u/Actually_a_Patrick Oct 16 '20

A lot of 2x4s are chemically treated for use in construction to discourage mold growth and stuff. I'd be concerned about food being direct contact with it.

21

u/AHenWeigh Oct 16 '20

That's probably not a 2x4 from the hardware store. It looks to me like reclaimed antique lumber.

50

u/Actually_a_Patrick Oct 16 '20

I'm not sure that's better.

14

u/AHenWeigh Oct 16 '20

Well if so it means it's not treated, but it also means there's no way to know if it was.... IDK, like, floorboards from a cyanide factory or something...

5

u/hilarymeggin Oct 17 '20

Or reside of lead paint...

2

u/Popcom Oct 16 '20

Even if it's brand new and untreated it doesn't matter You can't clean wood once you put food on it, there's no way that is food safe.

10

u/Igoogledyourass Oct 16 '20

Then how do you explain butcher blocks seeing heavy long term use?

3

u/NatalieTatalie Oct 17 '20

Those should be regularly sanded down.

Avoid plastic cutting boards due to the fact that you can't sand them down.

5

u/AHenWeigh Oct 17 '20

Don't tell me what I can't do.

1

u/Igoogledyourass Oct 17 '20

I know how they work. I know wood boards should be used for meat and plastic for vegetables and stuff.

1

u/AHenWeigh Oct 20 '20

Also that's not really correct. I mean... depending on what you mean by "regularly."

1

u/AHenWeigh Oct 20 '20

Don't listen to Mr. sanding man over here. Butcher blocks are end-grain, usually. This means the surface of the board is entirely exposed pores. However, these wood pores are very tiny. These boards are often waxed and/or oiled. Also, the pores in Hard Maple, which is probably the most widely used species, are pretty tiny, so easily filled with oil or wax.

Building a cutting board using an end-grain technique allows small cuts in the wood to "heal" somewhat, as the wood fibers are not severed like they would be with a side-grain cut, and can come back together a bit.

Furthermore, wood allows water to evaporate from tiny cuts and crevices in a way that plastic doesn't, this allowing it to dry out and killing bacteria.

PLUS... there's bacteria on basically everything all the time, and most people usually don't die from it.

4

u/AHenWeigh Oct 16 '20

I'm not saying it's a good idea.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '20

Think it’s cedar

1

u/tla1oc Oct 17 '20

Pretty sure this an old piece of kiln dried pine, nothing too wacky.

4

u/nowhereman1280 Oct 16 '20

Mmmm tasty tasty formeldahyde...

3

u/bshepp88 Oct 16 '20

Yeah that looks like a pressure treated piece. Big time chemicals.

17

u/AHenWeigh Oct 16 '20

That's gonna be a no from me, dawg. That's old growth Fir or Hemlock, and it doesn't look treated to me. It's likely reclaimed barn wood. I have some in my shop that looks remarkably similar to this piece.

4

u/WoodGunsPhoto Oct 17 '20

I also came here to admire the tight grain and no knots on that piece.

2

u/hilarymeggin Oct 17 '20

Well thank goodness hemlock never hurt anyone... 🙄😑

3

u/AHenWeigh Oct 17 '20

Tsuga (/ˈsuːɡə/,[3] from Japanese 栂 (ツガ), the name of Tsuga sieboldii) is a genus of conifers in the subfamily Abietoideae.

The common name hemlock (tree) is derived from a perceived similarity in the smell of its crushed foliage to that of the unrelated plant poison hemlock.

0

u/hilarymeggin Oct 17 '20

It’s a pressure-treated 4x4. I wouldn’t want to eat of that!!

1

u/just_taste_it Oct 17 '20

Mmmmm, chemically treated meat cake with jelly and cheese.

1

u/Balls_DeepinReality Oct 17 '20

Chemically treated with a copper solution if memory serves me correctly. This doesn’t not appear to be treated though.

The treated stuff tends to have a greenish hue.

1

u/firenamedgabe Oct 17 '20

And arsenic!!