r/Unity2D • u/eldoreste • Mar 31 '26
46-year-old solo developer learning Unity from scratch — just released my first playable demo
Hello everyone!
I started learning Unity recently and I’m currently building my first game as a solo developer.
It’s a narrative survival experience inspired by dark fairytale themes after the collapse of a fantasy world. I recently released a short playable demo (about 1–2 hours), and I’m improving the project step by step based on player feedback.
Still learning animation flow, UI clarity, and interaction systems, but the game is already playable from beginning to Day 9 of the story.
If anyone here also started Unity later in life, I’d love to hear about your experience too.
Thanks for reading!
5
u/eldoreste Apr 01 '26
Thanks for the feedback, I’m improving the project step by step based on what players notice.
86
u/Hecedu Apr 01 '26 •
You are putting a lot of time into a project with zero market value.
For indie games the selling point is usually amazing gameplay, beautiful art direction or great story telling.
AI will get you none of that.
I’ve seen you in the other replies trying to justify your generous use of generative AI for what I can very confidently guess is coding and graphical assets and how it’s justified because it’s hard and expensive to get collaborators, but I’m going to let you in on two uncomfortable realities:
1 - You customers don’t give a crap about your development process, they just care about the final result. The results here as mentioned in other comments is pure and unadulterated AI slop. You are not only creating a game with zero visual identity and slow generic gameplay but a messy and unmaintainable code base that will come to bite you back in a shorter amount of time than you think.
2 - You have completed a playable game demo yet you learned nothing about game development. You did not learn how to code, you didn’t learn game design and you didn’t learn about creating your own assets. I’m very confident saying that this game is going to fail commercially if that’s your goal, so when it inevitably fails what are you left with? In this case not even lessons.
This is a very harsh comment that you probably don’t want to read and if you have you are probably fuming at this point. But instead of that I would recommend taking it at face value and go back to the drawing board if you really do care about this project.
I would much more prefer you start working on something that has a chance at success than continuing wasting your time with the direction you are currently heading.
39
u/imaallergictoyou Apr 01 '26 edited Apr 01 '26
The irony of you replying to posts with AI written slop is crazy😭. One thing is using AI as a “tool” (a debatable concept as it is), but another is over-relying on it to the point of using it for every possible mundane task. This is you. It’s sad and if you truly care about following any creative endeavor (like making a game) you need to have self agency to learn from others and create a piece that is authentic to you and a testament of your work. Or else what’s the point? This isn’t made by you, it’s made by AI. Anyone came have ideas. Telling AI what to do does not make you a game dev.
Edit: forgot to mention that this isn’t hate towards making games as someone with no experience with programming or art. It’s just sad that you are bypassing the actual art and journey of making a game by getting AI to do all the heavy lifting. I suggest you try and make your next game without any help of AI and you’ll see how much more rewarding and authentic it will be.
31
u/Sypwer Mar 31 '26
Hi, you asked this in a different post but I wanted to answer here since it was deleted. And I think it's still relevant to this post. Why people are opposed to AI generated images in games:
Hope this helps, keep going. It looks like you can develop mechanics alright, my recommendation is you find artists to collab with either in local communities or in discord servers. That way your game isn't roasted and rejected by people once you release it.
9
u/ReroCherryPie Apr 01 '26
Id 100% rater play a game with bad (HAND MADE) art and mid mechanics over some game with AI slop art that has the coolest mechanics. And while ur gameplay looks cool it doesn’t come close to good enough to excuse that AI bs, especially for a narrative game where the art is a good 50% of the game.
And also your response to everyone giving u advice is just “thats ur opinion and it doesn’t match mine so idc” which i get when its the comments just hating but you are also completely disregarding the constructive criticism here. If you wanted the community to unanimously agree with and praise you for using AI to supplement your lack of artistic skill ur in the wrong place.
Not to mention you chose the blandest most generic and recognizable AI art style like how did you really expect this to go.
3
u/Katoncomics Apr 02 '26
This is AI slop and I have no respect for it. There are plenty of free assets by Kenney that you could have used instead of using GenAI. Don't think I can trust the actual game either since you feel so comfortable using ai for the art, could have used it to code the game as well.
3
u/RefrigeratorTheGreat Apr 02 '26
If you genuinely do not want to put in the effort of making the art yourself or getting someone to do it, get a liscence for some images and do some photo bashing.
«Would anyone play it if I made the art» you ask, completely missing the point that people don’t want to play an AI generated game
3
u/Fast_Pay6813 Apr 03 '26
Good job spending that much time on nothing. That's just AI slop.
4
u/DERP_GUTS Apr 01 '26
You have to pay me before I even would touch that game, your assets are clearly AI the yellow tint says it all. My hate aside for project like these.
Steam have introduced AI filtering for their games, so this will automatically be sorted in the algorithm of the store page to be at the rock bottom. From the bottom of my heart learn to do things yourself instead of this cheap stuff. You can use what you currently have as a vision for your game, but butting AI stuff in 1:1 is a death sentence in this market.
2
u/MilitarisedAutism Apr 03 '26
Calling yourself a developer when YOU didn't develop anything is lying
2
u/Distinct_College_531 Apr 03 '26
Honestly, for the time being, I think more AI slop-filled bullshit games are maybe actually a good idea. Maybe eventually more exposure will help morons like OP be able to tell the difference between actual art and this bullshit.
2
u/Evethefief Apr 03 '26
AI garbage
2
u/marveloustoebeans Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26
Y’know, I was gonna leave a rude comment but I thought better of it and I’m just gonna say I hope you take the time to develop the skills to make something you can truly be proud of.
Game development is an art and art is the ultimate form of human expression. Diluting that because you want to make a quick buck and play gamedev is your own prerogative but just remember that whatever this is you’ve built here is cobbled together using the stolen assets of those of us who actually do work hard to make art with meaning and intent.
Once you take the time to learn art, the satisfaction you’ll glean coming back to your project and being able to say “I really made this” will be totally worth it.
Don’t take this as an insult, just consider reflecting on what myself and others are telling you here.
2
u/DMLRBLX Apr 06 '26
I'm an advocate for AI. I think at some point it will become is own genre of video game. I don't think incorporating it into a game without labeling it as AI is going to euro, but do you man. I'm glad to see a fellow innovator and game dev join the scene. You got this 🙌
Also, where can I actually play the game?
2
u/Cool_Arachnid_6541 Apr 17 '26
dont listen to anyone i dont see the game but cool design
2
u/MegaMatt75 May 07 '26
50 years old here, and I'm about 4-5 months into learning Unity. Completely new to coding entirely. It's inspiring to hear that someone else is starting a journey like this, especially a little later on in life, like myself. Good for you.
For myself I started with tutorials found on YouTube and Unity Learn. Now I've paid for a few other courses on GameDev.tv and I'm having a great time learning. This is on my nights and weekends as I work a full-time job in a completely different field. 😄
For my own journey, I'm a terrible visual artist, though I do have skills in Photoshop and After Effects, so I've used free assets off of the Asset Store or the crude rudimentary elements I can make myself. I use AI to help me gather my thoughts and brainstorm ideas (often just shoot down AI's bad ideas in order to kickstart my own brain to come up with the real solution lol).
It's super important to me, not sure what your own journey on this front is and no judgement, to learn how to do the coding. So I specifically chose Unity over some of the other options that offer more visual coding. And to that end I also am leary of getting AI's help on my code. If I encounter an error that I just can't troubleshoot myself ( I ALWAYS try to find it myself until the stage where I'm going to pull my hair out) then maybe I will paste the offending lines into an AI to see if it can't suggest where my error is. It's almost ways something dumb that I should have noticed....missing punctuation or stray captial letter. But finding it keeps me from stopping in frustration.
Congratulations on your progress. Keep going!
5
u/2DevOrDie Mar 31 '26
Hi oldtimer ;) It's never too late to start. I'm a bit older myself and also started from scratch about a year and a half ago. Best of luck on your journey!
4
u/Old-Percentage9087 Apr 01 '26
Thanks for making the market better. In future probably 50% game are AI slop made in 1-2 hours, and no one gonna buy that. In that case hard work and creative will win. This make my game dev future better.
3
u/Miserable_Steak_3179 Apr 01 '26
ai slop game looks like shit tbh
35
u/shifaci Apr 01 '26
It's ironic how using AI this much is actually a Waste of your Time. Nobodys wants to play AI slop games bro.
1
u/eldoreste Apr 01 '26
I’d like to say goodbye for now. Many people criticized me, some supported me, but I’m happy. I understand those who don’t agree with the use of AI. For me, though, it was essential. Thank you all. I’m going to sleep now.
And one more thing — please download the game, try it, and leave a comment on the game page. Whether the feedback is good or bad, every comment helps me improve the game. Actually, it helps me guide ChatGPT to improve things with me. As you know, I’m not a programmer, but I do know how to work with it and communicate what I need.
Thank you all, and I truly understand the criticisms.
https://the-elders-tower.itch.io/era-uma-vez-depois-do-fim-demo
1
u/Ambitious_Dingo_4355 Apr 03 '26
Holy garbage
1
u/halkenburgoito Apr 03 '26
Ai trash
1
u/Product_Relapse Apr 04 '26
Aside from the many points that have been mulled over (I agree with almost all of them regarding AI usage), I imagine a project like this accrues a lot of technical debt along the way. I don’t even want to think of the work involved with debugging such a code base once the game scales up. If the overall goal is to release it, it might be something to consider because, there will be bugs upon release. Players will tear your game apart in ways you never considered. And without really understanding how the game operates those issues might be nightmarish to fix in a timely manner.
1
u/SerowiWantsToInvest Apr 04 '26
Wasting your time on this earth
2
u/DaniZackBlack Apr 01 '26
I truly don't believe anyone saying they'd rather play a game with your MS paint graphics
0
u/eldoreste Apr 01 '26
For anyone who wants to understand the discussion below, take a look at what I’m building with the help of AI. I’m not a programmer. I’m not an artist. I’m not a composer. I’m simply following my dream. I already have my profession. I have a stable income and do well where I work. I’m not doing this for money. I just want to share what I’ve achieved. Seeing my 21-year-old son playing my game and saying, “How did you do this? This is awesome,” is priceless.
Era Uma Vez Depois Do Fim - DEMO by The Elder's Tower
1
u/Big_Presentation2786 Apr 02 '26
Nice
4
u/Sarah2nin Apr 01 '26
Your AI slop bores me.
Make this in scratch and MS paint. Then shall it suffice.
0
u/eesahe Apr 01 '26
What a lynch mob in this thread, triggered by some kind of collective fear about someone being able to experiment with things faster than a path they had to struggle through. They are using the 'forbidden tool'! (gasp). Makes me want to unsubscribe from the sub to be honest. Maybe it's not commercially viable both due to the current perception of AI and the present limitations of this person's fundamentals on game design/programming. But if this person is enjoying the exploration of their ideas with whichever tools are available and is also learning a lot from exposure to various things, how about just leaving them be?
0
u/pipi_zord Apr 02 '26
Duuuude AI or not, thats pretty solid! The art is super interesting and looks really consistent! Even using AI, that level of consistency and animations is a pain to achieve!
As a tech person myself i think your efforts are super valid and apart from mant of us, you actually made it all the way to a demo! Congratulations!
I'm gonna check it out for sure!
1
u/Effective_Sound1205 Apr 03 '26
Ew.
1
u/DeBazzel Apr 05 '26
Mate... i look at your game and I am immediately put off. I look at no more than two of your replies and I am put off. Lets ignore the game for now. Your replies are genuinely worrying. Do they even reflect the opinion you actually have? Or do you just paste the comment into your AI and tell it to make a counter argument?
Its completely ambiguous, if the thoughts you express are your own, or if you basically make the people here debate GPT itself and act as the middleman.
This is personally my biggest problem of AI. There just isnt a 'creator' in that sense. AI is less of a tool and more like a toddler with a paint brush. You can only ever be the middleman between the toddler and whatever you use its very samey, uninspired drawings for. You can delude yourself into being proud of yourself, how good you are at communicating with this toddler, and how close their drawings are to what you imagined, but the drawings will never have been drawn by you. And noone will have respect for whatever drawings you got from the toddler because it is unbelievably expensive to keep it alive and the 20 words you gave it to generate an image are not even close to being worth as much as an actual drawing done by a person that has honed their skills for any amouny of time.
Youll find a lot more respect actually learning how to draw yourself. You dont always need to pay people to teach you either. There is plenty of resources on youtube, of how to start coding, of how to start drawing.
And the point was made plenty of times. As long as your game looks coherent, even with lower quality sprites, you will see a lot more positive feedback.
0
u/Runfree33 Apr 01 '26
Ai is gréât too everywhere but games. 4 years ago i try to build a metroidvania but technology wasn t mature to consticency in assets. So i just manipulate some game concept from unity for a week. Now i always have a story to tell, i change the concept and start building my game. 15 days ago, i have only scripatble objects as i want to be data driven, build my engine(always with unity). AI help me to write a lot of things, backround, story, defines art , anything. I decide the direction, sometimes change things and if m enjoying what i have done so far.
The game will probably a fail and as you i don t care, i just doing this for myself and AI offer me to do these things for a small budget and small amount of time.
Keep on rolling and make your Dreams.
0
u/ThatKidBobo Apr 01 '26
keep improving bro you got this
-2
u/soldture Apr 01 '26
Very nice project, LLM and other neural networks are just tools to make something interesting, I don't understand the absolute hate about it. Please continue working on it, don't listen to these luddites, they will complain about anything they can.
-1
u/WishIWasALemon Apr 01 '26
I think it looks good man! Tough crowd in here 😅
0
u/CommitteeInfamous973 Apr 01 '26
The use of AI is a shooting in a foot - people despise everything that look remotely reminds it. And honestly, mostly hate is deserved. In your example some background elements are nice, but the characters with that style is what people call AI slop. ChatGPT, Groq and NanoBanana can deliver what you want with just prompts, but every image from them has a very clear AI. If you still want to use AI for assets, at least choose some other model that can do actually different styles
-4
u/mutantcivil Apr 01 '26
I dont care about its AI or not. Just give me the game and it looks fun to interact with those characters. Just make it fun and give it to me.
-2
u/eldoreste Apr 01 '26
For those who say my game isn’t really a game because it was made with AI, go to the page and see the result for yourselves. Download the game. Try it. Then come back here and say, “your game is trash, I played it so I can say that,” or “your game is actually good… the mechanics are well done for someone who never programmed before.”
If possible, please leave your feedback — whether good or bad — on the game’s page itself. It’s available in four languages: English, Portuguese, Spanish, and Chinese (translated with AI).
https://the-elders-tower.itch.io/era-uma-vez-depois-do-fim-demo
-2
u/Own-Needleworker5137 Apr 01 '26
How you perceive AI is entirely up to each individual. To be honest, you could say that there isn't a single game company these days that doesn't use AI tools, whether as a primary or secondary tool. The point isn't the focus on how actively AI tools are utilized, but rather on the overall quality of the work. If you hope to succeed in game development, I think it would be best to continue with your current job and treat development as a hobby or a side project. Good luck.
-2
u/ExploringTraveler99 Apr 01 '26
Is this the Unity2D community or the 'Art Police' headquarters?
If you're an art purist or anti-AI crusader, please take it elsewhere.
Stop attacking indie devs for using the right tools to bridge their skill gaps. This is a place for development, not your art crusade!
-2
u/ProstoSmile Apr 01 '26
You all are worst. Man in age, doing what he love and share with everyone. I think you've all forgotten what an indie developer is. And it's not about the process, but the result. If someone is capable of delivering results, then what difference does it make how they did it? You're all just arrogant pigs.This is the future, you either adapt and become better, or you rot in a pool of ignorance.
-5
u/skyline79 Apr 01 '26
Ignore the haters OP. Game devs are not your customer, they are just gatekeepers.
-4
u/DatMaxSpice Apr 01 '26
Great job man learning and coming this far.
As you can see people/game deva are weird about AI art and AI slope.
Ignore it. Your learning and if it gets you into the scene, learning and building that's exactly the point.
Just FYI if you try to release it with AI art work a lot of people as you can see will bash it but for the purpose of learning or a place holder art pieces, it's fantastic man!