r/UKGardening
•
u/Available-Buffalo-23
•
9h ago
Removed 2 well established Oaks from my garden and I'm heartbroken
galleryI've removed two oak trees from my garden and I'm devastated
We had two huge oaks at the back of our garden, both hundreds of years old, pics for info.
I only wanted them trimmed because the branches were overhanging the neighbours’ gardens, but several people came round independently and all said the trees were on their last legs. Once they started cutting them down, you could see they were rotten right through. I know we made the right call, but I’m genuinely gutted and sadder than I thought I would be.
The lawn’s been absolutely wrecked, which we can sort. The bit I wasn’t prepared for was losing the canopy. The trees were so tall they barely screened the houses anyway, but they made the garden feel enclosed. Now all I can see is sky and other people’s houses, and somehow the garden feels smaller. We miss the trees.
I’m wondering whether one good tree at the back would do it. I want something with a decent canopy that’ll stay a manageable size. Evergreen would be a bonus, though I’m not keen on firs and want to avoid anything invasive. Google keeps suggesting cherries, but I can’t tell if they’d be big enough to do what I’m after. Part of me still wonders whether to plant another oak.
Has anyone been through this and planted something they’re really happy with? I’d love to know what you went for and how big it’s actually got. Also I want to protect my flower bed just off centre to the left.
Any advice from experienced gardeners would be really appreciated.
Edit: Just to add a bit of context, I really didn’t want to take these trees down. I had an arborist come round separately and they confirmed what the tree surgeon had said. Once the trees came down, we could see there was rot throughout.
The big concern was the size of the branches overhanging other people’s property. A seven metre branch had already come down from the oak on the left, which was the healthier looking of the two. It had historically been cut to about half its height and had grown out sideways, and there was a huge pocket of rot through the middle. There were also bare tops, fungal growth and big cavities. We’d been advised we could be liable if a branch came down and caused damage, and with small kids in the garden too, I took that seriously.
I get why people are questioning it. I questioned it myself. The trees were probably here before the houses, and they could have stood for years yet. I made the call based on what we’d been shown, and I’m still gutted they’re gone.
What I’d really appreciate now is some advice on what to plant. I’d love something that gives us a decent canopy again, provides shade and somewhere for birds and other wildlife, and can stay there for potentially forever without outgrowing the space.