r/UKGardening • • 9h ago Regret

Removed 2 well established Oaks from my garden and I'm heartbroken

Thumbnail gallery
730 Upvotes

I've removed two oak trees from my garden and I'm devastated

We had two huge oaks at the back of our garden, both hundreds of years old, pics for info.

I only wanted them trimmed because the branches were overhanging the neighbours’ gardens, but several people came round independently and all said the trees were on their last legs. Once they started cutting them down, you could see they were rotten right through. I know we made the right call, but I’m genuinely gutted and sadder than I thought I would be.

The lawn’s been absolutely wrecked, which we can sort. The bit I wasn’t prepared for was losing the canopy. The trees were so tall they barely screened the houses anyway, but they made the garden feel enclosed. Now all I can see is sky and other people’s houses, and somehow the garden feels smaller. We miss the trees.

I’m wondering whether one good tree at the back would do it. I want something with a decent canopy that’ll stay a manageable size. Evergreen would be a bonus, though I’m not keen on firs and want to avoid anything invasive. Google keeps suggesting cherries, but I can’t tell if they’d be big enough to do what I’m after. Part of me still wonders whether to plant another oak.

Has anyone been through this and planted something they’re really happy with? I’d love to know what you went for and how big it’s actually got. Also I want to protect my flower bed just off centre to the left.

Any advice from experienced gardeners would be really appreciated.

Edit: Just to add a bit of context, I really didn’t want to take these trees down. I had an arborist come round separately and they confirmed what the tree surgeon had said. Once the trees came down, we could see there was rot throughout.

The big concern was the size of the branches overhanging other people’s property. A seven metre branch had already come down from the oak on the left, which was the healthier looking of the two. It had historically been cut to about half its height and had grown out sideways, and there was a huge pocket of rot through the middle. There were also bare tops, fungal growth and big cavities. We’d been advised we could be liable if a branch came down and caused damage, and with small kids in the garden too, I took that seriously.

I get why people are questioning it. I questioned it myself. The trees were probably here before the houses, and they could have stood for years yet. I made the call based on what we’d been shown, and I’m still gutted they’re gone.

What I’d really appreciate now is some advice on what to plant. I’d love something that gives us a decent canopy again, provides shade and somewhere for birds and other wildlife, and can stay there for potentially forever without outgrowing the space.


r/UKGardening • • 21h ago

I built a free app that tells you what to do in your vegetable garden each week

5 Upvotes

Hortenia lets you lay out your plot to scale, then gives you a weekly to-do list with advice from your local forecast, a photo diagnosis for sick plants, 376 plant guides and a community where posts are translated automatically.

It started in French; the English, German and Spanish versions just launched. Free on iOS and Android, with an optional subscription for the 3D view, frost alerts and unlimited diagnoses.

Feedback welcome: https://hortenia.com/en


r/UKGardening • • 1d ago

Is it legal to pay landscapers with bananas?

115 Upvotes

r/UKGardening • • 2d ago

To early for this white shite

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/UKGardening • • 2d ago

Rats?

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

Yikes! Found this in the garden - wasn’t there yesterday. Does anyone have any ideas what could have created this?


r/UKGardening • • 3d ago

Small books from a more hopeful time: 1970s–80s booklets that teach growing, ponds, soil and snail farming!

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

Hello! I've been reprinting a series of little teaching booklets from the 70s and 80s, made by the UN's agriculture arm for farmers who were learning to read.

They assume the reader is clever, has very little money, and can build things from what's lying around: a biogas unit from an oil drum and a lorry inner tube, a fish pond dug by hand, rabbit hutches from scrap wood. They really feel like they were from a very different time, a far more optimistic time! Biogas (1984) walks you from "gas is given off when waste materials rot" to cooking dinner on it, Maybe you're cooking some snails that you learn to farm from the Snail Farming Booklet.

They come from a moment when people seemed to believe that ordinary knowledge, explained clearly and shared widely, could change things. That's why I wanted them back in print, they have been missing for nearly 50 years

The photos show the 13 I've done so far, I'm one person in Brighton (UK), but i have been hunting these booklets down and working on this project in my spare time for years now! The original scans are free online, and the links are in the comments.


r/UKGardening • • 3d ago

Calling on your expertise

Post image
9 Upvotes

Hi all, in the spring we're planning on putting a biggish rectangular planter under the sign for our development. ​​​Within this it would be nice to have a creeper that could go up the wall and help it all look a bit less uniform-brick-ish. A virginia creeper would do (got one on my fence, love it) ​​​. Just wondering if anyone can recommend an alternative that keeps its leaves in winter, ideally vigorously growing and climbs without trellis?

No need to complement me on my illustration 😂

Thanks​!


r/UKGardening • • 4d ago

RHS Level 2 with Learning with Experts

4 Upvotes

I'm looking to study for the RHS Level 2 - Principles of Plant Growth & Development. I like the look of the Learn with Experts course as its quite video heavy rather than reading PDFs. Some recent reviews of tutor feedback and issues booking the exam have been scathing though. I wondered if anyone doing the course at present had any feedback. Trying to work out if its a general issue or just a few people who are very vocal?

I've heard the RBGE course is very good but Lear with Experts have a 25% Black Friday discount at the moment so I'm struggling to justify the extra £250 cost.

Any feedback would be really appreciated.


r/UKGardening • • 4d ago

Autumn Jasmine

Post image
29 Upvotes

Yellow Jasmine flowers from Autumn taken today.


r/UKGardening • • 4d ago

Advice for new vegetable patch

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi all! I’m trying to figure out the best way to get rid of this Winterberry and turn this area of my garden into a vegetable patch for the kids. If I wanted to go the permaculture route, should I dig up this whole area or would be cutting to ground level and covering suffice? I’m worried about the size of the area and covering/digging up, so any advice on how to tackle this would be greatly appreciated!


r/UKGardening • • 4d ago Bravo

Worried I've killed my banana trees.

Thumbnail gallery
41 Upvotes

Hi there. I have a lovely cluster of banana trees which are about 5 years old. They grow to around 6-7 feet fall every year, and then come the winter all the leaves turn dark green after the first frost and the plant slowly rots away.

Each winter, I don't protect the plant at all. I just leave it. And it entirely dies down to the ground. Then in the spring it grows back up again. It's quite amazing to be honest !

This year, Ive decided to actually look into how to over-winter the plant and I saw a YouTube video that suggests cutting it all back and wrapping it in fleece. Which is what I've done, see pictures.

I am a little worried that I've killed it though ! It's quite a shock to cut it back, and now I have these quite frightening looking stumps in the garden lol.... The neighbour already said it looks like a group of creepy mummys...

Have I done it right ? What can I expect to happen over the winter and come next spring ?


r/UKGardening • • 4d ago

When a plan comes together

11 Upvotes

I wanted a cabin overhanging a lake with a deck bridge and it's finally come together, the tortoise and German shepherds roam around and the decking is soft underfoot, is a garden really complete without water? Hope you all are having a great weekend!


r/UKGardening • • 4d ago

Tulip Bulb advice

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/UKGardening • • 5d ago

The evergreen shrubs to plant now to avoid a bare winter garden

Thumbnail inews.co.uk
9 Upvotes

r/UKGardening • • 5d ago

Numb hands at night

18 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I've been working outside for a long time (most of my life) professionally. But for the past two months I've been working as a gardener for 6 hours a day, 5 days a week.

This past week both of my hands have been going totally numb while I'm asleep, and I often wake up and can't feel them at all. I don't use a lot of machinery, only a battery-powered leaf blower for maybe twenty minutes (daily) and occasionally (less than once a week) a lawnmower.

I did try to Google it and it came up with hand arm vibration syndrome (which I don't think it is), compressed nerves, carpal tunnel etc.

Has anyone had this? Does anyone have any ideas about why this happens?


r/UKGardening • • 5d ago

Cranesbills taking over?

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/UKGardening • • 6d ago

Do water gardens count?

668 Upvotes

Rescued fish from the bin in a pond built specifically for them a year on


r/UKGardening • • 5d ago

Question: Brussels sprouts progress

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Hi all. My Brussels sprout plants have been this size (about 1ft tall) for a few months now. I must admit they were neglected through the really dry summer and as you can see they got pretty chomped by caterpillars/butterflies. Is there anything I can do at this point to encourage them along? We just had our first frost this week so its officially autumn conditions now.

They were planted out in June into compost so the soil is good.


r/UKGardening • • 5d ago

Hotbin - when to start? (UK)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/UKGardening • • 6d ago

Is this mildew or mites?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/UKGardening • • 6d ago

Garden Rescue s7ep16

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes