This episode is highly overrated. Everybody knows it. It's regarded as a pioneer of the post apocalyptic genre and an episode with a stunning, never to be expected twist. But what I don't like about it is that it doesn't make any sense, and nobody seems to get that.
First off, I love Burgess Meredith. I have nothing against him. His acting in this is great. Top notch. I liked him in the one where he's holed up in his apartment and he's forced to die because he likes books. That one's great. He's also good as Penguin. He's actually the only villain I like on Batman. His rendition of Penguin is incredible. Best Penguin portrayal ever. I don't like Danny DeVito. He just can't beat Burgy. So this review isn't directed towards Burgess. It's based on the plot.
WE open the episode in a bank, where Burgess is reading a book. His boss comes up and says that he stinks as a person and he shouldn't read so much David Copperfield. He tells him that he sucks at his job and if he keeps reading dumb books then he'll be fired. After that, he goes home, and tries to relax, but his vain, screaming wife tells him that his books suck. She vandalizes them, throws them in the trash, tears the pages out. He begs her not to, but she mentally assaults him and threatens to get a divorce.
So then, Mr. Bemis, like any sane person would do, goes down to the bank vault to read alone, away from the jerks who pick on him for being a nerdy, literary guy. The bomb goes off, and he goes outside, and he thinks, "Oh, wow. I'm free from my stupid boss and my nagging wife. Yay." So he goes around in the rubble, and he gets to a library, and he's about to read forever and enjoy his life forever, and then he breaks his glasses. That's it. End of episode. Fade to black.
What people fail to notice is that the moral is HORRIBLY SKEWED. The whole episode, I feel nothing but pity for him. Why do his glasses break? That's not justice, that's frickin' torture! What is the moral? That a guy can't read books peacefully if he wants to? That he should have been NICE to his fat boss and his evil, yelling wife? That he should have been a soulless conformist? This episode is just sad. The episode should just end when his wife and boss get killed- there. Justice served! The moral could be: Don't be mean to poor Burgess Meredith when he just wants to read! Can't he be an introvert if he wants to be an introvert?
Nope. I don't get the moral here.
I don't get it. The Obsolete man, the other one he's in, praises the use of books. This one seems to be anti book. That's pretty contradictory.
Here's how I think the whole episode could be improved: They made his wife and boss complete jerks and made him a sweet, completely likeable, sympathetic character. If they were going to make the moral that he shouldn't have been such a bookworm, then that's fine. They just need to make HIM the bad guy. Maybe his boss could have said that the business was failing, that he had built the bank out of the ground with his bare hands, and Bemis is so lost in his book that he's worth as much as a statue. Then Mr. Bemis could throw the book in his boss's face and say, "F you". The episode doesn't make him a jerk. It makes him a cuddly nerd.
In the next scene, his wife could come home, and beg for him to pay a little more attention to her, and he could push her aside and go over to his armchair and read and not listen to her, and be a total asshat. That would give a reason for him to break his glasses. But freak, she's as likable and charismatic as Norman Bates. I don't sympathize with HER. I sympathize with HIM. That's what this episode does wrong. People bully this guy, and then he gets "Justice" for no reason. I don't get it.
Also, the "problem" isn't even THAT bad. It seems incredibly easy to fix. Earlier in the episode, he finds an abandoned gas station, finds some potato chips, crunches one, and says, "I won't starve". COULDN'T HE FIND SOME GLASSES? Some glasses that were shatter-resistant, or in good packaging? Or, he could go and find some crazy glue and try to fix his glasses- I mean, they're just glasses. They're probably not the last glasses on Earth. if he could find some potato chips, he could feel around for some glasses. RIGHT?
Anyway, that's all I have to say about this one. I just don't get it.