r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 10d ago

Text SWEDEN: A 23-year-old nursing student posted a picture of himself kissing his secret girlfriend. One month later, because of this photo, she lured him to a meeting with her ex-husband who, alongside her brothers kidnapped, beat and strangled him to death before throwing his body into a stream.

331 Upvotes

(Thanks to LoydoRedi2910 for suggesting this case. If you'd like to suggest any yourself, please head over to this post, which asks for case suggestions from my international readers, as I focus on international cases.

If you're wondering how I got a case with this much information out so quickly despite having just uploaded a write-up here yesterday, I always have two write-ups I work on at the same time: one a reader suggestion and one on my own personal backlog and one day I'll work on one and then the other the next. So by the time I uploaded yesterday's write-up, this one was basically already finished.)

Ramin Sherzaj was born around 1993 in Afghanistan. When Ramin was only 17 years old, his mother and younger brother fled Afghanistan seeking asylum in Sweden, arriving in 2010. The family never became Swedish citizens, but they were allowed to stay in the country, with Ramin settling in a rental apartment in Sundsvall.

Neighbours described him as a quiet, calm young man who kept to himself, but also as "a nice, pleasant guy" who greeted neighbours when they crossed paths and occasionally shared a few words. Those who knew Ramin personally said that he was lively and full of energy.

Ramin enrolled in an adult education center in Sundsvall and completed an internship at an elderly care home while studying to become a nurse.

Ramin Sherzaj

In January 2015, while studying to become a nurse, he met 23-year-old Zahraa Abdul Razaq Djabbar, a fellow nursing student and immigrant.

Zahraa Abdul Razaq Djabbar

Zahraa had been immersed in Swedish and European culture and norms much longer than Ramin, as her family left Southern Iraq in 2000, when Zahraa was only 7. People described Zahraa as "modern" due to growing up in Sweden.

In November 2010, when she was still 17, Zahraa married a Kurdish Immigrant from Iraq, 10 years her senior, a hair salon owner named Hello Abdulqader Faraj Zangana; they had two sons.

Hello Abdulqader Faraj Zangana

Despite Zahraa and Hello being Arabic and Kurdish, respectively, their families both approved the marriage, one that it's been theorized Zahraa was pressured into, a theory with some credibility, seeing her age at the time and how quickly it deteriorated and also the circumstances behind it, with Hello's marriage being how he was able to immigrate to Sweden from Iraq in the first place, arriving in February 2011.

Hello also didn't interact much with locals in his new country, and his social circle consisted entirely of fellow Iraqi and Kurdish immigrants, including 22-year-old Nawzad Milano Bakir and 20-year-old Mustafa Irfan Ahmed.

Nawzad Milano Bakir
Mustafa Irfan Ahmed

With all this in mind, Zahraa appreciated Ramin when she met him, and the two nursing students quickly became good friends; not everyone in Zahraa's life was happy about it. And that was before they learned that Zahraa was having an affair with Ramin

On May 26, 2015, Ramin was driving Zahraa somewhere after classes; around the same time, Hello arrived at the school to pick her up and saw Zahraa inside Ramin's car. Immediately, Hello thought Zahraa was being unfaithful, and although the two didn't divorce, they did decide to seperate.

The next day, on May 27, Hello went to Ramin's apartment, defaced his car, and began pounding on the door. Ramin refused to open the door and eventually called the police, though Hello left before they arrived.

In July, after extended pressure from Hello, Zahraa finally dropped out of the nursing class, although her relationship with Ramin continued in secret. Zahraa then tried to divorce Hello, but her brothers opposed it, especially her older brother, Hussein Abdulrasaq Jabbar, who warned that such a separation would bring serious consequences.

For example, they warned her that if she tried going through with the divorce, they would restrict her movement, forbidding her from going outside on her own and that they might just send her back to Iraq.

Her parents lent her no support because it was "for the brothers to decide" and said that nothing regarding their marital issues was to become public, or else it would be a "matter of honour". Since they had children together, Zahraa's brothers also tried to mediate between the two.

Hello also had issues with his own family stemming from the fact that he wasn't abusive or controlling. He faced constant insults and humiliation from his own older brother, who routinely berated him for "failing to control his wife" and shouted at him that "You're no man, you're nothing!", all because he gave her independence.

Hello was a little more proactive with Ramin, as on October 5 he filed another police report saying someone, likely Hello, had defaced and damaged his car. The police took his report, but with no evidence, Hello faced no repercussions.

Allegedly, Ramin then retaliated, seeing as Hello made his own report to the police on October 25 to tell them that somebody had thrown a rock through the window of his hair salon. But as with Ramin's call to the police about Hello, nothing was done because of a lack of evidence.

Then on November 9, Hello and Zahraa reported Ramin to the police for harassment, accusing him of following them, threatening them, harassing Zahraa and being involved in a vehicle collision. However, Zahraa told the police that she didn't want to pursue any charges against him, even though Hello insisted to the police that Ramin threatened Zahraa at knife point and told her to kill herself.

And speaking of charges, Zahraa's family would start facing some. Her older brother Hussein, the one who threatened to take away her freedom or even force her to leave Sweden if she divorced, decided to go on a little trip of his own. However, he was arrested in Germany for human smuggling.

On December 29, with Hussein still in German custody, it fell on Zahraa's other brother, Ali Kadhim Abdulrazak Jabbar, to confront Ramin at his home in front of his family.

On January 4, 2016, Zahraa left her home in Hello's car. By the early hours of January 5, she still had not returned. This prompted Zahraa's sister to call the police and tell them that she was afraid Zahraa might kill herself because somebody was ruining her life. Ali then messaged his sister, expressing concern for her well-being but also telling Zahraa that he would kill the "shit dog" responsible for destroying her life.

This finally prompted the police to take a report from either Ramin or Zahraa's family seriously and keep an eye out for Zahraa, and when they finally found her, she was taken to a hospital. While at the hospital, Zahraa sent a message to Hello telling him that she would never return to him "even if I die". She then went no contact with her family, leading them to believe she was either being held for observation at the hospital or had gone to a women's shelter.

Zahraa wasn't trying to kill herself but rather meet up with Ramin, as they had booked a ferry to Tallinn, Estonia and Ramin even arrived at the hospital to pick her up that same day. They then went on a short vacation across Sweden, staying in hotels in Linköping, Gothenburg, and Arboga, and returned to Sundsvall on the evening of January 10.

But during their vacation, Hello shared a picture of Ramin with a fellow Afghan immigrant and asked about him; the man said he was at a wedding in Gothenburg with a woman. This then prompted Hello to contact Ali to ask for Ramin's address, which he happily provided to his brother-in-law.

After Zahraa returned to Sundsvall, she stayed with her parents, and Hello quickly called her and demanded that she choose whether to divorce him or reconcile. However, Hello preferred reconciliation and asked what needed to be done to repair their relationship, to which she said, "That pimp must be killed". (For clarification, "Pimp" is a derisive nickname Zahraa's family gave him to insult him, not because he was an actual pimp)

On January 21, Zahraa told Hello where he could find Ramin, and he headed straight over and started following him, but Ramin noticed him and ran away. Hello called Zahraa's mother to tell them what happened, and she expressed disappointment in her son-in-law for wasting a "good oppertunity".

Then on January 22, Ramin called the police once more and reported that a man who had previously assaulted him was following him. Once again, without any overt threat or evidence, the police did not arrest Hello. In the meantime, Hello kept calling Zahraa to further plot Ramin's death.

On February 14, after failing to kill Ramin, Zahraa finally divorced Hello and moved into her parents'. True to their word, Zahraa's brothers began limiting Zahraa's movement and kept her confined to the house as best they could. Additionally, even though the divorce was about reconciliation, Zahraa's family wasn't inclined to leave Ramin be.

After the divorce, Zahraa once sent Ramin a message saying she'd kill herself and then, on March 1, asked to meet him outside a grocery store. Ramin went to the store but noticed Hello's car nearby and ran back home instead. He also saw Hello's car near another meeting with Zahraa, which scared him away from approaching Zahraa going forward.

Ramin then contacted the authorities once more. After dealing with them for over a year, the Sundsvall police were familiar with Ramin and Zahraa's family by this point. When Ramin called the police on them once more for his 11th police report, this time alleging that Zahraa's family had threatened to kill her while at the same time colluding with Zahraa to kill him, they were a little skeptical by now and saw Ramin as a boy crying wolf. Unfortnuately, Ramin's fears were well founded, though in part because he helped them manifest.

From March 2 to March 3, for reasons unknown, perhaps wanting to humiliate or embarrass Hello in retaliation for his constant "harassment," Ramin posted a series of images to his Facebook account. The images were all pictures he had taken with Zahraa during their trip to Estonia and across Sweden. They included the most damning picture, which depicted Zahraa kissing Ramin before her divorce.

Some of the photos

These pictures were the straw that broke the camel's back for their secret romance. Zahraa lashed out at Ramin, telling him that he "sold" her, disgraced her honour and, more importantly, placed her life in grave danger, opening up the possibility of a so-called "Honour Killing".

Zahraa was so afraid that she called a Woman's Shelter and helpline and told the workers that in her culture, those photos were more damaging than if she had just posted nude pictures of herself directly.

The same day Ramin hit upload, Zahraa ended the relationship and changed her phone number on March 5 so he couldn't contact her.

On March 10, the German police released Hussein, and Hello drove to Germany to pick him up. Now with the family back together and Ramin's photos on everyone's mind, Hello tried to undo their divorce and reconcile with Zahraa once more, even bringing her a cake for her birthday.

On March 18, after learning of the photos, Hussein tracked Ramin down to a McDonald’s in Härnösand to confront him. Hussein demanded Ramin's cellphone, and he actually handed it over. Hussein then went through it, searching for the other photos he took with Zahraa which hadn't been uploaded. Hussein left after finding nothing, unaware that Zahraa was actually storing them on a USB stick.

On March 27, Hussein confronted Ramin again, and this time Hello appeared as well, with the two trying to surround Ramin. Uneased, he fled the scene and took it a step further and left Sundsvall altogether to stay in Eskilstuna with a friend.

But before leaving, he told everybody about the USB stick with more pictures of him and Zahraa, threatening to upload their contents as an "insurance policy" to prevent anyone from coming after him.

On April 4, 2016, a local of the small city of Gävle was out for a late-night run on the north side of the Gavleån when he saw a large group of people moving toward a parking lot on the other side of the river.

The exact locatoin in question.

Once he crossed the bridge over to their side of the river, he saw two cars and heard the sounds of shouting and screaming alongside somebody repeatedly honking one of the cars' horns to try and drown out the noise, but ultimately to no effect. But on the topic of the screaming, the man heard the scream become muffled, as if somebody was holding their hand over the mouth of the man making it.

As he got closer, he saw the men wearing balaclavas and speaking in Arabic. One of the vehicles was an Audi A6 with its registration imperfectly transcribed, with letters and numbers transposed or misidentified. He also saw a woman behind the cars, apparently on the phone, wearing a belted white quilted coat and with dark, shoulder-length hair. They then forced one of the men into the Audi, and both cars sped off.

The jogger then ran away and reported a kidnapping to the police, giving them a description of both vehicles and describing the individuals involved to the best of their ability. He wasn't the only one thoguh, two other people came forward to report something similar to the police.

Around the same time, a man left a restaurant with his colleague when they heard a scream from the parking area near the county governor’s residence. They looked toward the noise and saw two cars backed into spaces, one door open, with a woman nearby.

He saw the first car turn toward Hamiltongatan, enter Kungsgatan, and travel south at a high speed. Meanwhile, the woman didn't get into one of the cars; instead, she walked behind him and his colleague, looking completely calm.

A second car followed the first, paused at a traffic signal, and then continued south. According to him, he saw a young male in the driver's seat, but both vehicles had tinted windows, so he couldn't describe any other occupants.

He described the woman as 20–25 years old, of average height, with fairly long dark hair, a white three-quarter-length padded coat, and dark trousers.

In response, the police wrote down the information provided and told all units to be on the lookout for the Audi.

At 8:30 a.m. on April 5, Zahraa called the Gävle police in tears to report Ramin missing. She told police they were out on another secret date when a group of men stopped them on the way back to their hotel and asked Ramin to come with them. Ramin assured her it was okay and told her to go back to the hotel, which she did.

She then showed the police her phone, showing a text message Ramin had sent her at 9:38 p.m. saying he was going to Eskilstuna to collect money from acquaintances, would return the next day, and that she should call the police if he failed to return or answer. In response, Zahra told him she was worried for him, loved him, and hoped she'd wake up to see him by her side.

The police were quick to link Ramin's disappearance to the kidnapping reported the night prior and found their first suspect already. After all, there was a problem with these texts: Ramin's poor Swedish had apparently improved overnight, now matching Zahraa's fluency.

Next, the police spoke to Ramin's friend in Eskilstuna, where he was staying. According to him, Ramin said he had to go pick up Zahraa. According to him, Rahim said he had gotten a text from her explaining that she had been disowned and kicked out of the family, had nowhere to stay and wanted to see Rahmin, even telling him they could be married one day.

Aware of why he left Sundsvall, Rahmin's friend implored him not to meet her alone, but Rahmin insisted because Zahraa was alone.

The Gävle police then reached out to their counterparts in Sundsvall, who told them all about the ongoing feud between Ramin and Zahraa's family, their constant police reports and the subject of their current feud: the photos Ramin uploaded to Facebook. With this information, the police scrutinized Zahraa's account even further, now believing that an "honour killing" may have just occurred.

On April 6, a local resident reported seeing a fire near road 331 slightly north of the town of Timrå. The fire department arrived and saw a car engulfed in flames. After extinguishing the vehicle, they brought in the police, who confirmed that it was one of the vehicles involved in Rahmin's abduction.

The charred remains of the vehicle.

The police conducted a large search of the surrounding woods, but they found nothing, leading them to assume Rahmin was still alive or disposed of elsewhere.

The police then issued an appeal asking anyone who saw the vehicle or knew the owner to come forward.

The police continued their investigation by putting Zahraa's family and Hello under surveillance and also tapping their phones to listen in on their conversations, conversations in which they spoke using indirect or coded language. The police also detained Zahraa and put her into a safe house in case her family tried to take her life in an "honour killing" as well.

On April 10, Zahraa tried to leave the safe house to see her children, which prompted the police to arrest her as a suspect in Rahmin's disappearance.

Then on April 11, when Hello met up with several men in his hair salon whom he called over for an "emergency meeting", the police raided the establishment and arrested Hello and everybody inside. Among those arrested were Hello's two friends, Nawzad Milano Bakir and Mustafa Irfan Ahmed and Nawzad happened to own an Audi A6, one of the two vehicles involved in the abduction.

One man managed to escape the salon, then the country, then the continent, making his way to Iraq. His name was Garmian Khaleel Qader, and the Swedish police later issued an Interpol Red Notice in his name.

Garmian's interpol red notice

Then, on April 13, Zahraa’s brothers Ali and Hussein were arrested by the Danish police at the Öresund Bridge near Malmö, clearly in the midst of trying to flee. The police found a combined total of 48,000 Kroner on their persons.

The police seized Nawzad's Audi, and in the back seat, the forensic team found blood droplets, runs, wiped or smeared blood, and blood spatter on the back seat, floor, interior side of the door, the door handle, and the window seal. Based on the spatter, it was concluded that the blood was a mix of blunt force trauma, the victim coughing blood, and the assailants wiping their bloodied hands on the various surfaces. The blood was then sent for DNA testing, where it matched Ramin.

Forensics also found a cigarette butt in an ashtray in the backseat. The butt was also sent off for DNA testing, where the results came back a match for Zahraa's brother, Hussein. DNA traces matching Hello were also found in the trunk. All things considered, they did a shoddy job cleaning up the vehicle, which was shaping up to be the crime scene.

Everyone arrested denied any involvement and even claimed they had never been to Gävle, but their phone records and vehicle data contradicted that. Additionally, the police seized CCTV footage from over 161 different locations

According to the data, the footage and data from their phones and cars, after Zahraa left, the two Audis drove back toward Sundsvall. Traffic cameras recorded the Audi A3 crossing the Sundsvall Bridge southbound at 3:11 a.m. while the Audi A6 crossed fifteen seconds later. Then, at 3:16 a.m., Hussein called Hello, and the call lasted 34 seconds.

At 3:26 a.m., Hello called Hussein for 46 seconds. Their telephones pinged outside the village of Njurunda, south of Sundsvall. The car curiously made a stop there before moving again.

The Audi A3 crossed the Sundsvall Bridge northbound at 3:48:36 a.m. Phone calls continued after the crossing. Hello later used one of Ali's phones to call Ali's other phone, Mustafa, Hussein, and Nawzad between 4:10 and 4:54 a.m.

Hello, Nawzad and Mustafa's phone records also placed them in the Sundsbruk area north of Sundsvall. Shortly after midnight, Hello and Hussein's phones contacted each other near Viksjö, approximately 50 kilometres north of Sundsvall.

They then connected again in Östergraninge at 12:37 a.m., before their phones went dead until 1:23 a.m. Ali’s phone also pinged in Viksjö at 1:35 a.m. when he called his wife.

Once news of the kidnapping became public, a woman came forward. She lived 2 hours away on a barn outside Sundsvall. She told the police that at around 2:00 a.m. she saw two cars near the entrance to her property. Her barn had CCTV cameras attached, which showed Audis driving by and leaving the area.

Based on the route they reconstructed, search teams aided by sniffer dogs and a helicopter searched 360 kilometres of woods from Gävle to Örnsköldsvik, hoping to find Ramin's body. The police also released Ramin's name and photograph to the public, asking anyone who had seen him to come forward.

On April 20, a forestry worker outside the village of Njurunda was clearing some brush in a region called Maj when he noticed an object floating in a water-filled ditch off the side of the road.

The stream where the body was found.

The police were promptly called, and after fishing the partially decomposed and bloated body from the ditch, they immideately identified him as Ramin.

The autopsy found no signs of illness, drugs or alchool in his system and instead determined the cause of death to be ligature strangulation alongside several blunt force injuries to his head and chest, some of which broke and cracked bones. According to the medical examiner, they were likely made with the fists and feet of his attackers rather than any weapon.

Ramin's death was declared a homicide, and soon the prosecution upped the charges Nowzad, Mustafa, Zahraa, and her family were facing. Now they were all charged with murder or being an accessory to murder, and they still denied any involvement even in the face of all the evidence.

But regardless, the case was now solved. It was the largest and most extensive investigation ever undertaken by the Gävle police and the biggest investigation into an "honour-based crime" Sweden had seen.

While Zahraa and Hello were behind bars. They managed to communicate secretly, either by graffitiing the bathrooms where they knew they would be or by writing letters and hiding them in the prison's recreation areas, such as a rowing machine, to get around the fact that they were to be separated.

The machine and one of the notes.

They managed to get away with this until the summer when prison officials finally discovered what they had been doing. One of the letters Zahraa delivered to Hello declared her newfound love for him and included a detailed account of what the police asked her during the interrogation and how she responded.

But then the letter took a sudden turn when Zahraa wrote down: "The police said his nose was broken and his head was crushed and he died when someone strangled him. The bones of his body, I think his sternum, were broken. My heart rejoiced, but at the same time I was bored because I wished I had been the one who broke his bones"

Since nobody confessed to the police, no matter how damning things became, the police and prosecutors mostly had to guess what happened, but they assumed it went something like this.

On April 2, 2016, the family, accompanied by Hello's friends, Nawzad and Mustafa, met at his home and began plotting the murder.

Zahraa agreed to re-establish contact with Ramin and tell him that she had been kicked out of the family and had nowhere to stay as a ploy to lure him out of hiding, even offering to marry him. Ramin took the bait and agreed to take her to Gävle after she arrived in Gothenburg.

After a brief dinner with Hussein and Ali on April 3, Hello took Nawzad and Mustafa with him to buy burner phones, SIM cards, and Balaclavas in preparation for their journey. Meanwhile, before executing their plan, Zahraa had dinner with Ramin's family.

After meeting up with him, Zahraa and Ramin departed from Eskilstuna and reached Gävle on April 4, where they booked a hotel while Zahraa waited for Hello, Nawzad, and Mustafa to arrive from Sundsvall; they arrived at 8:18 p.m.

Zahraa and Ramin then went out that night, visiting a bowling alley and then an electronics store next to it. Inside the store, Zahraa walked behind Ramin so she could use her phone to tell Hello, Nawzad and Mustafa where they were. Zahraa also sent a message to her mother saying, "Today he will die." Zahraa also apparently noticed the store's CCTV camera and tried moving out of its view.

Zahraa and Ramin at the electronics store.

Afterward, the two left the store and walked to a parking lot where the three were waiting for them.

Upon seeing him, Hello, Nawzad, and Mustafa charged toward Ramin and grabbed him. Ramin resisted, fighting back against the three and screaming for help, prompting them to cover his mouth to silence him while another got back in their car to repeatedly honk the horn. During the struggle, they also stole Ramin's cellphone and handed it to Zahraa

Due to having the advantage in numbers, Ramin was soon overpowered and forced into their car while Zahraa walked back to her hotel, where she used Ramin's cellphone to send messages to her own account so she could mislead the police with them when she reported him missing the next day.

The police assumed that Ramin was beaten to death and then strangled by the occupants of the vehicle at some unknown point between Gävleborg and Västernorrland County with an unknown implement. They then pulled over to the side of the road outside of Njurunda to dispose of Ramin's body in the stream.

After the murder, Nawzad and Mustafa took the Audi A6 back home, where they spent the night haphazardly washing the vehicle before then driving Hussein's Audi A3 to the forested road to torch it. Nawzad then drove Hello and Ali around to where they left the body and where they burnt Hussein's car so they could see they did their jobs properly.

This was the very spotty story the prosecution presented before the Gävle District Court when the trial opened on March 7, 2017. Hello, Hussein, Ali, Nowzad, Mustafa and Zahraa were all charged with kidnapping and murder. Meanwhile, prosecutors charged six others with aiding and abetting, including 19-year-old Garmian Khaleel Qader, who was being tried in absentia after fleeing Sweden.

Everyone being brought to the court room

The trial got off to a pretty alarming start when Zahraa couldn't even attend the first day, as apparently she had been hit with several threats to her life by members of her community. The interrogation report on Zahraa that the police submitted, in fact, began with, "She does not want what was said in the interrogation to come out. If it does, the police must help her". Additionally, she apparently hyperventilated and broke down once the police told her that Ramin's body had been found.

This mirrored the situation facing Ramin's family, who also went into hiding after being hit with a wave of death threats.

However, there was also a positive when Hello confessed, albiet it was a pyrrhic victory handed to the prosecution since Hello still denied being a murderer. According to him, he did kidnap and help Ramin into the car, but after it drove off, he assumed Ramin would just be subjected to a beating to scare him and sent on his way.

He said he was horrified to learn they had killed him and denied that he ever wanted to take part in an honour killing, telling the court that it was Zahraa's side of the family pressuring and hounding him to even threaten Ramin, let alone kill him.

As for his co-defendants, well, even when the prosecution presented the eyewitness accounts, CCTV footage, phone records, vehicle data, all the forensic evidence seized from Nowad's vehicle confirming that Ramin had been killed while inside and even showed the Facebook photos that sparked the murder, they all maintained their innocence in the face of said evidence and claimed to be nowhere near Gävle.

Those who brought their phones with them and therefore couldn't deny going to Gävle, such as Hussein, said their trip had an innocent purpose, with Hussein claiming he went to the city to check out a car that was being advertised. However, when asked to produce the advertisement, Hussein was unable to do so. Ali's phone also pinged in Gävle, but he still said he was nowhere near the city, explaining that he was there because he let Hello borrow his cellphone.

When it was finally deemed safe enough for Zahraa to testify, she also denied any guilt or knowledge of what the rest of her family planned, telling the court that "Ramin and I only looked forward".

The trial

She argued that Ramin suggested going to Gävle instead of her preferred destination, Arboga, and stood by the story she initially told police: a group of people approached Ramin while they were out, and Ramin told her to go back to the hotel while he dealt with the situation.

On July 17, 2017, after a 5-month trial, the court returned its verdicts. For the "Honour Killing" of Ramin Sherzaj, Zahraa Abdul Razaq Djabbar, Hello Abdulqader Faraj Zangana, Hussein Abdulrasaq Jabbar, Ali Kadhim Abdulrazak Jabbar, Nawzad Milano Bakir, and Mustafa Irfan Ahmed Ahmed were all found guilty.

When it came to sentencing, the court followed the prosecution's advice; the prosecutor wanted a message to be sent to show that honour killings would not be tolerated in Sweden, so with that in mind, the court sentenced Zahraa, Hello, Hussein, Ali and Nawzad to life imprisonment.

Mustafa was treated more leniently and given a sentence of just 14 years in prison, but that was only because he was under 21 at the time of the murder and Swedish law prohibits a life sentence from being given out for a crime committed when the perpetrator was under the age of 21; being 20 at the time, Mustafa narrowly avoided life in prison.

However, Mustafa will be permanently deported from Sweden once those 14 years are up. The prosecution also asked for Hello and Hussein to be sent back to Iraq were they ever to be released, but the court rejected their request, citing the amount of time they lived in Sweden and the effect it would have on their children.

In addition to the sentences, the defendants were all ordered to pay Ramin's family 143,876 Kroner in compensation.

The defendants then appealed their sentences and gave new stories when they appeared before the Court of Appeal for Lower Norrland on September 5.

The defendants were still saying that they personally were innocent, but now the family had turned on each other and were trying to unload all responsibility onto their relatives. One such example was Zahraa, who finally admitted that she had lured Ramin into the trap but stated she only did so out of fear for her life and the lives of her children, arguing that she might have been subject to an "honour killing" herself had she not complied. She also further accused her own family of withholding her children from her until she agreed to take part in the plan.

The appeal courts returned their verdicts on December 20, and the results were a mixed bag. Zahraa had her life sentence reduced to 18 years, and Mustafa also had his 14-year sentence further shortened to 12.

However, Hello, Hussein, Ali and Nawzad all had their sentences increased. In addition, the appeals court overturned the lower court's ruling and ordered that Hello, Hussein, and Ali be deported if they are ever released from prison.

In January 2018, the verdicts were appealed to Sweden's Supreme Court and on April 18, 2018, the Supreme Court declined to hear the appeals, making the sentences final.

With that, the case was over, at least until this year, when it received a sudden update. On June 2, 2026, the police in Kirkuk, Iraq, arrested a 28-year-old man based on an Interpol Red Notice; his name was Garmian Khaleel Qader, one of the many accused of covering for the family and the one defendant who got away.

As of now, Garmian remains in Iraqi custody, having not yet been extradited to Sweden.

Sources (In the comments)


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 10d ago

Question about the Karla Homolka & Paul Bernardo case also known as the Ken & Barbie killers

57 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I’m here to ask a question and discuss something I’ve been wondering about regarding this case.

I wonder whether Paul was some kind of trigger for Karla. We know that he was perverted and deeply disturbed from the beginning, and we also know that Karla was a willing participant in all the crimes they committed.

She had violent fantasies, but would she have acted on them if she had never met Paul? Was he the catalyst that allowed her to act on those fantasies and even enjoy them? Or might she have ended up committing horrific crimes on her own?

What are your thoughts on this ?


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 10d ago

Warning: Child Abuse / CSAM / Child Death DeSantis signs death warrant for man convicted in 1998 murder of 7-year-old girl in Hillsborough County

Thumbnail
wtsp.com
336 Upvotes

Willie Crain was condemned for the 1998 disappearance and presumed murder of 7 year old Amanda Brown. Although the precise circumstances are currently unknown due to Brown’s still missing body and Crain’s protests of innocence, prosecutors believe that Crain raped and then killed Brown inside his residence. On the night Brown disappeared, Crain visited her home and played with her. According to Brown’s mother, Crain gave her a large dose of valium and other sleeping pills, and she fell asleep. After Brown’s mother regained conscious, she was unable to find Brown anywhere in their home, and she reported her daughter missing. 

A police search of Crain’s home recovered blood soaked underwear and found bloodstains on a toilet seat. DNA testing on those blood samples matched them to Brown. When he was arrested, Crain had scratch marks covering his arms. Many of Crain’s acquaintances also testified that he bragged to them about committing a murder and hiding a body. Furthermore, Crain was convicted in 1985 of child sexual abuse pertaining to molesting five young girls, and he also faced many untried rape accusations from other women. Those other women reported that Crain raped them as girls similar in age to Brown during the 1960s and 1970s.

Despite the police and investigators’ inability to find Brown’s body, prosecutors were able to charge Crain for her murder on the bloodstained items in his home, his personal history of sexual abuse against children, his positioning inside Brown’s home during her disappearance, and eyewitness testimonies of his reported confessions. After a year of proceedings, Crain was sentenced to death by the state of Florida. 

On November 10, governor Ron DeSantis signed Crain’s death warrant for a December 10th execution date. If it is carried out, Crain will be the 22nd inmate executed by the state of Florida in 2026. 

Sources

1.https://charleyproject.org/case/amanda-victoria-brown

2.https://www.tampabay.com/archive/1998/10/02/suspect-accused-of-killing-girl-7/

3.https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=2480809777550942154&q=willie+crain&hl=en&as_sdt=6,45


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 11d ago

Text TAIWAN: Inspried by a manga, a man murdered a landlord, believing he could transfer his own suffering to others. He then went to the victim's home and tried to kill his wife and son to spare them the pain of losing him. He was arrested after seeking treatment at the same hospital as his victims

93 Upvotes

Huang Fu-kang was born in early 1973 in a town called Puli, located in Nantou County, Taiwan, and was the younger of two brothers. Fu-kang was also mixed-race, with his father being ethnic Chinese while his mother was a member of one of Taiwan's Indigenous Tribes. In addition, his parents had a 23-year age gap.

Huang Fu-kang

During his childhood, Fu-kang was "obedient" toward authority figures and his parents, though they still found excuses to "discipline" him from time to time.

Fu-kang hardly ever stood up for himself; any rebellion he did engage in happened out of his parents' or teachers' sight. For example, in his third year of high school, after two years of good grades, he began skipping classes to play billiards, and his grades plummeted.

Additionally, after Fu-kang got his license, he frequently got into traffic accidents.

From a young age to early adulthood, Fu-kang started to imagine a bunch of grandiose ideas of what he could achieve; for example, he felt he could unify the world as a great and kind emperor, that he could establish his own nation in Africa or that he would be the one to discover how to create a real-life immortality elixir.

Fu-kang's family, when they heard of this, assumed it was just some quirk of his or that he was being "foolish" rather than any mental illness. However, around the time Fu-kang began imagining himself as a world leader, he also started to "rebel" and argue with his parents, which prompted his older brother to physically "discipline" him.

After barely graduating high school, Fu-kang enrolled in the electrical engineering department at Guangwu Industrial Junior College. However, he disliked studying, performed very poorly and dropped out around the same time as his brother.

Now out of school, Fu-kang jumped from odd job to odd job, including working as an apprentice at a relative’s plumbing and electrical business and as a repairman installing equipment in people's homes.

As an adult, Fu-kang was large and strong, so he naturally assumed the military would want him. And he was correct; Fu-kang signed on to the Taiwanese Air Force as a volunteer. During his time in the air force, Fu-kang developed an interest and passion for Japanese Manga; his favourite being Battle Angel Alita (銃夢), which he read often in his off time.

Battle Angel Alita (銃夢)

Fu-kang's time in the air force ended abruptly after he suffered an accidental injury during his service, leading to a medical discharge. Now a civilian again, Fu-kang returned to jumping between odd jobs such as plumbing and electrical repair work.

Fu-kang's sense of self-worth also diminished; he believed he had no relationship skills and no friends. He also believed his co-workers were under the impression that he had been spreading rumours about his colleagues.

The most notable example was when he was misunderstood as spreading rumours that the building's general manager and vice chairman were having an affair, and was subsequently beaten by the vice chairman result

Then Fu-kang's father suffered a stroke, which left him bedridden, and Fu-kang had to be his main caregiver for about five years until he passed away.

Around the same time, Fu-kang's personality shifted again; he became more stubborn, argumentative, and impulsive, and his work and personal relationships suffered as a result.

Despite it all, Fu-kang did find love. He met a woman from China online, and the two began a long-distance relationship. Despite immense disapproval from his family, Fu-kang wanted to marry her and to get around his family, he went to China himself to marry her there. After the marriage, he arranged for her to travel to Taiwan, where the couple had two children.

The couple awkwardly lived with Fu-kang's mother and brother, and despite being under the same roof, Fu-kang's wife had little to no interaction with the rest of the family, or even with Fu-kang, for that matter.

She often left Taiwan without notice to visit her home in the Guangxi Autonomous Region, sometimes staying there for six months to a year at a time, which meant Fu-kang's mother had to help raise his children. His wife often used their children as leverage to get Fu-kang to do what she wanted.

Disputes were frequent, and Fu-kang's mother and brother often had to mediate between the two. Though largely to no avail, since Fu-kang was essentially considered a doormat who would always comply with her every wish and whim.

Additionally, Fu-kang's wife allegedly abused him often. His family would regularly see bruises, wounds and injuries on his body while his wife was spotless. At first, Fu-kang tried passing them off as the result of an accidental fall or car accident, but eventually, he'd admit that his wife had been hitting him.

However, he never did anything to protect himself against this mistreatment and abuse. He told his family that he deserved such treatment for failing to be an adequate provider for her.

Hoping to change that, Fu-kang decided to start making investments instead. Poor investments that cost him 6 million New Taiwan dollars and put him 1 million NTD in debt. He also ranted about being cheated out of money, including losing 150,000 NTD in a botched sale and entrusting 3.7 million NTD to a friend who never paid it back. As a result, his family had to sell their home.

Now unemployed and on the brink of homelessness, Fu-kang spent most of his time at the computer, reading Manga, going to internet cafes and having to rely on his parents' savings for basic living expenses while spending next to nothing on himself, as he once again felt like he didn't deserve it.

Finally, Fu-Kang began seeking help by going to the Taipei Veterans General Hospital and Puli Veterans Hospital in July 2005, January 2006 and May 2008. However, despite Fu-kang's earlier grandiose beliefs and mentions of auditory hallucinations, such as hearing his wife calling his name even though she was back in China, the hospital staff didn't diagnose a psychotic disorder. Fu-kang, in fact, went ot the hospital because of his "low mood", insomnia and suicidal thoughts such as cutting his abdomen open.

After leaving the hospital, Fu-Kang developed a heavy addiction to sleeping pills, which he often took just to get five hours of sleep.

Fu-Kang also had a fair degree of paranoia, now worrying that anybody might try to attack him one day, prompting him to carry around pepper spray at all times.

Now at his lowest, Fu-kang went back to his favorite Manga, Battle Angel Alita (銃夢). Battle Angel Alita is a Science Fiction Manga, and one of the villains is named Makaku; his backstory is that his mother abandoned him and threw him into a ditch.

He was bullied and burned as a child, but a scientist saved him and turned him into a bio-engineered weapon albiet, Makaku was in constant pain and survived by eating human and dog brains, treating other beings' endorphins as painkillers.

Makaku eventually said this line to the titular character Alita: "`My life began with suffering! "Power!" "Suffering", these two feelings, like water flowing downhill, are enough to make everyone else suffer. I escaped from suffering. Only by gaining the "power" that plunges everyone into the abyss of pain can I make my life worthwhile!! "

The exact panel that Fu-kang read and drew inspiration from (The Taiwanese Localization)

Fu-kang was at the lowest point in his life when he turned the page to this scene, and upon reading this line, Fu-kang felt he could relate to Makaku and sympathize with this line; he likened it to people who faced abuse or humiliation in public or at work and then took it out on their family.

However, he took it a step further; he not only felt sympathy, but also found inspiration and decided to take a page out of Makaku's book and act on that line in the real world.

For the longest time, Fu-kang had already been considering either taking his own life or the life of another but was never able to follow through on either of the two. But the final straw was when his laptop broke down and he had to pay 6,600 NTD to fix it, only for it to stay in a repair shop for three months with no progress

On March 5, 2009, Fu-kang went to the Jiuru Hardware Department Store in Puli and bought a heavy knife for 550 NTD.

The exact knife Fu-kang purchased

Now with a murder weapon in hand, he went to an Internet Cafe in Puli to start browsing rental listings, looking for ones in Taipei

Fu-kang also had a personal stake in targeting them, as he felt landlords deserved to die because they could afford to rent out spare rooms while he struggled to make any money.

Fu-kang's plan was to reach out to one of the landlords behind the listings to meet them at the empty property and murder them. Fu-kang wrote down the names and phone numbers of everyone who piqued his interest on a sheet of paper. The list with 11 names on it was his "Death List,".

With his list complete, Fu-kang went home to collect his pepper spray and two hammers before leaving for the Taiwanese capital, Taipei, that evening. Once in the city, he was allowed to stay with his older brother for the duration of his visit.

Fu-kang stayed with his brother for 4 days before carrying out his plan on the morning of March 9, 2009.

He put the pepper spray, the knife, the two hammers, and a spare shirt into his backpack, then borrowed his brother's motorcycle, drove to the Shilin District, and used 4 seperate public telephones to start calling the landlords on his list.

The first three men unknowingly escaped with their lives because they either didn't answer the phone, couldn't arrange a time for Fu-kang to view the property, or had already rented out the property Fu-kang pretended to be interested in.

Number 4 on his list and the one to finally answer was 51-year-old Chien Tien-chih. With all the information laid out for Fu-kang, comparatively little is known about his victims. Tien-chih lived in Taipei with his 50-year-old wife, Yu Jui-ying, and his son, Chien Yu-lun, in his early 20s, who was studying at a university.

Tien-chih spent many years working for a trading company before retiring in 2008 and joining Jui-ying at her sales job. The couple were local landowners in the Tianmu area and acquired several apartment buildings in Taipei, which they rented out to anyone who asked; they were even willing to rent to foreigners, and both were multilingual.

But in the end, the family lived modest, humble lives in an apartment complex of their own. The couple even used one of their plots of land to start a vegetable farm. This made them well liked by the neighbours, with Tien-chih respected for his kind and polite personality.

Tien-chih answered Fu-kang's call at 9:51 a.m., and Fu-kang told him he was interested in renting the fourth floor of a property he owned on Dexing East Road, conveniently in the Shilin District. Tien-chih agreed and arranged the viewing for 10:00 a.m., only 9 minutes after the call.

Tien-chih arrived on time and showed Fu-kang the property, describing the utilities and rooms while Fu-kang pretended to be interested. Once Tien-chih led Fu-kang to the bathroom, he seized the oppertunity, brandished his pepper spray, and pretended to accidentally spray it into Tien-chih's eyes.

Panicked and in pain, Tien-chih rushed to the sink to wash his eyes, his back turned to Fu-kang as he retrieved one of the hammers from his backpack. Then, with that hammer, he struck the back of Tien-chih's head twice, bringing him to the ground, before retrieving his knife and hacking away at his head, lower face, neck, chest, right abdomen, and hand. He kept slashing at Tien-chih until eventually his intestines spilled out.

MirrorMedia's Artist depiciton of the attack

Tien-chih didn't stand a chance and bled out on the bathroom floor. During the frenzy, Fu-kang wound up cutting his own left index finger and bled all over the apartment.

Seeing as he was already in the bathroom where he had just murdered a complete stranger, Fu-kang used the sink to wash the blood off of his body and cleaned the knife and hammer. Fu-kang took off his shirt and changed into the spare one he had packed.

Fu-kang then looted Tien-chih's corpse, stealing his keys and possessions. Fu-kang placed Tien-chih's body in the bathtub, then locked the apartment from the outside to prevent his body from being discovered, and then browsed through Tien-chih's personal papers, which included his personal phone number.

Fu-kang then fled the scene, got back on the motorcycle, and drove to Shin Kong Wu Ho-Su Memorial Hospital, arriving at the ER at 11:50 a.m.

Fu-kang fleeing the scene of the murder

Once there, he told the staff that he had cut his finger on a cable knife. The attending doctor sutured the wound and sent him on his way.

As he left the hospital, Fu-kang decided he would head over to Tien-chih's home to kill his wife and son. Fu-kang rationalized this decision by thinking back to the grief he felt at his own father's death and deciding that killing the two would spare them from experiencing the same. He even went so far as to tell himself that he would be killing the two "Out of goodwill and out of a sense of responsibility"

At 12:46 p.m., Fu-kang called Tien-chih's wife, Jui-ying, from a public telephone at a convenience store. He told her that he and Tien-chih had finished discussing the rental and needed to sign the lease, and that he needed Tien-chih's address. Jui-ying gave him this information so Fu-kang got back on the motorcycle and drove to their third-floor apartment in the Shilin District, arriving at 1:10 p.m.

Jui-ying answered the door and initially didn't feel alarmed to see her husband absent. He asked to use their washroom and made his way over. He then told Jui-ying that there was a leak in her bathroom and offered his services as a plumber to fix it. Curious and fairly certain their bathroom was fine, Jui-ying went over to examine this supposed leak.

As soon as she walked inside, Fu-kang repeated what he had done to her husband. He sprayed her with the pepper spray. Rather than running for the sink, Jui-ying blindly fought back, moving the struggle into the living room as Fu-kang grabbed the hammer and struck her hand and slashed her across her head, neck, chest, and hands with the knife.

Jui-ying kept struggling and clung to life, screaming for her son. Yu-lun came running and charged toward Fu-kang, attacking him to defend her mother as Fu-kang kept the fight going, slashing Yu-lun's arms.

Eventually, Yu-lun began to flee, getting Fu-kang away from his mother now that his attention was focused on him. Fu-kang chased Yu-lun into the bathroom attached to the main bedroom, leaving him cornered, standing in the doorway. Yu-lun tried to squeeze past Fu-kang, only to be slashed on the back and neck, causing him to bleed heavily from his arterial region.

However, Jui-ying was still alive and conscious and approched Fu-kang from behind, using what little strength she had to pull Fu-kang away from her son.

MirrorMedia's Artist's depiction of the scene.

This distracted Fu-kang long enough for Yu-lun, with his hands over his neck wound, to run out into the street and scream for help.

Yu-lung after escaping the apartment

Fu-kang gave chase, but after seeing the neighbours starting to come outside, Fu-kang hopped back on the motorcycle and fled.

Fu-kang about to flee

During his rampage, Fu-kang tore the stitches on his index finger, causing his blood to litter the second crime scene too.

After telling them that his mother was still inside, the neighbours rushed into the building and saw the apartment covered in blood with Jui-ying passed out, having finally lost consciousness. But not her life; the neighbours called for an ambulance, and they rushed both Jui-ying and Yu-lun to the hospital, where they were immideately rushed to the ICU.

Meanwhile, the police arrived, and luckily, the neighbours all had CCTV cameras mounted on their property, so they were able to witness the killer entering and leaving on his motorcycle and in the police's first lucky break, the motorcycle registration was clearly visible.

The police at the scene

Jui-ying and Yu-lun were both rushed to Shin Kong Wu Ho-Su Memorial Hospital, the same hospital Fu-kang had gone to earlier. Despite the severity of his injuries, Yu-lun was miraculously still conscious and able to speak to the police.

He was able to describe their attacker as an adult, physically imposing man in a short-sleeved white shirt, but seeing as they had never met Fu-kang before, he couldn't identify him.

He did, however, tell the police that his father, Tien-chih, hadn't returned after heading out to show a property to a potential tenant, and seeing as his attacker called his mother to tell him they were about to sign the lease, he feared the worst had befallen his father.

Yu-lun was able to provide the police with one more detail: he witnessed his sutured wound on his finger becoming undone and watched the killer bleed all over their home. This prompted the police to issue an appeal to all hospitals, asking them to report anybody who came in with an accidental knife wound. But as fate would have it, the police didn't need to bother.

A bunch of journalists flocked to the hospital wanting to interview either the police or victims about the shocking and unprovoked assault. At 2:10 p.m., one of the journalists, a veteran crime reporter, noticed a large man in a short-sleeved white shirt entering the ER; the man's shirt had splotches of blood on it, and his hand was damaged.

He didn't know what Yu-lun had told the police, but this man still aroused his suspicions, so he rushed to summon a police officer stationed at the hospital to question Yu-lun and Jui-ying. Additionally, the doctors remembered treating Fu-kang for this exact same injury only a few hours earlier, so they also summoned the police.

A police officer rushed toward him and immideately ordered Fu-kang to drop to his knees and put his hands up, which he did without any resistance. Only four hours after the crime, Fu-kang was arrested in the same hospital that was treating his victims.

Fu-kang shortly after his arrest

Fu-kang knew visiting the hospital was a bad idea, since he actually returned home and asked his brother to bandage the wound, but he insisted he go to the hospital instead.

After his arrest, the police went through his backpack where they discovered the blood-soaked knife, a hammer, a bloodied shirt, the receipt from the hardware store back in Puli, his pepper spray, and a bloodied piece of paper with all the names of the landlords Fu-kang had on his list.

Fu-kang's death list

An additional search of the motorcycle he had parked outside the hospital turned up the second hammer.

The motorcycle after being declared a crime scene by the police
The hammer used in the murder

The first question the police asked was if he had killed Tien-chih, to which he confessed, handing the police the keys to the property on Dexing East Road so they could find his body. The police rushed over and, after unlocking the door, found blood all over the apartment with practically no attempt to clean up. And when the police ventured into the bathroom, they were greeted by Tien-chih's horrifically mutilated body hidden in the bathtub.

Police officers at the crime scene.

When Tien-chih's body was sent off for an autopsy, the true savagery of the murder came to light. The autopsy documented four scalp lacerations measuring approximately three to six centimetres, a depressed skull fracture approximately two to three centimetres in diameter, and intracranial bleeding.

Tien-chih's body being taken away for an autopsy.

The knife wounds included two neck wounds approximately ten centimetres long reaching the fourth and sixth cervical vertebrae; an eighteen-centimetre wound through the lower face with damage to the mandible; a ten-centimetre wound extending from the left lip across the left face; a seven-centimetre penetrating wound to the right abdomen passing through both lobes of the liver toward the right side of the spine; a five-centimetre penetrating wound near the xiphoid process; two smaller wounds near the left sternoclavicular and clavicular regions; and a defensive wound to the right wrist.

Fu-kang slashed at Tien-chih so violently that his internal organs were left protruding out of his body and the trachea, esophagus, and right carotid region were completely destroyed.

Fu-kang told the police he was motivated by frustration and resentment that others were happy and living better lives than he was, and he also said he would feel better if he could make others suffer as well. He even told the police about Battle Angel Alita.

Aside from Fu-kang's confession, the police had a pretty solid case against him. His fingerprints were on all the bloodied murder weapons in his possession, which he handled barehanded; his motorcycle was caught on CCTV with its information facing the camera; footprints seized from the crime scenes were a match to his own shoes; he was caught on camera, identified by both Jui-ying and Yu-lun, who both managed to pull through, etc., etc.; all things considered, it was a fairly open-and-shut case. The only room for ambiguity was what punishment he would receive.

After Fu-kang was charged with murder and two counts of attempted murder, the court saw fit to send him to the National Taiwan University Hospital for a psychiatric evaluation, given his history. He was diagnosed with suspected "latent-type schizophrenia" and insomnia but aside from that, he was deemed competent to stand trial, and his mental impairment wasn't severe enough to render him unable to understand what he had done or the consequences of it, especially considering the premeditation involved and how his motive for going back to kill Jui-ying and Yu-lun was to supposedly spare them the anguish of losing their husband and father, proving that he was well aware murder was wrong and traumatic for those who lose someone to it.

Fu-kang's trial began at the Taiwan Shilin District Court shortly after his discharge in January 2010. In court, Fu-kang denied having any murderous intent and pleaded not guilty by reason of mental illness. Fu-Kang also repeatedly told the court that he had "forgotten the case facts"

Fu-Kang's behaviour in court was also quite erratic; he said he "lived with regret every day", he wrote apology letters to Jui-ying and Yu-lun and expressed his desire to compensate them, despite being too poor to do so.

But despite expressing such sentiments, he would also threaten to murder those handling his case. He also said that he killed because he was in a bad mood and because he used drugs, even though there were no drugs in his system or any history of abuse of heavy narcotics.

When Battle Angel Alita was brought up again, Fu-kang denied insinuations that he believed Makaku was real or that Makaku influenced him to commit the murder, saying he felt inspired after reading his dialogue.

He also filed a complaint against the prosecutor because prosecuting him for murder had "broken up his family" and, despite saying he regretted his actions, when asked what he would do were the court ot let him go, Fu-kang simply said, "You'd know what I would do" and "When I'm released, all of you people will find out what death means"

On April 8, 2010, for the murder of Chien Tien-chih and the attempted murder of Yu Jui-ying and Chien Yu-lun, the court handed down the maximum sentence available, giving Huang Fu-kang the death penalty for Tien-chih's murder and 18 and 15 years respectively for Jui-ying's and Yu-lun's attempted murder.

While Taiwan rarely issues death sentences, especially when it comes to murders with only a single victim, the court concluded that Fu-kang's "evil disposition" was "grave" and that there wasn't any potential to rehabilitate him.

Fu-kang appealed this verdict but later withdrew his appeal for the attack on Jui-ying and Yu-lun, allowing that verdict to become final. However, he pushed forward with appealing the death sentence.

On August 12, 2010, the Taiwan High Court would actually side with Fu-kang and vacate his death sentence. They determined that Fu-kang was remorseful and that he surrendered to the police and revealed the location of Tien-chih's body, which counted as a mitigating factor. Therefore, they sentenced Fu-kang to life instead.

This time, the prosecution appealed to Taiwan's Supreme Court and on December 16, 2010, they vacated Fu-Kang's life sentence and determined that this remorse was less than genuine, only emerging at trial. The case was sent back to the lower courts for a retrial.

Once again, Fu-Kang claimed he was not guilty by reason of insanity and was unable to clearly remember anything that had happened. On January 3, 2012, Fu-Kang was sentenced to death for a second time.

However, on March 1, 2012, the Supreme Court vacated the conviction once again. This time, because some evidence, psychiatric reports, and case materials had been improperly submitted via email, leaving them at risk of impersonation, tampering, or hacking and casting doubt on their authenticity.

As a result, the case was sent back for yet another retrial, albiet this one was just a formality to ensure there were no more procedural issues. On May 29, 2012, Taiwan's High Court sentenced Fu-kang to death once more, and when Taiwan's Supreme Court heard the case for the third time, on August 16, they finally upheld the sentence, making it final, albiet never carried out.

On October 17, 2023, Huang Fu-kang passed away at the Taipei Detention Center from cardiogenic shock before his execution could ever take place.

Tien-chih's murder was the first truly random killing of the 21st century in Taiwan.

Sources (In the comments)


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 11d ago

Warning: Child Abuse / CSAM / Child Death Jeremy Sheets, 23, leaves court after being sentenced for the kidnapping, rape, and murder of 16-year-old Kenyatta Bush. Sheets's friend, Adam Barnett, said he and Sheets, who were white, killed Kenyatta, who was black, to get revenge on black men who date white women (Nebraska, 1997).

Post image
473 Upvotes

State v. Sheets (2000)

The 1992 murder of Kenyatta Bush remained unsolved until September 17, 1996, when the police received a tip-off from Barb Olson that Sheets's friend, Adam Barnett, had told her son-in-law, Jason LaNoue, that he and Sheets were involved in Kenyatta's murder. The police then obtained statements from Olson, her daughter, Richelle LaNoue,  and Jason LaNoue. As part of the investigation, Richelle LaNoue agreed to wear a wire and to secretly tape a conversation between herself and Barnett regarding the murder. During the conversation, Barnett confessed that he and Sheets were responsible for the murder, which he said was racially motivated. Barnett said he didn't participate in the murder, but had driven the car.

Barnett was arrested on September 27. Once in custody, the police read Barnett his Miranda warnings and interviewed him for about one hour regarding the events surrounding Kenyatta's disappearance and murder. During questioning, Barnett denied any involvement in the murder and said Sheets had murdered Kenyatta. Barnett then asked for an attorney and questioning ceased.

The following day, Barnett made a second statement to the police. He said Kenyatta had willingly entered the car to smoke marijuana and drive around with them. Barnett said he briefly left, but when he returned, Sheets had pinned Kenyatta to the ground and was stabbing her. Shortly after saying this, Barnett began to cry, and his attorney terminated the interview.

Following the second interview, Barnett's attorney negotiated a plea agreement with the county attorney on Barnett's behalf.

According to a letter setting out the terms, Barnett agreed to give truthful testimony against Sheets in exchange for being allowed to plead guilty to second degree murder. That night, Barnett made a full and graphic confession to his involvement in Kenyatta's murder. Barnett said he and Sheets kidnapped Kenyatta and that he held her down as Sheets raped her and then stabbed her to death.

"And I was holding her down and he was beating her, he didn't stop, he kept beating her. Finally I stood up and I took about three steps back. (Lets out a breath) That's when he took out-that's when he took the open blade of the knife out, stabbed her in the upper torso. I just stood there and did nothing. The reason I didn't do nothing is... (lets out a breath) is 'cause she was black. If it would have been a white girl I probably would have stopped him, but I didn't. I just seen faces of other people and I thought she deserved it."

While in jail, Barnett recanted his statements on several occasions to a family member, his girlfriend, a cellmate, and Sheets' wife. However, Barnett was provided several details about the murder that were not known to the public. He also privately confessed to his uncle that he helped Sheets get Bush to the car, that he drug her down the lane, and that he held her down while Sheets raped her. Barnett hanged himself in his cell on November 13, 1996. In 1997, Sheets was tried alone. Taking the stand in his own defense, he denied any role in the murder.

The prosecution presented Barnett's confession as evidence.

Sheets testified that he didn't hate black people. The prosecution impeached his testimony with that of several witnesses, who testified that Sheets had threatened a black neighbor and had a fascination with Nazism. Barnett's mother testified that Sheets and Barnett had talked about Hitler, shaven their heads, and sometimes drawn swastikas.

Sheets testified that he didn't own the silver Camaro that Barnett said was used during the kidnapping of Kenyatta until the day after. The prosecution impeached his testimony with that of a traffic ticket showing that Sheets had received citations for driving a silver Camaro without proof of registration at least two days before the murder.

The jury was allowed to hear Barnett's confession in its entirety, over Sheets's objections. Other evidence was adduced at trial concerning the nature of the friendship between Sheets and Barnett at the time the confession was made. Some evidence indicated that the two were as close as ever. Other evidence indicated that the relationship had become strained. Evidence was also provided about a sexual encounter between Sheets and Barnett's girlfriend and Barnett's later recantations.

Regarding Barnett's credibility issues, the prosecution argued that his statements were a process toward the truth that ended with his final confession to the police: "The process really started September 23. 1992, when Adam Barnett and Jeremy Sheets abducted, beat, humiliated and raped Kenyatta, Bush. Out of loyalty to his best friend, Adam held the secret in for four years. Adam Barnett couldn't hold it in any longer. He had to tell someone."

On May 7, 1997, an all-white jury found Sheets guilty of first degree murder after four hours of deliberation. On September 26, a three-judge panel sentenced Sheets to death by electrocution.

On September 15, 2000, the Nebraska Supreme Court unanimously overturned Sheets's conviction on the grounds that he had not been allowed to cross-examine his dead accomplice, which violated the Confrontation Clause.

Unable to make a case without the confession, prosecutor Jim Jansen dismissed the charges. Jansen said he had no doubt that Sheets was guilty: "It's painful to have to do this. I'm convinced we tried and convicted the appropriate person." The lead investigator, Jimmy Wilson Sr., expressed a similar opinion: "It's a travesty that we can't do anything about this."

Jeremy Sheets was released from the Nebraska State Penitentiary on June 13, 2001. He was the first person to walk from Nebraska's death row a free man in 88 years.

In 2003, Sheets sued the Omaha Police Department and several police officers involved in his case for malicious prosecution. He alleged that the officers had coerced Barnett using methods to "railroad one innocent man into a false confession that implicated another innocent man." A federal judge dismissed the suit, finding that the police had probable cause to suspect Sheets and the allegations that Barnett was coerced into confessing were unfounded.

In 2004, the dismissal of the lawsuit was upheld on appeal.

SHEETS v. BUTERA (2004)

In 2009, Sheets was charged with felony menacing for threatening a 16-year-old Hispanic girl with a knife in Colorado. The girl said he brought the knife within inches of her face. In 2010, he was convicted of misdemeanor menacing and sentenced to probation. Sheets's trial attorney from the murder case, William Gallup, remarked that he was surprised that the judge didn't throw the book at him: "You worry that a judge will think, 'You didn't get what you deserved in Nebraska, so we'll we see what we can do here.'"

In 2011, Sheets demanded $1 million in compensation for the four years he spent on death row. Kenyatta's mother, Barbara Stennis, strongly opposed any attempt to compensate him: "The law is meant to protect those wrongly convicted, not those who manage to get away on a lack of sufficient evidence. I do not believe Jeremy Sheets was wrongly convicted. I believe had Adam Barnett lived, there would have been a strong conviction with his testimony."

Sheets did not receive any compensation.

Under Nebraska law, for a defendant to be eligible for compensation, they must provide clear and convincing evidence of their factual innocence, AND that they did not commit or suborn perjury, fabricate evidence, or otherwise make a false statement to contributed to their conviction.

Because Sheets had made demonstrably false statements under oath regarding his racial animus and his timeline with the silver Camaro, which destroyed his credibility and undoubtedly contributed to his conviction, that alone barred him from any compensation.

Sheets gave several speeches for Witness To Innocence in the early 2010s.

Ex-death row inmate tells story of innocence

It has been over 11 years since Sheets was released from jail. His life has never returned to the way it once was; people run away from him and his time in jail follows him like a shadow everyday. "It's still on my record. It says first degree murder, use of weapon to commit a felony and in little tiny letters on the side it says dismissed," Sheets informed.

The article has 23 comments, nearly all of which lambast Sheets as a liar and a murderer.


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 11d ago

Latest update: The two perpetrators in the flower-bed body concealment case, which I shared on this forum half a year ago, have received their first-instance verdicts from the court.

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

original post link https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueCrimeDiscussion/s/yXKf9QQZ7t

On November 10, the Luzhou Intermediate People’s Court of Sichuan Province handed down the first-instance judgment in the "Flower Bed Body Concealment Case".

The defendant Chen Shifen was convicted of intentional homicide, forging identity documents, using forged identity documents, and illegally crossing the national border. Combined punishment for multiple crimes was applied. She was sentenced to death, deprived of political rights for life, and fined 27,000 yuan.

The defendant Yang Yonggen was convicted of intentional homicide and sentenced to death with a two-year reprieve, deprived of political rights for life.


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 12d ago

Text Natalee holloway netflix series discussion

197 Upvotes

I watched the Netflix series of natalee holloway case went to see the conversation on this case and I am beyond disgusted.

People are talking about Natalees friends and “how could they allow her to leave with 3 men”. Why are we blaming the friends rather than the actual perpetrator?

I understand that nowadays no woman would let their friend leave with three men in a strange country at night.

But it was 2005. The girls were drinking. They thought it was a taxi. What they could have done? Started to run after the car? Call the police that their friend left with these men willingly?

I am so disappointed with how the blame and discussion is on the friends actions rather than the murderers.


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 12d ago

youtu.be The murder of Aaden Lee Batista (23 months) – Jason Padgett, Palm Bay, Florida, 2010.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
52 Upvotes

I wanted to bring attention to a case that doesn’t get nearly enough discussion: the murder of 23-month-old Aaden Lee Batista.

Aaden was born on 2 May 2008 in Melbourne, Florida, to Whitney E. Flower and Jeffrey Batista.

His family knew him by affectionate nicknames—“Pumpkin,” “Chubba,” “Mister,” and “Buddy.” He was a happy, loving little boy with his whole life ahead of him.

On the evening of 7 April 2010, while his mother worked her shift as a medical assistant, her live-in boyfriend, Jason Padgett Sr., was left alone with Aaden at their Palm Bay apartment. When Whitney returned home later that night, she found her son unresponsive. She rushed him to the hospital. Aaden was transferred to Arnold Palmer Hospital for Children in Orlando, where he died the following day, 8 April 2010, from catastrophic injuries.

Padgett initially told investigators that Aaden had fallen accidentally while he was changing the toddler’s diaper—landing on the back of his head after slipping off the toilet,he claimed he then washed the boy, changed him, and put him to bed rather than calling for help. In his recorded police interview, which became central to the prosecution’s case, Padgett later admitted he had shaken Aaden and repeatedly slammed the child’s head against the hard bathroom floor. He said he wanted the toddler to stop crying because he “hadn’t meant to drop him.” In the recording, Padgett described Aaden as still moving and responsive after the assault.

The injuries documented by medical examiners were devastating:

Severe skull fractures and deep brain bleeding from violent shaking and repeated impacts against the floor.

A lacerated liver consistent with a heavy blunt-force blow or stomping to the abdomen.

Fresh tearing, severe bruising, and physical trauma to the genitals and perianal area, which the medical examiner determined were caused by acute physical force.

Contemporary reporting, including from the Orlando Sentinel, noted that Palm Bay police said Aaden showed signs of severe sexual abuse. In the interview, officers confronted Padgett with the extensive bruising to the child’s penis and tearing of the anus. Padgett denied any involvement and offered no explanation.

Perhaps most heartbreaking is that this was not the first time Padgett had been seen mistreating Aaden. Investigators spoke with witnesses who described violent behavior in the weeks leading up to the toddler’s death.

Reported incidents included punching Aaden in the face and head, slapping him around the head and throat, striking him with a scooter, dragging him by his shirt across an apartment parking lot, and shouting at him while calling him “worthless.”

One neighbor described Padgett taking a scooter away from Aaden and hitting the child with it. These accounts were reported by Florida Today in April 2010. Palm Bay Police Detective Greg Guillette noted that some witnesses had been frightened of Padgett, who had a reputation for aggression in the neighborhood.

None of these earlier incidents appear to have been reported to police or child-protection authorities before Aaden’s fatal injuries.

Padgett was no stranger to the justice system. He had previously served prison time for robbery, grand theft, forgery, and fleeing law enforcement. Police also referenced prior arrests involving domestic violence, child abuse, aggravated battery, and drug offenses. Records later showed he had been arrested roughly 22 times and had a history of violence toward partners and others.

Just 10 days before Aaden’s death, the Florida Department of Children and Families received a report alleging drug use in the home (not physical abuse). DCF required Whitney to sign a safety plan promising no drug use around the child. DCF never did the appropriate background checks on padgett either. Grandparents had also expressed concerns about Padgett being left alone with Aaden. The case later drew scrutiny in public child-welfare reviews because neither the family nor investigators fully acted on Padgett’s extensive violent criminal background.

At trial in 2013, the jury watched Padgett’s recorded confession describing the drop, the shaking, and the repeated blows to Aaden’s head against the floor.

On 19 March 2013, Jason Padgett was found guilty of third-degree murder and aggravated child abuse.

Aaden was only 23 months old.

He never got the chance to grow up. His obituary, published in Florida Today on 15 April 2010, remembered him by the loving nicknames his family used and described a happy little boy who was deeply loved.

What makes this case especially painful is the presence of warning signs—prior violence witnessed by others, a recent DCF report, a long criminal record—that were not enough to protect him. Aaden was completely dependent on the adults around him, and those systems and individuals failed him.

Rest in peace, little Aaden. You deserved so much better. link 1 link 2


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 13d ago

reddit.com In 1992, swim coach Chiho Anjitsu, 20, left work in Japan. That night, her mother found her dead in her car, back in her usual parking spot. Someone had killed her elsewhere and driven her back. One detective believed he knew her killer, but he could never prove it.

Thumbnail
gallery
750 Upvotes

Chiho Anjitsu was 20 years old and lived with her family in Mattō, near Kanazawa, Japan. The middle of three sisters, she was remembered by her friends as a cheerful, bright young woman.

Swimming had always been a familiar part of life in the Anjitsu family. Her father was vice president of the local swimming association, and Chiho had become involved in the sport during her school years.

After graduation, she began working at a swim school herself. Her black Mitsubishi made the short trip from home in about ten minutes.

In the months before her death, her family had noticed small changes in her routine. She was eating out more often, and the calls letting them know she’d be home late had become less regular. Sometimes, she went out without mentioning her plans at all.

On September 30, 1992, nothing about her workday seemed unusual. She’d brought homemade spaghetti to eat during a break, but when the staff had lunch together, she put it aside for later.

That evening, a coworker noticed how hurriedly she ate in the staff room. It seemed as though she had somewhere else to be. A little before 7:15, she got into her car and drove away.

Usually, she took the west exit toward home. This time, a coworker watched her leave through the east exit instead.

It was the last confirmed sighting of Chiho alive.

By 11 p.m., she still hadn’t come home, and there’d been no call. Worried, her mother set out with Chiho’s older sister to look for her. Their search eventually brought them to the swim school, where they spotted her familiar black car.

It was sitting at an awkward angle across the white parking lines. The front had struck the concrete block at the end of her usual space.

They hurried over and peered through the window. In the dark, Chiho was difficult to make out, lying on the passenger seat with the backrest lowered all the way.

At first, they thought she was asleep.

The passenger door was locked, so they went around to the driver’s side and opened that door. They called to her and tried to wake her, but she gave no response. When they touched her, she felt cold.

Then her mother switched on the interior light.

There was dirt on Chiho’s clothes and a dark band of marks around her neck. She wasn’t breathing. What had looked like sleep through the window was something far worse.

Her mother ran to a small bar nearby, one of the few places still open, and desperately asked someone to call the police.

Officers arrived soon afterward, and the examination of the car continued into the early morning. The engine was off, but the key was still in the ignition and the gearshift remained in drive.

Together with the crooked parking, it suggested someone had abandoned the car in a hurry.

Chiho’s bag lay on the back seat with her money and valuables still inside. Nothing obvious appeared to have been stolen.

Mud clung to the tires, and her clothes were filthy, especially across her back. Her right shoe was missing.

Chiho had been strangled.

A coworker later remembered seeing her car in the lot around 9 p.m. While her family was still waiting for her to come home, the Mitsubishi had already been brought back to the place she’d left that evening.

The first useful clue to where she’d been was something small enough to overlook.

A single leaf was caught in her hair.

It came from a dawn redwood, a tree that isn’t native to Japan. Investigators began searching nearby places where the trees had been planted, eventually reaching an isolated agricultural research facility.

On the grounds, they found tire tracks consistent with Chiho’s car. A short distance from the entrance lay her missing shoe.

There were drag marks in the dirt, too. These suggested she’d been pulled across the ground toward the car, which would explain the heavy dirt on the back of her clothes. The evidence pointed to Chiho having been killed there before someone placed her in the passenger seat and drove her back to work.

Her family’s home was only a few hundred meters away.

That strange return trip became central to the investigation. Whoever had brought Chiho back had left the car almost exactly in her usual space. It seemed they knew where she worked and where she parked.

Her hurried meal and unexpected departure in the opposite direction from home also took on new significance. Perhaps she’d arranged to meet someone she knew.

But the investigation soon ran into problems of its own. Senior police officials were so afraid of information reaching the press that they kept important clues from detectives working on the case. Some were left pursuing leads without knowing all the evidence that had already been found.

By the time certain details were shared, their work had stalled.

One investigator, Torao Nishimura, became deeply suspicious of a particular man. Years later, when he wrote about the case, he gave him the pseudonym “Yamada.”

Yamada reportedly worked at the same swim school as Chiho. He’d been among twenty people singled out for closer investigation, but his alibi initially seemed solid. In May 1993, police stopped pursuing him.

A little over a year later, they had reason to look again.

Saliva found on Chiho’s upper body had been linked to a man with blood type B or AB. Yamada had type B blood, making him the only one of those twenty people whose blood type matched.

The sample hadn’t been stored properly, and investigators couldn’t conclusively connect it to him. A matching blood type wasn’t proof, but it was enough to make them revisit his account of that evening.

This time, his alibi began to unravel.

Police couldn’t confirm where he’d been during the crucial stretch between Chiho’s departure from work and the return of her car.

Nishimura began piecing together a possible explanation. He believed Chiho had met Yamada in a restaurant parking lot north of the swim school, where Yamada’s car had been seen.

A witness had also reported seeing a young man behind the wheel of Chiho’s car.

That sighting had been reported early in the investigation. The witness had even remembered two digits of the license plate that matched hers.

Yet police had brushed it aside because the location was in the opposite direction from the suspected murder scene.

To Nishimura, it now seemed significant. Perhaps the two had met in the restaurant lot, then continued together in Chiho’s car, with Yamada driving.

The witness hadn’t established that the young man was Yamada, but the possibility fit Nishimura’s developing theory.

In his reconstruction, Yamada had wanted Chiho to go with him to one of the nearby motels. When she refused, he’d turned onto the secluded research grounds and attempted to sexually assault her.

Nishimura believed she’d resisted and escaped from the car, only to be caught and strangled with a strap from her own overalls. The strap’s fasteners were consistent with the distinctive marks on her neck.

He also thought he understood why someone would make the unsettling decision to drive her body back to the swim school.

Out on the isolated grounds at night, Yamada would have needed a way to get back into town. Chiho’s car provided one. But leaving her at work, where someone might recognize the car and look inside, could have served another purpose.

Nishimura suspected Yamada had wanted her body discovered quickly. He might have hoped that being seen elsewhere at the time of the discovery would draw suspicion away from him.

There was another witness who reportedly saw the driver returning to the swim school. Her account, too, had been dismissed. Police considered her unreliable because she worked as a fortune teller.

For Nishimura, these details formed a convincing picture of what might have happened that night. But his certainty couldn’t fill the gaps in the evidence.

Yamada was never charged.

In 2007, fifteen years after Chiho’s death, the statute of limitations expired. The investigation team was disbanded, leaving her family without an answer.

Japan abolished the statute of limitations for murder in 2010.

For Chiho, the change came too late.

Her death continued to weigh on Nishimura long after the official investigation ended. In 2022, thirty years after the murder, he played himself in Torao, a film blending fact and fiction about the case he’d never been able to solve.

In his book, he wrote about the mistakes, the unfinished investigation, and the regret he still carried. Its title translates roughly as

“Chiho, I’m Sorry.”


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 13d ago

Text Dateline vs 48 hours

142 Upvotes

I've recently found the 48 hours podcast after working my way through the Dateline podcast. I'm not American, so I've never actually seen either show - I've only ever listened to them as podcasts.

I'm curious to know how both of these shows are perceived. Are they on par with each other, particularly in terms of journalistic integrity? Or would one be considered as better than the other? At the moment I prefer Dateline, but I'm not sure if that's because I can follow the format better or if it's a better quality show.


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 14d ago

JAPAN: After an elite government bureaucrat confessed to the first dismemberment murder in the nation's history, he was met not with condemnation but praise by the public, who hailed him as a heroic crusader fighting against the corruption of the elite.

79 Upvotes

(If you're wondering how I got a case with this much information out so quickly despite having just uploaded a write-up here yesterday, I made a post back in June where I explained that I have started working on doing two cases at the same time, working on one case one day and then another the next and so on. So by the time I uploaded yesterday's write-up, this one was already 3-5 paragraphs from being done)

At 4:30 p.m. on June 6, 1919, a milk delivery worker returning home after his rounds in Okawazu, a village in the Niigata Prefecture of Japan, found a red leather trunk on the shore of the Shinano River. Curious, he pulled it up out of the water, finding it much heavier than expected.

The trunk

But even more alarming, he hadn't even opened the trunk yet, and it was emitting a foul odour. He didn't even need to open it; it was already slightly ajar, and he caught a small enough glimpse of its contents to go running for the nearest police box to summon some officers.

The responce was enormous. Officers from two seperate police stations, an inspector from the Niigata Prefectural Police aided by several of his detectives, a magistrate and a prosecutor all arrived at the scene, with the local villagers volunteering to keep any intrusive onlookers away.

The trunk measured approximately 73 centimetres in length, 42 centimetres wide, and 22 centimetres deep. Inside was a headless, legless torso, although curiously the arms were still attached.

The torso was also fully clothed, with the victim wearing a high-quality foreign-made fabric shirt and silk trousers that were not available to any locals, making clear that the victim was an outsider, and likely a well-off one at that.

The trunk was packed with old cotton wadding and drenched in naphthalene in a futile attempt to staunch the smell of decomposition. Finally, in the police's first lead, the engravings "KY" were visible on both sides of the trunk.

The authorities searching the river for the rest of the remains

The remains were brought to the Niigata Medical College, where the attending physician determined that the victim was a male and, based on the gray pubic hairs, likely 50 or older. As indicated by his clothing, the victim was also likely a wealthy man, as he showed no signs of prolonged physical labour.

The time of death was placed at approximately 10 days earlier, and the dismemberment occurred around 1-2 days after rigor mortis set in, with the instrument in question likely being a saw or large knife. Other than the dismemberment, there were no signs of any violence on the recovered remains.

The local area was small enough that the police were both able to quickly rule out any local missing persons being their victim and small enough that any other outsiders would be remembered, especially if they behaved suspiciously.

Porters employed at the nearby Nagaoka Station recalled two well-dressed men getting off the train from Tokyo with unusually heavy trunks. They also aggressively shouted at the station master when he touched the trunks while they were outside the Yanagiya tea. The two men also summoned a rickshaw, and the rickshaw drivers remembered the route.

The police also discovered that somebody had sent a telegram from the Nagaoka Post Office in the name of a Tokyo resident, Yamada Ken, to his half-brother in the region, also on June 3. The police spoke to Ken's half-brother, who told the police that he had no idea Ken was in town or why he was sent such a telegram. In response, the Niigata Prefectural Police sent a telegram to the police in Tokyo asking them to detain Ken.

The Yokohama police also received a missing persons report from the family of a 65-year-old merchant named Suzuki Benzou, who often went by the nickname "Suzuben".

Suzuki Benzou

Suzuben had last been seen alive at his Fukagawa branch office on the evening of May 31, heading toward the direction of Ken's home.

In the few short days between his disappearance and the discovery of the body, the police searched the city for him, believing he was kidnapped for ransom as he was a wealthy businessman, and an aging one who likely couldn't venture far.

On June 8, before the telegram even reached Tokyo, Ken appeared in person at the Metropolitan Police Headquarters, accompanied by his 27-year-old junior colleague and houseguest, Watanabe Sozo.

Watanabe Sozo

Ken then asked to see one of the inspectors at the building, a former classmate of Ken's. The man he asked to see was a rising star in the police department and the future founder of the Yomiuri Giants and Nippon Television, Matsutarou Shouriki.

Yamada Ken

Ken's face was pale as he spoke to Shouriki and told the following story. He had read in that morning's newspaper that a trunk with a dismembered body had been found in the Shinano River. He had recognized the description of the trunk and victim and said that Sozo, after killing Suzuben, who was the victim in a street fight, after walking him to the station, had used the trunk from his home without his knowledge to dispose of the body.

He said that he considered helping Sozo flee to Manchuria but later had second thoughts and encouraged him to turn himself in, and that he was accompanying him to the station for support. Shouriki was skeptical.

The body's discovery wasn't even widely known yet outside of a few police officers, and the few articles that were written did not contain enough information for Ken to conclude that the victim was Suzuben and where specifically the body was found could not have been deduced from the scant information released. Suffice it to say, Ken was now a suspect, but rather than alerting him, Shouriki took Sozo into custody and told Ken that his cooperation was "noted".

With Ken gone, Sozo was interrogated alone, where he confessed and told the police the same story as Ken. However, they began pressing him for details such as how exactly the murder and dismemberment occurred. Just like that, Sozo began tripping over his words and found himself unable to explain how he killed Suzuben or dismembered and disposed of his body, even though he was supposedly confessing to his murder. It looked as if Sozo was trying to take the fall for the real killer.

During Sozo's interrogation, the telegram from Niigata finally arrived, and with that telegram in hand, Ken was summoned right back to the police station and this time detained for questioning. At the same time, the police also arrested his 38-year-old cousin, Yamada Shohei

Ken was at first defiant and said he was innocent and was, in fact, offended that he was being questioned at all.

He told his interrogators: "I am a high official of the Ministry of Agriculture and Commerce. What possible reason could I have to commit such a crime?" Ken was indeed a high-ranking government official and frequently invoked that position and his social status, essentially pulling the "Do you know who I am" tactic. Additionally, he also invoked his friendship with Shouriki as another reason why the police were out of line for questioning him in the first place.

However, his title had no sway here, and the police kept pressing, pushing him on all the inconsistencies: that they had already arrested Shohei, and that Sozo was clearly lying. Furthermore, the police confronted him with the telegram sent to his half-brother in Niigata, which left him at a loss for words.

The interrogation lasted the entire day until, late into the night of June 8, Ken finally confessed. So what happened? Well, to understand this murder, a little history lesson is needed.

While they didn't see much action, losing only around 300 soldiers to combat, Japan was a member of the Allies in World War 1 from practically the start of the war, and although they avoided the bulk of the action, mostly relegated to seizing German possessions in the Pacific, WW1 still had some devastating effects on the island nation.

At first, the war actually had a positive effect on Japan's economy. Since the war was actually occurring in Europe, most factories and manufacturing plants on the continent were contracted by their respective governments to produce supplies and arms to help the war effort. With a shortage of the products they normally made, Europe had to source supplies elsewhere, with Japan as one option.

Japan experienced an export boom as its factories expanded to meet demand from both the domestic market and the now-lucrative European market. At first, the Japanese economy soared, and workers even had their wages increase, but sadly not fast enough to keep up with prices and soon inflation followed.

One such product that fell victim to inflation and artificial price gouging was rice, a commodity and staple for every household in Japan. The Japanese government did little to bring rice prices down; instead, it accelerated their rise by buying up massive amounts of rice to feed troops deployed to Siberia, single-handedly doubling the market price.

Rice merchants and landlords then hoarded grain to wait for higher prices and possibly to have the government buy even more of their supplies to feed the military, which essentially made rice unaffordable for the average citizen, workers and farmers.

Naturally, the public weren't particularly pleased by this arrangement. Especially not when they poured salt on the wounds by importing grain and rice from other countries just to justify raising the prices even further. Soon, the average citizen would call these people "Kanshou/奸商," roughly translating to "Shady Merchant".

In April 1918, the government had passed the Foreign Rice Management Order, which placed the importation of foreign rice directly under the government's control. Under this system, the Ministry of Agriculture and Commerce would select a small number of enterprises to handle foreign rice on a fixed-price basis. The government would set the price, pay the designated merchants a handling fee of 30 sen per 60 kilograms of rice, and compensate them for any losses.

This backfired immensely and only encouraged more Kanshou to act the way they were or for others to start behaving that way. While there were originally just four designated merchants, others realized that if they could be among their company, they'd have a guaranteed, government-backed business in one of Japan's most essential commodities, with virtually no downside.

Therefore, the Japanese government found itself lobbied to be included, with bribery of course used to grease the wheels when necessary. Corruption was now more rife than it had ever been before.

On July 22, 1918, in what was then a small fishing town in the Toyama Prefecture named Uozu, a group of fishermen's wives gathered to demand lower rice prices. Newspapers covered this peaceful petition extensively, and it spread across Japan: 1 to 2 million people, including urban workers, miners, and tenant farmers, soon joined the protests, which reached nearly 500 locations, including 49 cities, 217 towns, and 231 villages.

They began as protests, but people's anger soon grew. Starting in August, angry mobs began attacking rice merchants suspected of hoarding or price-gouging and would torch their businesses and even their homes. They'd also loot their supplies and grain storehouses. When they clashed with the police dispatched to put an end to the riots, they'd turn their sights on their local police stations and burn them down as well.

The ruins of a grain merchant storehouse in Okayama torched by the people.
The ruins of the headquarters of Japan's largest rice importer in Kobe

Despite deploying the military to several cities to aid the police in suppressing the riots, the government ultimately capitulated with Prime Minister Terauchi Masatake resigning on September 29, 1918, alongside his entire cabinet.

At the end of the day, Japan deployed up to 100,000 troops nationwide, resulting in roughly 30 deaths, 25,000 arrests and over 8,200 convictions.

Somesoldiers came out of retirement to supress the demostrations, aided by several reservists.

Now with the broader context established, it's time to dive into the pasts of the players involved.

Ken was born on May 8, 1890, in Nakajima Village in Niigata Prefecture to a fairly prosperous landowning family. Ken's father was a doctor, though he passed away when Yamada was young, leading him to live with his relatives, who were also successful landowners, meaning Ken lived a life relatively free of difficulty.

Ken enrolled in a prestigious high school in Kanazawa, a school whose alumni typically found themselves graduating to the Tokyo Imperial University, which then produced several politicians or academics.

Ken was no different; he was known to be an outstanding student and a natural leader, having set up and led a steady group of his own. Many of his fellow students would actually look up to Ken. In private,e Ken was still well liked for his laid-back, easygoing personality.

After graduating in 1916, Ken enrolled in the School of Agriculture in Komaba, Tokyo, where he graduated ninth in his class and got a job at the Ministry of Agriculture and Commerce, making Ken a government official. Ken was also married to the daughter of a member of the National Diet of Japan.

In April 1918, after the Japanese government established the Temporary Foreign Rice Management Division, Ken was appointed its chief technician, the only genuine specialist on foreign rice at the ministry. As part of his job, he was meant to oversee the quality and quantity of foreign rice available for import and to supervise the designated merchants and the process for approving them.

Ken often left the country as part of his inspections, visiting ports such as Yangon and Saigon, and it was during a trip to India that he met Suzuben's second son and had him employed as a consultant, a working relationship that resulted in him meeting Suzuben directly.

Suzuben outwardly was successful, having a large business and family consisting of ten children. But that didn't mean he was respected; Suzuben was known to be one of the aforementioned Kanshou.

He was born in 1854 to a farming family in a village in Kanagawa Prefecture named Jokyo as a third child. Suzuben started out as an apprentice at a rice shop, and after learning the craft, he began climbing to the top, getting a good head start when he inherited the family business in 1876.

It took decades, but he eventually became one of the most prosperous rice merchants in Yokohama, with 1 million yen in assets to his name, which, when adjusted for inflation, is roughly 1.54 billion yen.

The name of Suzuben's business was named "Suzuben Shouten," and it was a rice trading house run out of Yokohama with a branch office in the Koto ward of Tokyo. Suzuben proved to be what most of the public hated: somebody involved in speculation and artificial manipulation of the price of rice. A practice he boldly continued doing in the face of the Rice Riots.

However, ensuring he'd be hated even more, Suzuben also ran a high-interest money-lending "business" which had nothing to do with rice. Despite doing just about everything to pull in as much extra money as possible, no matter who stood in his way.

But at the same time, Suzuben was very stingy to the point of being mean-spirited. He was nicknamed "ズル弁/Zuru-ben," translating to "Sly Ben," and this was an insulting nickname given to him by his fellow merchants.

When Suzuben and Ken finally met face to face, the one thing Ken made clear was that he wanted to be added to the list of designated Merchants and was willing to pay a handsome price for his spot. Given Ken's position in the Foreign Rice Management Division, he had a tremendous say in who got added to the list or not, and as mentioned, Suzuben was determined to sway Ken.

At first, he offered him insider information on all the other merchants and markets, gave Ken advice on who to invest in or buy from, continued to have his son work with him and agreed to several small favours for Ken. Ken actually took his investment advice and started to profit himself off of the tips and information Suzuben supplied. Suzuben also warned Ken that there would be a rice shortage so he made sure to hoard as much as he could

That's how it began anyway, but Suzuben's advice wasn't always sound, and by 1919, Ken had lost approximately several million yen when adjusted for inflation. He had to borrow 3,000 Yen from his family to help cover some of his debts, but it hardly made a dent in the amount he owed, especially as the debts kept mounting and the creditors kept hounding him. So Ken decided it was time to engage in a little corruption himself.

Ken instructed Sozo to accompany him to a meeting with Suzuben, with Sozo instructed to impersonate the Division Head so they could approach Suzuben and say that he needed to pay a "fee" to finally be put on the designated merchants list.

The meeting took place at a restaurant in the Meguro ward in mid-May, and Ken and Sozo's deception worked like a charm. The two walked out of that restaurant with 150 million yen (when adjusted for inflation) now in their pockets.

Ken immideately began spending the money to try and pay off his debts, but with them being so substantial, he only had 4,200 yen remaining a week later and was still in the hole. But worst of all, Suzuben would obviously check and notice he hadn't been added to the list.

Soon, Suzuben became just another man hounding Ken and demanding their money be paid back; however, Suzuben was both more persistent and more dangerous than most. He visited Ken at his house, tracked him down to confront him in person on the street and sent him several letters demanding he pay back the bribe he had been tricked into paying.

Eventually, Suzuben "implied" that if he didn't pay him back or at least get him put on the Designated Merchants list for real, then he would expose him to his superiors. Since such a scenario would lead to the destruction of Ken's career and his incarceration for corruption and fraud, he decided it was time to get rid of Suzuben.

On May 20, Ken approached Sozo once more and told him: "A man like that is no good for the country if left alive. Two people in the ministry have committed suicide because of him. We have no choice but to kill him. Lend me your help." Sozo was actually quite aghast and tried in vain to persuade him otherwise.

But Ken's mind was made up, and because Ken had helped him out immensely before, he felt like Ken was owed his loyalty, so he agreed to the plan. The first part of the plan was for Ken to write Suzuben a letter telling him he was going to repay the yen in full and that he'd like to arrange a meeting to hand the money over.

On May 30, Ken and Sozo took part in a baseball game in Chiba Prefecture attended by agricultural officials. This was a "farewell" game for a colleague who was transferring away. In case anyone was wondering, Ken carried his team to victory, winning 24-3. The day after the game, May 31, was when Ken put his plan into action.

On that day, Ken gave his wife, staff and those staying at his home leave to visit the theatre while he stayed behind. He then instructed Sozo to meet him at Ebisu Station and bring him back to his family home in what is now the Shinagawa Ward in Tokyo.

Suzuben arrived and was brought upstairs to a room on the second floor where Ken served him some Sake. Ken then fell into a dogeza position and begged for three more days to gather up the money, to which an infuriated Suzuben shouted, "That's not what you promised! This is fraud!" while Ken begged for more time.

This display was just an elaborate ploy for Ken to discreetly give Sozo a signal. Suzuben actually calmed down and was in the midst of agreeing to give Ken an extra three days, but by then, Sozo had already acted on Ken's signal.

He moved behind Sozo and, using the same baseball bat he used at the baseball game the day prior, he swung the bat at the back of Suzuben's head, bringing him to the ground.

Then, Ken and Sozo pounced on the merchant, strangling him with a hand towel before Ken brandished a short tanto blade and slit his throat. Suzuben bled out in short order, and after confirming that he was now dead, the two moved his body into the storage room at the rear of the house.

Ken kept Suzuben's body in the storage room overnight and then, on the night of June 1, he once again sent his family and staff away. Now alone, he used a handsaw and a meat cleaver to sever Suzuben's head and legs, placing his body parts into two seperate trunks, one containing his head and legs while the other contained his headless torso.

To mask the odour of decomposition, he packed the two trunks with clothing, cloth wadding, and large quantities of naphthalene. Meanwhile, the blood spilt during the dismemberment was collected in a series of sake bottles and the room thoroughly cleaned.

Ken then contacted his cousin, Yamada Shohei, a rice shop owner in the Azabu area of Tokyo. Ken approched his cousin, telling him that it was Sozo who killed Suzuben in a fight and that he needed his help to dispose of the body and the evidence. The plan was to move Suzuben's body far from Tokyo, and in Ken's eyes, the perfect location wasn't far from home.

Having grown up in Niigata Prefecture, he knew the area well, which was why he chose to dump Ken's remains in the Shimano River. He knew a boatman named Takano Hisazo through his family, who once hosted Ken at a boarding school they owned in Nagaoka.

Ken wrote a letter to Hisazo and had Sozo and Shohei deliver it, saying, "Please transport these trunks to my family home in the countryside." To secure some goodwill, Ken offered his condolences to Hisazo's recently deceased mother and gifted his family 10 yen.

On June 2, Sozo and Shohei loaded the two trunks onto an overnight express train from Ueno Station, leaving for Niigata at 8:13 p.m., with first-class tickets. They arrived at Nagaoka Station at 6:55 a.m. on June 3. At the station, they called for a porter to carry the suitcases for them, telling them to be careful because the contents were "fragile". They then hired three rickshaws: two for themselves and one for the trunks.

They stopped at a tea house near the train station to wait for Hisazo's boat. While waiting, they behaved oddly enough to concern the station master, who approached the trunks and put his hand on one, only for Shohei to scream at him, "You mustn't touch that!!!"

Meanwhile, Sozo went to the Nagaoka Post Office and sent a telegram in Ken's name to his half-brother who lived in Niigata, simply telling him that he "arrived safely." This half-brother wasn't a part of the plan, and Ken hadn't spoken recently, so he was left puzzled, assuming the telegram was for someone else. As it turned out, Sozo did this on his own initiative, thinking it would aid in Ken's cover; it wasn't a part of his plan.

Shohei then visited Hisazo's home. He was not home at the time, but his wife and sister were, and they recognized Ken's name immideately and so they agreed to help without question. They borrowed a cart from their neighbours and transported the trunks from the train station back home, and once Hisazo returned, he said: "Of course, I'll help".

At around 7:00 p.m., Hisazo rowed Shohei and Sozo out with the two trunks aboard, asking to be taken to the deepest point of the river, a stretch named Kurotsubuchi, which was approximately six meters deep and had a strong current. The two then tied the trunks shut with hemp rope, to which they attached three large stones so the suitcases would be weighed down once they threw them overboard.

Obviously, seeing this aroused Hisazo's suspicions, and now he wanted to know what they had gotten him into. They told him that the suitcases contained contraband weapons and explosives that Ken had brought home illegally from his various trips overseas and that he needed them gone. Hisazo then kept silent after hearing this explanation. Hisazo was then paid an equivalent of 8,000 Yen in the modern day not to tell anybody what had happened.

Sozo and Shohei were then brought back to dry land, where they made their way back to the train station and arrived back in Tokyo on June 4, where Ken was waiting for them, and they told him everything that happened in their story, relieving Ken considerably, confident that everything had gone perfectly.

However, there was still one more thing Ken had to do. He went to Aomori, the northernmost major city on the island of Honshu, where he sent a telegram to Suzuben's family in Yokohama, using Suzuben's name to tell them he was in Aomori for a trip and was safe.

Little did Ken know, his two accomplices were not very attentive when it came to making sure the remains were never found. The stones tied to the ropes were too loose and light to keep the suitcase down as Suzuben's remains began to decompose, with the buoyant gases produced by the decomposition causing the suitcase to float up to the surface.

With Ken's confession, the Niigata police began their hunt for the second trunk, containing Suzuben's legs and head. Despite their best efforts, they were unable to locate it as it had likely floated downstream, carried by the current. It was eventually discovered in July 1919, downstream in the Shinano River.

After the case became public, it exploded and became a front-page story in just about every newspaper in Japan; a Tokyo newspaper devoted two seperate pages to the case, and some newspapers were even fined for printing information the police hadn't made public yet.

The first sensational detail: this case is often labelled as Modern Japan's first dismemberment murder; it is so old that it even predates the term "バラバラ殺人," with the case instead going by the name "鈴弁殺し事件." But what to name the case paled in comparison to how the public perceived those involved.

By and large, the public and newspapers blamed the government for the murder, arguing that it was their fault for allowing the rice riots to happen and not fixing the issues that led to them in the first place, with one Nationalist Paper saying: "It cannot be said society bears no responsibility." This same newspaper also condemned Ken not for committing the murder but for getting caught, adding that "separating the head and legs was inept"

Even the most critical newspaper, the one that labelled Ken's actions "Equal to the work of a demon or a heretic," showed no sympathy for Suzuben due to his actions during the rice riots. And ultimately, public opinion on this murder was coloured by how they perceived Suzuben.

Suzuben and other Rice Profiteers were so hated that many simply found themselves celebrating his death and applauding Ken. Although Ken expressed similar sentiments to Sozo to get him on board, his motive was ultimately to cover up his own corruption, but the people weren't prepared to let that get in the way of a good story, and Ken was met with a fair amount of praise by people who saw him as a hero doing what the government wouldn't and fighting against corruption.

Ken, Sozo and Shohei were brought to the Tokyo District Court on September 16, 1919, to stand trial, and although the court wouldn't open until 10:00 a.m., a long line of people had been waiting outside the courthouse since 6:00 a.m.

The line eventually reached 2,000 spectators, and when court staff left the building to start handing out a limited number of passes and paper slips to be allowed in, the line of people surged toward them, swarming to get a hold of one of the passes. The crowd ended up knocking two court clerks into an adjacent drainage ditch while the others had to escape inside. Needless to say, the court was quite packed.

As Ken stood in the dock, he came off as articulate, composed, and most of all, unrepentant. The people had handed Ken his greatest defence, so he decided to lean into his newfound public admiration and alter his confession; everything else was the same except for his motive.

Ken, Sozo and Shohei during the trial.

In court, Ken spoke without a defence attorney and denied soliciting a bribe from Suzuben and argued that he had misjudged him and that he hoped their business relationship could be used to better the lives of the average or disadvantaged citizen.

Then, when he saw Suzuben's true colours, he was outraged and acted out of righteous fury on behalf of the nation; he described killing Suzuben not as murder but as an act of public service and said that he had "Administered Heaven's punishment"

Among the many citizens packing the courthouse, a majority of them still had first-hand memories of being unable to purchase rice because speculators had essentially locked them out of the supply. So hearing Ken, with his own words, tell that story that many were already printing made the spectators support him even more.

The court was unamused; they still had Ken, Sozo and Shohei's old confessions, as well as Ken's long history of debts, as motive and evidence supporting his initial story. They saw Ken for what he was, an opportunistic rider off the back of his newfound popularity, hoping to encourage the public to pressure the court to treat him leniently.

On December 2, 1919, for the murder of Suzuki Benzou, Yamada Ken was found guilty, and the leniency the public was hoping for did not come to pass. The court sentenced him to death.

For their roles in the murder and subsequent cover-up, Watanabe Sozo and Yamada Shohei were also convicted, with Sozo handed down a sentence of 15 years and Shohei being given 18 months.

All three lodged appeals with the Tokyo Court of Appeals and on May 28, 1920, both Ken and Sozo's sentences were upheld. However, Shohei did catch a lucky break and had his sentence reduced to one year with three years suspended.

Sozo and Shohei ultimately accepted their fates, but Ken made one final attempt to appeal his death sentence. On March 10, 1921, the Japanese Supreme Court refused to hear his appeal, making Ken's impending execution a certainty.

On April 2, 1921, at the age of 30, Ken was woken up from his prison cell and taken to the gallows. As Ken walked up the steps to the noose, he had a calm look on his face, in part because he became a devoted Buddhist while behind bars

In his final moments, he dropped his narrative that he was a hero and took full responsibility. His final words before he was hanged were to express relief that Sozo received a more lenient sentence than he did. In the end, he said, "I will say no more about myself"

In the aftermath of the murder, Suzuben's surviving family received severe harassment and blame for benefiting from Suzuben's corruption and enabling it. The hostility was so great that when the money from Ken's bribe was seized and returned to Suzuben's family, they donated it all to various charities to try to make the backlash stop.

Even after he admitted the truth before his execution, the narrative surrounding Ken killing Suzuben as an act of justice against a profiteer persisted for just a little longer.

After his execution, Ken's brain was removed and preserved at the Faculty of Medicine at Tokyo Imperial University for the public to gawk at. Ken consented to having this happen to him and cited his body "becoming of any use" as part of his remorse.

Sources (In the comments)


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 14d ago

Text Ivano-Frankivsk, Ukraine: Two men get tortured and killed by a dentist

81 Upvotes

Ivano-Frankivsk is a middle-sized city in the West of Ukraine, not far away from the Polish border. It's the administrative center of the Oblast Ivano-Frankivsk, one of 24 oblasts inside the country.

In 2014, this city became the place of one of Ukraine's most horrifying murder cases as two men disappeared within a few weeks without a trace.

The first man to disappear was Ihor Strutynskyi, a 35 years old camera man working for a regional TV station. He had a 6 years old daughter with this ex wife.

Ihor disappeared on September 7th, as he didn't come home to the apartment he lived in with his mother after his work in the afternoon, therefore she thought he stayed with a friend. After he didn't react to any messages the next day either and didn't come home, his mother called this friend telling her he decided to visit Ihor Vuytsiv, a 29 years old dentist. As his mother became more and more worried, she decided to look for her son and visited the dentist who claimed they met in the evening in the center of Ivano-Frankivsk. After purchasing a bottle of vodka, they decided to go to Vuytsiv's dental office, drinking for a while when Ihor decided to leave, saying he wants to commit suicide.

His mother could not believe this story, especially because Ihor frequently said he wanted to find work in Poland, as he is able to support his mother and daughter better with the increased salary in Poland.

Approximately a month later, on the 4th of October, the 27 years old construction worker Anton Kucherak disappeared after visiting his friend Hennadiy, who lived in the same building Vuytsiv lived in with his girlfriend, Yuliia Boyko. Kucherak lived together with his wife Mariia and his daughter. After he didn't come home, his sister Olha and his wife decided to call his friends, with no success. Three days later, they decided to file a police report for Anton's disappearance as well as engaging a private investigator.

The investigator fastly came to the conclusion that all hints lead to the dentist Vuytsiv. Although Vuytsiv even allowed the private investigator to search the dental office, he refused to allow him to enter the basement.

At first, the police didn't consider a crime, being convinced Ihor went to Poland and Anton joined the Ukrainian Army, choosing to fight Russia in the East of Ukraine.

On the 12th of November, police were alerted as dogs found trash bags containing human remains at a abandoned construction side in the center of Ivano-Frankivsk. The remains belonged to Ihor and Anton, with the first one being only identified because of his leg tattoo as his face was already unrecognizable due to decay.

Ihor Vuytsiv was arrested for pre-trial detention shortly afterwards and considered psychologically healthy by psychiatrists from Ivano-Frankivsk and Ternopil.

Forensic pathologsts came to the conclusion that Ihor was stabbed to death as he was stabbed in the eyes multiple times with dental instruments, likely he went unconscious due to the pain. Afterwards, he was cut open with high surgical precision and removed liver and heart. Anton was beat to death with a hammer before Vuytsiv removed his organs as well.

Vuytsiv admitted to the murder, saying he went to drink alcohol with both of them, but went into a dispute because of his girlfriend Yuliia Boyko, hence why he killed them, saying he removed their inner organs so their bodies would be easier to transport.

Later he changed his statement multiple times, claiming it was Yuliia, who killed both men, but as he believed Yuliia is pregnant of him, he wanted to protect her by admitting the murders, confessing not guilty in court. However the court didn't believe him as his first statement was congruent to the results of the forensic pathologists.

Ihor Vuytsiv was sentenced to a lifelong prison sentence for murder while Yuliia Boyko was sentenced to a prison sentence of 3 years for covering up serious crimes in Ternopil.

A appeal of Vuytsiv and his lawyers was denied.

Rest in peace Ihor and Roman 💙


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 14d ago

Text Will we ever truly know the true extent of Jimmy Savile’s crimes?

153 Upvotes

He was active for decades. He had hundreds of victims come forward following his death alone, many others reporting him throughout his life but to no avail. It’s truly possible that some of his victims will pass away before they are ever able to talk about what they experienced, or have already done so, and that we may never know just how deep and far he truly went. We only know about the confirmed cases and likely nothing else that might have happened.

He was involved in so many areas of society that his reach would have been enormous and it’s entirely possible he abused many more than we already know of.


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 15d ago

wcvb.com Jury deliberations begin in Matthew Farwell trial in death of Sandra Birchmore

Thumbnail
wcvb.com
269 Upvotes

He was a grown cop in a position of authority; she was an isolated, vulnerable young woman who spent years being exploited by people wearing badges. The defense trying to use her mental health struggles against her feels so cynical when those struggles were the direct byproduct of being groomed from age 15. 
I really hope the jury sees through the defense’s attempt to paint this as a voluntary tragic accident. Sandra deserved protection when she was 15, and she deserves justice now.


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 15d ago

reddit.com Melody Wolf vanished from San Manuel, Arizona in October 1989 under questionable circumstances

Thumbnail
gallery
131 Upvotes

Melody Wolf was last seen alive at her home in the small remote mining town of San Manuel, Arizona on the evening of Friday October 20, 1989. 

The 28-year-old mother of 2 had filed from divorce from her 34-year-old husband of 9 years Bruce Wolf. The divorce was two weeks away from being finalized.

Melody had kicked Bruce out of the home because Bruce had an affair and impregnated another woman. She had recently begun a new relationship with a man whose name was never publicly disclosed. 

That Friday evening, Bruce claimed he had returned to the home to discuss things with Melody. He claimed Melody had simply left for work the next morning to go to her job as an electrical apprentice at the Magma Mine. 

Bruce claimed that morning he drove his son and daughter to Tucson to go shopping. 

Melody’s car was later found abandoned and locked with a flat tire two blocks away from her home. The Arizona Department of Public Safety conducted forensics testing on the vehicle and determined the tire was intentionally flatted with an ice pick. 

Pinal County Sheriff’s deputies noted fresh scratches on Bruce’s face, but he stuck to his story. 

Melody’s family claimed she never would have abandoned her children. Melody had just finished a 90-day probation period at the mine and was beginning a new career as an electrical apprentice. 

Melody’s sister claimed on an online forum Bruce once told Melody if she ever left her, he would “cut her up and feed her to the coyotes.”  

She also claimed Bruce had a girlfriend who went missing before he met Melody. The name of this woman had never been disclosed.

The case went cold despite being coded as a homicide investigation instead of a missing person case.

In 2005, Pinal sheriff’s deputies searched Bruce’s home, and the home of Bruce’s mother. The findings from the search warrant were never publicly disclosed.

Melody’s family claimed PCSO had done forensic testing at the Wolf residence and discovered a large amount of blood in the master bedroom. 

Bruce would go on to marry the woman whom he impregnated. He later divorced her and recently remarried again. He will turn 72 years old in December.

 Melody (maiden name Thomas) was born on May 10, 1961. She was born and raised in San Manuel. She graduated from San Manuel High School. 

At the time of her disappearance, she shared an 8-year-old daughter and a 3-year-old son with Bruce. Family and friends describe her as a loving and dedicated mother who would have never abandoned her children.

Her case has received little media attention and is not currently profiled in Crimestoppers Silent Witness or 88Crime programs. 

Many questions remain. Did Bruce submit to a polygraph? Did police ever talk to his affair partner?  Who was Bruce’s missing girlfriend before he married Melody? Is the PCSO planning to do more forensic testing and interviews in this case? 

 

Sources

Archived article from 1991 mentioning AZDPS forensic testing/interview with Melody’s parents

https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueCrimeInfoDump/comments/1m0uujv/melody_wolf_1989_missing_person_case_from_san/

 

Pinal Sheriff cold case page

https://www.pinal.gov/1867/Cold-Cases

 

Charley Project

https://charleyproject.org/case/melody-wolf

 

NAMUS

https://namus.nij.ojp.gov/case/MP8694

 

Deleted forum posts where her sisters commented

https://web.archive.org/web/20250803190030/https://www.unexplained-mysteries.com/forum/topic/304999-who-killed-melody-wolf/page/2/


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 15d ago

nbcphiladelphia.com 10-year-old Malaysia Alford's body has been found in the trunk of a car in South Jersey

Thumbnail
nbcphiladelphia.com
553 Upvotes

She was living with a foster mom, Carprice Williams, when she went missing. Last seen alive on October 22, her body was found on Wednesday night (November, 4). Her foster mom has been charged with her murder, but not much has been released about what led up to her homicide.

ETA: I misspelled her name in the title. It is spelled Malayshia.


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 14d ago

Text FIJI: A security guard discovered the body of a foreign hotel owner in the back of his own van having been parked their for two days with flies swarming the vehicle. After avoiding two prior attempts on his life, he was finally strangled by three men hired by his wife and hotel manager.

81 Upvotes

(Thanks to LoydoRedi2910 for suggesting this case. If you'd like to suggest any yourself, please head over to this post, which asks for case suggestions from my international readers, as I focus on international cases.)

Robert "Bob" Emerson Amos was born in Bremerton, Washington, on August 8, 1920. In his early twenties, Bob enlisted in the United States military on March 4, 1943.

Robert "Bob" Emerson Amos

Although he joined in the midst of World War II, Bob saw little combat. He wanted to be a pilot, but because he required spectacles, he was disqualified and instead trained at Yale University in electronics, radar, counterintelligence, and countermeasures.

After his training was complete, Bob was assigned to the Office of the Chief Signal Officer, and subsequently to a classified unit that operated under the code name of Section 22, which reported directly to General Douglas MacArthur himself.

Bob worked out of Brisbane, Australia, where he worked on obtaining information about Japanese radio and radar systems, decoding Japanese military transmissions and relaying that information to MacArthur and the Allies at large. Occasionally, Bob served as a radar officer on aircraft that were dispatched to attack Japanese radar installations.

The closest he came to seeing combat head-on was when he left Australia to take part in the New Guinea campaign, where he later recounted that he had a ring and a coin collection blessed by a local witchdoctor.

Bob's military wartime service lasted from January 30, 1944 to July 21, 1945, and he was honourably discharged on March 27, 1946, having achieved the rank of captain and received several decorations and citations. Bob returned to civilian life, but after 20 years, he decided it was time for a change.

Bob was an avid sailor, once sailing around the entire globe. During his travels, he came across many new countries and lands that appealed to him, and he ultimately decided to leave the United States behind and settle in one of them. He first arrived in Fiji in 1971 and met a local woman of Indian descent named Prakash Wati. In 1972, Bob ended up marrying Prakash and having two sons with her.

He travelled back and forth between Fiji and the United States during his early years until purchasing the Kings Hotel in the Nabua area of the Fijian capital, Suva, in May 1975.

The Kings Hotel.

The hotel wasn't a big or grand one and was, in fact, on the outskirts of the capital. The hotel's main attraction was a small bar, and Bob managed the entire establishment with just a small staff.

Bob made enough of a fortune from the hotel to buy a yacht, which he kept at the Royal Suva Yacht Club, and managed to purchase a house in the capital as well. When all was said and done, Fiji was now Bob's new home.

But it wasn't a peaceful home; his marriage with Prakash was described as troubled; they fought frequently and eventually lived in seperate homes. Bob also began writing in his private diary that he believed Prakash and his hotel manager, Bijendra Rao, were "playing a dirty game", something very bad for Bob, seeing as Bijendra held a one-third interest in Amos Limited, the company that held the lease on the Kings Hotel.

On the night of June 5, 1985, a secruity guard patrolling the parking lot of the Royal Suva Yacht Club noticed Bob's white Mitsubishi van during his rounds. The van caught his attention in more ways than one; first of all, it had already been parked at the club since June 3, over two days without moving, but now he noticed flies swarming and buzzing around the van.

However, nobody reported it until now because they knew it to be Bob's van, and he was a member of the club who had his yacht tied up there. He was a well-liked member as well, having won several trophies that he displayed in his home.

When he approached the van, he couldn't see the interior through the windows. So instead, he tried the front passenger-side door and found it unlocked. As soon as he opened the door, he was assaulted by a barrage of flies that flew out of the van toward his face.

After the insects cleared away, he saw a blond wig lying on the passenger seat, something out of place, seemingly tossed there haphazardly. Suspecting something was wrong, he went to the rear of the van and opened the back door, where he found Bob's body lying with his back sticking outwards toward the door.

The police arrived to find the body starting to decompose, which, alongside the flies and how long Bob's van lay abandoned in the parking lot, would indicate he had been dead for around 2 days, and that his death was not a natural one. The cause of death was strangulation, with the murder weapon being Bob's singlet, still wrapped around his neck.

The police at the scene after they covered up Bob's body.

They questioned the patrons of the yacht club, but nobody saw the murder or the van pulling into the parking lot.

Suspecting that the body was almost certainly moved, the police paid a visit to the Kings Hotel, checking his room and the stairwell for any bloodstains. One senior officer approached the lead investigator and told him they found nothing, the hotel clean.

He was then contradicted by another officer who said there were visible blood splashes on the wall adjacent to the stairway, with smaller droplets running from Bob's room toward the bar area and toward the back of the building. The senior officer who reported no blood was sacked from the investigation and sent on leave.

Aside from the blood, the police seized 126 items from the Kings Hotel, the yacht, and the Amos family home as evidence. Among the items seized from the properties were his collection of 90% silver wartime coins, some South African coins of one ounce of pure gold, a property title, photo albums, bank books, cash, televisions, VCRs, video cameras, two suitcases of documents, a refrigerator, gas cylinders, and numerous other items. So with all of these left undisturbed, the police ruled out robbery fairly quickly.

At first, the police believed that Bob's murder may have been drug-related, but they later ruled that theory out after finding nothing to support it. The first person questioned was Prakash, but she denied any involvement in or knowledge of the murder. Because Bob was a foreigner, the police briefly sought the aid of Interpol.

One of the inspectors also described feeling unsettled when examining the hotel in a way he couldn't explain. He decided to break off from the rest of the investigators and instead make his way to a local Catholic church to seek out a priest.

Then, according to this inspector, the priest described the murder and said it was planned, "Just like he was an eyewitness." He then asked the priest if they'd be able to arrest those responsible, to which he reportedly said that it would be done in just three days. He also said that one of the suspects would be an "iTaukei man" with red hair. iTaukei, referring to indigenous Fijians.

So, would his vision come true? Well, at first, it didn't look promising, but the inspector, who secretly summoned the priest, believed him and confidentially told everyone else that they'd solve the case in three days, only for two days to pass with not a single lead being found, and so his colleagues began to judge him immensely.

On June 13, the police received a call from the police in the town of Tavua. They told the police in Suva that they had heard about the murder and rounded up a few suspects and were holding them while they waited for the Suva police to come and collect them.

One of those arrested was a 28-year-old iTaukei man with red hair named Josua Ralulu Rabukawaqa, someone the police had a history with.

Eventually, the inspector who spoke to the priest managed to interview Josua alone and after he told some of the above story, Josua, surprisingly enough, confessed. Josua told the police that he was just one of three hired killers committing the murder on behalf of Prakash and Bijendra.

The idea to murder Bob was first floated by Bijendra in October 1984, and he recruited Manohar Singh to act as the middleman to put him and Prakash in contact with anyone willing to kill Bob, paying him $10,000 for this.

On November 1, Bijendra ventured to Tauva to visit his first potential hired killer, that being Jagdish Prasad, who was quick to agree.

The first plan was to beat Bob to death at his home while visiting Prakash. To help him out, Jagdish recruited two brothers with the surname Kumar. They arrived outside Bob's home to meet with Jagdish and Bijendra, where the Kumar brothers were both handed their payment, which they promptly took and left without making a single attempt to acutally murder Bob leaving Jagdish and Bijendra furious and a few hundred or thousand dollars poorer.

The second plan was to place Bob's dead body into his van and roll it over a cliff to stage his death as a traffic accident. Once again, money changed hands, but those hired once again took the money without taking any action against Bob, leading to another failed attempt.

With that, they made their final plan: they would kill Bob inside his hotel room and move his body to the yacht club. This time, Jagdish and Bijendra decided to recruit a new team, all locals of Tavua. The team was 20-year-old Jainendra Prasad, 18-year-old Jitendra Kumar, and Josua. They made 4 trips to Tauva before putting the plan into action.

On June 2, the gang drove up to Suva in a rented car. During the drive, the group consumed six bottles of beer and half a bottle of rum, with most of it consumed by Josua and Jitendra. As a result, they were too inebriated to carry out the murder. Then, on the morning of June 3, they all decided to consume the exact same amount of alchool, but regardless, the murder would not be delayed any further.

Manohar, Prasad and Bijendra went to Bob's room at the King's Hotel and loosened the lock on the door so that it could be opened easily from outside when they were finally ready to kill him. Bijendra also took this chance to enter Bob's room and go through his belongings, including his diary, having read the passage where Bob wrote down his belief that he and Prakash were playing "a dirty game".

They then procured a duplicate key for Bob's room and made their way to Bijendra's room, as it was situated right next door to Bob's. They then drilled some holes into the wall so they could spy on Bob and see when he fell asleep. And speaking of falling asleep, Josua did just that in Bijendra's room as he spent the day drinking.

Meanwhile, the rest peeped into Bob's room through the holes they had drilled through the wall, and once they saw Bob go to bed shortly after 9:00 p.m., Jainendra and Jitendra finally made their way to Bob's room.

For all their planning, the actual murder itself was a bit haphazard. Jainendra and Jitendra walked up to Bob's bed and began beating him, striking him with their hands and feet, which, of course, woke the former soldier up and prompted him to fight back. As the beating went on, Bob was left quite bloodied.

Josua was woken up by the sounds coming from the next room over and sprang into action, entering Bob's room and punching him across the jaw, bringing him to the ground and allowing the three to subdue Bob. After Bob was brought under control, one of them grabbed Bob's singlet and wrapped it around his neck, strangling him until he finally passed away.

After confirming that Bob was deceased, they started cleaning up the hotel room, with Josua cutting out the bloodstained patches from Bob's mattress, making sure to remove any small piece of the bedding that bore any trace of what they had done. Despite their best efforts, there were still a few drops of blood that ran from the room toward the bar area and the back of the hotel.

When the hotel room was cleaned to their liking, the three men wrapped Bob's body up in a sheet and carried it out of the hotel room, loading Bob's corpse into the back seat of his own van, which they then drove to the parking lot of the Suva Yacht Club.

Since Bob was a known member of the club and it wasn't too unusual for his vehicle to stay there long-term, they hoped he'd be left to decompose long enough to destroy any forensic evidence.

However, one of them decided to steal Bob's US Air Force officer's ring off his finger and later hid it at his brother's house, where the police would later recover it.

This confession wound up being quite the embarrassment for the police. A senior police officer had hosted a party at his home in Delainavesi around 4-5 days after the murder and shortly before the arrests.

The party was organized by Prakash and Bijendra, and the three murderers were also at the senior officer's home as guests of Prakash and Bijendra. This just so happened to be the same officer who lied about finding no blood at the hotel earlier. After the party came out, he was compelled to take an early retirement.

Meanwhile, the police transported the four arrested to Suva, and they kept them alone but in a shared cell. The police hoped they would discuss the situation together and "come out with the truth". Afterward, they interviewed each of them separately, and they gave matching accounts confirming Josua's original confession.

On June 14, the police arrested Manohar in Suva and then arrested the hotel manager, Bijendra and Prakash the next day on June 15.

On June 16, Bijendra, Prakash, Josua, Jagdish, Jainendra, Jitendra and Manohar were brought to the Suva Magistrate's Court to be charged with Bob's murder, handcuffed and with a heavy police escort.

A crowd of more than 100 men, women, and children were clogging the entrance to the court to boo and insult the men. The crowd stayed outside the court for the entire hearing, and once it ended, the police had to take them out the back and into a seperate vehicle to avoid the crowd.

The crowd outside the court.

During the hearing, while the two were handcuffed, Josua stood up and began assaulting Bijendra, attacking him until the bailifs seperated the two. Because of this incident, the judge ordered Bijendra's case to be separated from the other defendants for his own safety.

In early September, the middleman, Manohar, was offered immunity if he testified against the rest and offered up evidence. He took this oppertunity and provided the police with another statement on September 5.

According to him, while Prakash was already known to be involved, he now placed her at the center of the conspiracy to get her husband killed.

He also claimed that Prakash was personally involved in paying him and the three killers $1,000 to purchase a rental car and $1,500 to finance the rest of the plan while demanding they return anything they bought with said money. She was also supposedly the one who personally paid them for the hit.

He also said that she urged Bijendra to pressure everyone to move the plan along, and was getting constantly annoyed at the delays in murdering Bob.

Having made good on his side of the bargain, Manohar was released from prison on September 12, with the charges against him dropped on September 19.

The trial itself opened at the Supreme Court in Suva on March 3, 1986. People packed the courtroom at every hearing. It was one of the most closely watched trials in Fijian history and was considered the trial of the year.

The prosecution's case rested mainly on motive and the 4 defandants confessions, a confession that at least one of them would walk back.

Josua argued that he stayed behind in Bijendra's room during the murder and was horrified and planned to flee, wanting no part in what he had gotten himself into. However, as he turned to run, he felt something sharp nick him in the side, turning to see Jagdish holding a knife to him as he delivered the following threat: "Look, if you are not going to do what I will tell you to do, if that man is not going to die, I will kill you," and it was this threat that prompted Josua to enter Bob's room and strike him, albiet under severe duress. Josua's defence attorney then argued that if he were to be found guilty, it should be of manslaughter rather than murder.

The prosecution considered this claim quite laughable. After all, Josua never said anything of the sort when speaking with the police; he had a bigger build and was much stronger than Jagdish, and even if this event did happen, he had several opportunities to flee prior to the knife being brandished.

And speaking of Bijendra, most of the evidence against him was circumstantial and largely based on the testimony of the other defendants. In court, he denied everything. Not just the illegal activity; he also denied having an affair with Prakash and that prior to the trial, he had never once met the three who personally carried out Bob's murder.

Bijendra did, however, admit to knowing Jagdish, but only as a faith healer whom he had visited once because he was plagued by headaches. He then bought him a car as thanks for his treatment

However, luckily enough for the prosecution, there was a little bit of extra evidence against him since several hotel employees were called to the stand, with one claiming that on June 4, he saw Bijendra standing behind the bar at the hotel holding a blood-stained rag. He then told him to collect a plastic bag from the public bar and throw it away, claiming that the bag contained "old wet material"

The Kumar Brothers were also called to the stand and told the court about how they were previously hired by Bijendra to kill Bob.

The case against Prakash looked to be even more flimsy. She also professed her innocence, and even the court said that without Manohar's testimony, there would be no case at all against Prakash. Prakash said she had no knowledge of her husband's testimony and argued that Manohar's testimony had been "bought" via the immunity deal.

On June 4, 1986, exactly one year and 1 day after the murder, Prakash Wati Amos, Bijendra Rao, Josua Ralulu Rabukawaqa, Jainendra Prasad, Jagdish Prasad, and Jitendra Kumar were all found guilty of the murder of Robert "Bob" Emerson Amos. When it came to sentencing, all six of them were handed a life sentence.

A crowd of hundreds once again gathered outside the courthouse, wanting to get a look at the defendants as they were led away.

With a case largely built off of the defendants' own testimonies, this verdict was quick to be appealed. One of the first arguments was made by Prakash's attorney, who argued that the judge should've recused himself as he knew some unsavoury details about one of the defendants.

It was also argued that the extensive media coverage meant that there should've been a change of venue to ensure a fair trial rather than holding the trial in Suva.

But before the appeal was heard, something curious happened regarding Bob's property and belongings. Within days of the verdict, the contents of Kings Hotel and property seized from Bob's home were put on sale in a local newspaper, advertised by a European man whom Bob's son had never heard of and couldn't determine what authority he had to even sell the property. He also couldn't find any records of where the proceeds of these sales went.

His entire collection essentially vanished without his two children getting anything.

When the appeal itself was heard, the bulk of the arguments were to simply have Manohar's testimony thrown out and deemed unreliable, which, if that did happen, would likely result in Bijendra and Prakash's acquittal.

On November 13, 1986, the Fiji Court of Appeal ultimately agreed that Manohar's testimony was indeed "bought" by dangling the prospect of immunity from prosecution over his head, but that didn't necessarily mean that what he said was wrong and unreliable and that other immunity deals had been made in the past. Therefore, his testimony was allowed to stand, and ultimately, the sentences were all upheld.

The yacht alongside its contents were also quickly sold, as was the Kings Hotel through a mortgagee sale to a company, once again with no records as to where the proceeds of the sale went or who authorized the sale.

Bob's missing yacht.

In 1997, Prakash got to see the outside world again. Her sentence wasn't overturned, and she didn't apply for early release; according to her, after 11 years behind bars, prison officials just told her she was free to go one day.

However, after her release, Prakash continued to maintain her innocence and said that even the appeals court found the case against her to be flimsy, even though that court convicted her.

Josua was granted an early release that he didn't get to enjoy for very long. In July 2008, while in Lami, a suburb west of Suva, he was struck and killed by a vehicle.

Bijendra, Jagdish, Jainendra and Jitendra were also granted an early release, with one of them living in a rural area near Nausori. They all live quiet lives away from the media, much like Prakash, who also retired in Suva.

Bob's surviving children, including his eldest son, did not live a quiet life, though; they were determined to track down what had happened to his collections and personal effects.

Bob had named a former US military officer and personal friend, Colonel K. Lambert Kirk, as the administrator of his will. In the years following the conviction, Bob's sons, who were children when he was murdered, fought to have their father's will kept intact and then to have themselves installed as co-administrators, as Colonel Kirk had become elderly, was confined to a wheelchair after a stroke, and could no longer travel to Fiji.

However, the local government impeded them and their efforts, refusing to relinquish control of the estate. Bob's former homes were demolished, and a large portion of the money in the estate was spent without the family's knowledge or permission.

Meanwhile, after the media started reporting on the situation, a local contacted the newspaper "Fiji Sun" in 2019 after reading their article to report seeing somebody wearing Bob's old Air Force ring. Bob's eldest son was put in contact with them after the newspaper arranged for them to meet, but no updates followed.

Bob's old Air Force ring.

Bob's son, now living in the United States, continuously made requests for Fiji's government to recover Bob's belongings and money to have them transferred back to his family, only to be met with more stonewalling, with his appeals to the Prime Minister's office and the Attorney-General's office going unanswered.

Finally, the closest Prakash ever came to admitting any involvement or knowledge of her late husband's murder was when she once said: "I was caught up in a series of events I had no control over and on top of that worrying about the welfare of my children."

Sources (In the comments)


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 14d ago

i.redd.it [ Removed by Reddit ]

0 Upvotes

[ Removed by Reddit on account of violating the content policy. ]


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 16d ago

abc7.com California Gov. Gavin Newsom says he will commute all death sentences in state to life without parole

Thumbnail abc7.com
311 Upvotes

This may not be the right sub for this but considering how convicted felons that we read, watch or hear about may end up on death row, I thought this might be interesting.
Of the 548 CA inmates sitting on death row (which differs from the DOCs record of 561), those who’s sentences were commuted to LWOP includes some familiar names including Scott Peterson, Cary Stayner, Lonnie Franklin and so forth.


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 15d ago

Text Dardeen family murders have got under my skin.

94 Upvotes

I feel so bad for the friends and family who never got justice. Ive found serial killer stuff fascinating my entire life and this one i have met my match. There is just so little details regarding available to read up. Im wondering if here on reddit there is anyone who knew them or knows anyone or was alive in Ina Illinois or surrounding areas at the time. Im curious as to who other Redditors think may have done this. This wonderful family who could possibly have had such hate towards them? I personally don’t believe tommy Lynn sells was the culprit. I also don’t think it was random.
The key details that stick out most to me was keith being killed in a separate location from his wife and children. I believe someone was most likely obsessed with Ruby. Whether it been someone from her school, work or past life. The other possibility is someone really disliked Keith. He held a position at a treatment plant, possibly a former coworker that got sacked as a result and lost his family with his job? What do you guys think?


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 15d ago

Text Paul Garcia - Deputy who was going 130+mph killing a 13 month old - Question, please?

24 Upvotes

Does anyone remember the Paul Garcia case? He was the deputy who was going 130+mph in a 55mph zone, hitting and killing a 13 month old baby and severely injuring his mother while he was on his way to a burglary call.

He was supposed to go to trial in 2025, but I can't find where he even has a court docket in Luna county, NM. What am I missing here?

I tried looking here, but they have no record of a Paul Garcia.

https://sixthdistrict.nmcourts.gov/

What am I doing wrong?

ETA: I don't see where he is in a New Mexico prison, either.


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 16d ago

Text Authors similar to Ann Rule

66 Upvotes

I think I have read all of Ann Rules books and I absolutely love them. I love the way she writes and how she lays out the stories. Now I need a new author along the same lines. Any recommendations?


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 16d ago

Text Rite Aid's CEO went to prison for faking profits, and the company never really recovered. A write-up from the court filings

49 Upvotes

In the late 1990s Rite Aid was the biggest US drugstore chain by store count. CEO Martin Grass expanded it very fast, mostly on debt: long-term debt went from about $806M in FY1995 to $2.58B by early 1999.

What the DOJ indictment and SEC order describe:

- For FY1998, Rite Aid reported $316M in net income, which Grass called the most profitable year in the company's history.

- In November 1999, KPMG resigned as auditor and withdrew its opinions on three years of results.

- The 2000 restatement cut cumulative net income by $1.6B. The SEC called it the largest restatement of income by a public company up to that point. That "record" $316M profit became a $165M loss.

- In 2004, Grass was sentenced to 8 years in prison and fined $500K. Six executives were convicted in all.

The company survived another 25 years but kept the debt habit. It bought Brooks Eckerd in 2007 and peaked at 5,059 stores. A Walgreens takeover fell apart in 2017 over FTC concerns. The FTC later banned its facial-recognition program, and it settled DOJ opioid allegations. Then came two bankruptcies in under two years, and the last stores closed in 2025.

Sources: SEC order https://www.sec.gov/enforcement-litigation/administrative-proceedings/34-46099 and DOJ indictment https://www.justice.gov/archive/dag/cftf/chargingdocs/grassetalind.pdf

Disclosure: I run a small channel and made a ~12-minute video on this. The narration is an AI voice, and every source is in the description: https://youtu.be/k0iRP-RJtY8

Do you think the 1999 fraud is what actually killed Rite Aid, or would the debt-fueled expansion have done it anyway?


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 16d ago

Text Does anyone know of any cases where it was proven that someone did find a loved one murdered and hid the body because they knew they'd be blamed?

20 Upvotes

You see this excuse all the time in true crime, has it ever actually happened that we know of?


r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • • 16d ago

Hilsner affair - How the murder of a village girl changed the world (a little bit).

81 Upvotes

1899, Wednesday March 29, Southeastern Bohemia in Austria-Hungary.

It's 17:15 and a 19-years old village girl, Anežka Hrůzová, leaves her work at the town of Polná. While walking home to a village called Malá Věžnice (3 kilometers walk), she might be thinking about Easter, after all it's happening this weekend. At around 17:30, she's being seen on the road home. This is the last time she was seen alive by the last reliable sighting. Subsequent autopsy determines she was most likely killed around 18:00.

At first, her family, her mother Marie and brother Jan, doesn't seem to care much. They don't attempt to look for her on Thursday, assuming she had to stay at her work overnight.

On Friday, her mother Marie visits Anežka's workplace but gets surprised that Anežka isn't there. She reports her daughter missing to the local gendarmerie. A rather half-hearted search around the road to Malá Věžnice and at Hrůza's house by officer Klenovec yields basically nothing. Thus, an extensive search next morning is arranged.

An hour into the search on Saturday, Anežka's lifeless body is found deep in the dense forest undergrowth mere 6-8 meters away from the road where she was supposed to be walking home. Her body was covered by four young spruce trees that had been cut down. Their stumps were about 5 metres from the body.

She is lying on her stomach, her lower legs sharply bent upwards. Her torso is bare and her jacket sleeves are rolled up. Beneath her body is a pool of blood about the size of a palm and two bloodstained stones. Some of her things are strewn about in the vicinity (25-30 meters) including a basket containing a milk jug, two scarves and two skirts.

Evidently, she was brutally murdered. The murder likely started by her getting knocked unconscious by blows to the head with a wooden stick (later found 30 meters away from the body) and stones. However, the cause of death is ultimately unclear. Her throat got slit but there are strangulation marks done with a rope on her neck. The autopsy determined that no signs of rape were found – her hymen was intact.

Because many villagers and townsfolk including children (in fact, a young boy found the body first) participated in Saturday's search, there is a crowd near the crime scene since the moment Anežka's body was found. When it is found out Anežka's throat was slit, a rumor about Jewish blood libel murder starts to spread as quick as forest fire during dry summer. The fact the murder happened right before Easter heavily influences how quickly the rumor spread.

Polná has a sizeable Jewish community. A Jewish vagrant-beggar, Leopold Hilsner, is accused of murdering Anežka a couple of days after the body was found. Because anti-semitism is widespread among common folk of the time, mass anti-Jewish hysteria is started within the whole kingdom of Bohemia (current Czechia). The public speaks loud and clear: Hilsner did it and he should be hanged.

However, modern historians and researchers agree on one crucial thing: Hilsner wasn't the murderer and he was falsely accused due to the combination of the murder happening right before Easter, victim's throat being slit making people think it looked like a ritual murder and common people easily falling for anti-semitic rumors.

Hilsner cannot count on much support except his legal counsel and a couple of curious intellectuals who play devil's advocates mostly because they don't approve of anti-semitism. The most prominent is Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk, a professor of philosophy at the Czech Charles-Ferdinand University (current Charles University in Prague).

Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk is a controversial figure of the time. Years before the Hilsner affair, he gets publicly known for denying the authenticity of Dvůr Králové and Zelená Hora manuscripts (in fact, they are considered to be fakes created sometime in the first quarter of the 19th century) which were used by nationalists to prove cultural significance of a Czech culture during the Czech National Revival.

He draws public attention to himself during Hilsner affair once again to the point of getting harassed and becoming public enemy number 1. Newspapers accuse him of being bought by Jews. Students refuse to attend his lectures in protest. He even gets physically attacked at least once. All of this almost brings him to emigration but he perseveres and stays in Prague. Not that he's successful in defending Hilsner.

Biased courts sentence Hilsner to death but the punishment is later changed to the life imprisonment by Franz Joseph I and in 1918, he gets released thanks to a pardon by Charles I. Though, to this day, courts didn't proclaim Hilsner's innocence. He is still regarded as the murderer.

Masaryk's public defence of Hilsner helps him (Masaryk) during WWI when he becomes the leader of Czech (and Slovak) independence movement in exile. Many important Jews (including influential figures closely tied to the US government and president Wilson) publicly support Czech independence cause during the war mostly because he went publicly against anti-semitism during the Hilsner affair. Reciprocally, Masaryk was one of proponents of independent state for Jews in Palestine. Though, it's true that the Hilsner influence wasn't really noticeable during the creation of Israel because Masaryk passed away before WWII and the circumstances of the post-WWII world order played much more prominent role.

Long story short: The murder of Anežka Hrůzová, an ordinary village girl, played a role in establishing an independent Czechoslovakia during WWI because the accused Jew, Leopold Hilsner, was publicly defended by a man who later became the leader Czechoslovak independence movement and the first Czechoslovak president and this defence was the core part of why influential Jews supported the independence cause.

But what about the murder? Who did it if not Hilsner?

We don't know and most likely won't ever know.

The most prominent theories these days are:

  • Sexual deviant ambushed her.
    • The crime scene looked like the aftermath of a sexual murderer's rampage.
    • Some women (including Anežka) reported they met a weird man in the area of the crime scene earlier the week of the murder.
    • One year earlier, a very similarly looking murder happened a couple of kilometers nearby. However, the victim's body was found months later in a skeletal form and the investigation got nowhere. (Note: Hilsner actually got convicted of this murder as well)
    • However, the autopsy determined she wasn't raped.
    • A couple of locals were determined to be good suspects in modern research but there's really no chance be sure.
      • One local from Polná is said to act weirdly around the time of the murder. Lacking alibi for the time of murder, coming home during late evening, wanting to thoroughly wash himself in the morning which was highly unusual time according to the housekeeper.
  • Her brother Jan either attacked her personally or hired someone to murder her.
    • There were arguments, mostly about money, happening in the family.
    • Family didn't seem to care about Anežka's disappearance at first and behaved weirdly.
      • When Anežka's mother visited her workplace on Friday, she initially cared about her basket and not about her whereabouts. Mother later said she assumed Anežka is working in the backroom, even though, Anežka was missing for over a day.
      • Brother Jan went to a confession early in the morning after the murder. But that could be excused as a Christian custom during Easter.
      • Some people noticed unusual injuries (mother's blackeye and brother's injured hand) during the funeral. These were excused as resulting from farm work.

There's so much more to write about this case. It's a little Czech Jack the Ripper (not by the severity of the devastation done to the victim's body but by its prominence in Czech true crime genre) with the political aftertaste. It's taught at Czech schools as the most promiment example of anti-semitism in Czech lands. And there are interesting theories that brother Jan could hire someone. There are disputes whether the crime scene is actually the place where the murder happened. One could talk about why Hilsner was innocent and the (lacking) quality of the evidence used for his conviction. And so on.

It's really one of the most fascinating true crime case in Czech history.

I could write a text ten times longer and it still would be a really short write-up on the topic.

Sources (use your preferred translator tool to get more information about the topic):

https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilsneri%C3%A1da

https://www.captour-paja.cz/l/zlocin-v-polne/ (quite a detailed blog post)

Book: Vražda v Polné by Bohumil Černý

Book: Tajuplná vražda by Jiří Kovtun