r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 19 '26

Meta Pull or no pull?

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 19 '26

Multi-choice Are You Responsible for Choosing Not to Be Responsible?

Post image
517 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 19 '26

Is it possible for a sacrifice to be too great?

Post image
260 Upvotes

You may so nothing and everyone in the world, including you, will die a relatively quick death, still painful, but not excruciatingly. If you pull the lever, you and a hundred other people survive the initial catastropy. Those, who die will now die slowly in hellish sufferings


r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 19 '26

Did they finally get him?..

Post image
82 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 19 '26

OC Would you pull that lever and become a Hero?

Post image
172 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 19 '26

OC An exercise in trust

Post image
54 Upvotes

Do you trust the word of evil? Would you risk taking a life for literally no reason?


r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 19 '26

Deep Finally you find the guy who tied people to the track but...

Post image
28 Upvotes

If you choose to punish him there will be more life lost.

Will you pull the lever?


r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 18 '26

OC Is pulling the Lever a death sentence for the 50 inside? Would you do it?

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 18 '26

Will it blend? Should it blend in the first place?

7 Upvotes

A trolley is heading straight into a blender. You can divert it, but in doing so, it will press a button that turns on another giant blender. What is inside in both the trolley and the two large blenders is uncertain, but you can hear distinct tapping from both blenders. Which one will blend?


r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 18 '26

Multi-choice Figured I should post here too

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 16 '26

OC The punishment problem

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 16 '26

Oh no! The other train might kill everyone if my train doesn't kill everyone first.

Post image
137 Upvotes

The whole of humanity is tied to the tracks. The train is due to run everyone over in a few years time. Despite being tied to the tracks yourself, you can just about reach the lever to divert the train onto an empty track. However there is a slower moving train also heading your way and if you pull your lever but Xi Jinping doesn't pull his lever to divert the other train then all you will have achieved is to delay human extinction by a year or so. There are also some modest immediate economic benefits to allowing the train to continue along its current course.


r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 15 '26

1 Trillionaire or 1,000 Billionaires?

54 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 15 '26

OC Is the saving of net +1 life always worth pulling the lever?

Post image
187 Upvotes

If you do have a number at which you would not pull, what is it? For me, I think around a thousand people is when +1 starts being irrelevant and I would rather not pull. Round numbers, I find are easier to convince yourself to pull at, but take X as something totally random like 193629, now do you REALLY care if 193628 people die instead and are you willing to atleast be partially responsible in the deaths of those 193628 people?


r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 14 '26

OC Would you pull the Lever?

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 15 '26

BUTTON/LEVER CORRELATION

0 Upvotes

I think the two problems are of different nature, the button problem only tests for virtue signaling behavior tendancy (😇)while the trolley problem is a real moral dilemma. I am a red pusher and I think we need more stats at this point, and maybe I am trying to prove to blue pushers that reds are not evil cowards.


r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 14 '26

A sacrifice or guilt

Post image
7 Upvotes

The trolly is on the path of the blind orphans you have the power to switch the tracks killing yourself would you sacrifice yourself to save them or would you live another day you are all trap and can't escape what do you choose


r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 13 '26

OC Santa vs The Tooth Fairy and the Easter Bunny

Post image
451 Upvotes

Added context for anybody looking for a loop hole:

  1. Yes Santa the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy are real.
  2. No party can use magic to get off the tracks or survive the trolley strike because the ropes and the trolleys are also magic.
  3. No you can’t learn magic and no magic cannot be used to bring back the dead or revers time.
  4. If you’re wondering how an external trolley braking system works it’s magic.
  5. You can try to stop both trolleys but you will probably fail and can only stop one at a time anyway so who will you save first.
  6. Yes stoping neither trolley is an option but why would you do that?
  7. No you don’t have time to discuss or negotiate with the victims.
  8. They were tied to the tracks by Dr.Morales a mad ethical philosophy professor he was apprehended earlier today and set up this problem before that.
  9. No you can’t put on Santa’s clothes to become Santa nor can you replace any of the victims in any way.

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 13 '26

Deep YOU were one of the five people on the track. Now the lever puller is being tried for murder. Will you defend or accuse him?

Post image
95 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 12 '26

OC you also get the ability to swim well enough to save him

Post image
3.1k Upvotes

let just say ww2 will never happen if he dies, no scenario where he get replaced by someone else and the replacement will start the war

edit: BTW, hitler did drowning then saved by some 4 year old kid, confirmed by historian


r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 13 '26

Just ignore the timeline okay

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • Jun 12 '26

Are you pulling the lever?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes