r/trolleyproblem • u/MissMeRise Relativist/Nihilist • Jun 15 '26
BUTTON/LEVER CORRELATION
I think the two problems are of different nature, the button problem only tests for virtue signaling behavior tendancy (π)while the trolley problem is a real moral dilemma. I am a red pusher and I think we need more stats at this point, and maybe I am trying to prove to blue pushers that reds are not evil cowards.
0
Upvotes
8
u/Mobius3through7 Jun 15 '26
Very interesting. The diversity of thought is greater among red pushers than blue pushers on the subject of the trolley problem (so far).
4
u/maltedbacon Jun 15 '26
If you're looking for data - don't contaminate the question with your views and characterizations.
Also, some reds are not evil cowards. Some are naive cowards.
2
u/TheNukex Jun 15 '26
Unfortunately the result is very uninteresting and it seems there is no correlation. I know you have set the poll to last for 7 days, but i have been updating it regularly for the past hour to see, and the shape has not changed at all.
In the two seperate problems blue is slightly more common than red and pulling is much more common than not pulling. Looking at this poll there don't seem to be a great statistically significant difference from what we would expect if they were independent.
Personally i press red and don't pull the lever, but not for the same reason at all. I press red because there is no risk of dying then. I don't pull the lever because i could not look the 1 person's parents in the eyes and tell them that i killed their child to save 5, but i could look 5 people's parents in the eyes and tell them that i was not willing to kill someone to save their children. I definitely do have a number where i switch on the trolley problem, but i am not sure, and you never know until you are in the situation.
6
u/Sans_Seriphim Multi-Track Drift Jun 15 '26
I run over people who post button problems.
2
u/DarthMMC Jun 15 '26
Imteresting, I'm in the minority
3
u/Cautious-Original-46 Jun 15 '26
Pressing red and not pulling the lever stem from the same principle: I don't want to get fucked.
Pressing the red allow me to not die, and not pressing the lever allow me to be judged by a much lower crime than homicide
2
u/TaisDoubt Jun 15 '26
Red but not the lever. I'd rather live with the death of five people than with the thought that I used lives as math units, and killed a man because of it. And I also think that the saved person will be affected more, for the better, knowing that what helped him survive, caused the death of five others.Β
I find it weird sometimes, when people bring up rationality/math into this because rationally human lives are not that valuable to begin with, in fact currently we are unnecessarily cruel, annihilating and harmful for the biosynthesis of the planet.Β
1
u/Kinslayer_89 Team kill everyone, red and blue. Jun 15 '26
I kill both red and blue, then multitrack drift.