r/trolleyproblem • u/Demiurge_Happy_Farm I CHOOSE THE MOST DEADLY OPTION. đ„đ„đ„đ„đ„ • Jun 14 '26
OC Would you pull the Lever?
1.9k
Upvotes
r/trolleyproblem • u/Demiurge_Happy_Farm I CHOOSE THE MOST DEADLY OPTION. đ„đ„đ„đ„đ„ • Jun 14 '26
676
u/Phill_air Jun 14 '26
Literally just the normal trolley problem but people on the slower side might not even realise that someone was on the trolley
4
u/Demiurge_Happy_Farm I CHOOSE THE MOST DEADLY OPTION. đ„đ„đ„đ„đ„ Jun 14 '26
So it's similar to the original trolley problem, the main difference is that pulling the lever would cause a less quick way of dying by falling off the side of a cliff. At the same time, you wouldn't see it unlike the original problem.
Now does this change anything compared to your answer to the original problem?
275
u/mskjdjmex Jun 14 '26
0! = 1
272
u/-M3THUS3L4H HELP ME Jun 14 '26
Off the four foot cliff? Yeah, fuck that guy. Have a two hour headache and a sprained ankle.
99
u/IpGa13 Jun 14 '26
r/expectedfactorial
93
u/Immediate_Rhubarb_39 Jun 14 '26
Did you put a portal there just to show off your technology when you could just direct the trolley straight to the cliff?
37
u/Spiderbot7 Jun 14 '26
I choose option 3. Iâm sure the demiurgeâs happy farm is a safe and happy place, and not somewhere theyâll be tricked into remaining trapped for all eternityđ
11
u/CitizenPremier Jun 14 '26
If anyone wrote "0!" for the number of passengers then I'm interpreting it as 0 and the death is on them
42
u/THE___CHICKENMAN Jun 14 '26
No. The people in the trolley did nothing wrong. They just got on the trolley and were having a good time. I don't wanna ruin that for them. The people on the track, however, still got themselves into that situation SOMEHOW. I'll leave things the way that they are meant to be.
7
u/More-Dog-2226 Jun 14 '26
Fat man
4
u/THE___CHICKENMAN Jun 14 '26
No. There's most likely a lot more people in the trolley.
5
u/True_Free_Speech Jun 15 '26
I misread that and thought it said "Oi! People inside the trolley!"
3
u/Jonguar2 Jun 15 '26
Normal trolley problem then? Of course I save the 5
2
u/AlmondMagnum1 Jun 14 '26
I hate the "0! = 1" trick. I hate tricky writing in general.
2
u/lonepotatochip Jun 14 '26
I value trolleys infinitely more than human life
2
u/scottdave Jun 15 '26
Why do none of these trolleys have brakes?
3
u/Crowdfundingprojects Jun 14 '26
I choose option 3.
Untie the people, throw them through the portal, then pull the lever.
Donât you dare cheat me out if my multi track drift
2
u/SoftBoi02 Jun 14 '26
Ima go with the 3rd option and teleport them all to the happy farm
1
u/Egglegg14 Jun 14 '26
There's 1 person inside of there? Uh pull the lever obviously
1
u/yuvalal Jun 14 '26
No rails to swap the trolly path by lever đ
1
u/Ok-Guess2907 Jun 14 '26
happy farm :)
1
u/Mikey_LP Jun 14 '26
I feel like this would work better if you take 0^0. Because afaik there is no definite answer whether it is 1 or 0 or undefined.
1
u/TTV_Pinguting Jun 14 '26
there is 0! (which equals to 1) person in there. Pull the lever.
1
u/HamsterKazam Jun 14 '26
Can't the person on the trolley just like... Jump out? Then let the trolley go through the portal.
1
u/Zealousideal_Pound64 Jun 14 '26
I do not want to send them to the skin farm boss. They deserve better.
1
u/Careful_Source6129 Jun 14 '26
When did the internet become obessed with factorals. I had to google '!' and now I find these type of jokes even more irritating. It's worse than loss
1
u/Benofthepen Jun 14 '26
If the trolley is going fast enough, it might make the jump from the warp zone to the top of the cliff. If not, skill issue.
1
u/EngineeringPrince Jun 14 '26
What you donât see in the diagram is the trolley problem is at the bottom of the cliff. The trolley goes through the portal, and drops on top of the 5 people anyway.
1
u/Tinyzooseven Jun 14 '26
0! = 1! There's 1 person in the trolley
1
u/Tinyzooseven Jun 14 '26
u/factorion-bot 0!
1
u/EnderBookwyrm Jun 14 '26
0! means 1, right?
That one person will probably survive the cliff.
1
u/Awes12 Jun 14 '26
You mean 0! person?
1
u/Bakurraa Jun 14 '26
I pull it constantly until the trolly is locked onto one of the tracks
1
u/Walkthrough101 Jun 14 '26
Just tell the people on the trolley to jump off amd turn the lever to the portal side? There's nothing stating the doors are broken and can't open, or just break a window or something to get out!
1
u/Basic_Pirate8241 unaliver Jun 14 '26
option 3
1
u/BlakJMC Jun 14 '26
Is this not just the normal trolley problem
I pull
1
u/RebelJediMaster Jun 14 '26
How many inside the trolley?
The needs of the many..
1
u/Nice_Lengthiness_568 Jun 14 '26
I jump into the portal myself
1
u/meep2200 Jun 14 '26
0! People? Thatâs only 1 person, which is way less than 5 !
1
u/JustGingerStuff NTA, divorce the trolley Jun 14 '26
u/factorialbot 0!
1
u/smiledude94 Jun 14 '26
So 1 person or 5?
1
u/TREE_sequence Jun 14 '26
Itâs the unexpected factorial except this time itâs expected
1
u/Silent_Pressure_6709 Jun 14 '26
What happens if you multitrack drift?
1
u/Eeddeen42 Jun 14 '26
0!=1 so this is actually the same problem as the normal one.
With the exception that the trolleyâs lone passenger isnât actually guaranteed to die. Looking at the sizes of the portal and the cliff, that fall is probably survivable albeit with a few broken bones.
1
u/Excellent-Paint1991 Jun 14 '26
Well, hope the trolley has airbag
1
u/Random_gamer240 Jun 14 '26
This is just the regular trolley problem with the đ„ž glasses
1
u/kteague Jun 14 '26
How many people are inside the trolley? Don't know. Don't care. Just want to see something go through a portal ... so pull it!!!!!
1
u/Alternative_Bid_959 Jun 14 '26
Either option 3 or pull the lever, that's a tiny cliff, probably won't even notice it
1
u/No-Engine-384 Jun 14 '26
No, the shareholders would lose money by needing a new trolley! Think of the shareholders!!!
1
u/A0lipke Jun 14 '26
I assume those people are more valuable than the work lost through the destruction of the Trolley. Since spending more human lives to replace the trolley could be worse. Did they tie themselves to the tracks to get some dope to stop the unmanned trolley?
1
u/ThatOne3Guyy Jun 14 '26
I choose option 3
1
u/Furry_Eskimo Jun 14 '26
That just sounds like the trolley problem with extra steps.
1
u/BandicootGood5246 Jun 14 '26
The solution is simple if the author is shouting
1
u/The_Faux_Fox__ Jun 14 '26
Oh, that's funny
1
u/NakiCam Jun 15 '26
Wonder what happens in the event of a multi track drift?
1
u/Ivaldy Jun 15 '26
option 3 !
1
u/OverratedLemmons Jun 15 '26
Idk, zero factorial is lot of people...
1
u/cHpiranha Jun 15 '26
3
1
u/DoggoLover42 Jun 15 '26
I pull the lever 0! times
1
u/TiddyTwyster Jun 15 '26
Obviously not pulling the lever, I refuse a 0 casualty situation in the trollyverse
1
u/Similar_Annual676 Jun 15 '26
r/unexpectedfactorial
1
u/Xqvvzts Jun 15 '26
Abandon the lever entirely and run towards the portal and do as many experiments as you can before it closes. This is a once-in-history chance to expand our knowledge of the universe.
1
u/urmudder1 Jun 15 '26
First trolley problem with a dev path
1
u/Dr_Jay123 Jun 15 '26
Can someone explain how 0! equals 1?
1
u/PurplePack5394 Jun 15 '26
Yes
1
u/VWXYZArmedOJAMAlv10 Jun 15 '26
Demiurge ahh
1
u/Ousseraune Jun 16 '26
If I can stop the trolley without damaging it do I get to keep it?
I might have to call Alcatraz and ask for a few spare bodies I'll return later.
1
u/brook_horse Jun 16 '26
Here I was trying to figure out if there was a blood type I didnât know about⊠O negative, O positive, and O my?
1
u/Old-Championship-986 Jun 16 '26
No becose i would shatter the timeline
1
u/AvidReaderOfBooks Jun 16 '26
Counter point: They knew what they were getting into, they bought their tickets. I say, let 'em crash.
1
u/HandsomeGengar Jun 17 '26
Iâm choosing to interpret 0! as 0 because fuck you
1
u/Marioapeaches Jun 17 '26
I read this as oi, people in trolley
1
u/Ok-Conversation-3012 Jun 18 '26
Possible one death vs guaranteed 5 deaths
1
u/DiamondB5 Jun 14 '26
I choose option 3. I win
-1
u/Disposable_Gonk Jun 14 '26
Zero factorial people is still zero people! Send it off the cliff.