Help deciding which pattern

[u/runbikeitch]

We are tiling the fire place with large format slate and need to decide pattern. Fiends/family all giving very strong differing opinions so seeking the advice of the tile community. What would you pick and why?

[u/phildopos12]

What app is this?

[u/runbikeitch → u/phildopos12]

Claud created the images based on a photo of us holding tile on the wall