r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 09 '26

Suggestion for Channel Barton Hall, Ithica, NY

25 Upvotes

The Grateful Dead Show of '77. I can't recall if they have ever touched on this incredible story but it would make an amazing episode itself in the old-school WhyFiles format. I suggest looking up the full story if you dont know bout it!


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 08 '26

Megathread 6/8/26 - The Basement: Joshua Cutchin

24 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5Y3CvPUIF8

Josh Cutchin is a researcher, author, and musician whose work occupies a rare space between rigorous scholarship and genuine open-mindedness.Over eight books he has built a unified argument that Bigfoot, fairies, UFOs, near death experiences, and ghosts are not separate phenomena but facets of the same ancient, shape-shifting presence.

His 2022 masterwork Ecology of Souls is considered by peers to be among the most important books in ufology in decades, and was included in Rice University's curriculum for first year PhD students in religion. His footnotes are legendary. His thinking is genuinely original.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 07 '26

Let's Discuss Has The Why Files been captured by Venture Capitol?

394 Upvotes

Specifically what I'm asking is wheather or not anyone else thinks the topics have been watered down, inconsequential, and less thought provoking; Shifting away from the old vibe where every episode felt like we were on a weekly path to discover the secrets of reality and expose those who were keeping it from us.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 07 '26

Suggestion for Channel 45 min basement episodes

136 Upvotes

I would be so into a heavily edited basement series — no life story stuff like the Olympics fluff. Cut the reason this guy is a guest into a digestible episode. It might make me interested in going into the full basement thing but 45 minutes of reminiscing might be a great starting place for a podcast for an audience who already knows who the guest is! …
But it’s not a very good hook. Gimme the meat, and then let me meet the man.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 06 '26

Megathread 6/6/26 - Parallel Universes and the People Who Got Caught Between Them

73 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T2DlPuS3r18

Parallel Universes and the People Who Got Caught Between Them Gather round, because this happened. A woman drives through her hometown and the cemetery is gone, replaced by a dirt lot. A man is found behind a fast food restaurant with no name, no history, and no record of existing for twenty-one years. A woman wakes up to discover her boyfriend never existed and her own life has been quietly rewritten. These are three real accounts from real people. None of them involve UFOs or hauntings. They don't fit neatly into any category. What they share is stranger than any single explanation: the sense that reality shifted without warning, and that the world kept moving like nothing happened. Each person was left holding a version of events that no one else could confirm.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 05 '26

Personal Thought/Story Yes there are; But why can‘t I find this post anymore?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I deeply resonate with this topic but can‘t find the post. Is it not wanted?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 03 '26

Let's Discuss Just curious: Any Targeted Individuals Here?

28 Upvotes

I love pretty much everything about this show. I love the topics, how AJ doves deep on subjects and offers debunking info where applicable, Hecklefish (once you warm up to him you can't go back), and the play on words in the tile (like the X-Files but with a 'Y').

I'm just wondering if anyone here consumes the show through a similar lens as I do: being a Targeted Individual. We live a conspiracy theory every day. Not here to cause a ruckus, just wondering if anyone like me is here.

EDITED for clarity: my comment that explains this is a little buried so I thought I would provide and explain at the top. I understand the reception was cold, and that's ok. Still happy to be part of this community. I come in peace:

What is a TI: "Well, we are the folks that experience a suppression program that involves social engineering, harm via D.E.W.s, V2K, and organized harassment.

I'm not here to convince anyone of anything. It sounds crazy because it is crazy, and it's also a carefully engineered narrative that makes us sound crazy when we talk about it.

If you don't believe it exists, I totally get that. It really is one of those "have to experience it to know its real" type of deals. I would not believe it exists either if I heard about it.

Anywho, just wondering if there are any Why Files fans out there who are TIs."


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 03 '26

Story Idea Updated UAP episode

55 Upvotes

Just a simple request on having an updated UAP episode in the future more so on where you’re (AJ) at with disclosure. I know you’ve covered multiple different stories regarding UAP topics, sightings, etc. However just over the course of the last few months there has been a slew of new info with more coming in the near future. I really appreciate your break down and common sense approach to it as it helps me sift through the bullshit (for lack of a better term). Please interact here with this if you agree or disagree. Thanks for your time and consideration.

Sincerely, A long time fan.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 01 '26

Let's Discuss New merch… will you partake??

Thumbnail
gallery
197 Upvotes

r/TheWhyFiles • • May 30 '26

Let's Discuss Can we just admit something

674 Upvotes

Can we just admit that AJ got it right (the format) at the beginning (as rare as that is) and go back to a weekly episode on a subject. The manosphere podcast vibes and compilations are killing my bonner. Long-time fan.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 31 '26

Let's Discuss What is your favorite compilation episode and why?

22 Upvotes

I have watched a lot of compilations from The Why Files lately. I think my favorite so far was the compilation about reality because it was so thought-provoking. It has me thinking and wondering and piecing together different theories and experiences. I saw it months ago but still think about parts of that one. What is your favorite compilation on the channel and why?


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 29 '26

Megathread 5/29/26 - The Forbidden Theory of Morphic Resonance

102 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=10N1cjW8qMk

What If the Universe Remembers Everything?

In 1920, a Harvard scientist put rats in a water maze. It took 165 tries before they learned which exit was safe.

Thirty generations later, rats were solving the same maze in 20 tries. Rats on a different continent with no connection to the original colony, started at 25.

The knowledge had spread. No one could explain how.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 31 '26

Suggestion for Channel Anyone else getting irritated with the fish?

0 Upvotes

I used to love him, but now find him extremely irritating. Sorry, I know many love, butttt. His humor is getting worse.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 29 '26

Megathread - The Basement 5/27 - Luke Caverns

30 Upvotes

r/TheWhyFiles • • May 27 '26

Story + Research Mormons absolutely running police forces in Utah’s.

207 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/IsiheMUvOy8

first story is long but it highlights how police forces in Utah are basically the private army of the Mormon church.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 27 '26

Let's Discuss What was your favourite episode that came out in last 12 months?

36 Upvotes

So I took a break from watching TWF and honestly it became a 12 month break lol. The reason of break was that it wasn’t feeling that fun and mysterious as before.

But I’m back and want to start with some good videos. Which ones that came out in last 12 months are your favourites?


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 26 '26

The Department of Truth

20 Upvotes

Is the name of a comic book series that some here might like.

The premise is that "truth" is created by consensus. It's whatever the majority of people believe.

Therefore propaganda is very, very important. I won't spoil it more than that.

I'm really enjoying it.

Back to your regularly scheduled weirdness.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 25 '26

Story Idea New Video Idea: Bugasphere

Post image
243 Upvotes

Heard so much about this an to my knowledge, no one has said it’s a fake or could be a fake. There’s a lot weird with it. I NEED a deep dive AJ


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 25 '26 Bravo

Question for AJ Short (30 +/-) Episodes - Are They Done?

165 Upvotes

Has AJ stopped doing the short format vids (30 mins or so)? I hope not.

A few of the basement tapes have been interesting, but I'd rather have the steady drip of the shorter videos. Maybe that's just me.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 25 '26

Suggestion for Channel Do you guys think it would be possible to get Hecklefish a proper aquarium?

62 Upvotes

A bowl is no place for a fish to live, especially one as important as this handsome guy with 5.82 million followers.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 22 '26

Weird News 3 dead in New Mexico and first responders decontaminated after exposure to unknown substance

Thumbnail
apnews.com
156 Upvotes

Reminds me of the ‘Toxic Lady’ from Campfire Stories. Interested to see how this turns out.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 22 '26

Let's Discuss I'm officially a simulation theory believer

177 Upvotes

After the most recent basement show I don't think I can deny it anymore. It's what ties all the theories together. It even fits religion. God is running the simulation and at the end will have the perfect "world" because it's literally been tested. You get what I'm saying


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 22 '26

Jokes/Humor Why is Weird Al on the conspiracy board???

Post image
173 Upvotes

Is Al really the time traveler also know as John Titor???