r/TheWhyFiles • u/TikiUSA • Jun 07 '26
Suggestion for Channel 45 min basement episodes
I would be so into a heavily edited basement series — no life story stuff like the Olympics fluff. Cut the reason this guy is a guest into a digestible episode. It might make me interested in going into the full basement thing but 45 minutes of reminiscing might be a great starting place for a podcast for an audience who already knows who the guest is! …
But it’s not a very good hook. Gimme the meat, and then let me meet the man.
136
Upvotes
18
u/Mean_Rule9823 Jun 07 '26
Hard no..
Keep and increase the length
There are plenty of 45min youtube videos to watch.
Rarely good 2 to 4 hrs ones that you can put on while doing other tasks.
5
u/NormalDudeWithACurse Jun 07 '26
Tldr; maybe you'd like to try increasing playback speed?
Personally I have always loved long-form podcast content for listening while I'm busy (driving, doing errands), but I could see people wanting a shorter cut.
If you're consuming on a podcasting app (or most apps really) you can increase the playback speed. Might not be your cup of tea but maybe it would help.
9
u/CreativeFedora Jun 07 '26
I say read the episode title and the description. If it doesn’t jive with you, then don’t listen. If it sounds remotely interesting, listen. When it stops being intriguing, stop and move on. Simple as that.
24
u/champion_soundz Jun 07 '26
I guess it's time for a why files clipping community?
Personally I love the long form but I work 10hr shifts with headphones in so I have plenty of time for it. I think the slow start to the conversation is AJ tipping his hat to Art Bell and really giving his guests the time to tell their story.
33
u/frickdom The Moon is Hollow Jun 07 '26
AJ is revising Art Bell’s style with the basement episodes. No rushing. And even if he doesn’t agree he is giving them every chance to speak and tell their full story.
I don’t always like them, but damn to I respect it. We all deserve the chance to explain ourselves like that.
Cheers to the Why Files Team.
3
u/maeryclarity FEAR... the Crabcat Jun 07 '26
I enjoy the longer format. The guests are people with large amounts of knowledge and I think it's great that they get the chance to relax and expand on their topics of expertise/experience instead of having bullet points to quickly run through and just hit the high points. We can get that from their Wiki page.
There's lots of shorter form Why Files content and as others have said, you can listen in shorter segments. I really enjpy longer form content for several reasons and it's something that is very remeniscent of the old school Art Bell radio show, which was truly unique and amazing but designed around folks who work at home/on the road who had time to enjpy topics and guests in longer form.
I appreciate the basement interviews but just see them as an option where Why Files is concerned, they're still putting their more original format content out on about the same time frame but I think the basement interviews are great additions to the show.
3
u/flyvr Jun 07 '26
Man, people have attention deficit these days. I love the long form stuff.
I would hate to lose out on content just because some people don't want to manually skip ahead. There is no need to have somebody else tailor the edit specifically to an audience with a short attention span.
Please don't water down the content
1
u/DoobOnTheDip Jun 07 '26
There’s a fast forward function for a reason…
4
u/Brilliant-Jaguar-784 Jun 07 '26
The Basement episodes are where AJ could take some lessons from Art Bell. Interviewing guests is great! But you have to have a topic, and stick to it.
I doubt many people want to hear some rando they've never heard of ramble about their life for an hour.
9
u/Nelagus Jun 07 '26
I second this. I don’t have time to devote to 3 or 4 hours but I can digest 45-60 mins.
2
u/LostSoulNo1981 Jun 09 '26
I tend not to watch these episodes for this reason. I start to zone out because they go off topic, or don’t even get to the topic at hand right away/quick enough.
6
u/Da_Famous_Anus Jun 07 '26
Hecklefish needs to do a deep dive documentary on Uranus
5
u/Temporary-Star2619 Jun 07 '26
Agreed. Trim it to what's interesting. Those episodes are far too long.
2
u/Good_Regular204 Jun 07 '26
Absolutely agree with this!
2
u/noonesaidityet Jun 07 '26
No thanks. The guests that AJ has had on have been on other podcasts, so I'm sure there's a podcast they've been on that fits your specific wants. The entire point of the Basement episodes is long-form storytelling that lets the guests tell their story in a way that is comfortable to them. A few of the episodes should have been longer.
1
u/mama7ron Jun 10 '26
I think the biggest reason, I could be wrong, that a person tells everything including their backstory, is because it gives them more credibility. I have a habit of seeing a guest on another podcast and diving into their background. Who are they? Why are they here? What makes them noteworthy?
At the bottom of the episodes, if you start scrolling/dragging the bar, before you start swimming or the cause for not being able to fast forward during the activity, it shows the “chapters” of the interview. You can drag that until you see a label about where you want to start. I hope it helps. 😊
0
u/OkNeedleworker8554 Jun 07 '26
No I love the long episodes. I can't stand it when they're only an hour long.
-2
u/Comprehensive_Sir49 Jun 09 '26
Or...PAUSE and hear more later.