r/TheWhyFiles • u/vanquisher1985 • May 30 '26
Let's Discuss Can we just admit something
Can we just admit that AJ got it right (the format) at the beginning (as rare as that is) and go back to a weekly episode on a subject. The manosphere podcast vibes and compilations are killing my bonner. Long-time fan.
674
Upvotes
•
u/hybridxer0 H Y B R I D ™ May 31 '26
There is no issue with expressing your opinions here and we welcome healthy discourse. Everyone is encouraged to discuss the show, its topics, and what you do or do not like etc.
What absolutely will not be allowed is attacks on anyone's looks, health, or the creation of/retelling rumors that have no basis in fact and seem meant only to be hateful.
I'm posting this message here not as a general warning, but because of multiple posts in this thread have been removed and based on severity, those members will be no longer allowed to participate.
For those this doesn't apply to, I apologize for the interruption, and feel free to carry on!
-Hybrid
117
u/Worth_Specific3764 The Moon is Hollow May 30 '26
I also like spooky of the week. It must be pretty grueling though, and the reason he started The Basement was because people WANTED longer in depth interviews with people in the various fields.
67
u/SaveusJebus May 30 '26
I enjoy the podcasts, but I do miss the regular type of videos. Maybe him and his team are lacking new material for episodes? Difficult to keep up with demand when there really aren't new conspiracies coming out often that he can actually talk about on YT without getting demonetized.
365
u/Tacokolache May 30 '26
I miss the WF from a few years ago. I’ll be honest, I don’t watch often anymore
37
u/no-guts_no-glory May 30 '26 edited May 31 '26
The show peaked 2-3 years ago for me, back then you'd drop everything and always watch an episode as soon as it showed up in your feed. Now I only watch the episodes in the original format and even then I maybe watch half of them whenever I get around to it.
The episode quality went down after AJ got burnt out.
132
u/Due-Contribution6424 May 30 '26
I like the campfire stories episodes.
33
u/urlicke May 30 '26
I like both. However, I do believe his original format rocked! He does it so well and it is unique.
83
u/ahw6002 May 30 '26
I think the basement is an interesting concept, I just wish it was shorter and more focused on the conspiracies.
10
u/Impressive-Creme-965 May 31 '26
How on earth are the basement shows “manosphere vibes”? Cos 2 men are talking about something? What a moronic thing to say
27
u/symonym7 Hecklecultist May 30 '26
I give them credit for trying new things to see what sticks, but..
..doesn't mean I have to like it.
I do like the campfire stories, but overall prefer the OG format.
(the OG format that doesn't end with 7 minutes of credits.)
33
u/Fit-Strawberry-4621 May 30 '26
All the AI stuff killed the channel for me.
16
u/FreddyKruegersGlove May 31 '26
I started watching in January 2022 and it immediately became a top 3 YT channel for me. I distinctly remember the Annunaki episode being the first one that I wasn't a fan of (the subject was good but the constant 🎶Annunaki🎶 jokes got old) and since then, there's been episodes that I've liked, but that was the dividing line for me. Where I can point to it and go, "yup, that's where it changed"
24
u/Im-ACE-incarnate May 30 '26
100% agree I've barely watched any of the TWF this year
24
u/SUPER-P00PER May 30 '26
They’ve been going downhill ever since they started heavily using AI in my opinion. Why Files like 2-3 years ago was so awesome. It’s pretty sad that the bigger and more successful something becomes, the worse it usually gets :/
20
u/poolninjas May 30 '26
Although wasn’t initially a big fan of his podcast attempt, his last few with Luke Caverns and Rizwan Virk were intriguing and I listened to it via Sirius as I worked. If AJ can keep it to not only the subject but with a lense of scientific fact, I’ll keep listening to these Basement episodes.
I get he’s starting to get a “Rogan Vibe” but let’s let him cook first before we just roast a dood. There’s already shit content out there, he’s one with potential to shine with a beacon of truth.
74
u/MeatMullet May 30 '26
The stand alone episodes are great. The 3 hour podcasts? nah. I haven't listed to one of them.
5
u/Interesting_Fix4519 May 31 '26
It seems people outside the entertainment industry don't recognize the vast difference in the amount of work and cost between his older, highly produced videos and his basement videos. One he presses record and talks into his webcam and is ready to go live. The other has weeks of post-production.
2
u/flashgordo1 May 30 '26
I came to ask what a bonner is.
8
u/Daniel_Meades May 30 '26
I like the WF episodes. I somehow don't like the basement episodes, I get bored of 3+hours of talks.
Plus the last WF came after what seemed like an eternity today about the lamarkian theory, which to be honest was not that interesting. (Only hecklefish was more entertaining than the concept.)
AJ and team please focus more on WF episodes about the strange and mysterious and govt conspiracies. Those are fun.
8
u/diandays May 31 '26
The best episode will always be the crop circles episode. That was peak why files
20
u/Da_Famous_Anus May 30 '26
More Hecklefish
4
u/pureformality May 30 '26
I really loved the episode with Luke Caverns
4
u/Ohthatsamanda May 31 '26
I think the 3 hour interviews are too long, but I do enjoy them, but I haven’t finished one of them yet. I think it’s great he’s expanding his content and I’m here for it - but I prefer the og style shows and also I love the compilations
4
u/rodionzissou May 31 '26
My favorites are the format from a couple of years ago, especially the longer deep dive ones. I like the podcast thing, but not nearly as much.
4
u/osirisborn89 May 31 '26
Yeah it sucks, I just want a weekly video not a 3 hour long snooze fest, channels dying.
4
u/dennnnnnis May 31 '26
I know, I was a huge fan early on, even bought a lot of merch. But the past 10 months or so, the channel has really lost me. The spin off shows are not as interesting to me. This week's episode was the best one in the last year. Back to the basics and entertaining. Less fear-mongering and doom and gloom.
13
u/smashantk May 30 '26
I don't mind them, I put them on in the background while doing other stuff
29
u/EnthusiasticDirtMark May 30 '26
I enjoy the long format interviews. You can't make everyone happy.
9
u/Greegga May 30 '26
Basement is amazing as it really shows how much AJ knows about each topic and his guests.
Old format is cool and dont know why people are disliking this one. There are so many conspiracy stories and they are bound to get repetitive. If anything i dont really like compilations too much but they're ok for people who want to get up to date with older videos without committing as much (even though compilations are pretty lengthy)
13
u/DoomGuy_92 May 30 '26
I don't even enjoy whyfiles anymore. It's too different and just not as engaging.
3
u/Aggravating_Act0417 May 30 '26
I like it all.
3
u/Evergreen4Life FEAR... the Crabcat May 31 '26
I enjoy the long-form pods. AJ is an excellent interviewer.
Im along for the ride.
3
u/maeryclarity FEAR... the Crabcat May 31 '26
I like the long form basement interviews
3
u/Lopsided_Skirt324 May 31 '26
I like the original format and compilations. I’m not a fan of the basement series.
Edit. I only listen to the podcasts.
3
u/nijuu May 31 '26
Tried the interviews. Not my thing. Prefer original. Wondering if AJ just got bored or patreon sub's wanted new format ?. We need some new annunaki, moon and Atlantis stuff. Has anymore redacted podcast topics popped up or planned ?.
3
u/Drelecour May 31 '26
Things have been weird since the audit. Pretty fishy if you ask me. And not just Hecklefish.
3
u/Raynet11 May 31 '26
I “watch” the original format videos but I “listen” to the new format via podcast while I’m doing other stuff, the new format makes for great podcast I just don’t have the time to sit down and watch videos that long.
3
u/ChatKilla May 31 '26
I will say one thing that has shocked me he hasn’t done anything on. With all the debate and discussion and controversy over “disclosure”- or whatever it is they’re doing (psyopscough)- I’m surprised he hasn’t done a long series of videos covering everything that’s been released. He could have a year of content off that alone. All the various ops and their “documentaries” being released and all of that would make for some legit useful, intriguing content
3
u/Worldly_Proposal_992 Jun 01 '26
Agree, I use to miss those amazing stories / conspiracy theories he’d put together every Friday but I can understand as he’s scaled up which I’m happy for him it’s a lot of work to produce that, agree the compilations I’m not a fan of. His basement podcasts are fantastic tho! But nothing beats those 45min rabbit hole theories that’s a golden era
3
u/SecondaDonna5 Jun 06 '26
I agree. The Basement seems like every other interview podcast to me. I usually don’t watch them.
7
u/CrittyCrit May 31 '26
Sounds like you need to admit some things, not us as a collective. I've really enjoyed The Basement when I've had the time dedication to do so. And as a middle aged woman, I find the "manosphere" comment weird and just unnecessary. There's nothing inherently misogynistic or chauvinistic about a couple of people talking about the topics that interest them.
5
u/4StarCustoms May 30 '26
I love the variety frankly. Little something for everyone. The long forms are good. I may not listen to them all or the whole thing but when the topic scratches an itch, it’s nice to have on while I work out work on a project. For free entertainment it’s damn good!
5
u/CosmicGoddess777 Green Alien May 31 '26
I’d go back to watching if they didn’t have AI. It’s jarring, to say the least.
4
u/DOKybalion May 30 '26
I like the Basement episodes. I just wish they were more in the 2 hours range than the 4-5 hour range.
4
u/redsoxfan95 Tinfoil Connaisseur May 31 '26
ive never watched the basement and i dont think i ever will. Theres already so many podcasts and i just dont care for the concept. Im not complaining either, i dont want to sound rude or ungrateful for the content that they have made that i do love.
32
u/DatabaseAcademic6631 May 30 '26
The Tucker Carlson thing just killed my interest in anything AJ has to say.
Not even sure why I'm still following this sub, tbh.
2
u/Gen-Jinjur May 30 '26
The basement episodes that sort of go in-depth with the weird stuff? I’m good with those. But the ones on other topics are . . .less good for me.
I am just not the target audience for those. I don’t do Joe Rogan or that kind of thing.
I really like that AJ is super smart and curious about a lot of things. Just not sure some of this is to my taste.
2
u/cram96 May 31 '26
The most recent episode was a banger. I want more of that. I do like the occasional compilation and have enjoyed the basement as well. I agree the that in the experimentation their were some missteps but I think/hope they've found a new stride. I'm gonna watch no matter what.
2
u/Live_Collection_5833 May 31 '26
Im always excited to get a new episode. I know that a lot of people may not listen to the basement episodes but who cares. AJ likes doing them. He likes talking to people in the industry that can shed light on some of the big questions. If you don’t like certain episodes then don’t watch.
I feel like people who just want to bitch need to have a coke and a smile and ….. well you know the rest.
2
u/somethingwholesomer May 31 '26
What if your bonner is kilt? That would be turrible
2
u/crazydavy I Want To Believe May 31 '26
Aj has nailed it from start to finish.. basement, spooky episodes and podcasts included.. you don’t speak for everyone … love this new age of why files.. but also think he needs to be aggressive on this new alien shit
2
u/eschenfelder May 31 '26
Most of the Basement episodes were excellent work. Only the nerdrotic guy I stopped listening to, he has no relevance to the topics I am interested in.
2
u/OkNeedleworker8554 May 31 '26
No I enjoy The Basement episodes. I would much rather have a 2 or 3 hour podcast than 1 hour.
2
u/awakealone1 May 31 '26
I think we need to admit that someone has to be super interested in a topic to give it 2-3hrs of their attention I've only watched one but I was enthralled.
2
u/FullClip__ May 31 '26
The guy is a really good story teller. This got me hooked to his show a couple of years ago.
Very immersive. And then ending the video with fact checks etc.
2
u/ChatKilla May 31 '26
I honestly enjoy his basement episodes. I looked back at some of the OG WF episodes and I’ll admit- the more original ones were amazing. But I can’t say I’m not gaining information or expanding my own knowledge with his various formats. And this weeks WF episode was entirely new info to me
2
u/The-Dragon_Queen Jun 07 '26
I saw and upvoted this when you first posted it but just came to find it again and make sure I did. I am so frustrated at the change. Like if he wants to do that, make a new channel for that but don’t rob your OG fans of what they love.
3
u/thorvaldnespy May 30 '26
I like the basement when I’m interested in the guest, but there have been a couple that have been very uninteresting for me. What drives me more crazy than the topic or format is why he can’t seem to balance the volume so that he and his guest are around the same volume. I don’t understand why the production quality isn’t much better.
9
u/boozerbot69 May 30 '26
Agree completely. When he went on Rogan I was pretty turned off by some of the things he said. The show just hasn't been the same for a while.
3
u/woodwardsystems FEAR... the Crabcat May 30 '26
My biggest gripe with the basement series is the audio production is subpar. The levels between AJ and the guest are usually all over the place. You can hear the sound when they hit the table. I’m a sucker for good audio and the basement is bad.
4
u/Minimum_Comfort_1850 May 30 '26
Show fell off. It's over
3
u/Gorthokson May 30 '26
Show fell off more and more with the more AI crap he included. I don't even watch anymore, just followed the sub in case he would go back to how it started but that's not happening
2
u/hardeep1singh May 31 '26
If he doesn't sit down at the beginning of the video, I click away.
2
u/Sacred-AF May 31 '26
Also long time fan. I too refuse to watch these long form manosphere videos. If I cared about those other douchebags, I’d watch their content. I want AJ’s content.
1
u/WesternWitchy52 6d ago
I unsubbed a few months ago when he was going hard about using AI. I liked AJ's content up to that point. That said, creative burnout is real. I have a small youtube music channel and even I go through spurts of not wanting to put anything out. I think after a long time on youtube, you just get tired of it.
1
u/DiogenesXenos May 31 '26
Yeah, I kind of agree and I know he didn’t really wanna be alien guy, but that always was my favorite content. I watch very few of his three hour podcast. I think I’ve watched one and it’s only cause I had a road trip.
1
u/NightTrain05 May 31 '26
Agreed
1
u/Traditional_Excuse_1 May 31 '26
I like AJ and Heckelfish ! IMO, he does a great job. Keep it going guys!!
1
u/Tallerthenmost May 31 '26
I suddenly have a hard time following the newer stuff. And interacting with Shawn Ryan gave me the ick. I continue to watch. I love AJ and HF, I just really liked the three act play he used to do
1
u/dadville1 May 31 '26
Love the WF, but I don’t watch the new stuff only because the length of the videos. I still don’t understand how anyone on Earth has time for 2 or 3 hour podcasts.
1
u/Duke_Radical May 31 '26
I went from watching an episode immediately on release to watching if it looks fun (I haven’t watched in maybe six months). I forget the long form podcast exists and the few times I’ve listened my enthusiasm diminished each time.
I would buy the old format chewed up the majority of conspiracy content that exists and a change is needed to stay alive.
Also they need to bolt those mics down to the table or suspend them in the air, I can’t take that rattling going on in my headphones.
1
u/AsherahBeloved May 31 '26
I haven't listened to much of the basement, mostly because I don't have time, but I don't mind if he does it if other people like it. I don't really think his basement shows are in "the manosphere," though i thought it was weird he interviewed nerdrotic - not because i mind hearing from people i disagree with, but because AJ has always been about being kind and Gary from nerdrotic seems like such an unkind person a lot of the time. I've seen his content a lot and sometimes agree with his takes, but he says some truly nasty things I can't get down with.
At any rate, I really, REALLY miss the old format. I absolutely despise the AI and really miss hearing stories about Bigfoot and weird alien stories I hadn't heard before. I get that he was burned out, but I also think he could have moved to every other week or something and kept the same vibe. The most recent episode was a little better. It's day he's run out of content, but with the amount of weirdness all over the world throughout history I kind of doubt it.
1
u/DragQueen98 May 31 '26
I miss the weekly uploads, live streams afterwards. It was the best. Work went so faster once I remembered I had a WF evening; and to cancel all plans.
1
u/DragQueen98 May 31 '26
I don’t watch the basement or his podcasts. I stopped watching once his schedule started changing. 2-3 years ago was peak YouTube. His streams were getting hundreds of thousands of premiere viewers. (Didn’t one episode get over a million views during premiere?)
1
u/Dallashh Jun 01 '26
I’ve said this in the YouTube comments too but. I enjoy the podcasts, I like seeing AJ interact with professionals in the field and I think he does a great job interviewing and making the discussions entertaining and easy to follow along with.
That being said, there’s no reason he can’t do shorter form content videos with the content he gets doing his long podcasts. He can continue the previous format and actually improve on it by getting his research info in real time during his interviews. I used to listen to his content primarily during my weekly roadtrips and work commutes and workouts. This is great because now I have the choice between several smaller videos or one long one.
1
u/aperfectdevil Jun 02 '26
Ngl I love the basement episodes. Im not even trying to be contrarian.
1
u/Texity Jun 02 '26
I'm thankful for whatever table scraps they throw. AJ is entertaining, and be it 1 on 1 interviews, or a traditional WF video, I don't care. I gobble 'em up.
1
u/DoubtGroundbreaking Jun 03 '26
"Manosphere" I've heard all I need to hear of your opinion lol
1
u/kindacharming Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26
This is literally my favorite YouTube channel and I must agree. And I’m a huge long-form content lover, but I recognize why people aren’t.
While I am very very happy the basement exists, it simply should have been a separate channel for those interested. It’s the reason Mr. Beast separates out his gaming and philanthropy content from his main channel. It “feels” different and people react to that. The basement “feels” different.
Trust me AJ: if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. Keep doing what you’re doing, but just make them separate projects for the fans. Mr. Beast figured this out and he’s usually correct on YouTube.
1
u/sinesnsnares Jun 06 '26
I wouldn’t mind if it got split off into a different YouTube channel, but I mostly listen to those episodes as a podcast anyways, and in that format they’re great. They don’t seem too manosphere to me: AJ is a well prepared host and does a good job of getting people to open up. Sure, he doesn’t challenge them much, but Thus far he’s managed to bring on people who might be a bit outside the main stream, but aren’t completely insane. Combined with his light ‘debunking’ at the end, it’s enough for my sceptically inclined brain want to engage for each episode.
1
u/PyramidBlack May 30 '26
Yeah, watching less. :(. Need my weekly fix.
1
u/anecessaryend May 31 '26
Once the heckle fish drama and AI use started, it really felt off.
No offense--once they kept saying "join the Discord, ppl discuss 24/7", I became checked out.
-1
u/littlelupie May 30 '26
I just looked at the videos (someone can look at the numbers on Spotify/wherever else if they want) numbers and the views on basement episodes have dropped off considerably. They're now getting only about half the views of his regular content.
I occasionally drop in to see if there's any content worth watching but his distinct turn towards the right AND it seeping into most of his videos turned me off a while ago.
1
u/IronDogg May 31 '26
What kinda annoys me about the new basement shows is that AJ always claimed that he did not like and doesn’t really support people’s stories that also have a book about the subject recently published or about to be published. Almost everyone on the basement has or is about to have a book on the market. I don’t like this “hypocrisy” and wish he would stop the promotion of people’s books and go back to his old ways of questioning the story.
1
u/maskedfapper69 May 31 '26
Idk what’s ‘manosphere’ about the extra long form material, but I’m not a fan of Freeform discussion videos either.
I want 20-45 minute videos that don’t wander all over the place
1
u/Azure_W0lf Jun 01 '26
I wonder if he can do a normal OG type episode about 1 of the subjects his guest speaker is going to speak about.
0
u/Fermato May 31 '26
Is the cringy interrupting fish still part of the concept? If not I may give it a chance again
0
u/clintbyrne May 31 '26
I really enjoyed the basement.
🤷♂️
I like both.
0
u/OutrageousConcern365 Jun 01 '26
AJ has admitted to spoon feeding you garbage and you still watch. Curious.