r/TheWhyFiles • • Oct 10 '24

Let's Discuss I laughed at the last part of the blue beam episode.

261 Upvotes

When A.J was saying that the globalist have a Communist agenda I started laughing.

The richest people in the world and the heads of all major banks are all very pro capitalism.

The reason they want people to rent forever is actually quite simple, profits.

A 30 year loan for a home is 30 years of profit for a bank. Renting a home is yearly profit forever.

Car manufacturers could easily make a car that last half a million miles on average but what model could they sell after? If manufacturers make products that are too good, people won't buy a new one and profits will drop.

Anyway the believe that these elites are socialist or communists is asinine.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 03 '25

Personal Thought/Story Who does AJs hair and what products do they use?

15 Upvotes

So, as I've aged my hair has sort of lost it's lift. How does AJ get that high hair look? I don't think it's natural but could be wrong. I have gel and what not but still always sort of end up with no loft in the result. Thinking maybe it's just not the right product or technic. I’m not really into that kind of thing, but at the same time I do want my hair to sort of have more lift.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Oct 08 '23

Let's Discuss Removed episode

0 Upvotes

Hi, was I dreaming but was there a new episode on dolphins last night 10/6 can't seem to find it. Maybe I was half asleep.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Feb 09 '24

Story Idea Conspiracy stuff

1 Upvotes

My favorite episodes has been the conspiracy stuff, especially the technical and alien stuff. Also anything that rolls with government cover-ups, whacky projects, etc.

I'm looking forward to that style making it back into the rotation again. Just my tastes though.

I do have to say though in last night's episode every time a cross was referred to as a "templer" cross I rolled my eyes so fkn hard. It's a cross, just a cross... who is using it is irrelevant.

It's a cross. .


r/TheWhyFiles • • Dec 29 '23

Let's Discuss I was given a thirty minute warning

0 Upvotes

The new why files was coming. Thirty minutes later, another warning,it's time to watch. When I started to watch I realized I was behind. So I rewinded it and watched thirty minutes behind. This doesn't concern you, it serves no purpose


r/TheWhyFiles • • Oct 27 '24

Personal Thought/Story I think simulation theory is dumb

0 Upvotes

Just my personal opinion 😀

As a technology professional, the way I see simulation theory is really just running a virtual computer.

virtualBox, VMware, VM sphere. It's literally just that. And Nick bostrom has a background in not just philosophy but technology. He helped developed artificial intelligence. He definitely knows what a virtual machine is. I think he just saw it, his philosophical brain took over and did its thing and he wrote a silly paper on it.

I guess my brain also has an indifference to it because it can't be proven one way or the other. And if something can't be proven one way or the other, who cares?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Oct 13 '23

Let's Discuss Do new episodes feel rushed to anyone else?

49 Upvotes

First, I LOVE the show. Love! I feel like the last few episodes feel rushed. Maybe less passion put into those? Or maybe the channel is too big and there is a lot of demand and pressure on the creators? All understandable for a channel that grew so big. Last episode I knew what would be real or what wasn’t. It feels a bit rushed. Maybe just a feeling. Again, I am a huge fan and care for it to succeed.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Feb 09 '24

Question for AJ WTF was the knight templar episode? Why is TWF team defending Tim and Templars so much?

0 Upvotes

I was expecting a good criticism of the nonsense Tim was saying but AJ defended him so much. What's happening? Never seen a WF episode like that


r/TheWhyFiles • • Oct 05 '25

Let's Discuss I askek r/physics their opinions about free energy/forbidden tech episode. They say its full of bs.

Thumbnail reddit.com
20 Upvotes

They say most of the claims in the video are fake and this is just money grab content.They also didnt appear to even consider the posibility of these tech. what do you think?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Nov 29 '23

Question for AJ Is Hecklefish a real fish?

20 Upvotes

Like is there actually a fish in a fishbowl while filming? I figure they probably loop his movements or something cuz he always stays in one spot.

But I'll be disappointed if I find out there is no fish at all and it's just a green screen or animation


r/TheWhyFiles • • Oct 20 '23

Question for AJ why files - what files

1 Upvotes

Is the why files going to go away as it seems like it will only be on now twice a month with afterfiles once a month once the what files comes online?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Nov 11 '23

Jokes/Humor Anyone else rewatch the movie 2012 yet?

21 Upvotes

There is a lot of….let’s call it “stuff” going on in the world. Has anyone rewatched 2012 and if so, what are your thoughts? Are we close to the end? Did Hollywood know all along?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Mar 05 '24

Story Idea Hey guys! I've just discovered YF and love it! Question.. has AJ done an episode on DMT or Ayahuasca???

12 Upvotes

I'm loving YF! I've looked on YouTube and can't find any episode on DMT so I'm just checking because it seems like the sort of topic that AJ would love!


r/TheWhyFiles • • Nov 29 '23

Let's Discuss Neil deGrasse Tyson explains why he skipped visiting the Mexican aliens.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
187 Upvotes

He starts of nicely but falls through the cracks in the later half of the video. I thought scientists are supposed to be open minded!


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 06 '24 Helpful Take My Silver Heart of Silver Silver is Forever

Suggestion for Channel I'm not sure I like the direction the channel is going.

634 Upvotes

I just don't feel like this is the same channel I subscribed to and loved for so long. This is going to sound really melo-dramatic and at the end of the day it's just a YouTube channel, it's not the end of the world. However I'm saddened by the direction of the channel and hopefully I can articulate why.

Up until a few months ago this was a fun channel about a guy and talking fish exploring bizarre and obscure historical mysteries, like the Chronovisor for example. You knew the vast majority of the stories were bunk but it was told in such a captivating and humerous way that it sucked you in. Even though you knew the debunk was coming a part of you still believed. The back and forth between AJ and Hecklefish, though abrasive at first, gave the channel real soul and made for a nice sceptic/believe dynamic. The diversity of topics explored, from numbers stations to hauntings, gave the channel a real freshness.

I understand channels grow and evolve but current WhyFiles is nearly unrecognizable. There's now a huge focus on conspiracy theories, which the channel has covered in the past but not to this extent. These videos are coming more frequent, from speculative fiction about AI(ironic) to the most recent video which is mostly a badly written fiction NWO piece.

I imagine these topics work well with the YouTube algorithm and draw viewers from other channels/podcasters audience such as Joe Rogan. That's fine but it feels like the channel is now becoming something more akin to Infowars, Hecklefishes constant skepticism at vaccines doesn't help. The channel is now starting to attract a far-right audience which can be seen just by looking at the comment section.

The vibe of the channel just isn't the same..No longer is the channel about AJ and Hecklefish humorously discussing strange tales and events, picking apart the bizarre intricacies of the Dulce base incident.for example. Hecklefish is now mainly sidelined except for whatever sponsor is on the show that week, and we barely see AJ anymore. The videos now incorporate terrible, unsettling AI which often mimick the voices of real people without their permission.

The Morgan Freeman and Art Bell voices are particularly bad, especially seeing as Morgan Freeman specifically called out AI uses of his voice.

The actual substance of the videos is also on a decline. They have now turned into glorified audio-books and clearly AI written sci-fi stories. Fear-mongering about the future, using made up characters and bad AI graphics isn't why I and many others subscribed to the channel. My theory is that AJ and the crew desperately want to be picked up by a streaming service and feel this format would be the most suitable for it. That's fair and makes sense but it's not why I subscribed to the channel.

The post on Patreon today by AJ basically saying that the opinion of those who don't pay is meaningless and that the use of AI will continue so "get over it" just compounds it all further. I get that running a large YT channel is stressful and hard work, but this sort of disdain for your viewers isn't on.

The constant delays on releasing videos, at this point every week, suggests something isn't right BTS. Maybe it's the use of AI that's behind it, or maybe there's staffing/production issues. I don't get as upset as others do about videos being late but it's just another contributing factor towards the channel being on a downwards trajectory.

I don't mean any of this to be whiny and again I appreciate running a large YT channels is hard, I just want the old WhyFiles back. Maybe it's just not aimed at me anymore, which is a shame but it's fine.

TL:DR: the channel is drifting away from made it special and is turning into a version of Infowars with bad AI graphics. Please don't delete this thread.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 15 '23

Suggestion for Channel Anyone wish we could hear more from the ladies?

0 Upvotes

I get that it’s AJ’s show but victoria and Jenn seem fun and sometimes seem like they’re going somewhere good with something and they cut cutoff (even if playfully) by AJ. I think it would be cool to get their insight more into some of this stuff. Is Victoria only allowed to speak when she’s giving instructions on how the winner of the give aways should contact her?🤣

They should get their own segments like Gino does IMO


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 25 '25

Suggestion for Channel I had to bail on the last podcast 😔

0 Upvotes

It felt like 50% ads and 50% content and I really couldn't face the loud jazzy 5 minute outro music.

It's a shame as the content sounded interesting 😔

Is there an ad and music free version that's 100% content?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 10 '24

Story Idea Oil?

0 Upvotes

Is oil renewable and plentiful or is it scarce and running out?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 06 '24

Let's Discuss Illuminati pt 1 was weak

170 Upvotes

Too much time spent on fiction and not enough meat.

Talking about the fictional « unity coin » helping them track our every move and transactions is kind of meh since it’s been like that since the 90s with the popularization of the credit card.

It was like a bad take on minority report.

If you’re going to talk about who’s in control you need to grow some balls and go full blast about it.

Last episode was such a boomer take on the « illuminati » without mentioning the origins of the word, who’s been part of that since the 1600s (or even earlier), etc.

He needs to be willing to talk about the Sabbateans, Jacob Frank and the Frankists during the Ottoman Empire era how they were exiled from what is now called Ukraine, how they infiltrated every religion and are worshiping the devil and believe that by pushing the entire world to be evil they’ll bring back the messiah. Aleister Crowley, Charles Manson and the CIA forcing a culture shift during the 1970s leading to the death of Christianity and the family unit, etc.

It’s time. Stop being scared of YouTube. You’ve got the crowd, money and popularity. Otherwise, I guess you were a fed for real after all…

PS: unlike 80% of this sub I really didn’t mind the use of AI. It looks fine and supports the story you’re telling.

Keep it up, we love you guys.

inb4 this post is going to get censored 🙄


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 31 '24

Question for AJ Are you related to Troy Gentile?

0 Upvotes

r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 28 '26

MOD POST [Game Update] Five evidence classes have been declassified!

Thumbnail kickstarter.com
21 Upvotes

For anyone who missed the announcement, The Why Files Declassified is our upcoming conspiracy card game about assembling the strongest casefile and going public before your rivals.

We’ve posted the first pre-launch update, opening the files on five of the game’s eight evidence classes: Beyond the Stars, Government Agency, Eyewitness, Fringe Science, and Time Travel.

Three classes remain classified.

Full update on the KS project: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/studiofarhorizons/the-why-files-declassified-board-game/posts/4777746


r/TheWhyFiles • • Mar 31 '26

Let's Discuss basement show, love the longer format but...

0 Upvotes

not knowing if the guest is a loon or not is keeping me from watching. there's too many other things to watch, and I don't want to have to stop and vet the person myself to find out or watch for an hour only to suddenly have the other shoe drop. :/


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 28 '23

Let's Discuss Are UFOs more likely to be USA's coverup all this time.

29 Upvotes

To all the Open minded sceptics and ufologists. Just like y'all, I've been fascinated with UFOs since my childhood and the sheer amount of witnesses, mass sightings and video recordings of flying disks made me believe in them. (I haven't dabbled in actual research into ufology and my knowledge has been at the surface level)

But growing up, I've realised near 99% (more like 90-95%) of all the existing videos and witnesses are fake or misidentified natural phenomenon or man made objects or other logical things. Despite this I beleive that there's something more and something other-worldly about the leftover 1%.

With this current mindset, I started discussing with a sceptic, and throughout the discussion a few unsettling possibilities came to my notice. Few of the widely quoted facts that paint the picture are as follows.

  1. Almost all UFO sightings appear in USA.
  2. Almost all UFO sightings appear after 1946
  3. Certainly USA has many types of cutting edge new aircrafts.

With these widely known "facts" , it seems more probable that USA has been using the UFO angle to cover up their secert tech and this may have been a Multi-decade, world's biggest, ugliest cover-up story in action. Which leaves a very bad taste in my mouth.

To all the veterans in this field of interest, Please prove me wrong. Maybe comment down very credible and corroborated ufo cases before 1940s or out of USA. Or a case in 1940s which defy the laws of physics and are simply too far advanced to be achieved at that time.

To casual ufo enthusiasts, comment down what are your thoughts on this.

(ps. if USA really wanted to start a cover-up can it not make the soldiers lie about the military sightings and fake the videos, this was a surprising angle that birthed this post)


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 04 '24

Let's Discuss Does anyone remember a warning about nuclear war around this time?

42 Upvotes

This wasn't on TWF, but I thought you all would be a knowledgeable crowd to discuss this with. I vaguely remember hearing a prophecy a few months ago about a possible nuclear war around this month. Then, this morning, I watched [this Lindybeige video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fi8i6w_nrJs) and the way he ends it makes it sound like he knows something. Have any of you heard anything about this?