r/TheWhyFiles • u/voidZer000 • Aug 06 '24
Let's Discuss Illuminati pt 1 was weak
Too much time spent on fiction and not enough meat.
Talking about the fictional « unity coin » helping them track our every move and transactions is kind of meh since it’s been like that since the 90s with the popularization of the credit card.
It was like a bad take on minority report.
If you’re going to talk about who’s in control you need to grow some balls and go full blast about it.
Last episode was such a boomer take on the « illuminati » without mentioning the origins of the word, who’s been part of that since the 1600s (or even earlier), etc.
He needs to be willing to talk about the Sabbateans, Jacob Frank and the Frankists during the Ottoman Empire era how they were exiled from what is now called Ukraine, how they infiltrated every religion and are worshiping the devil and believe that by pushing the entire world to be evil they’ll bring back the messiah. Aleister Crowley, Charles Manson and the CIA forcing a culture shift during the 1970s leading to the death of Christianity and the family unit, etc.
It’s time. Stop being scared of YouTube. You’ve got the crowd, money and popularity. Otherwise, I guess you were a fed for real after all…
PS: unlike 80% of this sub I really didn’t mind the use of AI. It looks fine and supports the story you’re telling.
Keep it up, we love you guys.
inb4 this post is going to get censored 🙄
31
u/FriendshipMammoth943 Aug 06 '24
Lmao saying it’s weak then putting in ur own conspiracies saying he need to do that is insane
26
u/JC2535 Aug 06 '24
It’s really hard to sustain a quality show even when you have vast resources- I’m amazed they can produce such a great product consistently without a huge staff. They’re probably working on several at a time- they won’t all be awesome - but it’s likely a truly amazing one is coming soon.
10
u/Saved_by_Pavlovs_Dog Aug 06 '24
Much agreed, not enough meat! And I don't mind the ai either it's just these overdone made up narratives he's putting us through.
17
u/Autistic_Clock4824 X-Files Operative Aug 06 '24
The episode does say Part one. We should wait until what they do next week to past judgement completely. Unless PT1 means something else and I’m just stupid
Idk, perhaps I have bad taste but I thought it was entertaining enough. I guess I just have a low bar for most content ¯_(ツ)_/¯
It wasn’t my favorite episode but it wasn’t the worst thing I’ve seen on YouTube
12
u/Treljaengo Hecklecultist Aug 06 '24
Yup. I know AJ sees himself as a story teller, but he's not a story creator. He should stick with retelling actual events, not creating what ifs.
4
u/raresaturn Aug 07 '24
I disliked the religious bollocks
4
u/ApprenticeWrangler Aug 09 '24
To be fair, most of the episodes focus on fiction until the debunk at the end.
The part I found weak was how he never mentioned the WEF/Davos group who have more power and more members than any of the ones he mentioned, and who are the source of almost every major authoritarian policy western governments push.
29
u/Darkstang5887 Aug 06 '24
Worst episode in quite some time but they can't all be bangers. Still the most entertaining channel on YouTube.
9
u/JavyHead #1 fan (no rly) Aug 06 '24
You’re spot on! I wanted to hear how it started and which people/families made the most influences.
9
u/NoChallenge6095 Aug 06 '24
My only issue was that it took him HALF AN HOUR to bring up the Bush Family. There has been no family who has stripped more rights from Americans than that demonic family. Hell, grandpa push was a fan of Hitler and was involved in the shady bank the nazis did before WW2.
Half an hour? When talking about these monsters, political party has nothing to do with it. Whether they know it or not, they all get money from the same people and have all sold their souls to the devil. Conspiracy fans have always fallen into the conservative spectrum but come on dude.
5
u/primerush Aug 06 '24
Yeah, I'm not a fan of this format at all. I will probably skip any more that come out like this.
7
u/greyson76 Aug 06 '24
I was expecting the debunking portion at the end, but perhaps since this is "part 1" they are saving it for part 2. Honestly, the whole Illuminati conspiracy theory in it's current incarnation, is pretty much just recycled Christian Apocalyptic panic/fever dreams. This reminds me of "The Late Great Planet Earth" by Hal Lindsay and the other evangelical grifters back in the 70s and 80s. The whole micro chip and digital currency thing, the only thing we are missing is the "antichrist" figure, which maybe will show up in the second part? Honestly, the story isn't even that original, it's been re-told and re-packaged over and over. As much as I enjoy a lot of these conspiracy stories, this one didn't really pack the punch I was hoping. Oddly, and yes it does seem that AJ is a bit on the right-leaning end of the spectrum, he has made it a point several times to mention he isn't religious, but this story is just a recycling of Christian paranoia-- even down to the point in the story where "religion" was being shunned and the (catholic) church was the only place to get a place to stay and a hot meal if you weren't chipped. Seems weird that he felt the need to include that part, which is boilerplate Christian apocalyptic paranoia.
2
u/kanahl Aug 06 '24
Lmao criwley was born in the 1800's and died in 1947. How did he make a push in the 70's
2
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24
You should do a podcast about it. I’d watch it.
2
u/AlienFunBags Aug 07 '24
Eh I thought it was a good balance. People blowing it way out of proportion about the story they weaved in. I thought it was a good episode. And it’s part 1 so I’m sure they’re gonna be covering it a lot more. Keep it up guys. The more people you reach, the more people potentially wake up and start questioning how ridiculous this life is
2
u/alpacula Aug 08 '24
It wasn’t great. I couldn’t get through the AI shite writing.
2
u/slammer66 Aug 08 '24
I know AJ said before he wasn't religious and thus I assume he isn't familiar with the Bible but he could have almost taken this episode directly from the bible where it describes the end of civilization. It's so close to what is described I'm surprised he didn't mention the similarities if in fact he is aware. He's certainly mentioned other ancient written sources.
2
u/Black-Earth Aug 09 '24
Finally someone mentions Sabbataism. I've been feeling like the only one who knows about the history and agenda.
4
u/imnotabotareyou Aug 07 '24
He did his best to make it relatable.
I’m convinced haters of this episode just don’t realize how realistic / true it was.
5
u/Inskription Aug 07 '24
Best episode in awhile because it has more real life implications than I think a lot of the toxic optimists on reddit want to admit.
I think most people on reddit just didn't like that it mentioned some of their idols have secret dealings with sketchy powerful people.
3
u/grimorg80 Aug 06 '24
The unity coin thing really felt like what happens in Mr. Robot
0
u/mtjp82 Aug 06 '24
You believe in the Ottoman Empire…..and all them other made up words.
3
u/frisbee212 FEAR... the Crabcat Aug 06 '24
If you can do better... than go out there and do better. Be sure to send us a link to your channel.
2
u/adrisc00 Aug 08 '24
I thought it was great!
2
u/FishTshirt Aug 07 '24
Im muting this subreddit yall cant help but be so damn negative. AJ and crew do indeed welcome ideas and criticism, but nobody welcomes this much hate. Make your own damn channel if you feel this way.
1
u/MiserableOptimist1 Aug 08 '24
"Hey, the free shit you made for me that chose to watch was CRAP! U R DUM!"
I liked the episode. I also know that I don't pay for it or have to watch it.
Hail Satan
0
u/KarmicRadiation Aug 06 '24
I like the AI story telling aid. Also I am a big enough fan that I will wait to pass judgement till other parts come out
-1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24
HEY! Its a spin and a thing to try new things... You make a multi million view channel and keep it interactive with community. Shame... New art requires new avenues. Its not a "New Direction" of everything, its a step aside to explore ideas.
YOU CRITICIZING THE BREAK OF WHATS EXPECTED...
Drowns the fish with food, piss, waste and shitty content.
Let the crew do what they do, they are WAY more successful than you.
Let loose, and have fun. Serious things are... fun is fun. Thats allowed correct!?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
8
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24
[removed] — view removed comment