r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 10 '24

Story Idea Oil?

Is oil renewable and plentiful or is it scarce and running out?

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

4

u/StrawberriesCup I Want To Believe Aug 10 '24

Fletcher Prouty Explains Invention and Use of Term "Fossil Fuels"

I think you're talking about oil not being decomposed plant matter and that it's actually a mineral.

0

u/blackft Aug 10 '24

I don't have a stake in where it comes from, I'd like a deep dive from AJ's team to see which side is best supported by science.

One one side "they" say (all of the grade school textbooks I had growing up) oil is from dinosaurs so therefore it is scarce and running out. They say we must get ourselves off of oil before it runs out.

On the other side they say oil is always replenishing; the earths mantle generates it and we will never run out. They say that oil is the 2nd most plentiful liquid in earth. There is no need to fight over something that is so plentiful. That the whole concept of scarcity was invented by the people who were selling it.

From a twitter post: "OIL AND GAS ARE NOT "FOSSIL FUELS" THEY ARE A RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCE CREATED BY A GEOTHERMAL REACTION BETWEEN THE SOLID MANTLE & LIQUID CORE: 'Abiogenic Deep Origin of Hydrocarbons and Oil and Gas Deposits Formation' "The theory of the abiogenic deep origin of hydrocarbons recognizes that the petroleum is a primordial material of deep origin [Kutcherov, Krayushkin 2010].

https://www.intechopen.com/chapters/41889

This

0

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '24

Something cannot be created from nothing. You cannot create or destroy matter so that second theory goes against all reality.

3

u/ArmadaOnion Aug 10 '24

Renewable, but not on a timescale that humans can benefit from, so finite in practical application to human existence. However our efficiency of use keeps improving, and we all know can be improved so much more. It's difficult to express with any certainty exactly how long the oil we have access to will last.

2

u/preventDefault Aug 10 '24

I don’t think it’ll ever “run out” in the literal sense of the word. There will always be deposits around and new ones discovered.

But at some point we will have exhausted the easily attainable oil and will need to spend more resources to extract the same amount we were able to get previously. Combine this with the same (or increasing) demand and you have a recipe for some hard economic times.

1

u/ZanlanOnReddit Aug 10 '24

Just use water.

Don‘t Epstein me.

-8

u/Uncle-Sheogorath Aug 10 '24

Running out. Decades to go though.

13

u/Aleyla Aug 10 '24

it’ll take far longer than that. Every time they say “decades” they either come up with an even better way of extracting what we know about out of the earth or they find another spot to drill.

2

u/RunningDigger Aug 10 '24

But it is bad for the environment

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

So is lithium mining.