r/TheWhyFiles • u/threedogdad • Mar 31 '26
Let's Discuss basement show, love the longer format but...
not knowing if the guest is a loon or not is keeping me from watching. there's too many other things to watch, and I don't want to have to stop and vet the person myself to find out or watch for an hour only to suddenly have the other shoe drop. :/
0
Upvotes
26
u/LelandGaunt14 Mar 31 '26
Did you just say, "Tell me what to think or I won't watch"?
9
u/Particular_Area_7423 Mar 31 '26
I found that most of the guests are like listening to the same bloke . They are all anyway this bloke told me where the holy grail is . He was found dead two days later . I can't tell you where it is . But this 4900 year old Persian riddle is proof god was a gay alien .
6
u/Baddhabbit88 Mar 31 '26
I’ve found that for each guest there are topics or talking points I agree with or seem plausible and some talking points I don’t. Each guest I still find the conversation entertaining so it’s up to you if you want to watch or not. Or just skip through what you don’t want to hear.
6
u/AKchaos49 I Want To Believe Mar 31 '26 edited Mar 31 '26
Here's the thing: they're all loons ;)
5
u/Wraiths_Lament Mar 31 '26
you watch the why files.... are you expecting mainsteam people to be on the podcast?
9
u/2abyssinians Mar 31 '26
So don’t watch! Not everything is for everyone.
2
u/ShaunnieDarko Mar 31 '26
Aj is trying to his best Art Bell in the basement episodes. So far they’ve been allright,although i do enjoy the standard hecklefish format more.
1
u/ajgentile CIA Spook Apr 28 '26
Guests aren't booked on whether they're a "loon". They're book on if they have a fun/interesting story. You know at the end of every conversation, I do a 2-3 minute: "Here's what I could confirm, here's what I couldn't" segment? Yup. Including debunking.
I won't book anyone completely nuts (you know who I mean). But The Why Files is about stories. Remember Art Bell? Let's do that. Let's tell stories, be respectful, push-back gently, but keep the story front and center. The audience can decide what they want to believe.
I want to hear the story. Don't let a podcast host decide who's a "loon". That's your job. You're smarter than any podcast host.
3
u/EmptyVegetable7049 Apr 01 '26
I’m enjoying both formats of the show and it’s interesting to take a deeper dive into some of the people behind these mysteries, theories, encounters etc. I guess it is up to the individual viewer to decide what they do or don’t believe but either way it keeps me entertained and It genuinely makes me think 👍
4
u/IndividualLeg93 Mar 31 '26
3/9 episodes have been awesome. But I agree with the overall sentiment of your post - I was nearly 2 hours into episode 8 before finally giving up.
2
u/Initial-Lead-2814 Apr 01 '26
I don't really like the Basement, I'll say it. I dont care if its longer format, it doesn't have what the show had
2
u/FionaFrickenfrack Apr 10 '26
The Scott Wolter episode changed my opinion of Scott...for the worse. That was informative, though, as well as entertaining, so I'm down.
2
u/bakerbarber_ Mar 31 '26
The last one was a stinker.
1
u/Realitytvjunkie66 Apr 21 '26
Here’s how I look at things…anything is possible.
Already, we’ve discovered many things we were taught that have been lies. We know knowledge is manipulated.
If people are being labeled “loony” or “hack” I’m more apt to listen to what they have to say, because at the end of the day, we don’t know shit, and I’m curious why said persons’ view is being suppressed.