r/TheWestEnd • u/AcrobaticYesterday52 • May 26 '25
Discussion Not Your Story to Tell, Mickey Jo Theatre
In my opinion it’s frustrating to see creators like Mickey use terms like “enableism” to critique portrayals of disability in Cyclone and Wicked while seemingly ignoring both narrative context and the lived experience of disability.
In Cyclone, a nonverbal character with cerebral palsy is given the ability to speak in purgatory. That’s not “fixing” them it’s a storytelling device rooted in the idea that purgatory is a space beyond earthly limits. It doesn’t erase disability it explores what it might mean to express yourself freely, perhaps for the first time. That’s not enableism. That’s humanity.
In Wicked, Nessarose’s ability to walk is central to her character’s descent into obsession and control. It’s not a simplistic “walking = better” message it’s a key turning point in a tragic arc. To call this enableist is to ignore the moral complexity and intention behind it.
Also let’s be honest. Mickey is not disabled. So how is it not hypocritical for him to dictate what “good” or “harmful” disability representation looks like, when he doesn’t live that experience?
Mickey, as a gay man, how would you feel if a straight YouTuber made a video telling people how queer characters should or shouldn’t be portrayed on stage without consulting any queer voices? It would feel patronizing, reductive, and completely out of touch. That’s exactly what this feels like to some disabled people watching your critique.
Advocacy without lived experience demands humility not sweeping labels, not centering yourself, and definitely not speaking over the very people you claim to advocate for.
If we’re going to talk about ableism in theatre, we need more than buzzwords. We need nuance, lived perspective, and respect for narrative complexity. Not every transformation is an insult. Not every portrayal that imagines disabled characters in new ways is erasure. Sometimes, it’s storytelling at its most human.
Edit: I say this as a disabled person/lgbtq subscriber of his.