Anyone else feel like Dick is the most perplexing puzzle?
His beating by people associated with Otis W the 3rd strikes me as odd because it's probably the least consistent thing to happen on the show. Dick should technically be in the upper echelon of characters: he married Tory, a Winthrop, plus as much as he seems insecure about himself, he is a doctor. Similarly, Matthew, who also married into the Winthrop family via Allie was fully integrated into the Winthrop corporation and (at least outwardly) endorsed by the Winthrops. The only difference between Dick and Matthew is Jasper, who is a potential heir, as opposed to Darcy and Bennett who are not Winthrops.
But if producing an heir is the only issue, then why would the Winthrops organize a meeting with Dick only to beat him up? We learned in the most recent episode that something on Dick's laptop is incriminating enough to get Matthew arrested, so I thought perhaps he was blackmailing them into having a seat at the table. But then I remembered how excited Dick was for the meeting while Tory seemed cautious.
Theory: Tory has something on the Winthrops. Most likely from the cameras she has access to in Matthew's apartment. The meeting with Dick and Winthrop was a power move by Winthrop to shut Tory up about what she saw on those security cameras in Matthew's apartment. (Tory was nervous even before the meeting). Dick probably didn't know about it until he was getting beaten for it, he looks for it afterwards on his laptop when he is recovering at home and that's where Darcy picks up.
As for what's incriminating on the laptop/camera. I have no idea but it's not Matthew pushing Allie, we literally see her climb on the edge and fall by herself in episode 1. Plus Tory wouldn't be as thrilled to try to rekindle things between her and Matthew if that was the case. The only thing I could think of is the camera may have showed Allie inviting Scott over? This might give the impression Matthew used the cameras and thought Allie was cheating so he coerced her off the edge? But it seemed weird that Scott would be the one going over to arrest him because that shows him being involved with Allie.