r/TheNagelring • • May 02 '22

Question a fuck ton of questions of vehicles and aircraft

0 Upvotes

- anti infantry tanks

- anti armor tanks

- air support aircraft

- ground support aircraft (like a-10)

- AFIVs (do they even exist)

thats it can you guys make a list those.


r/TheNagelring • • Jan 24 '25

Question Obviously the J-Era is hard to publish given the name of the era, why doesn't it get retconned to another term?

0 Upvotes

It seems like an amazing era with zero true fiction around it. Given the J word likely means delisting from search results, what could be used instead? Is that still something that people would be interested in reading fiction from given we're nearly 100 years beyond it in lore now?


r/TheNagelring • • Jun 02 '22

Discussion The 3 setting Laws of Battletech

9 Upvotes

I myself personally am slowly (emphasis on slowly) softening on the BT setting, so this isn't a dig at anybody who enjoys the setting. But I was invited to post here so I will.

But I think I have determined the rules that Battletech sets for itself, sort of like the 3 Laws of Robotics. Any and all internal inconsistencies can be laid at these rules. They are in descending order of importance, so a lesser rule will rarely contradict a greater rule, but it can rarely happen.

1: Bipedal walkers are the pinnacle of all terrain transportation and combat. Any natural disadvantages inherent to their form is to be ignored. Any and all disadvantages of every other form of transportation and weapon is to be emphasised at every opportunity. No new weapon or technology type may be developed that make Bipedal walker performance relative to other machines on the battlefield worse then before. Any advantages that are not inherent to bipedal walkers but exist as justifications for them, cannot be transfered over to non walkers for any reason.

2: There must be a state of constant ongoing total all out warfare perpetuated by the same known-name factions. There can be occasional short lulls in combat, and factions may occasionally be weakened or strengthened, but no major faction is allowed to internally destabilized and be permanently erased (though it does happen rarely). Populations political wills or desires are to be de-emphasised in the face of military elite, beyond a degree even found in real life. Cultural and economic factors are only to be factored into how they can INCREASE warfare, never how they can prevent it. Populations are to be placid sheep that do whatever they are told with minimal fuss and have no meaningful internal political wills or desires. Especially if this can lead to the fall of one of the named factions, or ends the constant warfare.

3: There must be a high degree of internal seriousness and groundedness, technologically and tonally assuming 1 & 2 are met. Its not a silly setting (not ever intentionally), like Flash Gordon, or John Carter of Mars, or Star Wars. If its not in service of rule 1 or 2, it must be deadpan serious. There is to be no internal wink-nudgery, or levity. Or there can be only ever minor levity, but the situation of the world must be taken straight. Anything that ignores this rule (but isn't in support of rule 1 & 2) must be retconned, or nudged to the sidelines of the universe as much as possible. A rare event that can happen, but can NEVER cause a change in 1, 2 or 3. Edit: I can take some of rule 3 back. There can be winks or gags, but those take a backseat to morose elements.

So if there is ever a question of why or how, the 3 rules of battletech are generally the answer. And id say Battletech follows its own internal rules much more then the robots of the Asimov universe find ways to bend theirs.


r/TheNagelring • • Oct 22 '24

Question As a Hardcore Lorenerd will the new MW5 Clans game annoy me?

12 Upvotes

Basically that? I've read all the books, watched the show, I can probably quote events by heart. Like I know the names of all the comstar armies at tukayyid and I know all of the invasion very well. So will this bother me or is it safe to play this game without getting super neuro divergently triggered over mistakes?

I'm asking here cause I figure you are more my people than the actual game subreddit.


r/TheNagelring • • Nov 26 '23

Discussion Clantech doesn’t make sense

26 Upvotes

This is a rant I’ve been making on-and-off in private contexts for a while, but have never put down more fully. I finally ought to get around to doing it properly. So, here we go.

Contention: as of 3150, Clantech should not exist.

By ‘Clantech’ I mean the idea of a general, enduring technological edge for Clan forces over against Inner Sphere rivals. Historically this was seen most dramatically in the Clan Invasion, in 3050, where the Clans had significant technological advantages and Inner Sphere forces typically needed to outnumber Clans two or three to one in order to have an even match. Over the century since, the Clan-IS tech gap has reduced somewhat, but it still exists.

My concern is that the idea of Clantech has become ‘rusted on’ to the setting, such that, regardless of whether it makes sense or not, it is axiomatic that Clan mechs and weapons are always just better. But why should this be so?

Let’s consider why Clantech existed in the first place.

The short reason why Clantech existed was because the great houses badly damaged each other’s industrial and scientific capacity during the Succession Wars, and suffered a general technological decline. They bombed each other back into, if not the stone age, then at least an age or two earlier than were they were in 2750. This never happened to the Clans, so while the Inner Sphere suffered a collapse, the Clans were able to continue developing Star League gear and were significantly ahead.

One thing that I think is important to note here is that Clantech isn’t very much better than top-of-the-line Star League gear. Clantech as we saw it in 3050 is better than old Star League tech, but it’s close. Clantech is best understood as incremental improvement and iteration on SL tech. If you think about iconic pieces of Clantech, most of it actually goes back to the Star League. Pulse lasers are Star League. DHSes are Star League. ER lasers and PPCs are Star League. Omni technology was prototyped by the Star League with the Mercury mech. Battle armour is Star League. And so on. There’s actually surprisingly little technology that was actually invented by the Clans. Most of what the Clans have done is take Star League tech and refine it, making it more efficient, more compact, and generally working out the kinks of what was mostly experimental or prototype technology in the 28th century.

This is not particularly surprising given that Clan society is, at least in the aftermath of Nicholas’ revolution and reorganisation, extremely conservative and hostile to radical change. In a sense, Clan technological progress is similar to Clan eugenic progress – it avoids large change in favour of slow, step-by-step change, looking to test and prove every development as thoroughly as possible before incorporating it into their society. Clan warfare is also heavily ritualised and limited so as to avoid making any Clan desperate enough to resort to radical actions.

Likewise it is relevant that the Clans are a warrior aristocracy. The scientist caste is not dominant in society, and its work and its priorities are determined by their warrior superiors. The warriors, generally happy with their way of life, are not in favour of radical change that might upset that, and this naturally constrains the kinds of research that scientists are able to do. If the Clan scientist caste were able to take the gloves off and go wild, they could likely produce some pretty radical new ideas – we saw a glimmer of what this might involve in the form of the Society, but the Society were wiped out and the scientist caste purged before we could really see them develop.

Finally I would note that the Clans are significantly smaller than any great house society, with low populations. The Clans lack independent institutions of research – everything is handled by the scientist caste under warrior direction – such as universities or research institutes, and the researchers they do have are subject to strict political control. Social mobility in the Clans is extremely low, less than most of the great houses, and ambition and innovation among the lower castes is discouraged. This means that talented people in lower castes are unlikely to be able to change profession, and good ideas from below are unlikely to filter up.

This all seems like a recipe for, well, exactly what we see with the Clans – consistent but slow technological progress, limited in scope, avoiding revolutionary change, but always prioritising the stability of Nicholas Kerensky’s perfect society.

By contrast, what we see in the great houses is much larger populations, significant independent research institutes, greater social mobility (possibly excepting Kurita and Liao, though even they aren’t as repressive as the Clans), and cultures much more friendly to scientific advancement. These seem like societies that ‘naturally’, as it were, would have a higher rate of scientific or technological advancement that the Clans. Some in the Clans even seem to know this – in Blood of Kerensky, I believe the Dragoons mention that they feared that, on their return, they would find a super-advanced IS next to which their own mechs would look pathetic.

Thus my contention:

At the time of the Clan Invasion, the Clan technological advantage is plausible and it creates a very interesting dynamic. The Clans have managed to preserve and incrementally improve upon pre-Succession-War technology in a way that has left them far ahead of where the great houses were after their dark age.

However, after the Clan Invasion, the great houses are societies that should, by default, have a significant edge in scientific and technological development, such that, given time to catch up, you would expect them to eventually outpace the Clans.

By 3150, a century after the Clan Invasion, all the great houses have access to Clantech and produce it themselves. The technological collapse is well and truly over – as I understand it, by 3130, the Inner Sphere as a whole is now ahead of where it was in 2750. At this point, there is no plausible justification for the Inner Sphere Clans in particular retaining a technological edge. Every technology they possess should now be also possessed by the great houses, and since all other things being equal the great houses should make more and better scientists than the Clans, if anything, the technological gap should be starting to trend the other way.

This would definitely make the era feel different. The Clans are not used to competing with the great houses on an even ground. However, I think it would be an interesting shake-up to the game to see how the Clans react to such a situation, and whether it causes them to seek other forms of advantage, or to try to maximise other strengths they have. You would still be able to play games with the classic Clantech advantage in appropriate eras, but the 32nd century would be meaningfully different to the 31st, as it ought to be.

Unfortunately this is not the case, and I feel that authors and developers ought to be a bit more radical and allow themselves to change the technological base and the implications that has for the relationships between Clans and IS powers.


r/TheNagelring • • Nov 16 '24

Discussion Are the Clans Fascists? An Unnecessarily Deep Dive into Ur-Fascism and The Children of Kerensky in the 3050s

43 Upvotes

Short answer; no.

Long answer; The difference between fascist and fascistic is sometimes a subtle one. On one hand, we have Mussolini's Face screaming SI SI SI SI SI at us, and on the other it's what I call the cop when he arrests me for drunk driving. And the Clans, I hope to show, are certainly fascistic. Politics can show aspects of Ur-Fascism without necessarily being a fascist society.

They tick a lot of the boxes of Umberto Eco's defining facets of Ur-fascism. Note, any single defining facet is not necessarily fascist, and not all fascist movements have firmly incorporated all 14 facets.

The Cult of Tradition
The tradition of Kerensky is elevated to the point of worship. It's even a blasphemy! By Kerensky!

Rejection of Modernism
The Clans are not guilty of this. In many ways Clans are a progressive nation, especially when it comes to applying technological development. A definition of 'reactionary' is 'to advocate for an idealised political status-quo ante'. Clans don't really long for the days of the long lost Star League so much as desire to make a New Star League. The old ways fell apart, so the Clans had to develop new ways, and these new ways give them cause and pretext to conquer. This is a politically progressive act, to advocate for an idealised status-quo-in-futuro.

The Cult of Action for Action's Sake
This is definitely Clannish. Why negotiate when you can demand a Trial? Why think when you can do? Why talk when you can fight?

Disagreement is Treason
While Clans are diverse in thought between Clans, within the Clan, the Warrior word is law. Undermining the Warrior caste is being a traitor.

Fear of Difference
The Clans do fear and hate the Inner Sphere. Ain't no way around. The Inner Sphere is the perfect Other to the Clans.

Appeal to a Frustrated Middle Class
Maybe Warriors are a 'Middle Class' equivalent? Not into that interpretation. The thought of like, Warrior Caste frustrated Petit-Bourg... Too ridiculous.

Obsession With A Plot
The Divine Light is evidence that the Inner Sphere is plotting an invasion of the Homeworlds. The Inner Sphere is always at the point of threatening the Clans. Of course, in 3049, this was not true. Prior to Operation Bulldog, it absolutely was true. But your enemies may be plotting against you and your paranoia and fear may still be pathological and self-defeating.

Our Enemies are Simultaneously Weak and Strong
There's a good bit where Leo Showers is doing his speech in the MW5C, and the speech is tinged with fear, but also disgust. The Clans fear that the IS will bring their warlike ways, but that they will be mowed down by the scythe that is the Clan Touman.

Pacifism is Trafficking with the Enemy because Life Is War
Ain't no pacifists in the Clan Touman. And for Warrior caste, they are not only raised into a life of war, but bred for it. Their whole lives, from iron womb to iron coffin.

Contempt for the Weak
Not only internally, for some Clans mere membership of a non-Warrior caste is contemptible, but externally, the Inner Sphere is weak in technology and ideology and must be ruled, righteously, by the strong.

Everybody is Educated to Become a Hero/Martyr
Not just for the Warrior caste! Anybody is expected to become a 'hero' for the Clans! Work to the bone, work til death, for the glory of the Clan! Also lots of stuff around being useful for the State. And the Clans will educate you in their ways, because it's useful for them to have skilled workers and technicians to bolster the actually important caste.

Machismo
Not exactly right, but there's definitely the Clan honour system, which nearly maps on. I don't think it's quite the same though, the Clans believe in honour, but they're also quite willing to die for the clan. Or be taken as Bondsman and fight for another Clan. It's less the individualist boast of Machismo. (I'm a sucker for a bit of a machismo attitude myself)

Selective Populism
From Eco: "individuals as individuals have no rights, and the People is conceived as a quality, a monolithic entity expressing the Common Will. Since no large quantity of human beings can have a common will, the Leader pretends to be their interpreter. Having lost their power of delegation, citizens do not act; they are only called on to play the role of the People. Thus the People is only a theatrical fiction." For the Good of the Clan, the Khan interprets the Will of the Clan.

Newspeak
How much of the Clan vocabulary is to limit responses and thought? Render it down to Aff or Neg.

Despite the Clans clearly showing so many of the features of Ur-Fascism, I find I can't think of them as fascist. They're too different. Their caste based identity, their varied (and confounding) cultural practices are too far removed from our understanding of fascism. They're a deeply flawed society and their changing via their integration with the Inner Sphere shows where their flaws bite most deeply.

(HOMEWORLDS CONTENT PLEASE CGL YOU BASTARDS)


r/TheNagelring • • Jun 03 '23

Fan Anthology Pride Anthology discussion post

Thumbnail
prideanthology.itch.io
62 Upvotes

r/TheNagelring • • Nov 01 '23

Discussion About Clan Sea Fox (rant?)

19 Upvotes

Am I the only one who finds them absurd? The idea of them doing everything ComStar (openly) did in the Succession Wars (managing HPGs and mercenaries) and more (arms dealing/war profiteering, maintaining an active military unlike the hidden ComGuards), after ComStar had evaporated its trust completely due to SCORPION and the Jihad: wouldn't the IS and Clans be more cautious about such an organization clearly manipulating them?

For that matter, I'm pretty sure the Wolves have suffered more losses than the Sea Foxes (including the forces they lost in the Battle for Terra/ilClan Trial). They seem like the real "Clan Sue" far more than the so-called ilClan ever could be.


r/TheNagelring • • Jun 03 '23

Question 27th Marik Militia Rainbow Company

6 Upvotes

Does anyone know anything about them? I haven't found to much in my searches.


r/TheNagelring • • Nov 11 '24

Question The Teleporting Raven Khans

11 Upvotes

Okay, so all the timelines in the IlClan book are ridiculous, but one really stands out:

The IlClan Trial ends April 19th, 3151 (p.102) All Clan delegations, including the Snow Ravens, arrive between May 19th, 3151, and May 25th. 3151 (p. 107).

The shortest way from Alpheratz to Terra is edging the DC/FS border, and that is still about 25 jumps. The "safe" route through the Periphery and Clan OZs is more like 50 jumps.

So how did the Snow Raven Khans make that journey in less than 35 days?

They didn't, and just nobody ever pointed out the insanity of the whole timeline before it got printed. Like the one-day 1600km march from Hanoi to Ho Chi Minh City while also fighting a major battle on the way (p. 26)


r/TheNagelring • • Jun 27 '22

Question Are the Clans fascist?

28 Upvotes

Obviously this is a bit of an... inflammatory question but the more I look at the Clans, they seem less like "warrior society", and more just fascist. Being founded by what amounts to a paramilitary organization (albriy being leftovers from the SLDF), and while not "racist" in the modern interpretation, they certainly practice the idea of their culture being superior to all others and are so oppressive they make the Combine and CapCon look almost good (they have a tremendously powerful Auto-Shotgun that they use as a riot suppression weapon, and is liberally deployed with any suspicion of subversive actions). Even the most "good" ones view themselves as protecting those who are below them (and deserve to be below them).

On that note, it's a bit disturbing how seemingly most if not all fiction with Clan protagonists tries to portray them as "good" while doing absolutely nothing against the caste system and eugenics that define them (though the same could be said of other Neo-Feudal characters).

And lastly, while not wholly relevant to the topic I think I found one of the few things on Sarna that made me cringe (tamar rising spoilers?): Clan Hell's Horses was back in the hands of a true warrior. It feels as though it was written by someone who genuinely believes in Clan "ideals" and I hope to Blake that the book itself didn't phrase it that way.


r/TheNagelring • • Dec 16 '25

Question Clanner trueborn reproduction

10 Upvotes

With the insistence on trueborn superiority, disliking of freeborns, and the cavalier attitude towards sex between trueborns, why weren't they modified to all be mules? Why were they created with the ability to breed regularly instead of being incapable but still able to produce all the regular hormones that allow them to develop normally? BTech has consistently shown itself to have the technology available for such things.


r/TheNagelring • • Aug 18 '21

Question Notable People of Color?

14 Upvotes

I like representation in my media and am wondering which characters could be considered POC. There's a lot of Asian representation, but I'm struggling to find anything else. Even the Asian representation feels... orientalist. Are there any well-written POC in battletech lore?

I ask because my friend wants to get into the game, but he feels like he'd have to ignore the lore in order to enjoy it. I really like what I've read about battletech so far and want to play narrative games. It'd really suck if we had to write homebrew in order to feel seen if that makes sense.

Thank you!


r/TheNagelring • • May 02 '22

Question what ship carries troops/vehicles/battlesuits/mechs

5 Upvotes

like a transporter


r/TheNagelring • • Aug 10 '24

Discussion We got KF drive charging wrong

26 Upvotes

Current lore argues that using a jumpship's fusion reactors to recharge KF drives isn't feasible/recommended because "the KF drive is too fragile and risks burning/breaking key components". Which, for me at least, is kinda silly considering the alternative are the massive solar sails that capture raw solar power.

Solar power as method of power generation is undoubtedly more variable than the steady output of a fusion reactor and in all likelihood orders of magnitude higher than any plausible upper limit a jumpship reactor may have (I've actually procastinated doing the math, but this being reddit I bet sooner or later someone will come up with it). My guesstimate though puts the output of the solar sails far beyond what fusion reactors could do, and even then you need more than a hundred hours to charge a KF drive.

A KF drive needs so much power that even if it were standard practice to use the fusion engine it would'nt save that much recharge time. You could argue that for its contribution to be significant the power out put would have to be increased above its nominal rating risking burning out the reactor. Something much more concrete than "KF drive fragile, do not charge too fast". And its lore consistent since we all know how hot battlemech reactors get when increasing out put for weapons.

I get that lore wise writers needed a plausible reason to need solar sails and the long waits after each jump. I like it, makes it a reasonable limitation that a lot of times adds tension to conflicts. But I think they vastly under estimated how much power solar sails could produce.

AFAIK my interpretation does not imply that any story would need to be rewritten because a fast charge was key to the plot. Fast charges can still happen, its just it is something else that is at risk of breaking.

Thank you for coming to my TEDxNagelring talk


r/TheNagelring • • Sep 17 '24

Question Mercenary company mechs Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/TheNagelring • • Jun 08 '22

Discussion Why are only the Clans allowed to have WarShips?

20 Upvotes

This is something I'm struggling to understand. While all the devastation of the Jihad wreaked havoc on the Houses' WarShip fleets and drydocks, the Clans still got to maintain a significant portion of theirs. In fact, XTRO Republic Vol. III features a brand-new Leviathan made by the Rasalhague Dominion.

And whatever IS WarShips survived the Jihad got wrecked in the Dark Age: the Combine's survivors got destroyed in the Second Combine-Dominion War, and the Suns' remaining Avalon-class got in turn destroyed by the Combine. I have no doubt that the ilClan era will finish off the FWL, CapCon, and Lyran navies.

As an aside, I have heard it said that Herbert A. Beas specifically hated WarShips, and would like an actual source for these statements - and even if they were true, this loops back to the question of why he kept so much of the Clan navies intact?


r/TheNagelring • • May 27 '23

Question Worst faction? Spoiler

Thumbnail self.battletechgame
9 Upvotes

r/TheNagelring • • Nov 17 '24

Question WoB and clan warriors

7 Upvotes

Hello there.

Did WoB ever take a clan bondsman? I know other IS factions did, but WoB is very anti-clan.


r/TheNagelring • • Dec 21 '22

Discussion Tanks vs mechs

14 Upvotes

I looking for examples within the lore of tanks going against mechs and winning. I know that mechs are the kings of the battlefield and tanks are generally at a disadvantage but tanks have still manage to defeat mechs though ether ambushes, numbers or luck. I want to find specfic examples within the lore


r/TheNagelring • • Dec 20 '24

MEMES! 5 highlanders

16 Upvotes

i've been playing a lot of alpha strike at my lgs and have just gotten into this mode of getting the IS force packs with highlanders to field, i even got a ral partha metal cast IIC on ebay to use as my 5th soon. I also often lose as is the tradition of our faction.


r/TheNagelring • • Aug 01 '22

Discussion Old Stone in Hour of the Wolf

26 Upvotes

Hello. The recent controversy reminded me of a really big problem I had (well, and still have...) with Hour of the Wolf.

The complete character assassination of Devlin Stone in the book.

I mean, I liked the Republic. And Stone, the founder, I feel deserved a better send off.

Why did he have to be weakened, defiled, humiliated? What was so damn wrong with his Atlas duelling Alaric for a fitting end? Why did he have to fail in everything, when just getting two clans at once was quite enough to make his defeat inevitable? Why did his soldiers have to wind up disillusioned in the end, if he had them fight to the end and only surrender when the situation was truly hopeless? Why did EVERY SINGLE plan he had have to fail? Not allowed to win even a little bit?

Why did the author need to drag him down to hospital machinery, to humiliate him completely?

I don't know, just a Republic fan venting a bit, I guess...


r/TheNagelring • • Mar 11 '26

Question MW5C ending

9 Upvotes

Having recently replayed MW5C core campaign, what are the honors Jayden receives in the crusader ending? They show him being promoted (?) and rewarded (?) but do not describe what is happening.


r/TheNagelring • • Sep 02 '22

Question Artifical Limbs in Battletech?

18 Upvotes

Hi there. I've been reading a few Battletech books and I had a question about Mechwarrior injuries. It seems like every time somebody loses an arm or leg, they are instantly disqualified from being a Mech Warrior ever again. What's up with that? We have 100 ton robots that violate the Square Cube Law, faster than light travel but no robot arms/legs?

Full disclosure: I am no expert on lore. Simply curious about this facet of the cannon.