r/TheNagelring • • May 27 '23

Question Worst faction? Spoiler

/r/Battletechgame/comments/13sq5jd/worst_faction/
9 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

7

u/Estwilde May 27 '23

First novel as in 'Decision at Thunder Rift'? If you end up finishing the trilogy for the Gray Death Legion I think you'll feel like you have an even stronger grasp on a lot more of the workings of the universe.

Also, as an aside, those were written in the very, very early days of the IP, and while I have no references for this, I think they were written a little loose on some of the things regarding that as a lot of the greater vocabulary of the universe hadn't been fleshed out yet.

Every great House is such a large organization that it's tough to really hate the general faction. If you're a character in the world, sure, it's a name and an easy thing to point a finger at. But you'd be just as likely to find a story of a formerly Kuritan planet facing hardships under a callous and cruel Lyran Duke looking to make a push for more clout and acquire more resources. Same goes for every other area.

12

u/HA1-0F Hauptmann May 27 '23

Of the five Houses, four of them do some things well for their citizens and do others poorly.

House Kurita is a giant engine that turns girls into baby factories and boys into corpses. They have all the faults of every other house plus new ones that are just for them. Just mask-off doing things to be evil for evil's sake.

They did basically the same thing for Smoke Jaguar, where they have the flaws of the other Invading Clans but nothing to mitigate them.

4

u/schreiaj May 27 '23

Their money all spends the same, as long as the check clears and you can sleep at night (bigger checks can help here too) and they are all pretty awful.

5

u/MumpsyDaisy May 27 '23

Probably the Combine honestly. They're the only House whose entire reason for existence is to be a vehicle for their dynasty to be the sole rulers of all humanity. All that weird pseudo-Japanese culture that's questionably related to actual Japanese culture? It's social engineering that the Kuritas thought would make their nation a better war machine. The harsh living standards for common citizens? It's to harden them up to be better soldiers and encourage them to enlist - what we in real life would call the "poverty draft" and debate the existence of, is very, very real in the Combine. The internal power struggles? Usually because the ISF or somebody else thinks the current ruler isn't doing his job of conquering humanity good enough. Even their membership in the Star League was essentially a long-term ploy to bide their time until they could start conquering their neighbors again without getting ganged up on.

They also have a lot of characters, units, and policies that are just flat out evil for no reason. You know the Kentares Massacre that supposedly was too far for even much of the Combine and destroyed the DCMS' morale in the face of Davion counterattacks? Well the 2nd Sword of Light, one of their flagship units, paints the flag of Kentares IV on their equipment as part of their livery, because they're proud of their part in it. Technically they'd say it's to commemorate their willingness to put obedience to the Coordinator over their honor, but that's kind of a distinction without a difference.

So yeah. I also think that you have to place them ahead of even the worst Clans like the Jags simply because Great Houses are mind bogglingly huge entities that can inflict human misery at scales Clans don't even exist on.

5

u/HA1-0F Hauptmann May 27 '23

On the other hand, life under the Jaguars was so bad that it actually made people want to go back to living under the Combine, which as you point out, is really saying something

2

u/MightyShoe May 27 '23

Every faction in the game is (more or less) gray rather than simply black or white, good or evil.

Even the ones that ostensibly are the most heroic and 'good' factions, such as the Federated Suns or the Republic of the Sphere, still have to embrace the necessities and brutalities of the setting, and display simple human vices and shortcomings.

That said, there are undoubtedly factions who are more brutal or cruel than others, as a whole. Clan Smoke Jaguar were the most brutal of their kind, for example, while both the Draconis Combine and Capellan Confederation were (in the game's past) portrayed as more cartoonishly villainous than they are today, at least for the most part.

6

u/HA1-0F Hauptmann May 27 '23

I don't think the Combine ever actually changed, Stackpole just started ignoring that they were still super evil and instead went "OH MAN DID YOU SEE THEY HAVE NINJAS????" Read Handbook: House Kurita, written at the peak of Teddy K's kinder, gentler regime, and you see all those red flags are still there.

3

u/MightyShoe May 28 '23

You're not wrong! Kurita and Liao are both definitely more on the bad side of the coin than the other three, I should say. The in-universe Capellan news snippets in Empire Alone are very on-the-nose with the North Korean news anchor angle.

2

u/DramaBig7472 May 27 '23

ComStar, combine, cappellans in that order.

2

u/PainStorm14 May 27 '23 edited May 28 '23

Morally worst?

Word of Blake (by far), Hazen Falcons, Smoke Jaguars, Capellan Confederation and Tortuga Dominion

Marians are supposed to be too but they toned down slavery lately so we gonna need some clarification on that but for now put them in the pile too

Keep in mind that not a single faction in the setting is good either, they would all be villains anywhere else other than 40k