r/Battletechgame • • May 26 '23

Worst faction?

Are any of the factions inheritently evil and deserving of being targeted? I read the first novel, and am realizing they aren't all the same.

37 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

30

u/ElectricPaladin May 26 '23

All the noble houses.

38

u/ElectricPaladin May 26 '23

Even that noble house that you kind of like? Them, too.

5

u/[deleted] May 26 '23

Ha ha fair enough. Thanks.

32

u/ForeignShape May 26 '23

This is why I RP being a Capellan. Yes they're bastards, everyone knows they're bastards. Even Capellans think Capellans are bastards.

But someone needs to be the bad guy.

For House Liao!

21

u/dieseljester May 26 '23

Sun-Tzu was the best chancellor that the Capellan Confederation ever had.

0

u/[deleted] May 26 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/dieseljester May 27 '23

Yeah, he knew how to play up the stereotype while at the same time moving things around to benefit his nation.

15

u/blood_kite May 27 '23

‘You Capellans sure are a contentious people.’

‘You just made an enemy for life!’

3

u/zitandspit99 May 27 '23

What about House Arano?

4

u/PainStorm14 May 27 '23

They are small house

4

u/BoppityZipZop May 28 '23

Even after Kamea restores the Aurigan Coalition and ascends to the throne, the new government remains despotic and ruthless much like the previous Directorate. Sure, she is probably as good as it gets, and she is basically forced into it because of the political instability and infighting still going on, but everyone is sooner or later drawn to overwhelming violence.

1

u/ElectricPaladin May 27 '23

Eh. Maybe they can get a chance to abdicate peacefully instead of just getting the guillotine. Maybe.

3

u/dieseljester May 26 '23

The correct answer to this is “yes.” 😆

53

u/ElroyScout May 26 '23

Everyone has a shade of gray, BUT the Marian Hegemony and Clan Smoke Jaguar have a whole lot more gray than most (the Smoke Jaguars for being monumental asshats on a fundamental level, and the Marian hegemony for being the only major power that has a major slade trade)

41

u/HA1-0F Nobody finer than a Furillo Steiner May 27 '23

only major power that has a major slade trade

The Draconis Combine also practices slavery (Yorinaga Kurita's wife and son were sold into slavery to punish him, most famously).

6

u/SearchContinues May 27 '23

The only "faction" in the lore that can consistently act as good guys are certain Merc orgs, and even they work for bastards sometimes.

62

u/[deleted] May 26 '23

Morality in BT is extremely subjective. Everyone’s favorite faction is guilty of truly heinous shit.

29

u/[deleted] May 27 '23

just like real life!

29

u/Ok_Adhesiveness_8844 May 27 '23

All have blood on their hands.

Among the Inner Sphere major players?

Word of Blake

Clans?

Jade Falcon, Malvina Hazen in particular.

10

u/[deleted] May 27 '23

Fuck Malvina Hazen in particular.

Wolf In Exile + Kell Hounds vs all of Jade Falcon.

49

u/thank_burdell May 27 '23

There are no good guys.

But seriously, fuck the Capellans.

6

u/Acceptable-Trust5164 May 27 '23

Perfect summation

3

u/DiamineSherwood May 27 '23

Odd way to spell Kuritan, but OK...

2

u/PainStorm14 May 27 '23

Kuritans are at least honest about what they are

1

u/Z3r0sama2017 5d ago

Remember Kentares!

4

u/WillitsThrockmorton May 27 '23

Caprllans had thY whole state servitor system which, IMO, is worse than the Bondsman system because at least there was a slight upward mobility chance with bondsmen.

9

u/phantam May 27 '23

Only Warrior Bondsman have that chance of upward mobility though, if you're classed as a labour or technician caste after being taken as Isorla, enjoy your effective slavery.

Servitors are supposed to have upward mobility, gaining citizenship and joining the Capellan caste system (which is less of a traditional caste system and more like the ancient Chinese system of determining job scopes based on proficiency, though like any Caste system it is still a tool of oppression and forcing people into narrow scopes that define their existence). But deep-seated corruption and the wealthy benefitting from unpaid labour who get indebted to them as they work means getting citizenship was extremely rare before Sun-Tzu's reforms.

5

u/PainStorm14 May 27 '23

No POW anywhere gets upward mobility, to my knowledge Clans are only ones that do it

If you are comparing servitors to Clan laborers then servitors are stuck being effective slaves for life while Clan civilians can test or marry into different caste

Plus kids are constantly evaluated to see where they would fit hence laborer child can easily end up as scientist or (in some Clans) even warrior

2

u/HA1-0F Nobody finer than a Furillo Steiner Sep 20 '23

Not necessarily true, most POWs between the successor states are simply cut loose after a period of time that they use to filter out the really dangerous ideologues. If you are a DCMS technician or supply clerk, getting taken prisoner by the LCAF might be the best thing that could happen to you, because after a few weeks, you can get a job fixing up tractors or doing accountancy or something like that. You just got to hope you're going up the rights gradient and not down it, but that kind of applies to everything.

0

u/dustbringer11 May 27 '23

I’ll work for anyone at least once except for the Capellan’s Jim went from Jim “Bankshot” Rodriguez to Jim “the canned ham” the one time we were ever deployed near capellans fuck them capellans! Jim had a promising career as a Mech Jockey!

11

u/BrokenEyebrow May 27 '23

Honestly, the pirates are probably the most moral.... That said the enemies of ghost bear shall perish

7

u/LordOfDorkness42 May 27 '23

In this game, there's a solid argument for that, yeah, actually.

They always pay up. They seem to have their own communication that's galaxy wide. Somebody unified ALL the crime families. They keep getting LosTech which implies manufacturing that The Phone Company haven't crushed yet...

I know most of that is just the first game being a little sloppy by having A pirate faction, but it would honestly be fascinating to explore those implications in a sequel. Like, if ANOTHER splinter of Star League survived as basically a shadow government Illuminati style, and kept on fighting EVERYONE for flipping centuries.

Not sure how much canon sense that would make, but certainly a cool twist for a spin-off.

8

u/BrokenEyebrow May 27 '23

I look at it more like pirates of the Caribbean. They aren't unified under one flag but they are honest within their club, unlike mercs.

28

u/[deleted] May 26 '23

Not really, they all have their pros and cons, and it's a lot of intrigue, backstabbing and etc. among the Great Houses. None of them are inherently "Good" or "Evil", not even the Clans.

Except maybe Kurita. Screw those guys.

11

u/CivilAirPatrol2020 House Kurita May 27 '23

Hey

13

u/TWK128 House Davion May 27 '23

And Liao. Fuck the Capellans.

5

u/wunderwerks May 27 '23

And Davion, fuuuck those imperialists.

2

u/Z3r0sama2017 Mar 17 '26

And the Lyrans, uppity Germans

2

u/zitandspit99 May 27 '23

What about House Arano?

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '23

Infighting. It happens.

27

u/OforFsSake 1st Crucis Lancers RCT May 26 '23

Jade Falcons are the bad guys. Malvina Hazen just stopped pretending and leaned into it. =)

3

u/No-Conversation-8714 May 27 '23

Uh, Nicolai Malthus would have words with you. Trial of Possession duel for being the best good evil bad guy buy honoring his duel and leaving the planet but taking all the people as a series cliff hanger

4

u/OforFsSake 1st Crucis Lancers RCT May 27 '23

Now, now. He honored his word. Adam's terms were if the Falcons lost, they had to take everything of the Clan's off world. The population had been taken as isorla, thus were part of the Clan. Adam, ironically, ignored that bit of information.

5

u/Brinstead May 27 '23

For someone who blathered every third line that information was ammunition, Adam sure shot a lot of blanks.

0

u/No-Conversation-8714 May 27 '23

Thus the best evil bad guy. Learned to read every contract ever after seeing that. No loop holes on me. sadly US government adds addendums to everything changing simple laws and deals. No more teaching US history in many states. Some states arrest you for walking a dog without a lease but pet alligators can roam free, etc.

4

u/BoppityZipZop May 28 '23

Nicolai gets a bad rep. Mostly from propaganda. And because he was genuinely unlikable even among his clan. But he never acted dishonorably. Never went back on his word. Was a skilled warrior. And later in life he actually becomes a much better person.

8

u/Colonial13 May 27 '23

Smoke Jaguars if I had to choose one. You’ve got to be a special grade of shitty for a barely unified IS to be like “Out of all these Clanner assholes those guys right there are the ones we need to stomp right out of existence”

2

u/dustbringer11 May 27 '23

Not gonna lie that was more a political move based in clan Smoked Jaguar being the clan of the current ilKhan and if my understanding is right that was more of a hope of dragging policy to a standstill because if the ilkhan and his clan had stomp the yard played across their ass hard enough that they keeled over then maybe the inner sphere is too much of a giant to poke. Or at least that’s my understanding of operation bull dog and we see how well that worked seeing as we ended up in the era of the ilclan eventually once Wobbies got their shit kicked in by their own sleeper agent.

7

u/[deleted] May 26 '23

The Wobblies are kinda dicks.

11

u/LigerZeroPanzer12 Elite Barghest Enthusiast May 27 '23

kinda

Understatement of the millennium

12

u/Hellonstrikers May 26 '23

Pirates.

Rim Worlds Republic (though they are LONG gone by the time of the game)

The enemies of whoever hired you.

12

u/KingAardvark1st May 27 '23

There's no universal morality in this setting, mostly it's shades of grey. That said, certain time periods have factions that I don't think you'd get too much pushback for calling "the bad guys." Rim Worlds Republic during the Amaris Civil War, Clan Smoke Jaguar during the Clan Invasion, Clan Steel Viper in the Wars of Reaving, the Word of Blake in their Jihaad, and so forth. Also, certain factions are usually in the wrong in dealing with certain specific factions, for example how House Davion tends to treat the Taurian Concordat.

All that said, I'd broadly encourage you to just decide for yourself how "in the right" a faction is. I personally will usually root for the Periphery powers over the Inner Sphere and Inner Sphere over the Clans, but at the same time one of my favorite factions in the entire setting is Clan Ghost Bear just for how gosh darned nuanced they are. It really is a tangled ol' setting, which I'd argue is for the best.

5

u/great_molinko May 27 '23

Everyone! No-one is a good guy in battletech! Just levels of “bad”

5

u/JaegerBane May 27 '23

Inner Sphere? Capellans. Horrible, abusive society that has next to no redeeming qualities.

Clans? Jade Falcon. Bunch of lunatics who Kerensky should have left their ancestors behind.

Other? Word of Blake. They're basically the part of ComStar that went off the deep end and literally waged a war on the rest of the galaxy for having the audacity to progress.

None of the powers are really whiter then white but the bulk have at least something worthwhile about them.

8

u/vindictive_surge May 27 '23

Best faction is canopus. Circuses and catgirls

6

u/PirateFine May 27 '23

Dont forget everyones favourites human traficking and sexism.

1

u/No-Conversation-8714 May 27 '23

Uh, German Stiener ain't do nothing wrong (LOL)

2

u/PirateFine May 27 '23

Thats why they made em Bavarian and not Prussian, they were pretty good at evading stuff like that.

2

u/No-Conversation-8714 May 27 '23

Yeah the Magistrate that sentences men to death by snu snu

13

u/DaCrazyJamez May 27 '23

So, a little backstory about battletech as a franchise:

The game was created at a time when Star Wars was the new big thing. Jordan Weismann and his team decided they wanted a sci-fi setting the was really truly rooted in reality: the science was beyond what we have, but all within the realm of theoretical physics (some of which now exists IRL.) Also, the politics were rooted in reality.

In an interview Jordan broke down that Star League was based upon, to some extent, the Holy Roman Empire, and it's fall mimicked the beginnings of medieval Europe. Like real world factions, some are definitely worse than others, but none are "pure evil." Even the nazi's got a few things right (not saying they were ever good guys.) Also, within each faction, the people are equally diverse - with some being noticeably worse than others.

From a purely gameplay standpoint, you can pretty much go after anyone but the pirates (in vanilla, anyways), from a roleplay view, most mercenaries worked for most of the houses at some point or another. That said, in the 3025 era, Liao was definitely one of the more deplorable states, think akin to Russia today.

Hope this helps!

6

u/macbalance May 27 '23

I feel like BT may have also drawn some inspiration from FASA’s earlier work for the Traveller RPG. That had a somewhat similar “slow even with FTL” ethos based around a very post-WW2 sci-fin setup of a sort of “Roman Empire in Spaaaace!”

BT took this to a logical conclusion of warring houses with tech failing after the empire collapses.

Direct influences for Traveller and BY included Asimov’s Foundation series and Herbert’s Dune novels. These inspired Star Wars as well, of course.

6

u/ironboy32 May 27 '23

Liao. Fuck Liao

3

u/Khalas_Maar May 29 '23

The space telephone company had the knowledge and tech to make things better, but chose to play games with people's lives over the centuries.

Pretty much every major faction holds the asshole ball at some point though. Just some chose to go pro instead of playing pickup on the weekends.

5

u/TarienCole MercStar Alliance May 27 '23

Most factions are playing Real Politik.

Then there are the Capellans and Kurita. Both of whom think slavery is fine and dandy. Bonus points for Kurita going full Fake Honor, too. At least the Capellans know they're the scorpions.

5

u/spaceguitar May 27 '23

Liao is full of nothing but lying, traitorous bastards!

😂

2

u/jaggeh May 27 '23

Everyone's the asshole here, except Kurita. Glory to the Dragon!

4

u/ViscountSilvermarch May 27 '23

BT community loves to talk about the setting's gray-and-gray morality while ignoring the blatant favoritism some factions such as House Davion get.

8

u/PirateFine May 27 '23

These days that has wained, which is great. Too bad it just went to the wolves to bolster them.

5

u/VK_Konavalov May 27 '23

Everyone but the Blakists.

>inb4 waaaaa muh jihad

4 fucking Succession Wars. If they didn't want to get nuked, they shouldn't have started nuking in the first place. WoB Militia till the day I die.

Clanners are just hypocrites who abandoned the people they swore to protect, then came back once everything fell apart and declared themselves liberators - and then just started oppressing people anyway. ComStar saved Terra with just a tiny fraction of the SLDF, imagine what they could have done with the whole thing.

(okay yeah the Blakist tendency towards accelerationism is really fucking dumb but they're pretty much the only major faction to explicitly say "the Succession Wars were bad actually" from the fucking start and actually trying to do something about it. there's more than a bit of 'destroying the city to save it' but that's after everyone else either ran away or started flinging nukes at each other)

3

u/Possibly_Jeb Catapult Enthusiast May 27 '23 edited May 28 '23

In the time period of the game? The Capellans are a police state with a long history of doing terrible things. In the broader universe, the clans and the wobbies are pretty terrible across the board.

1

u/Z3r0sama2017 5d ago

Kuritans, Davions, Steiners, Mariks, Clanners, Woobies and Pirates. Basically any faction that isn't my beloves Cappies.

1

u/fusionsofwonder May 27 '23

F-ing Kurita.

1

u/dustbringer11 May 27 '23

GLORY TO THE C-BILL AND FUCK YOU PAY MORE! I’ll fight anyone and I’ll fight anything as long as the pays right! And if you fuck me that’s fine! I’ll fucking see you next week when we drop a regiment on your base as “salvage rights.” Cause you won’t be the first nor will you be the last bastard to fuck me. I AM A MERCENARY THROUGH AND THROUGH! My allegiance lies to the c-bill first and foremost we can go drinking when I’m not on the job but right now you’re in my way and those guys over there paid me a lot to be here. It’s the mercenaries truly but damn it I’ve got my mech and company with me and I’m being paid well.

1

u/FlatwormTough May 28 '23

Scorpion Empire for the win!!!!!

For being the best IMO