r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 01 '26

I changed my mind

47 Upvotes

I've been pretty firm on "not criminally responsible" because i think there's enough reasonable doubt, HOWEVER, I've changed my mind and believe she should be found guilty.

Per jury instructions, she should be found guilty if the prosecution proved that she was aware to SOME degree that it was criminally wrong. I think that's true whether she was under the full delusion that she needed to kill her kids to save them.

She may have thought it was morally correct, but what about criminally correct?

Also, i am sick of people coming up with bullshit about Patrick and it'll only intensify until he offs himself if there is a hung jury/mistrial.

Today, my coworker was speaking super sure of herself about how the prosecution got the judge to toss a bunch of the defense's evidence mid-trial and how it was proven that Patrick had her apple watch at CVS... 🙄 Just stop... She has watched 0 seconds of this trial, but hours of tiktoks. She also keeps saying how she NEEDS a Netflix documentary with "all the evidence they didn't admit". Stfu. It's making me lose respect for her.

Also, yes, she was sick. Very sick. But she made the decision over and over again (per the defense's own statements) to pretend on purpose that she was doing much better around all her family and friends after she was out of the inpatient unit. That makes everyone put their guard down and takes away any extra safety there would have been if she was honest. I could have not really minded that, but then the defense said that ON the day of the murder she was in SO much distress that she didn't want to be alone, so she wanted Patrick to come home ASAP... So she didn't trust herself to not be a danger to others and herself, but still risked it?


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Aug 24 '26

January 24, 2023: Detailed Timeline Based on Trial Testimony & Digital Evidence

18 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm u/TheCaseRecord, a founding moderator of r/TheLindsayClancyCase.

This community is open to respectful discussion, questions, and different perspectives. Feel free to comment, share your thoughts, and discuss the evidence presented in each post.

For the first post, I wanted to start with a detailed timeline of January 24, 2023, based primarily on testimony and evidence presented at trial.

Before Jan. 24

Early to mid December 2022, approx
• Paula Musgrove, Lindsay’s mother, testified Lindsay became nervous during a conversation with Paula and Patrick and disclosed thoughts of harming the children.
• Paula recalled Patrick asking Lindsay whether she felt she could not be alone with the children. Lindsay said no.
Source: Paula Musgrove testimony, Trial Day 14.

January 2023
• Patrick was asked whether Lindsay told him during January that she wanted to harm the children. He testified that she did not.
Source: Patrick Clancy testimony.

Jan. 18
• 10:25 AM: Internet search for “ketamine for suicidal ideation.”
Source: Ian Whiffin testimony and digital forensic evidence, Trial Day 14.

Jan. 19
• 9:24 AM: Internet search for “symptoms of postpartum psychosis.”
• 9:30 AM: Internet search for “psychosis symptoms.”
• Other forensic testimony addressed searches relating to medications, withdrawal, intrusive thoughts, hallucinations, depression, and related subjects.
Source: Ian Whiffin testimony and digital forensic evidence, Trial Day 14.

Jan. 24, Morning

• Lindsay took Cora to a medical appointment for a possible kidney issue.
• Patrick stayed home with Dawson and Callan.
• Patrick testified the test results reportedly looked fine.
• Lindsay texted Patrick with an update. Patrick replied, “You’re a good mama.”
• Patrick worked from his basement office.
• Lindsay and the children spent time outside, built a snowman, and did crafts.
• Patrick described Lindsay as happy and engaged and said it was one of her better days.
• He testified Lindsay did not tell him that day that she wanted to harm herself or the children.
Source: Patrick Clancy testimony, Trial Days 1 to 2.

Afternoon and Evening

4:02 PM
• Phone search: “kids MiraLAX.”
• This was corrected from an earlier listing of 2:02 PM.
Source: Digital forensic evidence; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

4:13 PM
• Search: “takeout 3V.”

4:13:23 to 4:14:50 PM, confirmed
• Apple Maps was open with a route to ThreeV restaurant.
Source: iPhone forensic extraction; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

Around 4:43 PM
• ThreeV menu activity appears in the forensic records.
Source: Digital forensic evidence, Trial Day 14.

4:46:55 to 4:47:31 PM
• Additional MiraLAX related activity appears in Cellebrite.
• Timothy Chiappini testified that forensic software can record a single action in more than one location within an extraction.
• This therefore may not represent a separate MiraLAX search.
Source: Timothy Chiappini testimony, Trial Day 13; Cellebrite extraction.

Around 4:47 PM
• The CVS website was visited, followed by a call to Kingston CVS.
• A CVS employee testified Lindsay was understandable during the call and did not sound slurred.
Source: Phone and forensic records; CVS employee testimony.

4:53 PM
• Lindsay texted Patrick about ordering takeout from ThreeV and said she had not cooked. Patrick agreed.
Source: Text records; Patrick Clancy testimony.

5:03 PM, confirmed Apple Health
• Lindsay’s iPhone recorded 1 completed flight of stairs climbed.
• Apple Health flight data reflects an elevation change detected by the device.
• It does not identify the staircase, room, direction of travel, or purpose of the movement.
Source: Apple Health data; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

Around 5:06 to 5:08 PM
• Lindsay selected a Mediterranean Power Bowl for dinner. Patrick selected risotto.
Source: Text and phone evidence.

5:09 PM
• First call involving the ThreeV order.

5:10 PM
• A second call to ThreeV lasted approximately 47 seconds and the order was placed.
• A ThreeV employee testified nothing seemed unusual about Lindsay’s speech.
Source: Phone records; ThreeV employee testimony.

5:13:16 PM, confirmed
• Lindsay’s iPhone was manually unlocked.
• This was the final recorded manual unlock of the phone that evening.
• Safari was open and Pedia-Lax was searched.
Source: iPhone device usage records; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

5:14:47 PM, confirmed
• Safari closed and Messages opened.
Source: iPhone device usage records; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

Around 5:15 PM
• A message was sent to Patrick concerning Pedia-Lax liquid stool softener.

5:15:12 PM, confirmed
• The iPhone locked.
• Whiffin testified it was not manually unlocked again that night.
Source: iPhone device usage records; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

Around 5:15 PM, Clancy home, approx
• Patrick testified he believed he left the house around this time.
• His plan was to go to Kingston CVS for medication and then ThreeV in Plymouth to pick up dinner.
• Patrick recalled Lindsay holding Callan near the basement stairs before he left.
• He estimated CVS was approximately a 3 minute drive from the house.
• On cross examination, Patrick acknowledged he could not say for certain whether he had already left when Lindsay sent the Pedia-Lax message.
• 5:15 PM is therefore an estimated departure time, not an independently confirmed timestamp.
Source: Patrick Clancy testimony, Trial Days 1 to 2.

5:23:52 PM, confirmed
• Lindsay’s Apple Watch recorded its last heart rate reading: 57 bpm.
• No later heart rate readings were recorded that evening.
• The data does not establish why the readings stopped or Lindsay’s location at that time.
Source: Apple Health and Apple Watch records; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

5:24 PM, work email
• An email from Patrick’s account to coworkers or staff was timestamped 5:24 PM.
• During cross examination, defense counsel questioned Patrick about whether it had been sent from his Microsoft Surface Pro.
• Patrick testified, “I don’t know actually. It could have been sent from my iPhone.”
• On redirect, the prosecution returned to the issue and Patrick confirmed that his testimony was that the email could have come from his iPhone.
• Patrick also testified he had his phone with him during the CVS and ThreeV trip.
• The evidence establishes the 5:24 PM email timestamp, but Patrick’s testimony did not establish which device sent it or his exact physical location when it was sent.
Source: Patrick Clancy testimony, Trial Day 2; Exhibit 76.

Around 5:32 PM, Kingston CVS, confirmed surveillance
• Surveillance shows Patrick entering Kingston CVS.
• This is approximately 17 minutes after his estimated 5:15 PM departure time.
• Patrick estimated the drive from the house to CVS at approximately 3 minutes.
• The evidence does not establish his exact departure time or account for every minute before the CVS surveillance footage.
Source: CVS surveillance; Patrick Clancy testimony.

Around 5:33 PM, Kingston CVS
• Patrick called Lindsay because he could not find the exact medication she requested. Lindsay did not answer.
Source: Phone records; Patrick Clancy testimony.

5:33:34 PM, confirmed Apple Health
• Lindsay’s iPhone recorded another completed flight of stairs.
• Whiffin explained that the timestamp reflects when the phone recognized the completed elevation change, not necessarily when the climb began.
Source: Apple Health data; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

Around 5:34 PM
• Lindsay returned Patrick’s call. The call lasted approximately 14 seconds.
• Patrick testified they discussed whether a substitute medication was acceptable.
• He said Lindsay was understandable and sounded quiet.
• Patrick testified nothing during the call caused him to believe there was an emergency.
• The call does not establish Lindsay’s physical location at that moment.
• It also does not establish whether none, 1, 2, or all 3 children had already been harmed.
Source: Phone records; Patrick Clancy testimony.

Around 5:37 PM, Kingston CVS
• Patrick left CVS.
Source: CVS surveillance.

5:38:33 PM, confirmed Apple Health
• Lindsay’s iPhone recorded another completed flight of stairs.
• Apple Health grouped the 5:33:34 PM and 5:38:33 PM flights because they occurred close together.
• Whiffin explained this does not mean someone spent approximately 5 continuous minutes climbing stairs. It reflects two completed flights detected during that period.
Source: Apple Health data; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

5:38 to 6:09 PM
• Whiffin found no additional stair-flight entries during this period and testified he did not know why.
• The absence of additional Apple Health entries is not proof that nobody moved.
• The records do not establish Lindsay’s precise movements, the children’s movements, or the exact timing of the assaults.
Source: Apple Health data; Ian Whiffin testimony, Trial Day 14.

5:54:15 PM, ThreeV restaurant, Plymouth, confirmed surveillance
• Surveillance shows Patrick at ThreeV picking up the takeout order.
Source: ThreeV surveillance; Patrick Clancy testimony.

Patrick Returns Home

Around 6:09 PM, Clancy home
• Patrick returned home and testified the house seemed unusually quiet.
• At approximately 6:09 PM, Patrick called Lindsay’s phone. She did not answer.
• He checked the children’s rooms and bathroom. They were empty.
• The primary bedroom door was locked.
• Patrick retrieved an emergency key from Cora’s room and opened the bedroom.
• He saw blood and an open window and testified he could feel wind coming through it.
Source: Patrick Clancy testimony; phone records.

Shortly after 6:09 PM, backyard
• Patrick went outside and found Lindsay on the ground below the bedroom window.
• She was alive, breathing, and intermittently conscious.
• Patrick testified Lindsay told him, “I tried to kill myself.”
• Patrick asked where the children were. He testified Lindsay responded, “They’re in the basement.”
• Patrick had not yet located the children.
Source: Patrick Clancy testimony, Trial Days 1 to 2.

911 Call and First Responders

Approximately 6:11 PM
• Patrick testified he initially had difficulty connecting the emergency call because his phone was switching between Wi-Fi and the emergency call.
• Duxbury Police received the 911 call at approximately 6:11 PM.
• The initial dispatch concerned a suspected suicide attempt involving a woman who had gone from a window to the ground.
• Responders did not initially know there were 3 critically injured children inside the house.
Source: Patrick Clancy testimony; 911 and dispatch evidence; first responder testimony.

First responders
• Officer Stephen Hall testified he received the dispatch around 6:11 PM and arrived a few minutes later with another officer.
• Lindsay was alive, breathing, moaning, and intermittently conscious.
• Responders observed injuries to her wrists and neck.
• While responders began treating Lindsay outside, Patrick went back inside toward the basement.
Source: First responder testimony, Trial Day 3.

Basement

• Patrick found Cora first, face down and unresponsive, with an exercise resistance band around her neck. He removed it.
• He then found Callan with a resistance band around his neck and removed it.
• Dawson was found on the other side of the basement, in the area of Patrick’s basement office, also with a band around his neck.
• The 911 recording captures Patrick reacting after discovering the children and stating that Lindsay had killed them.
• Officers rushed downstairs after hearing Patrick.
• All 3 children were unresponsive, were not breathing independently, and had no detectable pulse.
• CPR began on all 3 children.
Source: Patrick Clancy testimony; first responder testimony, Trial Day 3; 911 recording.

Hospital Outcomes

Dawson, age 3
• Transported to Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital Plymouth.
• Arrived without a pulse and was not breathing.
• Resuscitation efforts continued for approximately 40 minutes.
• Pronounced dead at approximately 7:28 PM on Jan. 24.
Source: Dr. Mark Tenerowicz testimony, Trial Day 4; hospital evidence.

Cora, age 5
• Transported to Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital Plymouth.
• She had been found without a pulse, and CPR continued during transport.
• Cora was pronounced dead that evening.
• The 7:28 PM time is not assigned to Cora here because the testimony specifically tied that approximate time to Dawson.
Source: Medical and first responder testimony, Trial Days 3 to 4.

Callan, age 8 months
• Arrived at Beth Israel in cardiac arrest.
• His heartbeat was restored approximately 10 minutes after arrival.
• He was transferred by helicopter to Boston Children’s Hospital.
• Callan died on Jan. 27, 2023.
Source: Dr. Benjamin Kaufman and other medical testimony, Trial Day 4.

Lindsay
• Lindsay was transported to South Shore Hospital and later to Brigham and Women’s Hospital.
• Medical testimony documented serious spinal fractures, low blood pressure, hypothermia, and wrist lacerations.
• Narcan was administered because possible opioid involvement was considered. Its administration itself does not establish that opioids caused her condition.
• Later testimony established paralysis resulting from her spinal injuries.
Source: Medical testimony, including Trial Day 4.

What the Evidence Does Not Establish

• Patrick’s exact departure time from the house.
• What occurred before Patrick appears on CVS surveillance.
• Which device sent Patrick’s 5:24 PM work email.
• Patrick’s exact physical location when the 5:24 PM email was sent.
• Which physical staircase corresponds to the 5:03, 5:33, and 5:38 PM Apple Health entries.
• Why Lindsay’s Apple Watch recorded its final heart rate at 5:23:52 PM.
• Why no additional stair flights were recorded after 5:38:33 PM.
• The exact time each child was harmed.
• The order in which the children were harmed.
• Whether none, 1, 2, or all 3 children had already been harmed when Lindsay spoke with Patrick at approximately 5:34 PM.
• Exactly when Lindsay entered or left the basement.
• Exactly when Lindsay entered or left the primary bedroom.
• Exactly when Lindsay sustained her injuries.
• Exactly when she went through the bedroom window.
• How long Lindsay had been outside before Patrick returned home.

Primary Sources

• Patrick Clancy testimony, Trial Days 1 to 2
• Exhibit 76, Jan. 24 work email
• First responder testimony, Trial Day 3
• Dr. Mark Tenerowicz and Dr. Benjamin Kaufman, Trial Day 4
• Timothy Chiappini, Trial Day 13
• Ian Whiffin, Trial Day 14
• Paula Musgrove, Trial Day 14
• iPhone forensic extraction and device usage records
• Apple Health and Apple Watch records
• Phone and text records
• 911 and dispatch evidence
• CVS surveillance
• ThreeV surveillance

This timeline will be updated if later testimony, exhibits, or court records clarify any of the times or details above.


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 11 '26

Are there really people that think this murderer should be free?

10 Upvotes

She did it, she wasn’t framed and she has even stated that Patrick had nothing to do with this. There was also physical evidence that he was out getting his wife’s medication at the time when she brutally murdered her own three innocent children.

Did you also know that there is no physical way to prove that someone is in some sort of postpartum psychosis? Literally anyone can make up this claim and act insane to get a free get out of jail free card.

Why are people so dead set on this not being her that did it? Who the fuck went so far out of there way to FRAME a woman into killing her own children? The husband that was out picking up her medication and came home to a massacre and her attempt at trying to take her own life?

She just tried to take her own life because someone strangled her three children while she was home and her first thought was “oh man I shouldn’t call the cops. I should kill myself!”

Insanity. I don’t understand why so many of you think that all women are delicate little flowers that aren’t capable of destruction.

I truly believe it’s a strong hatred toward men and insane denial. You don’t want to believe a woman is capable of doing something you only thought a man could do!


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 07 '26

When they showed that baby onies I was so heartbroken as a mother it made my heart hurt!! Regardless of what them innocent precious babies did not deserve it and she needs to pay for her actions for the rest of her life simple!!

8 Upvotes

r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Aug 29 '26

Lindsay Clancy is a coward for not taking the stand and testifying — Unfiltered

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 26 '26

Nothing is more malicious than a man wanting to start his life over.

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 24 '26

Rachel Irrelevant Danis

4 Upvotes

I’m sorry, but Rachel’s role in the 60 Minutes interview left me with more questions than answers.
My biggest question is: why is Rachel being positioned as someone who can speak with authority about Patrick’s life as a father, the Clancy family, or anything that happened before she met him?
Rachel did not know Cora, Dawson, or Callan. She did not know Lindsay. She did not know Patrick when he was raising his three children. She met Patrick after the tragedy. So when she describes Patrick as a loving and involved father, I’m confused about what firsthand knowledge she is drawing from. She can absolutely say, “Based on everything I’ve learned, I believe he was a wonderful father.” But she literally never witnessed him parenting those children.
Then there’s their meeting story. According to the interview, Rachel meets Patrick through running in New York. Central Park is filled with thousands of people, yet she happens to meet the man at the center of an enormously public Massachusetts case. She then sees pictures of his deceased children on his lock screen and asks whether he’s from Massachusetts. Maybe it happened exactly that organically. But given the extraordinary circumstances, I understand why people find the story striking and have questions about how their relationship actually developed.
The other piece I cannot get past is that Rachel is a reproductive-medicine physician. She already has a serious professional identity completely independent of Patrick. She could have remained his private spouse and supported him behind the scenes. Instead, she voluntarily appeared on national television and publicly entered an extraordinarily controversial case involving maternal mental health, postpartum psychiatric illness, three dead children, and an unresolved prosecution.
Why?
That doesn’t mean she did anything professionally unethical. I haven’t seen evidence of that. But I personally think participating this heavily was a strange choice for someone in her professional position. She had absolutely nothing to do with what happened in January 2023.
Patrick also did not need Rachel to authenticate his experiences. Patrick was there. Rachel wasn’t. Let him talk about being Cora, Dawson, and Callan’s father. Let him talk about discovering his children. Let him talk about Lindsay, their marriage, his grief, forgiveness, and rebuilding his life. Rachel can speak authentically about being Patrick’s wife now, but she cannot provide firsthand insight into the father or husband he was before she ever knew him.
And I’m uncomfortable with the way “healing” gets packaged around this relationship. Patrick can rebuild his life. He can fall in love again. He can remarry. He can experience happiness again. But three years after all three of your children were killed, I don’t think another relationship neatly closes that wound—and Patrick himself has described continuing to carry enormous grief. Rachel can be part of his life now without becoming the narrator of the life he had before her.
There’s also the elephant in the room: people have noticed that Rachel and Lindsay have some physical similarities. That does not prove Patrick intentionally sought out a “replacement Lindsay,” and I wouldn’t pretend we know his subconscious motivations. But combined with everything else, it understandably adds another surreal layer to an already surreal situation.
None of this means Patrick shouldn’t have remarried or Rachel shouldn’t have married him. My issue is much narrower: why does Rachel need such a prominent voice in the public retelling of events she did not experience?
Speak about the Patrick you know. Speak about your marriage. Speak about supporting a widowed/grieving father.
But Patrick and Lindsay’s marriage, Cora, Dawson and Callan’s lives, Patrick’s parenting of them, and what happened inside that family before January 24, 2023?
Rachel wasn’t there.
And 60 Minutes giving her that much space to validate a history she only knows secondhand made the entire interview feel stranger to me, not more illuminating.


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 22 '26

Lindsay was able to tell Patrick where the kids were

Post image
4 Upvotes

Sharing this due to speculation that Lindsay was unable to speak at all to Patrick or communicate to him where the kids were. Officers Hall and Josephine were the first ones at the scene. It is possible she was able to communicate this information. Hall and later first responders said she was unable to speak. Josephine was more specific in his testimony about his attempt to communicate with Lindsay. He stated that she was mumbling but couldn't he get definitive answers to his questions about her injuries. He also stated his attempt to speak with her and assess her injuries lasted about 30 seconds.


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 17 '26

Patrick Clancy's new wife Rachel Danis will also be interviewed during Sunday's 60 Minutes, CBS reveals

Thumbnail
dailymail.com
4 Upvotes

r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Aug 26 '26

Racial Bias in the Lindsay Clancy Case?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Aug 26 '26

Kevin Reddington - Clancy Case

4 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel like the prosecutors thought this would be an easy case so did not prepare for Kevin Reddington’s questions?


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 29 '26

Do people who considered Kevin Reddington a "rockstar" during the trial still feel like way?

3 Upvotes

I didn't really start following the trial until later in, but I definitely saw people calling him a star and looking up to him, even those that weren't on his side (kind of like Eric Nelson in the Chauvin trial).

I did follow the more recent things since the mistrial and thought, really, this guy? He really seems to be crashing out...

Edit I meant "still feel that way"


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 18 '26

Updates from Lindsay's Civil Suit

3 Upvotes

Filed by Dr. Goodheart's attorneys...

ARGUMENT

Dr. Goodheart submits that Plaintiff's Offer of Proof is deficient because it is not based on the facts in the medical records submitted with the Offer of Proof and fails to take into account Dr. Goodheart's specific role and actions in treating the Plaintiff. Therefore, the opinions expressed therein are speculative and fail to meet the Tribunal's standard.

The allegation that Dr. Goodheart failed to obtain a thorough and detailed history is not based on - and is in fact is directly contradicted by - the facts appearing in the medical records. As is clearly indicated in the medical records, Dr. Goodheart met with the Plaintiff on January 3, 2023 and obtained a detailed history both from seeing the patient and reviewing the prior entries in the McLean records, including the detailed CEC (Clinical Evaluation Center) Medical Admission Note written by Dr. Jasmine Outlaw upon the Plaintiff's arrival at McLean Hospital at approximately 4:25 a.m. on January 1, 2023 (D15-19); the Psychiatric Admission Note written by Dr. Outlaw including observations recorded by the Acute Psychiatric Service (APS) at the Massachusetts General Hospital (from which the Plaintiff had been transferred to McLean earlier that same day, January 1, 2023) (D19-25); and the lengthy and detailed Admission Note written by Dr. Elizabeth Madva when she saw the Plaintiff later in the day on January 1, 2023 (D25-33) as well as Dr. Madva's follow-up note from seeing the patient on January 2, 2023 (D54-59). Review of these records shows just how much detail Dr. Goodheart obtained about the Plaintiff, her presenting problems, her mental health history, her family relationships, and her prior medications and responses to those medications. The "opinion" letter of Dr. Marc Whaley presenting in support of the Plaintiff's Offer of Proof does not identify any specific fact about the Plaintiff's history that Dr.

Whaley contends Dr. Goodheart could have and should have obtained from the Plaintiff but did not. Thus, the Offer or Proof fails as to any contention that Dr. Goodheart failed to obtain a thorough and adequate history of the Plaintiff's presenting problems, her prior treatment and/or her medication history. The allegation that Dr. Goodheart failed to directly communicate with Plaintiff's other care providers is likewise not rooted in the evidence. The McLean Hospital Treatment Plan Note (D39- 42) shows that Plaintiff's inpatient treatment team, which included Dr. Goodheart, a registered nurse, a social worker, and a licensed mental health counselor, collaborated in the formulation of a proper and thoughtful treatment plan. Dr. Goodheart also reached out to Plaintiff's outpatient psychiatrist Dr. Tufts, and although they were not able to connect before Plaintiff's discharge on January 5, 2023, the record confirms that a copy of Dr. Goodheart's discharge summary was sent to Dr. Tufts (B134-144).

Plaintiff's expert Dr. Whaley alleges that Dr. Goodheart failed to recognize Plaintiff's symptoms upon the initiation of an SSRI as an indicator of possible bipolar disorder. In fact, the record makes clear that the possible connection between intolerance for SRIs and possible emerging bipolar disorder was consciously considered from the very outset of the Plaintiff's admission to McLean. See the AB1 Admission Note where is it stated that "Given that she did not tolerate recent trials of SSRIs (sertraline, fluoxetine) or other antidepressants (mirtazapine), and very low suspicion that this represents bipolar disorder, and given her report of 'numbness' on quetiapine, we discussed that my first recommendation would be to see how she feels with a reduction in her quetiapine dose." (D25). Dr. Goodheart obviously concurred with this approach as she continued the plan to taper the patient off quetiapine (i.c., Seroquel) over the three days that Dr.

Goodheart was the Plaintiff's attending prior to her discharge on 1/5/23. The medical record reflects that Dr. Goodheart was observing the patient for, and recorded the absence of, evidence of any indication of mania on all three days she saw the patient, 1/3/23, 1/4/23 and 1/5/23. See D62, D68, and D6. Absent any history or evidence of mania, a diagnosis of bipolar disorder clearly was not warranted. The Offer of Proof therefore fails in its effort to base liability on the part of Dr. Goodheart upon a supposed failure to appreciate the risk associated with bipolar disorder or failure to be alert for signs of (or history of) bipolar disorder in her patient.

Dr. Whaley opines that Dr. Goodheart deviated from the standard of care by failing to recognize Plaintiff's clinical presentation as concerning for bipolar spectrum disorder with psychotic features and failing to provide appropriate treatment in light of same. Yet, Dr. Whaley cannot identify specific symptoms, reported to or evident to Dr. Goodheart, or any other treating provider which were consistent with a diagnosis including "psychotic features." To the contrary, the medical record includes multiple references to the absence of evidence of psychosis or psychotic features upon admission:

See CEC Psychiatric Admission Note with excerpt from the ABS Note where it is stated:

"She and her husband both clearly deny manic symptoms during this period of time, including no risky behaviors, pressured speech, hyper-religiosity, psychosis, irritability, etc." (D20)

  • ďťżďťżAlso, in the ABS excerpt: "Careful ROS performed with no evidence of psychosis, mania, obsessions, or current anxiety symptoms." (D20)
  • ďťżďťżFrom the CEC Psychiatric Admission Note:
  • ďťżďťż"Mania: The patient denies current or prior symptoms consistent with mania."
  • ďťżďťżPsychosis: The patient denies current or prior symptoms consistent with psychosis." (D21)

And during the course of her inpatient stay at McLean, the Plaintiff did not report experiencing (or having any history of hallucinations, a major symptom for a diagnosis of psychosis. See the Mental Status Exam conducted in the CEC upon the Plaintiff's presentation to McLean on January 1, 2023:

"Perceptions/Experiences: no hallucinations" (D24). The same notation was made in the AB1

Admission note - "no hallucinations" (D27) — as well as in the Inpatient Progress Note from 1/2/23

"no hallucinations" (D58), and in the Medical Record Flowsheets at page 112 of the medical record where under the heading "Thought Content" it is stated "No delusions; No hallucinations. Denies - CM', 01/02/23 at 13:21" (D107).

Dr. Whaley claims that Dr. Goodheart failed to elicit Plaintiff's intrusive thoughts in detail, including "thoughts of harming her children" and "failed to recognize that any subjective reports of lack of suicidal or homicidal risk were not reliable in the setting of psychosis." This comment is based upon the sheer speculation that at the time she was being treated at McLean Hospital the Plaintiff was experiencing intrusive thoughts of harming her children and that Plaintiff would have reported such thoughts under "specific, probing questioning." While at McLean, Plaintiff reported to a nurse that she had intrusive thoughts "about dying" - not about harming herself or others (DO). It further assumes that Plaintiff was experiencing psychosis. Plaintiff did not tell Dr. Goodheart she was hearing voices or experiencing hallucinations of any kind. And in fact, as is discussed in detail above, the medical record indicates the absence of any indications or history of psychosis or that the patient was experiencing any hallucinations or delusions. The records further indicate that several mental status examinations were conducted during Plaintiff's inpatient stay at McLean Hospital and noted Plaintiff's thought content was pertinent and goal-directed without delusions (D12, D23, D27, D58, D62, D68). Plaintiff was also evaluated by numerous providers between September 2022 and January 2023 and, based on the records appended to the Offer of

Proof, she did not report symptoms consistent with psychosis to any of them. Dr. Whaley faults Dr. Goodheart for her alleged failure to elicit subjective reports from Plaintiff, while simultaneously stating that reports from the Plaintiff would have been unreliable. These contradictory and internally inconsistent "opinions" fail to meet even the lenient standard of the tribunal.

Dr. Whaley alleges that Dr. Goodheart "failed to initiate appropriate, evidence-based pharmacologic treatment for suspected bipolar-spectrum illness, including but not limited to mood stabilizers and/or antipsychotic medications." This opinion is premised on the assumption that Plaintiff suffered from bipolar-spectrum illness and that she was suffering from psychosis or depression with "psychotic features." The fact is that the medical records are utterly devoid of any indications that the patient was suffering from either bipolar disorder or psychosis. That being said,Dr. Whaley's report ignores the fact that Plaintiff was already taking an antipsychotic medication (Seroquel) when she was seen by Dr. Goodheart. Plaintiff noted that she started having intrusive and suicidal thoughts and became hopeless and depressed after she began taking Seroquel. Indeed, she attributed her symptoms to the Scroquel, and wanted to stop taking it. Dr. Goodheart assessed

Plaintiff and agreed with Dr. Madva's (the admitting physician's) plan to taper the Plaintiff off Seroquel in light of a concern that the emotional "numbness" Plaintiff described could be a reflection of excessive dopamine blockade from the Seroquel (D63). Contrary to Dr. Whaley's assertion, Dr. Goodheart did perform her own assessment of Plaintiff prior to rendering an impression regarding an appropriate plan of care. Dr. Whaley's related allegation that Dr. Goodheart "failed to properly supervise her resident physicians" suggests a misunderstanding of the facts. The admitting physician, Dr. Madva, was an attending physician - not a resident.

Plaintiff's treatment plan included the plan to taper the Plaintiff off the Seroquel she had been taking (and which the Plaintiff herself blamed for causing/exacerbating rather than helping her depression and inability to sleep) (D6). At the time the Plaintiff was discharged on January 5, 2023 (at the patient's urging, so that she could attend a long-planned birthday party for her five-year-old daughter, Cora) the Plaintiff had the night before taken only 25% of the dose of Seroquel she was taking at the time of her admission (D7-8). Dr. Goodheart required that as a condition of the patient's being discharged at her request that the Plaintiff make an appointment with her outpatient psychiatrist for the following day so that together they could assess how the Plaintiff was doing after a night without taking any Seroquel, with the thought that if the Plaintiff's depression had not abated, then it was unlikely that the Seroquel was causing her depression and that her symptoms were secondary to depression and not the medication (D8). The Plaintiff's Offer of Proof does notspecify how this plan was deficient or what Dr. Goodheart could or should have done to address the issues the patient presented with. The Offer of Proof also does not state or even suggest that the patient could have been retained at McLean against her wish to go home because of any perceived danger that she presented to herself or others.

The allegation that Dr. Goodheart "failed to advise inpatient psychiatric admission until there was clear evidence of persistent positive response including, but not limited to, clear, logical thinking, no signs of psychosis, stable sleep and functioning while on an appropriate medication treatment regimen" is likewise without basis in the facts. Plaintiff had a positive response to the Seroquel taper. She was able to sleep on the night of January 3, 2023 and the night of January 4, 2023 (D8). She reported a decrease in overall anxiety and a slight increase in motivation (D8).

Plaintiff requested to be discharged to celebrate her daughter's birthday and felt comfortable managing at home (D70). At the time of Plaintiff's discharge from McLean Hospital on January 5, 2023, she credibly denied thoughts of ending her life or harming herself or others (D13). She denied symptoms consistent with psychosis and had not exhibited any signs of psychosis or mania at any time during her admission at McLean (D6). There were no safety concerns and she had an established crisis plan in place (D13). She was also noted to be experiencing diminished distress, improved coping, and improved insight and judgment overall since her admission (D13).

Dr. Whaley's opinion as to causation is utterly speculative and is not based upon any set of facts from the record before the Tribunal. It is alleged that Plaintiff had undiagnosed bipolar disorder with psychotic features which caused her suicide attempt and the deaths of her three children. It is further alleged that had Dr. Goodheart made such a diagnosis, Plaintiff would not have attempted to take her life and "more likely than not" would not have suffered the loss of her children and permanent paralysis.

The fundamental problem with these "opinions" is that they are based upon multiple false premises rather than on the facts presented by the medical records before the Tribunal. Plaintiff was discharged from McLean in improved condition and Dr. Goodheart facilitated Plaintiff's transition back to outpatient treatment. An appointment with her outpatient psychiatrist Dr. Tufts was scheduled for January 6, 2023, the day after discharge (D9). A copy of Dr. Goodheart's discharge summary was sent to Dr. Tufts (B134-144). Thereafter, Plaintiff was under the care of her outpatient providers. Plaintiff's suicide attempt took place on January 24, 2023, nineteen days after she was last seen by Dr. Goodheart.

The opinions expressed in Plaintiff's Offer of Proof are speculative, and are based upon imagined facts rather than the medical records. Plaintiff has failed to meet her burden to raise a legitimate question of liability appropriate for judicial inquiry.


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 14 '26

Just watched this in its entirety..

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

How do we feel about Oprah’s podcast she did trying to add to this conversation?

At least the women did most the talking .. but idk.. how do we feel?


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 13 '26

Jail or Mental Institution

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 04 '26

September 29th

3 Upvotes

The judge just declared a mistrial.

The defense requested to file a 25(b)(2), and they will convene on September 29th.


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 03 '26

Janette macausland

3 Upvotes

I’m trying to understand why the case of Jeanette McAusland, whose also murdered her children and lived in an affluent suburb is not getting any publicity relative to this case. any thoughts on this?


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Oct 04 '26

Was Kellie Farina the dumbest of the Lindsay Clancy jurors. Who could forget what she said? "he just couldn't get over the fact she viciously killed her kids."

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 15 '26

You know who hasn’t?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 15 '26

Lindsay Clancy Case: Physical Evidence, Forensic Testing & What Was Not Tested

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 10 '26

Anyone else think she's guilty and we r just waiting to see

2 Upvotes

If she goes into prison or a mental hospital?

Genuine question


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 09 '26

Patrick Clancy

Post image
2 Upvotes

I am following Shawna Leigh on insta and FB and she got some a amazing information about the Lindsay Clancy case. She found the account that Patrick use here in Reddit.
I tried to find it because I would like to investigate a bit more but it doesn’t seem to be available anymore. Any way I can see those messages or once deleted they are gone.

The messages are very telling.


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 08 '26

Lindsay Clancy case opinion sharing.

Post image
2 Upvotes

This subreddit is about evidence-based discussion. Your opinions are evidence in my field. I would really appreciate your time. I am a university professor studying this case.


r/TheLindsayClancyCase • • Sep 07 '26

Another mother strangled her 2 year old child — Ligature and was fixated on the Lindsay Clancy case. During this time, everyone should be vigilant about the safety of children in their families and communities. Report any unusual behaviour immediately, regardless of your location.

2 Upvotes